With so many pizza places in the area and moving back to the area after.several years I had…read moreforgotten about East of Chicago. Placed an order last week via the website for a standard pepperoni pan and was not disappointed. Can see why they were voted a favorite at the Marysville Pizza Challenge.

Great place, became a home staple for my family weekly. We recently moved to Ohio last year and…read morehave been finding a good place for pizza and settled on East of Chicago and are pretty happy after trying lots of other places nearby. Good prices and even some unique pizzas like the taco pizza. Staff is friendly when you call and always happy to help you with your order/delivery as well.

Ty MW&Thingz, Marion, Oh for a 5 Star sweet and O'sooo…read moregood, savory, chicken wing meal combo....on a Sunday evening. I've tried several of your sauces, but this is my 1st time trying this combination. It was very pleasing to my eyes & very satisfying to my palate! Hot & Fresh! Just the way I like it! Most def will be back 4 more! 5 Star! Loved your 5-Star curb side service! Most def will be back to try somethg else!

This place has improved over the past 2 years, but it's still just ok and a few bad eggs and…read moremediocre kitchen continue to hold it back. With that being said, it's always just slightly "good enough" to go back. With that being said, BOGO night is literally the only positive thing about BW3 as a chain in 2026.

Great service and atmosphere! JD and Dave do a great job keeping smiles on everyone. The new menu…read moreis a hit along with the new rewards program.

This small down gem, located in an old dairy bar, has great food. The portions are large. You can…read moreseriously get two days worth on an order or feed two people. They have a select menu plus a menu that rotates weekly. Everything is fresh and flavorful. The owner and his staff are amazing and will bend over backwards for you. I can't recommend this place highly enough!

We were in Bellfountain and stopped here for lunch. This place is take out only, no tables. It's a…read morehealthy option. I had the Mediterranean bowl. It had grilled chicken (chewy but tasted good,) brown rice, Kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, cuke bees, chickpeas, and roasted red peppers. A serving of good tzatziki sauce came with it. I had a side of the slaw which was way too creamy. My son had the Asian bowl. Same good chicken he said he liked it. He also had a side of hot potato salad which was just ok. I'll try some other things next time.

Wings. This simply is the place in Richland county to get wings. Even the plain dry rubber ones…read moreare stellar. Atmosphere wise, it's like stepping into an old English pub. The real kind, not the Instagram ready pretty one. Nice people, great food.

We went here with some friends today, and were not impressed. The service was slow, and the food…read morewasn't that great. I don't know why everyone is raving about the wings, because mine were hard and dry, and the garlic parmesan coating wasn't sticking to them at all, just kind of laying there in clumps. Their fries had an odd seasoning on them, were kind of limp, and not very crispy. They brought my bf a Reuben when he had ordered a burger, and by the time they finally brought the right one out, almost everyone else at the table was finished eating. We ended up taking it home to eat later, and were given no compensation for the error. Also, I ordered six wings at $1 each, and when we checked our receipt later, they charged us for seven. Not a ton of money, but irritating nonetheless. I guess it always pays to check your receipt before you pay. Our waitress was not very knowledgeable about the specials of the day or the beer selection, and was also not very attentive. It took forever for the food to come, as well as getting the checks and to-go boxes. I guess as long as the locals think it's a good place to go, they should do OK......lol.

My daughter ordered a pizza from the Marysville store for 7.99$ went to pick it up and got charged…read more15.99$ well needless to say it came out of the bank she seen the mistake and asked why they didn't honor the original price which was 7.99$ argued about the price till she took her phone out and showed them what we were supposed to pay 7.99$ so now I got 25.00$ in this medium size pizza so now I called them and asked why the 15.99$ hasn't been returned and the answer I got from this "manager" we don't double charged a card twice and proceeded to tell me sorry about your luck you want your money back take it up with your bank if this guy wasn't a jerk to me I may have over looked the foul and still order from there but now I'm boycotting dominoes. I really enjoyed their pizza too

Placed an order online. Used a gift card for part of the purchase and credit card for the balance…read more Received a confirmation and a delivery time. Checked order a it showed cancelled but still charged the cards. Called the store and spoke to the manager who was not helpful and would not send the food even though she could see the order and not explain why it was cancelled. Her customer service skills need a lot of improvement. No more Dominos pizza here as service is king

Outstanding Experience - A Hidden Gem Worth the Trip…read more Although we're visiting from out of town and staying nowhere near the area, my wife and I were looking for a spot off the beaten path--and we're so glad we found this place. Simply put: they delivered. I ordered the jerk chicken, which was incredibly flavorful. The jerk sauce had great depth, and the chicken had a rich, smoky quality that really stood out. For sides, I tried the peach baked beans, which were different than expected but still solid--I'd rate them a 7.5/10. The coconut rice with sweet potato, however, was exceptional--possibly the best rice side I've ever had. 9.5/10. My wife had the brisket, and we both agreed it was excellent--8.5/10. The kids ordered chicken tenders (surprisingly delicious) and a cheeseburger, which had great flavor. We just wished it came with traditional burger toppings. We'll be in town for another week and definitely plan to return before we leave. I also spoke with the manager--very friendly and welcoming--and he offered some helpful recommendations for things to do in the area, which we appreciated. The restaurant itself may look like a bit of a hole in the wall, but don't let appearances fool you--this place is damn close to perfect. Well done!

Disappointed in the food. The brisket was very dry and tough. No smoke flavor in the brisket or…read morepulled pork. Miso collards were a highlight. For the price, go somewhere else in YS.