First time here and first time on Maria island, and I've got to say I was slightly disappointed, the cheese pizza tasted of meat, the pizza al la vodka was probably the only good slice I tried, the pepperoni was also not that great, I will say the service and the owner are incredible. The ambiance is lively and has that ny pizza feel to it. The wings were also pretty good. read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

Nice pie. Decent flavor. Thin floppy store bought dough. Can't anyone make their own dough? If anywhere lies to you, look at the bottom of the pizza. If you see tiny holes everywhere or a pattern that could not be made by hand it's a sure sign. See the photos I posted. read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Store bought dough - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

See all

Great pizza. I have tried the meat lovers pizza, Arigento pizza and a pepperoni pizza. All were amazing. I highly recommend giving them a try. read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Small pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

We stumbled upon Agrigento by Style Pizzeria Café just a few months ago after relocating back to Manatee County from a brief season in Nevada--and let me tell you, this little gem has become our new happy place! As a single mom raising three growing boys, finding a spot that satisfies everyone is no small feat. But Agrigento delivers--literally and figuratively. The pizza is next-level, with that perfect blend of crispy crust and gooey cheese that tastes like it was hand-crafted in a Sicilian kitchen. And don't even get me started on the garlic knots... These are not your average knots. These are oversized pillows of buttery, garlicky heaven--I swear they were kneaded by angels. The house salad with that signature Italian dressing? A masterpiece. And speaking of masterpieces, let's raise a glass of their smooth and sultry Montepulciano--a rare treat to find as a house wine in a casual café! Add in some authentic cannolis or a slice of limoncello cake, and you've got yourself the perfect ending to any meal. My personal favorite? The eggplant Parmesan garlic knot slider--the kind of creation that deserves its own Food Network spotlight. They even have a daily $10 lunch special with two slices and a drink, which is an absolute steal. And while you eat, you're serenaded by music videos from the 80s and 90s--pure joy for this Gen Z momma with an old soul! Tucked away in a humble strip plaza on Manatee Avenue near our pediatrician's office, this place is so good I might start hoping the kids catch a mild cold just so I don't forget to stop by again. Agrigento, you've won our hearts (and stomachs). See you again soon--and often! read more

See all

Agrigento serves delicious pizza and even offers it by the slice. They also have excellent pasta, and when I wasn't sure what to order, the staff gladly made recommendations and even prepared something special for me. The salads are fresh, the desserts are tasty, and overall it's one of the best pizza spots in the area. Located in a plaza, there's also plenty of convenient parking. read more

Don't sleep on this place. It's SO good, I've never had anything I didn't like. They also have a great special for $10, 2 slices and a drink. The pizza is thin, fresh and crispy and the owners are lovely! I love the sliders on their garlic rolls and they have some great Italian beers and yummy desserts. read more

Excellent, Delicious food ... my family is from Sicily. It all starts with the sauce! Agrigento's is delicious. The servings are generous ... the meatballs were tender and so savory. From the food to the authentic desserts, the flavor is spot on! I found my homemade "Sicilian" food. The decor is welcoming, subway clean beautiful subway tile walls. It's spacious and for your TV fans, 3 big TV I had the meatball sandwich and cannoli for dessert. Cannoli was like my mom's and the shell was so fresh! I can't wait to order again . read more

Owner being mean to customers! You give people help don't yell at them! Why wasn't my family given silverware to begin with! Yeah yell at customers!! Real professional! Doesn't care about anyone! read more

I think it's the best pizza in the area by far. Although takeout doesn't taste as good as in the Pizzeria. Cute little place clean and the service is excellent, very friendly people read more

Ambiance was a super cute pizza place, seemed pretty busy for a Friday night which is always a good sign. Ordered the cauliflower Margherita crust pizza to go. I was super happy with my order and thought it was delicious. 5/5 stars. Thank you !!! read more

