Best Pizza in Thornton. Fast and lots of choices. Owners are great and staff work hard.

This restaurant used to be a favorite of ours, but has gone completely down hill since the change in management/ownership. They used to accommodate my kids' gluten free allergies by being able to get kids meals and just pay the gf upcharge on top of it and now they want to charge us fully adult prices plus we would have to pay the combo price to get a drink and gelato. So previously it would have been $14 for my kids to get a gluten free kids meal, now they charged us what would be $24 to get the same. So we would have paid $28 for 2 kids gluten free meals, it is now $48 for the same. They do not care about the customer and will not be back. read more

If I could zero stars I would. The The service was a disaster line at lunch and two people working well only one the other one watching and will ring you out. The pizza miserable we used to go all the time since new ownership this place is a downhill dumpster fire. No toppings hardly any sauce barely any cheese cook it long enough to crisp the cracker crust all taste like nothing. Upped prices for way less quality. Absolutely awful. 2 employees at lunch???? Nope! Took out the freestyle machine this place is just went to trash and it will now be taken out of places I eat ever again. read more

No...just no... lol. This is solely based on their gelato. I *may* return to try the pizza....but the gelato was so terrible that I don't know if I want to return. First it didn't look the greatest...like melted and processed...so O decided to sample a few in which I was told on my third sample request that only 2 samples are allowed. However the two that I sampled had no flavor whatsoever so I was hoping the other flavors were better. I felt obligated to place an order after a comment like that so I got a scoop to go and let me say it was the most disappointing gelato I ever had! Perhaps I am an ice cream/gelato snob as I've had my fair share, but this was...unpleasant. I'll give this place a star for the ambiance as it seemed like a very happening place and seemed like a lot of regulars come here. Sadly, I don't think I will be one of them. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Tasteless Butterfinger gelato - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

Spent 45 dollars for a pizza that looked and tasted like grocery store frozen pizza. Delivery driver left the pizza on the ground next to the front door, glad we were quick to pick up before it was loaded with ants or other bugs. When I picked up the box, I thought it was empty - it really felt like nothing was inside. Ordered large,, pizza was about 2/3 of box size and nothing there. Never again. read more

This place has gone downhill in a hurry. New owners have ruined this place. Used to come once a week. Went today never again. Prices have gone up and quality and amount of food gone down. I could write a book on how bad this place is. Toppings maybe sprinkles. Sauce like none. Not enough cheese to even cover the pizza. 2 workers at lunch with only one cooking with a line out the door pathetic. These owners are not I imagine living up to what the company is wanted to provide. Increased prices while downsizing food quality and quantity. New owners came in. Soda freestyle machine gone. Some knock off auto water machine that shoots splashes of water so you have to stand there for minutes to try and fill a small water cup. Charging 50 cents for buffalo sauce since I didn't ask for it on the pizza at the time I ordered insanity. This place is in a prime location and I hope it goes out of business so someone who cares gets that spot. Corporate should come to this location so you can see how much of a joke it is. $40 plus for 2 10 inch pizzas and 1 7 inch and there is not but sprinkles of toppings. Nope. I hope this place loses this store because they don't deserve this prime real estate. Oh and on 3/14/26, pie day, the owners were in there with a line through the door arguing with customers, threatening to call the police on one, and yelling at there employees cause they are behind. Embarrassing. I will gladly take my money and go to MOD Pizza or IPie your direct competitors. They can run a business. These people cannot. If you as company want to short cut and save money that's fine. The customer will speak at the end. If that's not how you want to run your company then you need to visit this store. I wasted over 40 dollars and I tipped for food that ain't worth half that. Should have went to Wendy's. I'm sure I won't hear back but some automated message but don't worry this will be posted on yelp and google reviews as well to warn people to not do business here. read more

