This is the best pizza ever! Excited to go back again soon! We had a cheese pizza and a sub. Both were amazing!

Good news the food was good not great. The bad news, this is a take out only restaurant. They do not understand the concept of dining in. There were three of us and they served each of our entrees about 10-15 minutes apart. So by time, I got my food, my son and husband had already finished. They had a big party of 8 walk out because they wanted to order and eat there but couldn't accommodate them with all the take out customers waiting at the tables and using up chairs read more

From speaking with who I think to be the owner, before the store even opened, to the flawless delivery, I can't say enough about Vincenza's. We were in desperate need of a lot of food in a short window of time for a party at NSH-Forsyth for a fellow employee. Vincenza's did us a solid!!! Pizzas were piping hot on delivery, delicious, huge and so very prompt. EVERYONE in my department now wants the address and contact number. You have gained a following of NSH employees. Thank you Vincenza's read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Baby shower - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

This is the best pizza in Atlanta hands down!!! I just found this place and I m so glad I did. I have lived from NY to Florida and 5 other states. The pizza rivals any pizza from any place I have lived or traveled. They also have an extensive menu and cater. read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Finally real pizza in Atlanta - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

This pizza shop is closest i've had to NYC pizza. I have never been disappointed with them i've been a patron for years now.

This food was absolutely delicious and i thank the chefs that cooked it so much for their hard work. The service was also fantastic. And so was the ambiance. read more

Food took a minute to be brought to my table but I didn't mind I wasn't in a rush. Food was good but not anything crazy, wasn't too expensive either. A little too much cheese in the calzone read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Cheese Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

I came here today with a coworker as I was craving a slice and some wings, and I had heard great things! You walk in and the first thing you notice is it's size. Or should I say lack thereof? This place is tiny, but that is not a knock on the restaurant. Just note that it mightnot be ideal for a large group. I get to the counter and am promptly greeted by a young lady and I place my order for a slice of meat lovers and 6 buffalo wings. Paid and I was lucky enough that as soon as I filled up my water cup a table was becoming open. My buddy and I sit down and his side salad arrives quickly. He said it was good, but he ordered a Greek salad and they brought him a garden. He is not one to complain so he demolishes the solid. Our slices come and they look promising. Taking a bite, the flavor is outstanding, but the slice is not necessarily hot. A few steps above room temp. That said, the flavor saved the day as it popped with flavor and not too much sauce. I am a "dip my crust in ranch" guy and was disappointed with the store-bought Ken's ranch. A few minutes later my wings come and they are some big ole Jumbo wings! They arrive piping with steam coming off of them. They were nice and crispy and tasted ok, but if I was a betting man, I'd say the sauce is Franks red hot or something similar. Nothing wrong with Franks, but I just expected more. All this is to say, would I go back and give them another shot? You bet. The pizza has a lot of potential for greatness. Maybe next time I will get a whole pie and take it home. 3.5 stars read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Wings! - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

I was hungry when I came in and got a pepperoni regular slice and a Sicilian. The NY style was perfect. Nice crunch piping hot. I like pizza to burn the roof of my mouth. Very happy with it. I will be back. read more

If you're from Jersey, you're going to feel right at home here. The smell took me back to Paterson where we had plenty of good pizzerias. The pizzas were good, perfect crust and cheese. The sauce flavor could be enhanced. This is a solid pizza place, I would come back. Great service! Not a lot of room for large groups, but def to hang out with a couple of friends and watch a game. read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice and Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

Excellent pizza and great customer service! Points for every purchase is very rewarding since I buy allot of pizza there. I highly recommend all to try it out if you have an opportunity. read more

I worked at the polls during the 2020 election and a very kind person ordered pizza from Vincenza's for all the workers. I remember the slice I had being good but it was awhile ago so I decided to give it another try. I ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza. Wasn't crazy about it. Greasy and salty! I like that it was thin but the taste wasn't very good. I ordered their bread knots. Seemed like some were cooked and others were doughy still. Ordered fries...those tasted fine. Got a salad which was also okay. And ordered tiramisu which was just okay. Everything was just eh. Don't think I'll be coming back to this pizza place. Will be on the hunt for another. read more