See all

It's hard, well, impossible really, to find NY pizza anywhere outside Florida, but this place was the closest we found thus far... The restaurant is located in a small strip mall with plenty of parking. The physical space reminds me of the pizza joints we grew up with, so that's a plus. Nothing fancy, booths and tables, and a big counter lol Service/ staff were very friendly and checked on us several times, deserving 5 stars. Caprese salad was delicious: good balsamic, fresh tomatoes and delicious mozzarella. The garlic knots had me worried at first, as they were bigger length wise from the usual garlic knot, but they were surprisingly light--not heavy ---and also delicious!! The pizza was good: thin and crispy crust, with a good amount of sauce, and the cheese was tasty, too----but, something was missing!!! Again, good pizza, but just not exactly what we grew up with...that's why "only" four stars. Will likely return in the future. read more

See all

the best pizza we've found in the area. we are on ami but have to go off island to find pizza and we finally found something worth the effort read more

We came in for the weekend and was looking for a great pizza joint! Well we found one! The pizza was soooo good! The buffalo chicken pizza was the best I have ever had if I am being honest!! The Greek salad was yummy too.. We went and picked it up!! It only took 20 minutes! The service was great!! It's in strip mall but the ambiance was amazing! I would give it 10 stars if I could!! Thanks for the great food and experience! We will definitely be back!! Jaime from St. Louis read more

We went there twice, once for pizza, once for pasta. We liked it, didn't love it, but it was a. Ice change of scenery. So, first, the pizza. I love a thin crust, and theirs is thin. Cheese and sauce ratio was about right, toppings were a little thin, and I mean that literally. I ordered sausage, and it was the thinnest slices of sausage I had ever seen. I mean paper thin. My husband's pepperoni was a little thicker sliced. We will try it again, maybe one with multiple toppings. They do a healthy carry out business, which made me wonder how a pizza that thin travels.... The pasta...we decided to split a ziti and an order of meatballs. Huge portions! We ate half and took the other half home for two more meals. Both were good, meatballs had an unusual flavor...cinnamon? Allspice? Not bad, just unexpected. Prices were fair for portion size. Dining room isn't anything special, but comfortable enough. Employees are friendly and efficient. read more

I have not tried the pizza yet but the Italian sandwich and antipasto salad are very good. The gentlemen that work here are very nice and helpful. read more

See all

Best pizza in Bradenton by far. Hidden gem! You can tell they take pride in the food served

Excellent NY-style pizza. Crust perfect - thin (but not too thin) and crispy. Just the right blend of cheese and sauce. Excellent piece of cheesecake for dessert. .Prices very reasonable. People friendly. No frills, with plenty of tables to eat in. Best pizza we've had in Bradenton, since Oma's was forced to close due to hurricane damage. read more

Fantastic margarita pizza! I've had pizza all over the world including Italy. It's a great reminder of Italy. The ingredients are fresh and they use fresh basil. read more

Best Pizza along with everything on there menu is Fantastic. Great service and friendly owners!!!! read more

We had the meat pizza, white pizza, garlic knots, and antipasto salad for take-out. All were very delicious.

This is the best pizza in Bradenton! Great service, the employees here are SO nice. Love this place and recommend it to everyone!

Very friendly folks serving decent thin crust pizza. The cheap paper plates and plastic cutlery are a fail and bring the place down.

I didn't think it was anything to write home about. Pretty bland on flavor although the crust was good. I was disappointed especially with all the raving reviews they had on other platforms. BUT their service was great! From taking my order to delivering the pizza - everyone was very friendly. read more

So far this is the best pizza "in the area" that I have found. The sauce was perfectly balanced, the crust was a good combo of chewey and crisp and held the ingredients really well. Some good also-rans would be Pizza Social and The Feast. read more

Have had pizza and can olive so far. Both are very good. Service and delivery are also excellent. Great restaurant!

