New to the area and this pizza is great! The staff is friendly and always cheerful! Will get a lot more pizza from here!!

Best pizza ever, go early or during off peak hours. I had two slices, one cheese and one pepperoni. It's the smallest pepperoni I have ever seen mini pepperoni. It must be home made. I don't know if it is or not . Do t quote me on that. With two good reviews onevin the Bradenton Herald and one on Next Door. I am sure this little pizzeria will stick around. At least I hope till I get the bf there to check it out with me. read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Two slices of pizza and a fizzy water - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

See all

Great pizza and food. Reminds me of Italian food from up north. Really loved their Italian sub too, fresh ingredients like mozzarella and prosciutto. read more

Stopped in for a drink and we were offered a sample piece of pie!!! Cannot wait to return! Open daily all day! 100 percent recommend! And they deliver themselves! read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Stupid cute place! - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

We loved this fabulous pizza place! Warm and friendly staff, great service and excellent pizza! Super happy we stopped in. Try the Greek pizza-you won't be disappointed!! read more

The pizza was very good. It was carry out so the role at the register was polite and efficient. Didn't eat there but it a clean, neat, bare-bones restaurant. Nothing wrong with that. It's about the food. read more

Pizza is consistently good! Love their thin, crispy crust. We always get the supreme and it's really good. They have a great variety of pizza by the slice if you need something quick. Everyone is very nice too! read more

Awesome pizza! The pizza crust is light airy and crispy. Pizza by the slice + a drink is very reasonably priced, good value and excellent quality. You can also order pizza to go or delivery. Highly recommend! read more

Best pizza and best prices in Bradenton! Staff are all super friendly and attentive. It's a great little spot with not too much seating and all the desserts seem homemade. It's out go to takeout place but have yet to dine in. It's a MUST try if you like thin crust NY style pizza. read more

Best pizza in my opinion here in Bradenton. We are from LI, N.Y. and it was hard to find a place we like. The restaurant is nice, clean and the staff is friendly & helpful. Try it you'll like it. read more

Great pizza. Lots of taste combinations and toppings. The large is very large. This is the first pizza in West Bradenton that we all can agree on. read more

Great pizza with succulent sauce, perfect thin crust and spot on toppings. Definitely a take out but there is seating for a limited number of diners if you so choose. There are other main courses offered but unfortunately I have not tried those yet. It's going to be hard to move me off their pizza. read more

Great pizza! Started with the house salad and it was fresh and tasty! Will and I split a large half pepperoni half meat lovers! Sue had a cauliflower crust small mushroom, red onion, banana pepper pizza! I had a piece of that and it was great! I could not tell it was cauliflower crust. Had a piece of NY Cheesecake for dessert. The whole meal was very tasty! My néw favorite spot! The staff is super friendly and we will be back! Thank y'all for a great evening! read more

Good atmosphere, awesome, friendly customer service. And delicious food. I come here all the time and crave it even moreso. Would highly recommend, one of the best pizza spots in this area! read more

First time that we went to Agrigento and we were very happy that we did. Greeted right away and got the last table available. The hostess/server explained things clearly and we ordered a white pizza. We were served it hot and fresh in about 15 Minutes and it was delicious. While we are in Bradenton now, we long ago were from NJ, so we have had great pizza growing up and this is right in there. Perfect crust and just the right amount of ingredients. ( Too much actually ruins the flavor and texture) We will definitely be coming back. Good food, friendly staff and fair pricing. Worth giving them a try if you prefer traditional Old World, Southern Italian style pizza. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Bradenton if not sarasota as well. The sauce is the star of the show. Well done! read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Lrg pep Togo - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

Food was really good! Service was great. They were welcoming from the time we opened the door. You won't regret eating here lol unless you are counting calories but this is a great cheat meal. No regrets!!! dig in. read more

Closest to NY pizza that I found clean and awesome staff Good prices as well Highly recommend in West Bradenton area read more

The best cauliflower crust I have ever had! GF . Crispy and delicious. My husband loved his italian sub! Caesar was also delicious!

