A charming mom & pop kind of place, with delicious pizza to feed a crowd! The kids are picky about…read moretheir pizza and asked for extra slices, gobbling them up. Our baby niece was overjoyed to gnaw on the crust, and cried whenever she ran out. The dough was pillowy soft, the crust was crispy, and it wasn't too greasy. If you're looking for a great local pizza place in Auburn, Amelia's is your place!

Needed a quick slice so stopped here. Inside of this place isn't very appealing. The pizza though…read moreis really good. The plain cheese was great. No flop and cooked to perfection. Nice sauce and cheese ratio. The Sicilian was average but not bad. It looks burnt in the picture but I like it that way. They had tons of flavors of pizza ready for their lunch rush. If you are in the area, try this place.

Amazing! Not only is the pizza great but their subs are the best I've ever had. Homemade bread is…read morebaked everyday and used to create your custom sub. I had a chess take with horseradish and was blown away.

Ordered cheese steak sandwich tonight. It was horrible, tasted like bbq sauce on it no beef taste…read moreat all. Never again

They have really good food at a decent price the bartender Alyssa is awesome. I was asking if you…read moreneed something else. I always enjoy going there whenever I'm in town.

Hadn't been here since last year when I was staying in the hotel. Just as good as I remembered…read more The open steak sandwich is awesome! A nice size New York strip, perfectly cooked with sautéed mushrooms on a piece of crunchy garlic bread. First rate onion rings as well. I really recommend this spot if you are in the area. The hotel is five star as well!

I was in town to visit my wife's family in Auburn, NY. My father-in-law spoke highly of this pizza…read morespot so we had to try it. Papa Paulie's is a small establishment with long wait times. They have very limited hours of operation. It is advised to call ahead and expect your pizza to be ready 45-60 minutes, minimum. Service was great. The young lady that took my order was kind and courteous. The gentleman that took my payment was cool and efficient. The pizza is good. Very good. I do wish the pepperonis had more flavor. I also wish the pizza was less greasy. We ordered a large and it was about the size of a typical medium. The crust is thick and the edges are crisp. For Auburn, New York, it is a great spot to order from. I am happy that we were able to support a small business. My only real complaint is the extremely limited hours of operation. Coming from LA, most businesses are open 7 days a week from 10am-8 or 9pm.

The Absolute Best Pizza!!! Thank you for making the most…read moredelicious pizza in Cayuga County.

I'm struggling with this review because while I acknowledge there were pieces of this experience…read morethat were somewhat out of their control, they could have taken control. I placed a pickup online order for a pizza and wings. Unfortunately there's no way to see the ETA for your order until you place and pay for your order online. They quoted me 1-1.5 hours wait time, which honestly was pretty disappointing to start, but I did give my phone number so if the wait time was shorter they could have called me. I waited, arrived after an hour (the earliest my food was estimated to be ready) and walked into a dark corner of the bar where the business was supposed to be mildly concerned they closed and didn't contact me. Apparently they close at 9p, the range of time was 8:35-9:05 which should probably be fixed in the online system. They were able to find my food, brought it out after a bit of confusion, and handed me a not very warm box. I brought it home (very short drive) to see a cold pizza with congealed cheese, and cold wings. The wings were supposed to be medium buffalo traditional wings, they were totally dry. It was like someone squirt a teaspoon of buffalo sauce after the fact. The pizza crust is odd; I get what people mean when they say it's like cornmeal. It really is, and when you receive the pizza cold, it's totally inflexible. The crust is good, I like that they bring the cheese all the way to the end. I gave it 3 stars because if I had received it at a palatable temperature and the wings actually had sauce, I bet it would be a decent meal. It's just really disappointing that after $40 plus tip that was the food I received and the experience I had. I appreciate online ordering, but I doing think this business is ready for it, or at least should consider different software to prevent this happening again.

Place was dirty, multiple health code violations, lady in the back was very rude and dishonest,…read morepizza was bland, should have gone to Little Cesar's.

Everytime I went here, food was either burnt (hard, overcooked skin) or not available (yes, I went…read moreonce and KFC had no chicken.) Service at the counter was indifferent.

Incredibly unprofessional and incompetent staff. Came in for an interview and and left completely…read moredisgusted. There's no reason I should be sitting here for 30 minutes late for an interview at a fast food establishment, that's unheard of. I would hate to see this place if it was actually busy. 0 stars

Pizza Hut should close it's doors. They believe themselves so large, they won't answer the phone…read more They lie when they say, business is booming. I tried an app just to get flagged for a fraud alert. Thank heave s for my credit union. If you want my business, pick up the phone instead of having someone in Florida. You ask for a supervisor, again, no one has a supervisor, imagine none of us having not to answer. . Dream job. Called Curley's, they answered. Good job Pizza Hut!

Food was surprisingly good and hot. Buffet salad section needed to be refilled never happened. 80%…read moreof the tables were dirty and waiter never came by to see if we needed anything.

Using GrubHub, I ordered 1 pepperoni pizza. Nothing fancy. Ordered at 8pm on a Friday (they close…read moreat 10pm). They said the order would be done by 9pm. Come 9:35pm, the order was still waiting and 10 min later it was cancelled due to "the order being unable to be completed". A refund was issued. Don't understand how they could not finish a pizza in 2 hours. Don't recommend for further orders at this locations.

I guess I should have checked Yelp before I ordered a pizza from this place. I ordered and paid…read moreonline. Pick up the scheduled for between 5:00 p.m. and 5:05 p.m. Arrived at 5:00 p.m. Zero pizzas in the coded warming bins. Waiting... No employees at the front counter half a dozen other people waiting for service. The place is filthy. I'm watching somebody cutting and boxing up pizzas wearing no gloves with a large afro bent over the food with no hair net. Finally at 10 after 5:00 I walk around the counter and yell into the back for somebody to come up and get my order for me. Five more minutes before I get the order. The pizza looks like somebody ran it over with a steam roller. The pepperoni looks like it's been sitting forever and is turned a light tan color and as hard as a rock. It is more than obvious that whoever owns/ manages this dump doesn't give a crap about the business, the product, or the customers. I wouldn't go back if they are offered me free pizza for life.