See all

Better slices than most places! I'm upping my review to 5 stars based on two things. 1. Noticeably better slices than most other places. I don't think I would have detected these were heated up slices had I not known. They're that good! 2. A deal of a house salad that you can add to any slice for $2.90. This isn't some bargain basement salad either. It's a good size for a side salad, not to mention for $2.90! It has lettuce, onions, grape tomatoes, carrots, cucumber, and black olives! You want a photo? Yeah me too, but I dug in too quickly so dream on! One ding though is that I notice in my previous review I praised their ranch dressing. Today I received Ken's ranch dressing. Why would they do that? I'm hoping it's temporary. Something is seriously wrong though. I've told you all this yet I don't see you walking in the door. What are you waiting for? read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Two slices with pepperoni, sausage, and meatball. These might be their meat lover's but I'm not sure. - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

We were on a liquor mission and after a few samples a piece of pizza was needed. We chose the pepperoni (large thin slices) and had it warmed up. The dough had a nice crisp while still being flexible. LOVE the self serve grated cheese, red pepper flakes etc. read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

Hands down best pizza place. Small italian joint serving authentic style Italian italian pizza. Try it to love it. It has bee our go to for years. Service and Ambiance are ok. read more

Good food but was a wait for pizza of over 20 minutes. Room was quiet. Counter service only

Great NY style Pizza. Very friendly staff. Yelp wants me to write more but I've got nothing else to say. Solid Pizza joint.

This pizzeria is a hidden gem! We found it on Yelp with its good reviews. As soon as we walked in, the small of pizza goodness hit us! We ordered at the front counter and the food was brought to the table we chose. It's a very small restaurant with about 5 tables and a counter area you can sit on. Everyone working here wear a mask. There's 4 TVs which we're playing 4 different sports at the same time. We ordered a slice of cheese pizza ($3.19) and an eggplant parmigiana sub ($8.49). Both were very good and we look forward to coming back soon! read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Eggplant Chicken Parm Sub and Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Meh. We live 5 minutes away and decided to pickup our order instead of having it delivered because we typically find it much more fresh when we pick it up. Unfortunately, this was not the case for us this time. Our order was close to 20 minutes late - which wasn't even the problem. The problem was our pizza was done on time and our stromboli took forever. So because our order wasn't timed properly, upon getting home the pizza had already been out of the oven for an extended period of time. Probably 20+ minutes at least. As we only live 5 minutes away, it is hard to blame ourselves for the issue. I understand that pizzas are normally set on top of the oven to keep them warm, but this is not the same as eating a fresh pizza. We ordered: (6) Garlic Knots $3.19 Large Hawaiian with Mushrooms $27.78 Veggie Stromboli with Pepperoni $12.48 Of course, there were consistency issues. The pie was totally soggy underneath and the cheese had totally clunked together. By the time we were on a second slice it was barely warm. We also found hardly any sauce on the pizza. I am not someone who likes a ton of sauce, but this just tasted like cheese bread. I really wish we could have tried the pizza when it came out of the oven, I am sure we would have enjoyed it much more than we did. One thing I will say is that the large pizza was definitely large - which was appreciated! The garlic knots were deep fried. I wish I knew that because I would not have ordered them. I asked for extra garlic and I am pretty sure we didn't get it. The knot was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, but it was so greasy it was off putting. It also had hardly any flavor. These were not for us. The vegetable stromboli had eggplant inside, which we were excited about it. Unfortunately, the menu does not say the eggplant is breaded and fried. I don't care for fried eggplant and the breading really got separated from the eggplant so there were bites with just breading which was not great. We paid almost $2 extra to add pepperoni and there were maybe 3 slices on the inside. Kind of another disappointment. The food looked a lot better than it tasted. It had great potential but fell flat tonight. Perhaps it was an off night. read more