I'm hesitant to write this review. Only because this is my favorite local spot to grab a quick slice. My family loves Agrigento. Truth is there is no better pizza in Florida. Yes I know you don't believe. It's ok this is not about Christmas it's about pizza . These guys know pizza - everything is made in house - absolutely fabulous. . read more

Saw a review that stated paper plates and plastic utensils, no couldn't be...called and it's true. Too bad. I might try pizza for take out, but not interested in a restaurant that feels like a cheap cafeteria. read more

We tried this place after Hurricane Ian as we were trying to find a pizza place open due to us having no power. Agrigento literally came to the rescue. We tried their large pizza- half pepperoni and half cheese, with a side of ranch. We got the caprese salad and my son got the plain boneless buffalo wings with the Italian fries. My son is so picky (he's 7) and he LOVED his food. He asked if we can always choose agrigentos when we get pizza haha. The pizza was so so good, the sauce was tame but flavorful and the cheeeeese, yum. The caprese salad was refreshing and delicious. For a fam of 5 we spent about $53 for all, that's not bad at all! Can't wait to try their garlic knots (they were out of those and bread for subs) read more

If you like your pizza crust thin and crispy, this is the place for you! They also serve beer and wine which is an added bonus. Interior is very modest but who cares when eating delicious pizza! read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

Delicious pizza !!!! Will order again!! Great white pizza with eggplant. Crust was yummy!! Great meat pizza

Posted the menu with new prices since they were different on here. Mom treated me to lunch and told me about this spot close to home. First time being here, cute little pizzeria. Decided to try the Italian hero, which was SO GOOD AND HUGE. The picture posted is only half of it and I still had half of that to take home. The wings were great too. Decent size with a lot of meat on the bone. Wing prices have been crazy lately but these were reasonably priced and delicious. The Italian blonde ale I had with lunch was also very smooth and refreshing. Will definitely be coming back! read more

See all

New to the area and this pizza is great! The staff is friendly and always cheerful! Will get a lot more pizza from here!!

Best pizza in my opinion here in Bradenton. We are from LI, N.Y. and it was hard to find a place we like. The restaurant is nice, clean and the staff is friendly & helpful. Try it you'll like it. read more

Yum ! Finally a real slice of delicious pizza Have been looking for decent pizza in the Bradenton area for a while! Had the 2 slice lunch special. Great deal too Friendly welcoming staff Not that close to my home but I'll go out of my way to p/u pizza here read more

With all of the reviews we decided to try several items. The Italian hero we had cold. It was large however the bread to filling ratio was mostly bread. Nice slice of mozzarella but very little meat, and the bread was dry. The pizza had good amount of toppings but our preference is for a lighter bake so the crust is not crispy. The cannoli was very good! We will try a pizza again with a lighter bake. read more

Its 7:30 its full house all but two tables..not making another pie tonight...and no ice water ...ok... thats kinda lame ...wanted wings and pizza but i guess your qhole page on your menu isnt your main seller? read more

See all

The pizza was very good. It was carry out so the role at the register was polite and efficient. Didn't eat there but it a clean, neat, bare-bones restaurant. Nothing wrong with that. It's about the food. read more

This Pizzeria is a delicious new restaurant in Bradenton. Their thin and crispy crust makes the pie great. Every day their luncheon 2 slices + 1soda is a good special. They have salads, appetizers and pasta dishes along with their signature Pizza . The restaurant is clean, bright and well appointed. A good Beer and a wine list selection is available. Table seating is well spaced and very new and clean. Try the pie and you will find you new favorite place to eat. read more

Great pizza and food. Reminds me of Italian food from up north. Really loved their Italian sub too, fresh ingredients like mozzarella and prosciutto. read more

Best pizza ever, go early or during off peak hours. I had two slices, one cheese and one pepperoni. It's the smallest pepperoni I have ever seen mini pepperoni. It must be home made. I don't know if it is or not . Do t quote me on that. With two good reviews onevin the Bradenton Herald and one on Next Door. I am sure this little pizzeria will stick around. At least I hope till I get the bf there to check it out with me. read more

Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe - Two slices of pizza and a fizzy water - Pizza Near Me - Bradenton, Florida

See all