My boyfriend and I always see a crowd when we drive past Vintage Pizza, so we decided to try it out. It was mediocre at best and the service was not great. They are pet friendly on the patio and I had my boyfriend waiting outside with the dogs while I waited at the hostess station. The hostess was on the phone modifying a take out order and it took over 10 minutes for me to even be greeted. From what I remember in my hostess experience, you always serve the customers in person first - turns out this to go order was calling to get double sauce on their pizza and the hostess ran to the kitchen twice while I was waiting. Eventually, someone else greeted me and took me to a table outside. Our server was prompt, but actually kind of rude, and we were not impressed. I ordered a white pizza and it grilled chicken and my boyfriend got the meat lovers pizza. The price was standard for 2 pizzas and alcoholic beverages, but we much prefer other places in the plaza. read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Meat Lover Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

I have gone three times to Vintage Pizzeria, recommended to me by a friend and the food has been amazing every time. Such yummy Italian food, great options for kids, and adults. The it can be a little pricey, but the quality of food and the size of the portion are definitely worth it. However the first time I went it was a bit busy and the service was pretty bad, we got our food at a reasonable time, but the waiter was a little rushed and antsy. Overall, very good! read more

I love this place, I eat it a lot, the pizza is always great and the atmosphere is too

This is one of our favorite pizza spots in the Crabapple area. It doesn't have separate adults and family sections like the Chamblee location does, but the vibe is still good. They have good beers on draft. The pizza is really good, as well as the salads. They do run some specials, such as $4 off a large pizza on Tuesdays. I haven't tried the pastas or sandwiches yet, but I'm guessing those are good also. They also have trivia nights. read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Cheese and garlic large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

This is the first time I tried this location as I have tried the Chamblee and Dunwoody location. There are curbside parking and also parking in the rear of restaurant. I was seated right away as there was nobody else there because it was only 11:30am. I ordered my usual Pizza/Salad lunch special. My house salad was perfect and fresh. The giant slice of pizza here was amazing as I got ground beef and onions. I definitely recommend this place if your in the mood for some good pizza or salad. I can't wait to come back again!! read more

See all

Great pizza in Milton! They have one of the best Greek salads I've had in a long time and delicious pizza. The parking is a little odd as it's either on the street or behind the restaurant, but don't let that deter you. The cheesesteak looked really good and the calzone and all the salads sounded good too. We'll definitely be back to try more things on the menu and another Greek salad! read more

See all

We came to This Pizzeria for lunch and really enjoyed their lunch special! They offer one slice of pizza including one topping, a beautiful salad (house or Cesar), and a fountain beverage or tea for $9.75. I ordered the slice with Sun dried tomatoes. It was huge and terrific! The house salad was also really good! Parking is free and plentiful. The service was quick and efficient. We really look forward to coming back soon. read more

My husband and I eat lunch at Vintage in crabapple at least a couple of times a month. All the food I have ordered has been very good. We especially like the lunch special of a large slice of Pizza ( I usually cannot eat it all), a salad and a drink. We also have eaten various sandwiches, hamburgers and the soup of the day. Vintage provides good service in a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. read more

Took home Birthday Dinner for 12 Yes they did our order of spaghetti, meatballs, caesar salads, 2/fish dinners well. Everything was delicious. They made it all so easy! A successful event. Thanks Vintage Pizza read more

Very consistent food. Good pizza and salads. French fries are to die for. Good choices of beer on tap. Good service. Closes too early! read more

We've been here several times and have always had a good experience. There is parking in the back and a few street parking spots out front. I have never had any issues finding parking here. The dining area is small, but there is also a bar area and a decent sized patio if the weather is cooperating. They have recently opened up every table for seating since the pandemic. If you are doing takeout, the time estimates are accurate, you just check-in and pay at the bar when you arrive or they will bring it out to your car. The kid's meals are for dine-in only and are very reasonably priced. I love that you can get just a slice of pizza with a kid's meal, instead of having to order an entire pizza that only your kid likes. Their wings are good as well, even though the sauce could use a kick. I always ask for them extra crispy and they oblige nicely. Last, but not least is of course the pizza. It is thin and the cheese is great. You can tell the ingredients are quality and it is a step above others. read more

Caesar Salad w/Blackened Shrimp was amazing!! I loved the dark lettuce!! Thanks Emily for great service!! read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Caesar Salad w/Blackened Shrimp was amazing!! I loved the dark lettuce!! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Just ordered a large 1.5 topping pizza for pickup. $28...they default pickup orders at 20%. What?? Decent pizza but mine was under-baked. First time and last time ordering from this place. read more

We had a really good time at this hidden gem. The Cesar salad was a little bland but I'm sure the masses love it. ( more Anchovies and Garlic please) the presentation was nice. The pizza was really good lots of basil - but the pasta my bf ordered with off the menu spicy sauce was sadly a one note sauce. It probably would have been good if it had simmered for a while - we will definitely go back. The server Valerie and the Ambience was really nice! read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Lively bar - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

