tried the new gelato and it was delicious. Smoothies are a must try also. Strawberry banana is my favorite. The store is very clean and the employees were so friendly. Best froyo on Long Island!! read more

The yogurts were acidic and tasteless, no flavor from the strawberry option and very disappointing because I was buying for people who never tried it, sad to say they won't be coming to this location ever again. On top of that, the service was mid. Now I'm not asking white glove service but at least some assistance or greetings to start, it's not rocket science. The two girls behind the counter were on thier phone, setting on the counter and had their friends there too entertain than the costumers actually paying? This was Wednesday around 7:45PM Ambiance was weak, no music or any energy. Definitely not as fancy as Yogurt Fancy claims to be, so sad :( read more

Decided to come here for dessert after having a delicious dinner. My friend and I were greeted instantly upon walking in. Everyone knows how things go at froyo places. You pick whatever froyo you want, as much as you want, and then top it off. Covid times are strange times. We went to chose our yogurt. All the handles that one has to push down are exposed, and there isn't any employee wiping them down after each use. Yes, I (or any guest) could have asked for this to happen. Toppings were another interesting story as toppings were also self-served. It used to be that one would head to the topping bar and top off their froyo. This is still the case, but instead of a spoon for serving being in each topping bowl, you get your own spoon and put said spoon in each topping that you want. While this is a good idea, what about allergies? For example...I put my topping spoon in cookie dough, and then in strawberries and then in shredded coconut. What if someone has an allergy to strawberries...and puts their topping spoon in coconut? There's a lot of cross contamination going on. While I get the concept so that all topping spoons aren't being touched and single serve topping spoons are better...allergies need to be taken into consideration. Anyway, I went with cake batter froyo. For toppings I had cookie dough, strawberries, shredded coconut and a rainbow cookie. Quite sweet, but very tasty. read more

Yogurt Fancy - There's frozen yogurt in there....promise! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Northport, New York

They LOCKED the doors at 9:40 and didn't allow us to come in when they literally close at 10. I understand that closing is a long process as I used to work at a similar place and I understand people coming in near close is annoying but locking the doors before the alotted time of closing is unacceptable. read more

CLEAN CLEAN CLEAN and the young lady working there on Sunday was amazing. She cleaned every machine after they were used and kept the toppings area neat and clean as well. The yogurt choices and topping were many and all great! read more

Yogurt taste sour. We all got different flavors and they taste expired. Had to throw everything out.

My friends and I went to the store 15 minutes before closing, and a girl said we couldn't come in because the shop was closing in 5 minutes. I downloaded yelp just to leave this singular review. I'm not mad I'm just disappointed, I really wanted some yogurt. So we went to an ice cream shop and we were ten minutes later, this shop closed at nine and they were more than happy to help us. I hate people who have the time to leave reviews, but I need my voice to be heard! read more

My kids absolutely love this place. We go there time after time after their karate lessons and each and every time we go there, the place is nice and tidy. It's so nice to see that they took covid warning seriously and they're doing a great job maintaining the place while serving those delicious frozen yogurt. read more

I personally love yogurt fancy. Whenever I get the frozen yogurt, I notice that the employees are always so friendly. The yogurt itself is self-serve which I like because it makes you feel more comfortable with how much you want and you get to do it yourself. As for the toppings, they are very sanitary in terms of the serving spoons. They always clean them and the toppings are amazing. Never disappoints. read more

Yogurt is sour and liquidy.Half of the stuff they offer they don't even have including the the dragon fruit bowl, half the smoothies and even the glowing sign for coffee is false.Tables are dirty this place is a mess and it smells horrible.Also overpriced half a bowl of yogurt is the same price as a large Ralph's ice.Go there instead of here place stinks. Last but not least most of there toppings are stale and old anywhere but here is better. read more

"Crazy" is just one word you can use to describe the FroYo revolution sweeping the nation these days. "Crazy" is also just one word you can use to describe the FroYo goodness coming out of Yogurt Crazy in Northport, NY. Churning out about a dozen flavors every day, YC also enjoys rotating in new flavors when ever possible. I'm talking about flavors like "York Peppermint Patty", "Pecan Praline", "Snickerdoodle", and "Pomegranate Raspberry Tart"! Feel free to mix together any of these concoctions and get ready for mind blowing taste bud bliss! Customers can also enjoy the plethora of fresh fruit and candy toppings that stretch practically the length of the store! Whether it be gummy bears and sour worms, or fresh kiwi and pineapple, YC will satisfy any craving you have. Now if you've never been to a FroYo shop, the main thing to remember here is that they weigh your order. It's very easy to get crazy on the toppings once you see the vast selection. This usually translates into about 25-50% of your orders weight/price. So, definitely crank up the flavor bonanza that's going to occur in your mouth and sample their many toppings, but also be conscious of how much! Average FroYo purchase for two is about $10, which makes it more expensive than Italian Ices or Baskin & Robbins. It's absolutely still worth the trip though and definitely the most healthy option out of the three! Overall, this location is clean, modern, bright, and family friendly. Yogurt Crazy has been one tasty addition to the area and I look forward to checking in again soon! read more