After years of loving this pizza (great crust and generous toppings) what a disappointment! The crust was like a hard thin cracker and the cheese barely melted And did not taste the same. The small drinks are now a "kid size" for $3.29. Before the new ownership took place, this was the greatest pizza place. read more

this was my first experience at a piece of place where they drizzled toppings like ranch or honey etc. there calzone type sandwich was amazing. I love that they do have a small outdoor patio. They could make it a little more inviting, however. read more

He got a regular pizza and said it was amazing I got a gluten free allergy one and it was amazing!! since becoming gluten free it's been hard to find some good food but definitely worth trying if your gluten free! They even have gluten free Gelato it was so good too:) The service was amazing! Very helpful and the place was clean:) no complaints here read more

Your Pie Pizza - He got a regular pizza and he said it was AMAZING!! I got the Gluten free pizza and it was AMAZING definitely worth trying! - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

The food was delicious and the staff was friendly. Great experience! We also enjoyed being able to watch the NFL games while eating and waiting for our pizza to cook. Also had a great selection of local beers. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

See all

The service was good and the place is casual. The pizza was just okay. I like Modpizza's crust much better. They have the same concept as Modpizza. The crust just didn't taste that great. We were all eating outside and suddenly it got really windy and their umbrellas flew off the tables hitting some of us. We all were holding onto the umbrellas to keep from flying and hitting others. The staff or manager should've secured their umbrellas which weren't. Enjoy, for those of you who likes this place. This place was not for me. read more

See all

Always great food. Pizza and Breadsticks. Fabio was so friendly and took good care of my GF and I. Thank you to Fabio and whole staff.

This is my absolute favorite pizza place! To start the staff is always so friendly and I love how they yell out "STICKS" when you order cheese sticks. The lines always go really fast so even if you see a line out the door don't let this deter you from staying and ordering. I have a gluten allergy so I love that they offer gluten-free pizza crust and it's actually good! If you've never been here just think of it kind of like a subway but for pizza. You're able to go down the line and add whatever toppings you want. My fiancé definitely takes advantage of this adding about 20 different toppings lol. I also highly recommend that you get some of their ranch because it is absolutely amazing and the best I've ever had. We usually order an entire pint and then use it at home to. read more

See all

Ordered through DoorDash. Excellent pizza! Dough is perfect. Arrived hot both times. Definitely recommend. read more

The food here is so good! Fresh too! Love that you can watch them make it! Perfect spot for family with kids!!! Service is super quick, and the ambiance is casual yet cozy!! I will be back! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

With frequent this Your Pie as it is a friendly, easy place to go. I like that they'll put whatever you want on your pizza and they don't give you a hard time about it. They have vegan options, vegan cheese, and wheat dough available on certain sizes of pizzas, and they have beer to top it off. The service is usually friendly, and the prices are very fair. The place is usually clean inside, and we have always been able to find a table. My only complaint is that the drink machines get pretty dirty and they don't seem to keep them as clean as they should sometimes. It doesn't bother me that much because we don't drink soft drinks. it's just something I noticed. We will continue to frequent this your pie unless something changes. read more

I had a delicious white pizza, gelato and soda all for only $13.48 plus tax. Your Pie in Thornton has a variety of create your own pizzas where you walk up to the line and choose your toppings. The crust was a perfectly crispy and delicious. The music was not too loud and the interior temperature was just right. I plan on returning soon. read more

See all

The food here is good, except for the wings which were mediocre. Would recommend only getting the pizza and liked all the available variety of toping and ways to make your own personal pizza. The setting is nice but even better when its not packed. Service was good with a nice staff getting our order. read more

When my family of three arrived they were making some online orders and asked for our patience. Okay fine. But TEN items later mostly pizzas, and ten minutes later we got to order. When we did receive our order the food was bland and not flavorful at all. It was def fresh and priced okay but not impressive at all. I am pretty sure I could make one better at home and will next time. It has been a year since we came here and now I remember why: save your money , go somewhere else. Maybe if we had been given a discount or acknowledgement of how long we waited we could come again but that didn't happen ‍ read more

I love your pie! The pizza and gelato are super yummy and the staff is always super kind!