Very friendly folks at the counter. Pizza came up just as I arrived for pickup. We had a small veg pizza and all the ingredients were fresh and tasty. Maybe came up short on cheese and sauce but knowing this I can order extra next time. And there will be a next time. read more

Great pizza!! Will definitely be back. I will say though that their delivery prices are a little steep so we will be picking up next time.

We ordered two large pizzas, a Margherita and one with pepperoni, black olives, and mushrooms. We also ordered two appetizers, calamari, and corn bites. The appetizers were not good. They both were small orders. The calamari was nothing like the calamari I have enjoyed over the years. The pizza was good, especially the Margherita--nothing to write home about. Not going back. read more

Best pizza in bradenton. Price of pie are cheaper than most. Almost everything taste authentic. Service was great. Place is immaculate clean . Hope they branch out in sarasota. read more

The pizza is Best of the Best , however I advise delivery or pickup . We ate there last night - music super loud , no wait staff ... can't even get a glass of ice water read more

Great food, great service, all my favorite dishes and nice easy location right there on manatee Ave!

Cute little restaurant. Very clean and the employees were friendly. You can order pizza by the slice or the whole pie. We had the special of two slices and a drink. We even took home a tiramisu for dessert later. Food was very fresh and delicious. I highly recommend! read more

Very good pizza, just wish they had draft beer and table service, The staff is very friendly and efficient. Try the Limoncello cake WOW! We will be back. read more

We got there at 7:48PM on Sunday, July 23rd, 2023 when they close at 8:00PM and the employees said they were closed. They should post closed at 7:48PM or post/list a time earlier than 8:00PM. Not sure who owns this place but they deserve what they hire to represent them. GOD BLESS! read more

Called at 8:13 to have a pizza delivered less than one mile away. They said it was to late and they were closing even though their website says they are open and deliver until 8:30. Bad Business. read more

Fabulous pizza!! The salad was delicious and service great but my favorite was the pizza!!!

Amazing. Authentic NY style, great customer service. Can't say enough good things about them, would definitely recommend if you're NYC homesick. read more

Best pizza in Bradenton,Fl! Staff is friendly and food order is always quick and never had to wait read more

I am originally from New York and stopped in last night for a slice of pizza and I thought that I was back in New York. I got a chicken parmesan dinner to go and it was delicious. The owner and staff was very pleasant and the place was spotlessly clean. The prices were very reasonable so this is my new go to place for Italian food. Frank L. read more

Always delicious ! They never miss . Friendly staff and great atmosphere . It is my go to at least once a week

After several visits to the Manatee Ave location for pizza...I feel compelled to write a review. We are locals and have likely eaten at most every restaurant within 20 miles at one time or other. Have to say that we now have a new FAVORITE! This place, the staff and the food are absolutely AMAZIMG. Pizza crust is wonderful and the toppings are abundant. FIVE stars isn't quite enough!! read more

Absolutely great evening with whole ingredients and perfectly cooked dinner. The service was second to none and we felt at home. Pleasantly surprised and will definitely be back. read more

I don't eat in NW Bradenton often, but I was in the area Anna thought I'd try it. This may be the best pizza in Bradenton (any area). The crust was thin, crispy and delicious. We ordered an Italian sandwich and didn't realize they make their own bread. OMG amazing.... Everything read more

The pizza is amazing. Ask for burrata on your pizza and you will be in heaven. The chicken cutlet sub is my favorite of all time. Chicken cutlet is crispy, fresh mozz, balsamic vinaigrette and their own fresh bread. It's delicious! read more

We picked up a pizza Sunday and it was awesome! So happy to find this gem and can't wait to try other options.

Did we go to the same pizzeria? Pizza & salad-MEH. $4.75 for a beer? We like to support local businesses so we'll try again but not for awhile. read more