OMG, food was so good! Had the cheesesteak and Toscano sandwich. Could only eat 1/2. Both stuffed, and the rolls, so good. Had to be some type of sourdough. Ribeye was cooked perfectly. The chicken, fresh mozzarella and sun dried peppers were perfect. Couldn't recommend more! read more

Great place for some pizza right behind the farmers market complex. We got a large plain and pepperoni to go with the Tuesday special. We ate a slice fresh when we got out of the restaurant and it was amazing. The cheese was goopy and melted off the slice, and the crust was nice. We will be back! read more

Victors Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hillsborough, New Jersey

In my opinion Victors is the best pie in Hillsborough- the sauce is fresh and tasty especially in the summer. I can tell they use farm fresh quality ingredients. It tastes very authentic. I order my pizza crispy - which comes out perfectly to my taste. I'm not a fan of wet floppy slices from other pizza parlors around town. read more

Great pizza! I ordered this for a kids party and the parents were blown away. The cheese pizza is very tasty and their specialty pies are amazing. This was a 10 out of 10. read more

Nope! Another swing and miss by this pizza restaurant. The crust is chewy and hard at the end. Soggy in the middle. Also, waaaaay overpriced. Almost $28 for a large with 2 toppings. Last time for this place, other choices abound in town. read more

Pizza slices the size of your head! The plain slice has good flavor with a good crust. I would've like more seasoning like salt, oregano but would go back for a quick slice. It's a nice looking place and May come back for dinner. read more

Victors Pizzeria - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Hillsborough, New Jersey

See all

I really want to like this place more. It's so nice inside. Staff so nice. Pizza is good but our pasta has been ok. Prices for some dishes are high for a pizza place and if it was great I'd pay. But just haven't loved the non pizza food. read more

The pizza was amazing that we ordered. love how they used fresh garlic on my pepperoni, black olives and garlic. the chicken bacon ranch is off the chain too. all fresh tasting and definitely made with a lot of passion. read more

See all

I stopped here while passing through town and was glad I did. Upon entering I was greeted by a friendly worker. I ordered two plain slices which came out quick. Cheese, grease, a great crust, large crust and piping hot. Everything you could want in a slice of pizza. The inside of the store had a great atmosphere and nice vibe. It was quiet when I went but I enjoyed the quiet. read more

Victors Pizzeria - Two big slices. - Pizza Near Me - Hillsborough, New Jersey

See all

Huge, delicious, thin crust slices. Could be crispier but no complaint from me. Clean restaurant and bathroom.

Had a slice for here and taste was amazing. Crust was so crispy and for here slices are huge (in a good way!). Workers were so kind. Restaurant itself was inviting and clean. Great energy, great food. read more

Delicious pizza and fabulous eggplant parmigiana! We have done both take out and eaten in and the food was so consistently delicious!

We've been working our way through the menu and have been hard pressed to find anything that isn't incredible. You can tell they take a lot of pride in what they do. Every time we go in folks are friendly! read more

We went on a Tuesday evening and got penne vodka and a few slices that were seemingly left over. Pizza was hardly a 2 out of 10 but the penne vodka really was nice. So as far as the pizza goes, I may revisit when it's a little busier and the pies are fresh. I'd give it another try. read more

This is hands down the best pizza place in Hillsborough. We would drive 40+ minutes just for good pizza, but very thankful it's so close. HIDDEN GEM read more

awesome food, awesome taste. we got 3 pizzas - chicken bacon ranch, tomato with pepperoni olives and garlic and then the funghi pie and we nearly finished them all. all so so so good and so fresh read more

we have been going to victors for over 10 years. The food has always been exceptional, even though the ownership has changed. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

I used to love this place. Since Danny is no longer there it is just not the same. This is the 2nd time in a few weeks that I have gone in there for 2 plain slices and was told they didn't have any. I was told they only had sciciian. What pizza place doesn't have plain old pizza.? read more

The place looks nice, but the food is trash. The pizza was extremely greasy, cheese and sauce no Bueno. Wings had a texture that was dense and gross, tasted like they have been frozen and thawed a bunch of times. They also forgot my salad. Needless to say I only went there because of Fourth of July they were the only place open but I'm glad Tried it out because now I can rule it out read more

I'm not sure why it took me so long to try this place after breaking up with Sal's but I think I had it confused with another pizza joint in the area. Victor's Pizza has consistently awesome pizza and cheesesteaks! We usually get delivery but we've eaten there a few times and it's rarely busy inside. I think most people pick-up or get delivery. Our go-to pizza is pepperoni and mushroom but we've had the plain cheese slice too and that's great as well. Unfortunately, their garlic knots leave something to be desired in the flavor department, but their bread rolls that they give with the pizza are excellent. (I think it's the same dough they use for the pizza crust.) The sauce they deliver with them is just OK. Frankly, the sauce a little bland - it could use some oregano and garlic or something but I usually just add that myself. Their salads are pretty good too. We like the chicken caesar salad, but the chicken isn't as flavorful as Sal's. Also, sometimes they don't give enough dressing with it, which is annoying. All-in-all, they make excellent food but it could be better. It's the best place in the area for pizza unless you want to go all the way out to Nomad in Princeton. read more

