Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Wicked Lilly

    4.3 (4 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Wicked Lilly Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Wicked Lilly

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Dena H.
    519
    576
    1258

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Todd N.
    1
    85
    114

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mia M.
    1
    12
    18

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bars 948 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Atlantic at the Tryst

    The Atlantic at the Tryst

    4.1(446 reviews)
    0.0 km
    $$

    Brought my daughter here for her birthday dinner on our last night in Puerto Rico, and the setting…read morealone makes it worth a visit. Right on the beach, beautiful views, lovely atmosphere -- exactly what you want for a special occasion dinner in San Juan. We made a reservation and noted it was a birthday celebration. The staff acknowledged it at check-in, which was a nice touch, but that was the extent of it. Once we were seated, the birthday wasn't mentioned again -- which, for a restaurant at this price point, felt like a missed opportunity. The food was genuinely good. The guacamole was fresh and well-seasoned, served with malanga and tortilla chips -- a nice twist on the classic. The poke bowl was solid, fresh tuna, clean flavors, well-balanced. The star of the table was the grilled octopus with achiote -- tender, flavorful, served over a pigeon peas risotto with truffle oil. Really well executed. Service, though, needed work. Water glasses went empty and stayed that way. Had to flag down the waiter for a second drink. For a restaurant at this price level, that's the kind of thing you notice. The food earns the visit. The service needs to catch up to the setting.

    I honestly did not expect to love the brunch so much. I mostly wanted to go for vibes and to enjoy…read morethe drag show, which was great, but the food was a pleasant surprise! I ordered the bottomless mimosas, which came with an appetizer and an entree. For my appetizer I ordered the watermelon bowl, which was pretty good, but basic. I did love that the watermelon had actual seeds in it, which I NEVER see in the states. For my entree I ordered the salmon salad, which was delicious! The salmon was cooked well and the salad tasted fresh. My side of fries were also tasty. My main complaint is that service was a little slow at times. Although I understand the restaurant was full, one of my friend's did not receive her final drink for almost an hour. However, this would not deter me from returning.

    Photos
    The Atlantic at the Tryst - Bar area

    Bar area

    The Atlantic at the Tryst - Chicharron de Calamares

    Chicharron de Calamares

    The Atlantic at the Tryst - Seating area with steps down to the beach

    See all

    Seating area with steps down to the beach

    Arena Medalla - Mac and cheese with pork

    Arena Medalla

    3.3(67 reviews)
    2.1 km

    T-Mobile District was such a fun place to visit at night! There are tons of restaurant options, but…read morewe chose this one because it had the biggest variety of different types of food. We ordered an appetizer, a burger, pasta, and a traditional Puerto Rican dish, and everything was delicious. It also seems like a great place to catch a game, with huge screens in the middle of the district and TVs throughout the restaurant. The staff was very friendly, the service was great, and the restaurant was spotless. My only complaint--and this seems to be true almost everywhere we've been in San Juan--is that it was freezing inside. Definitely bring a light sweater if you get cold easily! Would definitely recommend!

    I was really excited for Arena Medalla. We booked the Brazil game through OpenTable, which also…read morehappened to be on my birthday. We paid $101.95 in advance and arrived about 10 minutes before kickoff. Despite arriving before the match started, we were not seated. Staff spent several minutes "checking on it," and after the match had already begun, we were simply told there was "a problem with the table," with no clear explanation. From what I could see, it appeared our table may have been given away or the event may have been oversold. What made it worse was watching people from the walk-in line continue to be let inside while we stood there with our reservation. We were eventually invited to wait inside, but that meant standing in the doorway, directly in the servers' path, while the match was already underway. What bothered me most was the complete lack of respect, honesty, and basic hospitality. A simple, "We're sorry, we made a mistake. Let's get you inside, find you a seat at the bar, and put a cold beer in your hand while we sort this out," would have changed the entire experience. Instead, we were left standing around like an inconvenience. The frustrating part is that punctuality only seemed to matter when it benefited them. We missed the start of the match because of their reservation issue, and then when the match ended, we were asked to leave immediately before we had even finished our beer. It ruined the whole point of coming: watching the Brazil match in a sports-bar atmosphere for a birthday night. If you take prepaid reservations for a game-day event, honor them. If something goes wrong, own it and fix it. This experience was a huge disappointment.

    Photos
    Arena Medalla - Canada vs. Bel World Cup

    Canada vs. Bel World Cup

    Arena Medalla
    Arena Medalla

    See all

    El Refrán - NY strip with Root vegetable mash

    El Refrán

    4.5(335 reviews)
    0.2 km
    $$

    We ended up dining at Refran for dinner our first night in San Juan and it did not disappoint. Our…read moreserver was so sweet and attentive. We ordered the bacalaitos (codfish fritters) as an appetizer and the mofongo with shrimp (and another with pernil). The bacalaitos were perfectly fried, not greasy. The mofongo was the best mofongo I had in San Juan! It was full of flavor and the shrimp was the perfect compliment. My son housed their rice and beans. My husband ordered the tres leches cake. It was probably the best tres leches I've ever had. We'll definitely return next time we're in San Juan.

    A very small restaurant with absolutely authentic Puerto Rican food with about 10 tables or so,…read moreabsolutely do not miss this place! So what do you get by coming here? You get the real deal, real Puerto Rican dishes, with the greatest flavors and fair prices. Unless you prefer playing overpriced, find dining restaurants with average Puerto Rican food, which there are plenty of in the area. I'm not able to emphasize how small this restaurant is, it's located right along the main walking strip in Coronado Beach. Maybe 10 tables or so. No reservations walk up wait in line if you have to eat and leave. Not only will you eat the best tasting food during your trip, but probably also pay the least amount of money. We went here twice! Their rice and beans recipe is probably what it's all about! We got grilled shrimp and skirt steak over rice and beans and honestly, I could've had it all week long! This little gem local place is not to be missed! Highly recommended!

    Photos
    El Refrán
    El Refrán - Skirt steak on top of a bed of rice and beans

    Skirt steak on top of a bed of rice and beans

    El Refrán - Steak Quesadillas

    See all

    Steak Quesadillas

    Wicked Lilly - bars - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...