See all

I love that they have vegan cheese because it gives me something I can eat if I'm with people who want to eat or order from here. The reason I'm giving a 3 is because the prices are a tad ridiculous. We got two large pies and a small side of fries and it was nearly $80 lol so I personally wouldn't order from here if I had the choice because I know better places for less money but I do give props for having vegan options. read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Today, I walked into this place to fill my belly with something delicious and enjoy a quiet, peaceful time. But to my surprise, the owner of this place was scolding one of the cashiers, loudly and in front of all the customers. This is not the way of a wise leader. If you must speak to one of your employees, you should seek the right moment, clearly that moment is not during their work time and especially not in front of the customers. A true leader guides with compassion and justice, not with anger and disrespect. The owner of this place forgot that wisdom is shared in a soft voice and with respect, not with shouts and humiliation. May we all remember to walk in balance and harmony, and to lead with kindness and wisdom. read more

So good! Tiny pizza joint in the strip center with a liquor store and gas station on the west side of 400 at McFarland Rd. Not a lot of tables inside. More of a pick up or delivery place. They were so very busy and my pizza did take longer than anticipated however it was well worth the wait. I ordered a Cheese Pizza / medium and a Antipasto Salad / medium for $26.41 which will feed 2-3 people. It's delicious!!! read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza / Antipasto Salad - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Well first off the food is amazing . They offer a large variety of different pizza's, including Brazilian style pizza . The customer service is amazing as well ! They are super helpful and when you ask for something they get it done right away. I've been coming to this place for years now and I haven't had one bad experience. As soon as you walk in the smell should already be very convincing. This place is awesome !! Definitely try it out . read more

Love Vincenza's Pizzeria! They're my go to when I'm craving a good white pizza. I get it with artichoke, bacon, mushroom, onions, and sun dried tomatoes. So delicious!! They are pretty pricey though so I don't go often. read more

Stopped for dinner with my mom one evening. We were in the mood for pizza and this place did not disappoint! Yummy NY style pizza. They had a special going that included 2 soft drinks and their delicious garlic knots! Will definitely be back! read more

See all

Large pie half sausage other half pepperoni and mushroom, all extra cheese. Solid. When I saw the cups with the Roma Foods logo on them I thought "ok that's promising." Cheese had the right texture, you know, that certain toughness. If you know you know. Sauce was good too. Not sweet, not spicy. Just tomato. Crust not bad. Maybe a bit too dense for me. I like a little more airy. Airy like it gets those puffy bubbles. But all in all decent similar to NJ / NY pizza. You know, the good kind. As far as the place? Expect a no frills atmosphere. Truly a pizza joint. One more thing--no frills to the point of not even grated cheese in a shaker. Packets of cheese like sugar packets. I'll pass on that. read more

Vincenza's Pizzeria - Large pie half sausage other half pepperoni and mushroom, all extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

I've placed several orders for pick-up or delivery, but have yet to come in and dine. The pizzeria is adjacent to the Chevron gas station on McFarland Parkway. Just across the street from their sister restaurant, BB's Bagels. We've ordered the following: Garlic Knots (6 pcs) $2.99 Large White Pizza $21 + Pepperoni $1.75 Large Veggie Pizza $26 + Pepperoni $1.75 Sweet Braid (6 pcs) $3.29 Mini Cannolis $4.99 Everything is made fresh and delicious! Our favorite is the white pizza with pepperoni and I'm embarrassed to tell how often we order it... The large is 20" and the slices are huge! My photos don't do them justice. Delivery usually takes between 45 minutes to an hour, and they tell you that ahead of time. They've delivered to our neighborhood pool and to our house. We've never had any issues. Staff is always friendly. Prices are very reasonable. I look forward to dining at the restaurant soon! read more

See all

The pizza is soooo good and love how huge the large pizzas are. Every time we get pizza it's always great.