Stopped in with the family on Friday evening. Although the experience was ok the pizza just wasn't as good as I remember it. It was under done and lacked anything special about it. We also got the cheese steak pizza which lacked toppings. I would also describe the service as rather rude. The place was busy but the staff acted kind they worked at Dicks Last Resort. I can't see us trying it again. There is too much competition. Try Capania which blows Vintage away in terms or quality of food and attitude of its employees. read more

I've had the entire menu, and most everything here is absolutely delicious. The standouts are the cheese pizza, meatballs, and the spinach salad, but the cheese steak here is out of this world good, truly something special. This is one of the best sandwiches in Alpharetta. read more

/TL;DR This is my new neighborhood pizza joint. I literally mean that. I just moved into the area. ;-) It's a pretty good spot for New York style pizza. /ATMOSPHERE You know, I am glad I ate the pizza before I saw the carousel oven. That would have sent my bias into foodie territory. Overlook that if you happen to look behind the counter. It doesn't matter here. The interior and exterior seating spaces are all pretty nice. It's on Broadwell though so if you're sitting outdoors at the wrong time, you should expect a steady flow of traffic. /FOOD I've tried a number of their pizzas but really love the blue/white combination. It's basically half a blue pie and half a white pie. The blue pie is your hot wing pizza style. The white pie is the heavy garlic, white style. Great together. Their Greek salad is also pretty good. Haven't tried the subs myself our family did and really enjoyed it. /SERVICE One of my favorite things about this place is the way they do pizza halves. It costs exactly half of the full price. If you get a $16 half and $14 half, you get charged $8 + $7... not just the full price for the most expensive part. HOW TO READ MY REVIEWS: 1 Star - Does not approach edible. Enter at your own risk. 2 Stars - If I'm in the area, I'd pick something else. 3 Stars - I would stop by if I happen to be in the area. 4 Stars - I would pick this place out of other places nearby. 5 Stars - I would go out of my way to dine here. read more

"Vintage Pizzeria, where 12 inches is small!" If you were to ask me where the best place to get a slice for lunch in Alpharetta, Vintage is my number one pick. They are huge, thin, and perfect for the classic folding of a New York (or in this case NJ) slice. The interior is classy and casual. Service is a team effort and always great. Good selection of draft beer, and if you like cheap beer with your pizza, PBR served up cold as well. While the regular pizza is good in the evening, nothing beats the lunch pie slices. Miles to Jersey, minutes to Vintage! read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

We have passed the spot a couple of times and when we looked it up on yelp the reviews definitely made us want to try them. We got two pizzas to go, both large, their white pizza with the pesto sauce and then their veggie pizza. The white pizza was so delicious! I am definitely ordering another white pizza to go. The sauce is so delicious, with garlic and pesto, and the crust was not too thick so it really was amazing. The veggie pizza was OK to me personally, the crust was honestly rather soggy which really kills pizza for me. If the crust had not been so soggy I honestly would have thought the veggie pizza was way better. But like I said I will be back again for their white pizza! read more

Great food and great service! Would recommend for families. Kind workers and easy to get food to go

The lunch slice and salad can't be beat! Huge slice and cold crisp salad. The eggplant Parm and calzone are also delicious.

When we got there they told us to sit anywhere. We ended up leaving after waiting 10 minutes to be served. The staff looked our way many of times and not one of them even bothered to acknowledge us with a "I'll be right with you" or anything. read more

Love the simplicity of getting pizza here. The pies are tasty and a large variety available. Courteous and pleasant staff attending to your needs. Give it a try - I personally like the plain cheese pizza! read more

Amazing place to eat, great servers and staff. The BBQ chicken pizza and the Philly cheesesteak pizza is by far the best pizza for the money, and I've even taken multiple trips to NYC just to try pizza! 10/10 will be back again, if I could rate it higher than 5 stars I would read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Don't let the lighting deceive you, this pizza is hot and fresh! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I've had lunch and dinner several times at Vintage Pizza. The food is good but the service on every visit was terrible. The people that work there seem inconvenienced to take care of their customers. I will not go back. read more

Great za, one of our top 5 pizza locations in the area, parking can be a pain but food and staff are excellent

Food here is solid...tasty pizza and salads. Good ambience and mostly friendly service. Came here on a Thursday night, which is apparently trivia night and an extremely busy time for them. When we first walked in, there wasn't a hostess or anyone there to ask about a table. Flagged down a waitress eventually, then after awhile a lady came by and said she had no idea when a table would become available, since it was trivia night. However we could be seated outdoors, which we opted for. Our waitress was very friendly and pretty attentive, especially since it was so busy. Everything came out in a timely manner. Neat ambience too, interior has all exposed brick and the front patio was nice. The small salads to start with were pretty big. Caesar was really good...fresh with homemade croutons and delish dressing, they are heavy on the dressing though. Ordered a large pizza, they're generous with the cheese and toppings. It's somewhat thin crust, more like a hand tossed style, not super thin. Based on other pics, the individual slices look much thinner. Good sauce and had a nice chew to it. Drinks were solid too. Overall pretty good pizza and friendly service. Menu offers a good amount of options, even if you don't want pizza. Would definitely return, just not on a Thursday night. read more

See all

Great customer service I made an account just to say this. the guy with the ear plug was great to me and very helpful

One of the best white pizzas I have ever had, and spinach salad was delicious as well!