The pizza is delicious and you can tell that hard work and the goal of customer satisfaction has been incorporated into each bite. The restaurant has such a welcoming, happy atmosphere that makes you want to stay for hours. I definitely give this restaurant five stars and recommend to Pizza lovers. read more

"The actual product is significantly different from the photo."........... "The actual product is significantly different from the photo." read more

Your Pie Pizza - "The actual product is significantly different from the photo." - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

See all

First I will state for the record, I ordered online and it was one of the easiest sites to navigate and when I picked up my pizza and two sandwiches the guy working there was very polite. On to the problem. I ordered a large or extra large, don't recall now but the largest pizza you can order. It was told online that it is only a 14" pizza and I thought if the quality is really good I suppose size is not such a big thing. I looked at the undeserved ratings of this place and thought I was in for a treat despite the rather small size for a large. First problem is when I got there I was shown the pizza and it looked about as meh and blahh as you could imagine in your mind. I have seen more appetizing looking pizzas in gas stations. Plus on top of it I ordered a Supreme pizza and every other place I have gone for pizza the Supreme usually earns its name from having a a lot of toppings and being the most impressive pizza, you can get. Not here though, the toppings were anemic, the cheese looked fake and the crust looked like a factory formed cardboard crust. This already had me very dissatisfied and disappointed. By the time I got it home it needed a quick re-heat so I put the pizza on a 14" pizza pan I have to reheat in the oven. This pizza is supposedly a 14" pizza but it looked so small in this pan so I took out a tape measure and this pizza was about 12.75" in diameter. Then I was thinking I have not even tasted this pizza yet and for sure it is a rip off. When I did dig in to the pizza I can say I have had better frozen pizzas from the grocery store than this pizza. This pizza with tax was approaching $30. Now for the sandwiches, I have yet to try these. I got two, one for me and one for my wife for lunch today. I already peeked and saw that one of the sandwiches claiming to have chicken had no chicken whatsoever. The other had cold cuts but looked dismally anemic. I am not looking forward to lunch but not about to waste it either. So, save your money, if you must go out for a pizza, skip this place. Heck stop at the grocery store and get a frozen pizza, it will taste better and be more satisfying. I just can't imagine how this place got so many stars. Did they pay for them with the huge profits they are making off this shameful food? read more

Your Pie Pizza - This is the large 14" pizza from your pie. - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

I sat waiting for my food as two people behind the counter forgot they pulled my pizza out of the oven. When my wife asked for help, they finally brought over my cold pizza. read more

Awesome pizza! Thin Crust is amazing!!! Will definitely be back! Staff is friendly as well. read more

WTF?? We came to Denver for a wedding and after 2 days of the worse luck of trying to feed a hungry monster, we found this little spot by our hotel. Boy let me tell you, we are spoiled in Vegas. You think it and you can find, order, and eat within an hour lol. Here in Denver, we chose 2 spots thinking we'll get down and eat to find out majority was alacarte. At one time we spent $65 for 3 small dishes. WTF? Then still hungry! As mentioned, 2 days looking for good food and it took this spot to satisfy the hungry monster. It's like a Blaze Pizza. Choose your topping type spot. I made an online order using the Yelp app. So this review is for a pick up and food order. What ordered: Pesto pasta Build your own pasta. Let me tell you, I was so hungry that I put pretty much anything that you can on my pasta order. I was expecting a high dollar seeing as I had so many toppings. To my surprise, cost was as much as their specialty Pesto pasta bowl. For a meal under $25 with pretty much unlimited toppings, was what we needed. 20min from online order to pickup is all it took. It's not fancy and authentic. What it was is satisfying! Could this be a fluff review due to the hungry monster and I being so hungry? Maybe, but they did what so many couldn't on our trip out. Fill us lol. read more