Exceptionally good. Build Your Own Stromboli is excellent. Friendly and quick service.

Delicious NY Style pizza! This place is right down from my office and a wonderful regular lunch spot.

Wow what a delight! We had so much going on that we missed breakfast and lunch so we needed a quick late option. Yelp led us to the Vincenza's Pizzeria. Wow the toppings they offer!! The selections and combinations are endless.. I ordered a 14" all meat with the addition of artichoke, mushrooms, and green olives. My wife ordered a 14" pepperoni with jalapeño, and my kids got a 20" large cheese pizza. First... warning warning... the 20" pizza is huge!! I mean super big! Each pizza was perfect... loaded with toppings, the crust was crunchy and soft on the inside... the sauce was savory, and the flavor was ohhhh my Goddie toooo hottie!! I mean these pizzas were perfect. Great crust! Great toppings! Great sauce... just great great great! We will eat from here again soon... the pizza was outstanding... I'm looking forward to my next slice... one thing though... I'm stepping down the sizes... it was A LOT OF FOOD. read more

Love their buffalo wings. Whenever I go, everyone there is super nice. My family and I are regulars.

Definitely good, could be great. We will be back for more. Humm spots - pickup time and center crust. While we were on time, we had to wait 10 - 15 minutes for the pie. We could have stayed home and had more wine. Like a lot of pies, the toppings are clustered in the middle and the crust does not have the structural integrity to hold them. Still good ingredients and good to eat. read more

While the pizzas are wonderful, the calzones are amazing! The location is very convenient off McFarland. There are several tables and booths inside, however, we usually take out our orders. read more

Best pizza and wings ever in town. Service is always friendly and helpful. Highly recommend this family business.

We had the supreme and margarita pizza was very good!! We did take out so can't comment on service or ambience!! Had the left over today for lunch very good still. read more

Best pizza that I have found in this area. It is tucked away by a gas station off McFarland. Great for take out, catering, or a quick bite as it has limited seating inside. Only issue that I had was I ordered a salad and the dressing was a container of Ken's. I prefer house made dressing for salads. read more

I was very disappointed in this restaurant. My first visit. I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza. It was way too large for one person and had way too much cheese on it. It did not look anything like the picture on this app. I ate three slices and as soon as I got home, threw the rest in the trash. When it was served , they provided a flimsy paper plate which disintegrated after a few cuts with my knife and fork. Speaking of knife and fork, none were provided until I asked for them and then I was give a packet with plastic utensils. I noticed other diners with proper utensils and I asked if I might have some like those - which they provided. This place purports to be a dine in or carry out. It really is only a carry out. read more

Buckle in! This review is complicated but f'ed up. I placed an order yesterday afternoon about 4pm through door dash. Two medium pies for delivery. I made a mistake on the order platform. I wanted the pizza to be delivered later in the evening when I got home from work as door dash gives that option. I confirmed the order without setting the delivery time. Realizing I made the error immediately, I cancelled the order within a minute of placing it. Das dash informed me that I would have to eat the cost of the order I cancelled because Vincenza's already started making this order. A bit suspect but okay. I made the error so I understand I had to eat the cost, $65 by the way. I reordered the two medium pizza's, this time correctly for the time I wanted it delivered and confirmed it. The one star rating is for what happened next. Vincenza's proceeds to save and deliver me the original pizza's they made hours earlier that had been sitting in the box under the heat warmer that turned to cardboard. For what? As more punishment for making the error in ordering. IDK I think Vincenza's could have handled this better. read more

Best New York style pizza in the area hands down. Very delicious and generous portion sizes. The inside of the restaurant has a very comfortable feeling to it, the staff are very friendly and helpful. As far as taste and quality are concerned, I would recommend above all other pizzerias. A special thank you to G for the best customer service, and to the owner Mary for going above and beyond to make Vincenza's the best pizzeria in this area! read more