Overall great ice cream place. We've visiting both the Vineyard Heaven and Oak Bluff location and…read morethey both were great. The staff at both locations were very friendly and while it gets busy, they are very fast and efficient. They offer a rewards card so you can earn a free ice cream. Ambiance is like your classic ice cream shop and they have a great selection of flavors. The Oak Bluffs location is bigger, which allows for more inside seating.

PROS: This place is spacious, fresh ice cream, nice staff, hours are good, prices are fair, located…read morein the shopping area of town, menu variety was plentiful, and they make the orders fast CONS: They could add a few more tables to allow more sitters OVERALL: Amazing place to come for ice cream. It is street parking so be weary. If you're on foot and want a treat, come here

Our experience was great... commenting of the bad reviews one must wonder... was it a prior owner?…read more Melting ice cream is a good sign... no chemicals...stabilizers.. but some of the other stuff from 2019 and 2020 was inexcusible.. Hope that employee is long gone and hopefully it was not the owner. If the owner I spoke with can be believed, I can say it was truly a pleasure to have a shop deliver quality food items with gluten and dairy free options. We loved it.

Came to Visit Martha's Vineyard and immediately stumbled upon this cute ice cream spot. The words…read more"vegan" and "gluten free" captured my attention right away and had to come in and try! I was able to sample the vegan cookie dough and their matcha flavored ice cream and just had to get a scoop each! The lovely women behind the counter recommended adding strawberries, to which they make the Jam themselves. Which was also delicious. I had a fabulous time talking with the ladies and telling me their story! I enjoyed every bite and loveddd the cookie dough! It's so hard to come across a place that offers both and they sure met my expectations. The ambiance is lovely and surely a treat!

A lot of ice cream flavors! The ice cream is great! Prices are high but expected due to the island…read more Wish the portions were bigger

Absolutely delicious ice cream in an adorable setting. We went midafternoon (2:30 ish) which meant…read morethere were no crowds

Great ice cream shop right on circuit ave amongst all the other stores. Spacious layout and has a…read morevariety of ice cream flavors and treats to choose from. Service was fine with polite workers serving the ice cream. Opted to try their vanilla soft serve and it was very good. Recommending trying this place if you're looking for a new ice cream place to try since there's quite a few on circuit Ave. Can't go wrong with this place.

Ice Cream Shoppe [Martha's Vineyard MA]…read more This is a cute little ice cream shop with fun interior aesthetics. It mimicked the nostalgic charm of the carousel from The Flying Horses Carousel. It had an old wooden phone from the early 1900's, and there were a couple of wooden horses too. I'm not sure if you can mount them or they're just for looks. Lots of vintage photos hung on the walls. Seating is limited inside but it wasn't busy when we went. Very clean shoppe. Unfortunately, we just had ice cream from another shoppe in Edgartown so we didn't have any this time. We were parched from the day's activities so we purchased drinks instead. Service was friendly. Find this shop in the town of Oak Bluffs, located on the northeastern part of the island of Martha's Vineyard. Review #3032

Nice little cafe, brunch place right on corner of circuit Ave & oak bluffs in Martha's Vineyard…read moreturn right as you get off hy-line cruises dock. We had some coffee in the am & a chicken salad for lunch w chips & soda $21. Food was acceptable and more importantly quick as we only had 3 hours here. There are some beautiful gingerbread style homes right down circuit ave recommended to see. This is the bigger & less expensive of the 2 islands Nantucket being the next stop.

We had no idea what they had to offer in this cool spot in downtown Oak Bluffs. We always thought…read moreof it as "just ice cream" ... we were wrong! They have a full kitchen and a great menu! We tried the egg sandwiches and they were very good! They have donuts too!! It's a nice spot to grab a coffee and sandwich in the morning! We've been back multiple times since our first visit, after realizing it's "not just ice cream"! ‍

I know they are happy I made them bring their poncho. The rain took over that day. We were in line…read morefor over an hour and waited 15 minutes to hear our number called. Will it be worth receiving a freshly made fritter or donut??? I say yes! After all that waiting it took me another few hours to try a donut. But it was a good chocolate glazed donut. I look forward to trying the apple fritter which is probably as large as someone's face so I am definitely sharing. Or at least creating a now and later situation. DO NOT BE AN AMATEUR LIKE MYSELF. THEY CALL IT BACK DOOR FOR A REASON. YOU MUST GO TO THE BACK DOOR IN THE PARKING LOT. THERE IS NO WAY AROUND IT. THE FRONT DOOR IS NOT AVAILABLE. YOU'RE WELCOME!

Amazing!! Their apple fritter IS SO GOOD! So worth trying. Definitely shareable between 2-3 people…read moreor even more! My friend and I shared it & we both loved it. It came out hot & with real piece of apple in it! Such a great treat to start your morning!

Cash only. They do have an ATM machine but it was broken when we were there. The staff are really…read moresweet and give samples. We had pistachio ice cream in a cone. The Ice cream store was located in an indoor plaza with shops for families. The ice cream itself was hard and was not overly sweet.

Came here as a result of not wanting to deal with the crowds of the more popular places in OB…read more Ice cream itself isn't half bad but it is SO overpriced even by MV standards and the cones that they use are seriously from the stone age. Got our kid an oreo, and one of us got a moosetracks while the other got coffee. Again, the ice cream itself is passable, but more of the Baskin Robbins variety than anything original or artisanal. This is for the tourists who aren't in the know and we are *pissed* at ourselves for having fallen for their conveniently-located trap. Ah well, at least our kid was happy and rode their joy ride car for a hot 30 seconds for a dollar. Go up the street. Literally everything is better. This location has so much turnover and The "Sweet Spot" will be gone soon enough.

Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular…read moreflavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown. Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.

SUMMER ONLY and worth a step in for a selection of the most unique flavors on the island. Some are…read morea bit too creamy for my liking, but always natural and hearty flavor. Creamsicle is a perennial favorite but I have enjoyed others over the years as well. Mint and cookie dough would be right behind. Wish there were more opportunities to get these sweet delights ... but on the other hand, their limited availability helps make every taste count!