Ordered delivery. Took 20 minutes longer than originally promised. Pizza was barely warm. Ordered a salad - no plastic ware, no napkins, barely any dressing to go on it. Disappointed read more

Great little spot... Good pizza at a fair price. I took three kiddos and the wifey. Kids pizza were perfect individual sizes came with a drink and Gelatos. Hot Honey Pepperoni was delicious and the wife got the BBQ with drizzled hot honey and it was delicious as well. We will swing in here again. read more

See all

Pizza was great and the service/staff were phenomenal! They checked in several times to check if we liked our food and to see if we needed anything. read more

Service is always good, no matter how busy they are and you can't beat the value! Plus the kids love this place! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

See all

Our family stopped in at Your Pie before a football game last week. The best way I can describe this place is Mod Pizza on steroids! Instead of just getting 6-11 inch pizzas they offer a 14 incher which is great for friends and families. They also have more sides to choose from including Gelato for dessert. The service was fine. It's more of a self service experience and most are working behind the counter. The pizza tasted good. The breadsticks were okay. Nothing special. This is definitely a franchise model so expect to see more of these popping up in neighborhoods near you! This place is new and I expect they will fine tune their operations quickly. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Brand - Pizza Near Me - Thornton, Colorado

See all

This Your Pie location isn't what it used to be. This place was such a fun atmosphere, and me and my family loved coming to Your Pie. The employees USED to seem to love their job, super friendly, and our orders were always correct and cooked all the way through. The old owners, Kevin and Michelle, were also super friendly and were amazing. They made Your Pie feel like something more in the community, and built the atmosphere. Kevin and Michelle made Your Pie be a place you want to return to as a guest, and be a place you want to work at because of the great management there was. Now under new ownership, everything seems to gone downhill; employees don't look happy and aren't friendly, are getting yelled at by the owner in front of guests, and our orders aren't getting correct or all the way cooked. Recently, one out of the four pizzas we had ordered came out all the way cooked and wasn't still doughey. There really isn't anything friendly about this location anymore or a great atmosphere to visit. It's honestly a shame of what the change in ownership did to Your Pie Thornton, and I wish better for the employees that work there. read more

First time ordering here. They use Uber to deliver their items. Pizza was cold due to late delivery and we were missing our kids drink and gelato. When I called the restaurant they told me to call uber however I didn't order through Uber. Horrible customer service. read more

This place is good. Try the outer range ipa with the spicy sauce. Good experience, good food, nice people. Definitely try it

So we repeat the same order every time. We order carry out so it is hard to double check, but unfortunately one pizza was missing two ingredients. Not sure what you can do now except check better next time. Checked the receipt it was correct read more

Basically a local version of Pieology but with gelato. They offer a few crust options, one of which is a "keto friendly" crust for a $4 up charge (cauliflower and cheese; gluten-free). I tied it and thought it was really good. The staff are friendly and made regular trips around the dining area to bus and clean tables. I get tomatoes Lon the summer peach salad we're a bit mushy, and the salad could have used s little more dressing. Aside from this, we were happy with the food. The pizza came out super quick. I'd say about half the time it takes Pieology. read more

See all

This place has really good pizza. It is fast and delicious. Good ice cream and good salads. I think you should try it!

Pizza is awesome, staff is super friendly (especially Arjun)...if you eat here you won't be disappointed.

could have warmed up a frozen pizza and would have gotten more flavor. Another corporate restaurant selling that bs seed oil.

If I could I would put 0 stars. This places staff has the worst attitude and service I've ever experienced at a restaurant. I was really excited to come here for the first time with the church that I had attended and it really disappointed me. The food was decadent but I do NOT recommend merely for the experience. The people I came with all experienced some sort of negative or frankly inappropriate comment from a worker during their time here. Some comments including "it would be easier if you weren't gluten free", " can't you speak up" when you could barely hear the worker. We also apologize for there being a lot of us and he said don't do it again. They also gave a lot of mean faces. read more