Victor's pizzeria is my favorite local pizzeria to stop and grab a slice. The owner, Danny, is a really cool dude and very friendly. The pizzeria is located in a shopping mall along Amwell Road, right after crossing over Route 206. This central location puts Victors in the center of town to compete against the other 5 pizzerias within a 10 minute walk: Alfonsos, Angelos, Pizza Hut, Dominoes, and Roman Gourmet. On of the advantages of the location for Victor's is the proximity to the High School and the Park & Ride. This is the closest pizzeria to the High School and right next to an area where students park their cars, so the student crowd will often stop in and grab one of the massive to-go slices. I have fond memories of grabbing a slice after school and then going to the martial arts school I work at for an evening of teaching. The pizzeria is small and cozy, but has enough seating to pull some tables together for a larger group. The long window on the side by the counter-top seating allows a good amount of light inside and also lets someone eating at the counter to see the going-ons outside. There is a beautiful painted mural along the inside wall of the pizzeria that depicts a scene at a local square in some Mediterranean town where there are children playing soccer, boats in the harbor, and hot pizza being served to happy guests. Often I will look at the mural as I eat and imagine myself in that setting. It's quite peaceful. The pizza itself is enormous. One of the to-go slices is practically the size of two normal slices. If you enjoy pepperoni, they're quite liberal with the amount they pile onto the slice, so I recommend getting that. The slice is usually pretty greasy and often molten hot coming out of the oven. I like to eat some of the crust to allow some airflow in the slice to cool it down. I also fold the slice "hot dog style" and tilt it to drain some of the grease. The cheese is always fresh and always delicious. The sauce is tasty and rich. The crust is thicker than most slices and very fluffly. Overall, I highly recommend Victor's to anyone looking to grab a quick and hearty bite to eat in Hillsborough. The slices are delicious and very filling. read more

Victors Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hillsborough, New Jersey

See all

We stopped into Victors after doing some pumpkin picking. Being vegan it's always a little difficult to have someone make us good pizza. Usually it's dry with a few drops of sauce and out-of-the-can vegetables. Man are we glad we stopped in. We talked to Danny about leaving off the cheese and making sure there was enough sauce and HE NAILED IT. We ordered eggplant, mushrooms and garlic. The vegetables were fresh and sautéed perfectly. We haven't had pizza like this in years. Can't wait to go back and chat it up with Danny. Great guy, great service and GREAT PIZZA. read more

Victors Pizzeria - Eggplant, mushrooms and Gallic, no cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Hillsborough, New Jersey

Stopped in for quick dinner ordered the side of meatball. absolutely the worst meatballs i have ever eaten! no flavor, mushy like soggy bread. read more

This is the pizza spot I grew up on...literally, from grade school through college, Victor's was the place. A bunch of friends worked there over the years, and it was a family deal with them, we all knew each other. I am biased, but it's the best pizza around...and as mentioned the margherita pie is my favorite as well. They make good pies, so they don't have to be friendly ;) read more

Hillsborough is loaded with pizza places. From your small family business to your popular pizza chains, there is a pizza place for everybody in Hillsborough. But with so many places people often wonder which place has the best pizza. I don't think that's a simple question to answer. It depends on what you're looking for, what kind of toppings you want, are you eating in or carrying out. But if you are looking for a slice of pizza to eat in the restaurant then Victor's is the only answer. The Boardwalk pies for slices top any other slice you can get at some other pizza place. A couple other places try to do the boardwalk pie slices but Victor's is hands down the best at it. If you order a whole pie it's also really good so it's not like Victor's is only worth it for the Boardwalk slices. The sauce is a little sweeter than some of the other places, the cheese has a nice flavor to it and the crust is not too doughy, not too thin. Even ordering a pie to go the pizza has the perfect amount of crispness to it and is just as good. Simply put, it's the best pizza in Hillsborough. They also have very good wings which are big & crispy. Order them hot because the sauce they put on really is not hot so you won't need to worry about burning your mouth. Victor's Pizza has what I consider to be the best pizza in Hillsborough. read more