See all

Yogurt Fancy has a lot of favor varieties and the toppings all looked fresh. The shop was clean and organized. The lady at the counter was pleasant and ran all the customers quickly. Yummm! read more

Yogurt Fancy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Northport, New York

Understand it's hard to get help. Would've preferred the girl behind the counter wiped off the açaí bowl she served me. It was covered in açaí and I stood there wiping it off with napkins while she went back to talk to her friends and an older lady who were in customer seats. I thought what am I doing? And I asked the employee to wipe the purple liquid off the sides of the entire bowl. She coped some attitude. for over 12 dollars for an açaí bowl with a few banana slices and granola, I shouldn't leave there covered in açaí. The kid gave me such a dirty look that I told her I'd never be back, and I won't. read more

If you're expecting the price to be similar to ice cream, you're wrong. It's pretty expensive. Averaged over $10 a person, which I guess is fine for yourself but not when you're paying for 7 people. I was expecting it to be around half what I paid. The yogurt tasted good, but I don't think it's worth the price. read more

I really enjoyed the service while I was there and the boy working there was super accommodating to my vegan lifestyle and was super nice. I would definitely go again. I would love to see him there the next time I go, as well. read more

Let's be real here, frozen yogurt and toppings galore. What could go wrong here? They are open late, willing to let you try flavors, place is spotless, so it's expensive, that's the only reason I'm knocking off a star. read more

This place is definitely on the sweeter, more diabetic side of Frozen Yogurt, ^ sorry Nick! For a froyo place located in a random shopping center in Northport this place is definitely decked out on the inside. I tried a bunch of samples and I must say i hope the calories are correct because they actually taste pretty damn close like ice cream. They have about 6-8 flavors I forget how much preciously, and the toppings is what really makes this place great. They have all types of fruits including kiwi (Red Mango get on your shit), all different types of crushed cookie and nut like toppings, plus the Ghirradeli fudge and caramel toppings. Next time I'll get less yogurt cause I couldn't finish, this never happens to me at Red Mango or Pinkberry. read more

This place has great customer service, I've been to lots of yogurt places over the years but this one takes the cake or should I say yogurt :) James and Carly kept the place clean while being polite and helpful. Had a wonderful experience and would go back. read more

Let me start off that despite the low rating I will be back to try again, maybe on a day they have different staffing ! Yogurt is delicious, store is clean but the employees are the WORST ! It was 9pm, I made a yogurt for my daughter and proceeded to checkout. I told the blonde haired girl I wanted an acai bowl for myself . She stated " we ran out " so I said okay ? ( thinking that's strange ) and said then I'll make a yogurt for myself as well . She told me she already entered the yogurt in the system and that I'd have to pay before making another . I then said okay so did you charge tax ? She said yes ... I said ok I'm not paying tax twice . You can re enter it after I make another yogurt I made another yogurt and went to checkout again . My friend asked the other brown haired employee if they had acai bowls .. I told my friend they don't not knowing the other employee said they have it and they can make them . It was more than clear at this point the other girl told me they didn't have them, because she didn't want to make it . LOL Once I sit down to eat she reminds us multiple times they are closing . . So much to the point that it was uncomfortable and we'd rather just sit outside . On the way out at 9:54 an older man walked in the door in which the girl at the front said " were closing " and the guy looked so confused because it wasn't 10 he just walked out . I'd suggest management properly train their staff or have a word or two with the blonde who was on staff tonight . .... she made everyone uncomfortable because she wanted to make sure she was out the door at 10 pm on the dot ( her friend was waiting there for her shift to finish ) I'll come back on a random night during the week read more

Great Yogurt Store....I have been to many and Yogurt Fancy is clearly the best on Long Island. So clean and so many great flavors and toppings....I cant wait to go back....My kids also love it. Yogurt Fancy is clearly a place to go in Northport....... read more

This place is amazing!! Too good to be honest.. we come way too often! Lol the guy that works most days is amazing, I just walk in and he hands me the açaí bowl he knows I am going to ask for! Place is so clean and the amount of topping and quality of them is on point ! Also lots of vegan options! read more

They have many flavors to choose from and a great selection of toppings. Owner and staff are very friendly. The machines and counters are kept very clean. read more

Always has fresh fruit at hand, and any toppings could think of. I visit at least once a week

I've always loved this yogurt place but on my recent visit their was a young brunet girl working who was very impolite. The yogurt is always good and I am a very patient person but this was unacceptable so I will no longer be a customer here. read more

How can you go wrong with selve serve frozen yogurt? They allow you to taste test any flavor, and they have a wide array of toppings. Five stars for the friendly workers, cleanliness of the store, and good flavors. read more

Love this location. So clean and the staff is friendly. The owners are always there and are so nice and are very attentive to customers. Lots of toppings to choose from. My favorite yogurt flavor is pistachio. I have many other yogurt places closer to me, but I always come here. read more

I went here today. Since I could not find on their website the exact ingredients in this frozen yogurt, I asked the girl working at the store. She got very uncomfortable and told me only the manager knows that information. What?? For a company that keeps saying they use only healthy ingredients, this makes me nervous. What are the exact ingredients in their fro yo?? What chemicals are they hiding?? Never again.... read more

Great tasting yogurt and super nice owners. Came in here with our boys who loved it. Clean and great service