We came in on Saturday 5/2/26 around 5:45 and put our names on the waitlist. We grabbed a beer from…read moreKitchen 794 (which we also love) while we waited for our table. It was busy - as expected. But the overall vibe of the place is so cozy and intimate. We love it! We were able to sit at the bar and Hailey took such good care of us! She was attentive, friendly and made great cocktails! Started with a Smoked Pineapple Flan cocktail and a dirty martini. Both were delicious! Loved the martini glass. We each had a side Caesar salad to start. The lettuce was crisp and the dressing was perfect. Once again, we had the Old Chicago on Sicilian crust. One of these days I'm going to try the deep dish, I swear! But that Sicilian is just so dang good! It was perfection as usual. This was the first time we ordered dessert. I saw the Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlée and KNEW I was going to order it. OMG, it was everything I wanted it to be. Perfection. Excellent experience - again. Thank you, Capone's!

Love capones the lasagna is great the deep dish pizza is awesome its a must try the service was…read moregreat as well

I wasn't sure I was going to like the twist, but had to order it. Ask I can say is WOW! The flavor…read morecombination was perfect. We also ordered the bruschetta, and that too had lovely flavors. The hot wings were amazing. The ranch dressing is so much better than any ranch I can get on the west coast. Will definitely be back the next time I am visiting the area.

Their interesting and creative spins on how to make a pizza prove delicious! I'm so glad we found…read morethis place.

I love, love, LOVE pizza! Muskegon has a couple of "hometown favorites" that are near and dear to…read moremy heart, Top Shelf makes the best pizza I've EVER had...not just in Muskegon but of any I've had anywhere in the country. The cheese blend, the quality ingredients, the delicious crust...mmm-mmm-MMM! Granted, occasionally, there are times when other delivery stops are made between the time the driver leaves the store and makes it to our house, which means the cheese has 'set' and is no longer ooey-gooey, but those times are rare; 9 out of 10 times when it gets here it's still as hot as when it came out of the oven and the cheese is still deliciously soft and stringy, just like pizza cheese should be. On those occasions, the taste and quality can't be beat! I recommend Top Shelf pizza WHOLE-HEARTEDLY!!

The service was quick the pizza is great but the subs not so much we ordered a roast beef there was…read morehardly any meat on it. Oh the wings are great also.

No other pizza needs to exist honestly. If you come to Muskegon then Mr.scribs (simply Scrib's) is…read morea must . The service is good enough to get you what you asked for. Don't show up expecting some white table BS. The vibe is really rustic and has character, you know what you're getting into. Dont act a fool and you won't get treated like one. The pizza comes in a paper bag so less waste. Get the box if you're driving far

Consistently goor pizza. Year after year. The onion rings are also a family favorite. Service is…read morequick and personable. As for ambiance, it's a pizza joint. No frills, ALL SKILLS! I love that they haven't changed much about the place in decades. It feels like a visit home.

We came in on Sunday, 3/1/26 around 6:15 and sat at the bar. We were thrilled to see Carinna who…read morewas the bartender the last time we were here and recommended the wine school that they have the first Monday of every month! That deserved its own review and I can't believe I didn't! Carinna is definitely a highlight. She is so friendly and personable. We started with an espresso martini and a dirty martini, both were SO good. For an appetizer we had the spinach artichoke dip. It's served with seasoned toast points and it's incredible. For our entrees he had the Sunday prime rib special, he added 4oz for a total of 12oz. It was served with 2 sides for $20!! He also had it blackened which gave it an amazing flavor! I had the side antipasto salad and loved it! I liked that I had the option to order a side size or entree size. That's an option work all their salads, I love it! We really like how low key Handsome Hobo's is. Hobo's next door is great too - but it's much louder. Nothing wrong with that, but sometimes it's nice to have things a little quieter. Everything here is great, highly recommend!!

Artichoke dip and pita bread outstanding! Our waitress awesome!…read more Manager Cailyn short and not friendly at all!! Outside seating needs umbrella for customer use if they choose to do so.

I've been here only a handful of times over the years and each time they have been consistent and I…read morewould say a decade of consistence is a pretty good sign. The pizza is pretty good and they've got a ton of options for sizes and toppings -- including gluten free options! You might want to give take away a try though as the place itself is pretty small and the parking is truly awful as it's extra small angle parking, I can only imagine how many fender benders they've had over the years.

Excellent service and great atmosphere. Wife got the…read morecauliflower crust pizza, I got the wet burrito, and our friend got the fried mushrooms. Everyone was very happy with their food. Each order was large and required a take home box.

Downtown muskegon for the art fair and had a really nice meal on the patio here. I was skeptical…read moreabout the taco pizza but my friend swore it was good and I agree, really nice! I had the mamas sandwich which was also really nice, had nice flavor and the price was very reasonable. I will definitely be back.

Awesome dog friendly (server even brought a big bowl of ice water for our pup!) place. Great…read moredrink/food options. We enjoyed the Grand Slam pizza. It was excellent! Did not know these guys are part of Capone's! That explains the incredible sauce and crust on that pie! The manager was on top of things, making sure we were not waiting too long for our to go box and all. You can tell when a place wants your business, and this is it!! Will definitely be back soon!

Incredible food and service. Really glad we tried this place on a whim. We will absolutely be back!read more

We had an excellent date night dinner here! Loved seeing the fire going and pizzas cooking and ours…read morewas tasty. The Caesar salad was loaded with toppings and the giant mozz sticks were incredible, crunchy on the outside and warm and gooey in the middle. The fresh marinara sauce was good enough to eat alone. The menu has so many interesting flavors combos and options. Looking forward to going back!