Great place. Decent selection. Prices are why I've come to expect from most local gaming stores,…read morewhich is to say that it isn't cheap, but if you want these stores around you need to support them. Staff seemed friendly enough.

Overall there selection is nice, they have a large quantity of everything. Was really surprised at…read morethe amount of stuff that they carry in store especially pokemon singles. But sadly as a pokemon collector they're also somewhat disappointing. As a collector I watch prices especially on cards I'm trying to collect. When you're asking graded card prices on ungraded prices especially anywhere from 50-300 dollars over market value it's unreasonable. Their service is extremely friendly however as someone who only collects one thing this is not a store I'd visit again because of the unreasonable prices they ask for pokemon singles.

I visited this shop for the first time today, I had a great experience! There was a tcg tournament…read moregoing on in the large store. I believe they were playing YuGiOh but I'm not familiar with the game so I can't be certain. There were probably 40 people in there all playing, a very cool sight to walk into! I stopped in to buy Pokemon cards for my nephew and me to open together. They don't carry very much sealed Pokemon products and most of what they have is listed at market price. I don't know if they regularly get items at msrp. This shop has a pretty large and diverse selection of single cards as well and I ended up picking up some from the display case as well as a few from the $1 box. I had great service from Brian on this visit. I will definitely be back, especially if I'm looking for singles.

Great selection. Staff was very helpful and courteous. Saw the game I had selected and recommended…read moreone for a lower cost that had better value. A+ all around

We are wizened (old) players of MTG that hadn't really played since the late 90s, so we sometimes…read morefeel silly going to card shops looking to snag things. This place didn't make us feel weird or awkward. They're very kind and are happy to help you with questions about the game or cards you're looking for. I was highly impressed with the variety of boosters they had, and their case had some incredible singles (sadly I'll never afford most). The only thing I missed is being able to comb through singles myself. Here they have them in the back and you need to know ahead of time what you're looking for. Other than that, no complaints and we will definitely be back!

The service was amazing, great selection, and the staff were extremely nice. Was a great…read moreexperience. My child was so excited!

If you love this place, then you totally understand the hype to it however, if you're like me and…read moreyou were introduced to this from another person who absolutely adores it, but you don't care for places like this you find it confusing. So this is a massive bookstore, music store, video store, toy store that specializes in buying used items and reselling them. So if you have an aversion to musty dirty used items, this is not your place. Which I happen to have. However, this is not McKay's fault. It is a great place to offload things you don't need and get a little cash on the side. I have a touch of sensory bias, which is why it's difficult for me to enjoy it. But I totally understand why others do. If you are planning on selling stuff, make sure you get there early. If not, when they open there will be a line not of people wanting to sell stuff just people wanting to get in there to check out anything new that came in the night before. It is always busy so do not expect to come and it not be packed. If that is an issue for you probably not your place. But a big plus is the parking lot is absolutely massive. You will find a parking spot regardless of how busy it is. And to that I give it five stars.

I was so excited to get back to McKay's for the first time in years. I was completely taken aback…read moreby the prices of books here now. Many books I found were overpriced for used books. There's no pricing system based on book condition, which would be nice. You may find a book in fair condition and pay the same amount for the same book in excellent condition. Customer service was great as always.

I've lived in this area since 2006, so almost 20 years. BAM Clarksville used to have a whole lot…read moremore books and less merch. The magazine section is much smaller and sadder (I was looking for a specific issue of Time and they didn't have that, but plenty of AR-15 mags). Parts of the store that used to be full of books now have FUNKO figures and kids toys, as well as Bible calendars. They also have a section for anime and board games, so the nerd factor is still there, though not on the level of independent shops. They have a coffee shop and a lot of history/biography/study guide/fiction books. The spots reserved for sitting and reading are gone. It is past its prime, but in the time of Amazon, and outside of big cities, what place isn't?

I am not an avid reader. There are very few books I want to read. However I came in looking for a…read moreparticular book. Asked at the desk (didn't know the title) I gave her the authors name. Then had to spell the authors name-fine. The male at the counter says the books name by my author. Says that would be in autobiography by the cafe. Well there were not a lot in that area and they are just on the shelf in no particular order so after standing there looking over every shelf (for over 10 minutes) with no one else around to ask- I left. I'll just order it from another seller online (that is cheaper but I was willing to pay a little more to get it that day). This is why I don't go into book stores. I don't want to have to search through shelves of books trying to fine 1 book. Can we at least have it some what organized by authors last names alphabetical in the shelves. Like top shelf is A-c or something.

Amazing place to play your favorite tabletop or card game. I play Magic the gathering here and love…read morethe players and owner. Very inclusive space with wide selection. Love the dice selection. Great value for your money, Ad long as you buy something even just a bottle of water you are welcome to play

From the owner: Natural 20 Works is a locally and veteran owned tabletop gaming store that carries an assortment of…read moreTabletop RPGs, board games, card games, wargames, dice and many other accessories. We strive to have a space that is inclusive to all and can be a space where people can hang out, talk, and enjoy games and being themselves.

Wonderful mix of many types of stores in one. Part comic book store, part used video game store,…read morepart toy store, and even part card and sports memorabilia store. There are items for casual collectors or those shopping on a budget for kids or gift giving. There are exclusive and sometimes rare items for the diehard collectors as well. The staff is friendly and engaging as well.

Customer service was HORRIBLE! The white guy with black framed glasses and patch on the back of his…read morehead and neck doesn't know who to speak to people. He was so rude for no reason. We asked about trading services and shut us down with a tone as if we killed his dog. Gave us contradicting answers with his rudeness. Overpriced merchandise!!! If I could give ZERO stars I would.

Located in McHenry Shopping Center alongside Bath & Body Works, Five Below, Cici's and a few other…read morespots, The Game Trader is cool local game store that has all the games from classics, to nostalgia to new age. I popped in shortly before Christmas to scope a few games for my nephews and partner and was overwhelmed and impressed with the selection. The store itself brings back memories of the video/game stores of the 90's/2000's, so it was a trip down memory lane, especially with the old school TV's, posters and games of the past. I did not find what I was after, but had a good time wandering around. Service was friendly and helpful. Store was clean and in decent condition. Overall, cool spot to have in the neighborhood.

Best game store in Madison. Tons of old games for every system, old collectors editions, as well as…read moreall the new releases you could ask for. Also cool import toys and games from Japan

Great records and collectibles and it's not very expensive. Staff is awesome too, really helpful!read more

Nice place first time visit got Adele last release in Cd and a couple of other things held off on a…read morecouple of thing keep up the good work!

GREAT locally run shop and family business. John and his staff are very friendly and great to deal…read morewith. The vibe inside the store is great and they have a nice selection of sports, Pokémon and wax. John is fair on his pricing and I'll definitely be back.

Well, here we are again for the third time. As an infrequent…read morecollector, I failed to acknowledge market prices in my previous 3-star review- perhaps because it was written on pure adrenaline. PCC is a great atmosphere, and the employees really care- they hire young staff that actually collect cards and have a wide knowledge of them. While I'm not a frequent passerby any longer (due to the skyrocketing MSRP of packs), every time I've been in recently was a pleasant experience. The store is always clean and I've never seen the employees unhappy. A welcoming environment for kids and adults alike- whether you want to buy packs, slabs, boxes, or get a card graded, the staff will have you sorted.