Cancel

Open app

Search

Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

5.0 (1 review)
Closed 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza Photos

You might also consider

More like Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

5 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 12,919 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Grainery

The Grainery

3.8
(125 reviews)
0.1 mi
$$

Nice place!!! Except, the music trivia was a bit loud. We had friends visiting from out of town, so…read morewe were hoping to catch up. Food was pretty good and the deal for Taco Tuesday was fab! Andrew really made the night awesome, he was the best server I had in a while.

Modernized historic building with a large stage for live music/ open mic night- two bars. The…read morelargest TV I've ever seen behind the stage. Thecwaitress told us they bring in Nashville muscians;some that are starting out. The food was amazing! Theur menu is small but poserful. They are connected to Pioneer Pizza who makes theur subs and pizzas plus they smoke their meats on site snd had 3 house sauces on the table. I had the smoked wings. Naked but rubbed with a dry seasoning. The wings fell off the bone and were so flavorable! No sauce was needed. But I tried the three table sauces. Hubs had an italian sub. Heand I agreed it was provably the best italian sub we"ve ever had. I ordered the Grainery salad - it was great because I like Blue Cheese ceuymbles and red onion. Both flavors were strong so avoid it you are not a fan. I ordered the large and feel it was the equivilant of a side salad-kinda small. The Grainery attracted groups if friends, families with yound children and couples out fir a dare night. Highly recommend! Our server was great. I try not to ask "what is your favorite menu item"? Instead ask what is poplular. Our server had a real passion for the food, the history of the building and the Plain City community. When our meal was over, she directed us to the complimentary soft service ice cream with toppings. Great way to enjoy a touch of sweet after the savory meal! We will return!

Photos
Ice Cream station
Ice Cream station
Brisket tacos and salad
Brisket tacos and salad
Terrible Quesadilla

See all

Terrible Quesadilla
The Red Hen Cafe & Bakery

The Red Hen Cafe & Bakery

4.7
(65 reviews)
0.5 mi
$$

Get in the car and come here! The food was amazing! I can't wait to go again. Order at the…read morecounter and the servers will bring you your food. The chicken salad was so good and fruity. It was served on a toasted croissant. My husband had an egg sandwich on a croissant. We also had a delicious chocolate chip cookie with a pinch of salt on top. The place was pretty crowded for a late lunch on a Thursday. Quiet and comfortable. Perfect for conversation with your partner. I highly recommend this breakfast and lunch location. I will be back!

I'm not often in Plain City, but my sister-in-law had been raving about Red Hen for quite a while,…read moreand I finally had a chance to try it. First, let me say, this place gets BUSY on a Saturday. Parking can be challenging at times (I circled the block twice before a spot opened up). They have two patio areas so you can sit outside when the weather is nice. They have a pretty standard coffee menu, with seasonal offerings, and a lunch and breakfast menu as well. Let's talk about the coffee - I tried their blackberry blossom latte - and if I was wearing socks, they would have been blown off. Best latte I've ever had, and it's not even close. I also tried a half order of the Nest, which is a small skillet with hash browns, eggs, sausage, cheese, and gravy, with a side of toast. The perfect breakfast ensemble! It was delicious, and was scarfed down in short order. I can't recommend this spot enough. Worth the trip out to Plain City!

Photos
To go order for your private events
To go order for your private events
Friendly staff of locals
Friendly staff of locals
Sitting right by the parking lot

See all

Sitting right by the parking lot
Nickalena's

Nickalena's

4.3
(3 reviews)
0.0 mi

Had a great lunch buffet today, the pizza was delicious, excellent crispy thin crust and great…read moretoppings. Service was top notch. I highly recommend you give them a try

This place has been half a dozen different pizza joints since I lived out here 15 years ago. This…read morenewest one I can't quite figure out. It says Nickalena's, and on their Facebook page it says "formerly Lee's." But all of the signs outside say Lee's; maybe they just changed over. And the bar upstairs seems to be somewhat separate from the dining area downstairs. I'm guessing that the bar is still Lee's, and the pizza place is now Nickalena's. There are separate entrances, restaurant one on the right, downstairs, but there are interior stairs so you can move between the two. It's very basic. Pizza and subs, a few tables, nothing fancy. The reason I came out was they have a pizza buffet, every day 11 to 1. About $15. And it's pretty good pizza. Thin and fairly crispy, lots of cheese, loads of toppings, party cut. A pretty standard Columbus style pizza. They had four on the table when I got there. A nice variety. Fresh and hot, and pretty darn good. I ate till I was stuffed. It's a value if you do that. You pay for drinks, and there is a fountain. Service was minimal but friendly and helpful. If I lived out here again, I'd be here fairly often. And if you want a pizza buffet, there aren't that many options around Columbus, so if you are over this way it's worth hitting up.

Photos
Specials menu
Specials menu
Inside
Inside
Pizza menu

See all

Pizza menu

Buckeye Barbeque and Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...