I grew up in Hillsborough but I have never stepped foot into Victor's until a recent visit. Pizza places are a whole culture of picking favorites and (mainly) sticking with them. What did Victor's do right to get some new customers to step in their door? They were open on July 4th when everyone else was closed. I would give Victor's a higher rating than all the other pizza places in town (that I have gone to). I guess now it's obvious why they have always been there. The crust has a slightly sweet flavor that adds just enough sweetness to balance out the rest of the taste. We ordered a pizza with a bunch of different veggies on it and they were all fresh INCLUDING fresh mushrooms (I hate canned mushrooms). When I am back in town and looking for a slice I would definitely go to Victors again. read more

I've been coming here for as long as I can remember and the pizza is still the best. Customer service is outstanding and delivery is always on time. A great go to place for family dinners or a quick bite. read more

Love the specialty pizza with eggplant! My kids love the plain cheese. read more

Was visiting family in NJ and this was one of my stops on four occasions for lunch. The pizza here is awesome, huge slices and a good variety to choose from. I always got the plain or sausage slices. The sausage is some of the best I've ever had and abundant on the slice. Ownership is very nice and the restaurant is very clean. Great Jersey spot. They offer an expanded menu so maybe next time I'll try something else! read more

Best pizza in central NJ by far. Danny the owner is a true master! Pasta, subs, salads are all great too. Our entire family's favorite.

Somerset and Hunterdon counties are a tough venue to find an edible slice. Victors is tasty and their dough always seems to be fresh. The tell tale sign is the bubbling of the crust. The sauce is sweet and loaded with cheese . Like most area pizzerias Victors doesn't taste like the box in came in . The slices are super sized and for some reason the pie is always still hot when I get it home. I have not tried any of their specialty pies. In a nick for take out Pizza Victors is a good um read more

Disgusting, simply disgusting the guy touch our pizza twice with his bare hands after touching the computer and the card that we paid with. After we told him the other guy that was sitting taking a break I guess come to insult us while touch the pan for the pizza without washing his hands note he was on break. Imagine how they handle the food when people are not looking read more

This is a great pizza place! Service is quick and friendly and they have a few tables for outdoor seating. The best part of this place is when you go there and order slices, they are HUGE!!!! They make their slices from a 24 inch pie! My favorite slice is the white slice w ricotta. Out of habit, I usually order 2 slices, but I have yet to be able to finish 2 slices from here yet. I did try their garlic knots, but I didn't care for them. I'm not sure what they put on them, but the knots were very slimy and not all that garlicky. So, i will just stick with the pizza. The pizza is reasonably priced and a decent deal for the size of the slices you get. For 2 "non-plain" slices, and a drink, it was around $8. read more

A burnt base is always a huge disappointment...ordered a veggie pizza...the cheese and veggie toppings were good but the pizza base was burnt and made the whole experience a disappointment. read more

This place is ..eh..ok. It's not terrible, but it's not amazing either. If you need a quick pie, then go for it. But to me their sauce tastes really sweet and is just, off. They make a great meatball sub..but again with off tasting sauce. I wish there was a rating between 2 and 3 stars. I haven't eaten here in a bit, so maybe the food has improved? A good plus though is that they're in a good location and are pretty quick about prepping your food. read more

This place has the best pizza in NJ. I've eaten pizza at many of the top ranked places. And by far this pizza is at the top of my list. Stop by get a slice and you won't regret it. You'll see what I am trying to explain. read more

Although the staff could be friendlier, the pizza is the best in Hillsborough. Getting them to smile is difficult but they are not unfriendly, if you know what I mean. The regular menu is not bad but the pizza is what I go for. read more

Despite being listed on the menu, no tea anymore. No Italian dressing in an Italian restaurant. You're kidding, right? Maybe 50 degrees in dining room. Apparently the pizza is great, as evidenced by the continuous stream of customers. It is no place to dine, however, unless you want to lose your date. Food very average. Service? I didn't notice any. read more

What Happened??? First time Ive done this review thing but had to because am so annoyed and shocked ..normally the best pizza in town!! but tonight the pizzas were floppy, flimsy, and paper thin (crust) and totally different (like a giant cost savings project ... cut back on all ingredients!) We've been Victor's customers for many many years! what is this new pizza nothingness? All 6 of us said the same thing.. underwhelmed by a usually trusty source for our pies ... is there someone/something new? i hate to be negative but shocked at two unrecognizable pies! Suddenly disappointed after years of pizza happiness! give us our old Victors back! read more

I ordered here a few weeks ago with my mother and brother. She stands by that Victors is her and her boyfriends favorite place to get pizza in Hillsborough. I just say I was somewhat optimistic because I was never the biggest fan of victors. But my god that dinner just confirmed it for me that victors is terrible. Sorry to be dramatic but the wings tasted like they have been in a freezer for years and the pizza was soggy and gross. Will never go here again not worth another chance. Staff was very nice but that can't make up for the poor read more