Vintage is one of our favorite eateries in Milton. It's close to home for us, has delicious food and excellent service. The menu offers mainly Italian fare but also offers salads, subs, wings and burgers. Their pizza's are unique combos of fresh ingredients. We had our traditional calamari appetizer which is also unique because it's got fried okra and fried jalapeños mixed with the squid. More on that later. My beautiful wife is an eggplant Parmesan fan and the Vintage's is dredged in a deliciously thick marinara sauce. It is one of the best around. I ordered fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken in it. Remember the fried sliced jalapeños in the calamari? I cut them in half and mixed them with my fettuccine dish and then hit it with some chili flakes. Wow! Our server was a neighbor high schooler named Evan and he was ever present and fantastic. Thank you Evan! (We'll let your folks known that you were awesome!) Try Vintage in Milton. It's terrific! read more

See all

Placed a pick up order for 2 Large Pizzas, an order of Wings with blue cheese and ranch, and a pasta dish substituting chicken for blackened shrimp. The wings were the size of a thumb (photo for reference), we did not receive the dressings. And the pasta order was not correct. The phone call was loud, there could have been miscommunication. But BLACKENED shrimp was received in a broth, with no pasta. We called the restaurant to confirm our itemized order. Spoke to someone who seemed to be understanding and wanting to accommodate, but needed to get a manager on the phone. Emily, who took the order (and we assume is the manager) defends the order taking and did not even care to have any concerns about our satisfaction. Terrible take out experience when we were wanting to avoid a chain pizza restaurant night. read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Wings are small! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

It is a good little place to eat if you want a good meal. The food is pretty good as I have tried pizza and pasta. The decor is pretty ok on the inside and has a nice look. The outdoor decor is not great as there is only tables and chairs with nothing else. The servers are usually pretty good and it takes maybe 10 minutes for your food to be out. read more

Great atmosphere! Loved the brick walls and lantern style lighting. Had a simple lunch of a single sliced pizza and greek salad. My husband and I were able to eat for less than $15! read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Delish small Greek salad! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

We were pleasantly surprised. When we sat down at the bar and saw that towering carousel pizza oven we didn't hold out much hope; but this was either a really good pie or we were hypnotized by all those pizzas going round and round and round. The thin crust came out perfectly. Crisp on the outside but not at all dry with a nice taste.. The sausage had a nice tangy flavor and the mushrooms were fresh. The cheese was top shelf. Great pizza. We ordered a salad- unremarkable, and cheese fries, many of which were not done. Despite the fries and the salad, it is, after all, a pizzeria and they made a great pizza! read more

Vintage Pizzeria - Pizza Oven at Vintage - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Best pizza in Milton. Staff is great...family atmosphere as the turnover is super low. Also the house salad with chicken and meatball subs are top notch. read more

Nice menu, quick service and tasty food! I was in the mood for a salad and ordered a small Antipasto salad. Nice fresh salad with meat/cheese rolls, black olives, peppers, pepperonci and nice dressing. Also had the garlic bread. My son had two slices of pizza. The place was busy, but our server and associates kept us happy. The owner or manager also came by. Will return again! read more

I added extra cheese and meatballs as my toppings. I like my pizza pretty simple; if it's made right with quality ingredients, you don't need a lot of toppings. I have to say this is literally one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten in my life of 45 years. And trust me, my standards are pretty high. The pizza has just the right amount of sauce and cheese and the crust was ON POINT. I could taste the quality. I literally keep having flash backs. I can't say enough good things it was amazing! read more

Ordered using Postmates. Simple order (I thought) a medium pizza and a spinach salad. Well, maybe it was the fact that I asked for mushrooms on one half and meatballs on the other, I don't know, but when my order was delivered there was NO SALAD and the pizza wasn't what I ordered! I called the restaurant immediately and was basically told it wasn't their fault!!!! REALLY? I'M NEVER GIVING VINTAGE MY BUSINESS AGAIN!!!!! read more

Food was ok at best. Not very well executed. There are other options in the area. A friend said it use to be good

We've been ordering regularly during COVID because this is one of our favorite restaurants, but their limited hours and our last two orders have been disappointing. Two weeks ago, the house salad was missing cheese when we got it home. $9 for lettuce, tomatoes, and onions is ridiculous. This week we were charged $1.50 to add lettuce and tomato to a sandwich! We're done. read more