All around great place to stop for a bite to eat or just a twist cone , or both!…read more Burgers are hand made, not frozen patties, and delicious!! And prices are better than Dairy Queen. Nice spot to sit out in the fresh Mtn air on a picnic table too .

Made a quick decision to make a pit stop to eat. Great choice. Their "new" pro sandwich was great…read more Bonus it comes with tater tots. Fast service. Friendly kids taking orders. And I got to eat on a park beach outside under a tree.

Excellent ice cream and fudge, also rather large assortment of unusual flavors of saltwater taffy…read more When I get ice cream I usually get it in a bowl because eating from cone gets messy with mustache and beard, nice thing here is they have bowls made out of waffle cones Funny chocolate and coffee themed t-shirts along the wall. Good specialty coffees and lattes. Fast friendly service.

Loved the variety of sugar free sweets. Very busy but got taken care of quickly. Very nice staff.read more

Great service, great ice cream, highly recommended. Make it a stop to get your treat.read more

The ice cream flavors are amazing. Best ever. Great variety. On top of that they have the most…read moredelicious shakes and sundae combinations. The service is fast and friendly. The store is cute and clean; located right by the train station. Best ice cream in keystone by far. They also have great coffee too

Amazing, cheap, flavorful ice cream…read more Attention to all lactose intolerant individuals, this place is perfect for you. My partner and I are both slightly lactose intolerant, and this place gave us no issues. We shared an $8 specialty sundae and it was plenty for the both of us. The place is clean, the service was prompt and friendly, and the prices are great. Flavors are few, but very tasty. I'd recommend finishing your day here. Definitely worth it!

Horatio's gets 5 stars from me for serving high quality dairy-free ice cream -- but I deducted one…read morestar for having one one flavor available! If you're limiting choice to one flavor, why would you make it peanut butter?

By chance we were given chips for a free scoop across the street at Spearfish Brewing Co, which is…read morealso awesome! Stop by and get a scoop or two! Fast and friendly service too!

What a fun place! A collection of unique and delicious ice cream flavors, like Cherry Cola,…read moreBlueberry Goat Cheese, and Peanut Butter Oreo! Very sweet servers at the counter. A delightful end to a lovely date night!

Outstanding food and service! We both had the club sandwich with potato salad, which is served…read morewarm. I usually don't like potato salad, but this was fabulous.... Tried the beer cheese soup as a starter and again --- does not disappoint..... We arrived at 1:00 pm and was taken right in.... they told me they can seat 150 and was turning tables as fast as they could.... I tried paying with a CC, but was told no. Thankfully I had the cash... I didn't see a CASH ONLY sign, but might have missed it, or maybe they just don't take AmExp..... I'm going back for dinner tomorrow night....

We had a ground of 15 so we reserved a table. We came around 4:430pm and they gave us a beeper…read more When our group was all here at 5pm, we were seated promptly with a table prepared. It was already completely filled in the bar with wait times until 6:30pm at that point. Come early or reserve if you have a big group! There are two dinner options for adults - bacon wrapped steak and a German noodles dish. The bacon wrapped steak was great and also came with a wedge salad. The prices were incredible at about $20 per entree. It does have a strong bacon flavor so you have to be sure to enjoy that flavor. There was a hotdog option for kids and a vegetarian menu. The dessert menu was extension with more than 10 items. I had the napoleon and it was light, airy, and flaky. Everyone was happy with their desserts and the price was around $7 per item. Overall, it was a fun experience with decent food in this small town. I would come back and I recommend you try it!

Ice cream! [Keystone SD]…read more After all the walking in and out of shops, most of the time just window shopping, we eventually got tired and wanted something cool and refreshing. Jane's Boardwalk Pizza not only sold pizza but they have an ice cream shop too. I chose Jolted Cow (description: Caramel and Fudgy Brownies swirled in an Espresso flavored ice cream) and hubby chose his usual Mint Chocolate Chip. We enjoyed our treats in their spacious covered outdoor dining area. They also have a second level for more seating. Good service. Review #3491

Jane's combination was delicious! Thin crust loaded with toppings and lots of sauce! They even…read moredelivered a small pizza to our place.

Went into the candy shop today and saw the sweetest girl ever! They have an amazing set up and even…read morehave coffee! I got an iced coffee and it was to die for!!!

While in Custer, I stopped in here for some taffy for a friend. It turns out that the taffy they…read moresell is made in North Dakota (not local) but I still got some because it was better than nothing. From the candy case I got dark chocolate covered toffee and that was worth the trip. It was so very good that I ended up getting more for my entire South Dakota trip which was a great decision. If you are in Custer and need something sweet, stop in!

Arrived when there was a long line, but the staff kept the line moving and pushed out orders…read morequickly. I got a hot fudge sundae and it was great. There's seating outdoors and indoors (inside they had a Christmas in July theme). Cute ice cream shop that's worth a try!

I can see why this place was so busy! Tons of topping options and combinations paired with great…read moretasting ice cream is an easy winner. I got the dirt cup and loved it. The chocolate ice cream was really good and mixed with the crumbled Oreos perfectly, making each bite have little bits of cookies mixed in the ice cream. Highly recommend! Mom got Lauren's landslide and she really loved it too. She liked the vanilla and chocolate mixed ice cream as well as the huge cookie dough chunks. And how doesn't love caramel and chocolate on top of their ice cream?? We had to wait in line about 20-30 minutes, and then had to wait another 15 minutes or so before they called our name with our finished order at the window so be prepared to wait a little, especially if you visit during the weekend. But overall it was worth it to me. The ice cream was smooth and yummy and I loved the cookie pieces mixed into it.

My friends and I wanted to get ice cream after a meal, and we were unpleasantly surprised. One of…read moremy friends got a one-scoop ice cream cone and they gave him 2 scoops. That seems like a good thing, but it wasn't. The person who scooped his ice cream was in a "hurry" to go to the bathroom or on break. The cashier called the scooper back to get my friend's ice cream. He scooped as fast as he could, handed it to my friend and walked off. By the time he received his ice cream, it was lopsided and already about to fall. He paid for his ice cream and left. But that's not all. When he walked out, it had already started dripping down his hand and arm. About 5 minutes later, he had to throw away his ice cream because it was causing a huge mess and people were staring at him. The only good thing about this, is the fact the ice cream was good.

Prices here are bit high for ice cream. Its $9 for 2 vanilla scoops in a cone and $8 for 1 scoop in…read morea cone, so you are essentially paying a $1 premium for one more scoop. Regardless, the ice cream was still good and it was a fun quirky experience trying the original Thomas Jefferson recipe!