Cancel

Open app

Search

American Hardware & Supply

4.7 (3 reviews)
InexpensiveHardware Stores

American Hardware & Supply Photos

You might also consider

More like American Hardware & Supply

Recommended Reviews - American Hardware & Supply

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Mark W.
13
19
293

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hardware Stores 2,382 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Suding Hardware Store

Suding Hardware Store

4.9
(12 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$

Been using this hardware store for over 30 years, people here are great and knowledgeable, they…read moreremember you and usually say it when you walk through the door.( Don't try to pick up the quarter on the floor... .

This is the kind of old-school neighborhood place I have been needing in my life! I'm the daughter…read moreof a do-it-yourselfer so naturally that spirit lives on in me. My family loves out of state so though they can provide guidance I'm always stumped as to where to go for certain items. Now I have found it and better yet they give great advice! My war with squirrels brought me here. I needed chicken wire to deter those pests from eating my freshly planted tulips bulbs. I called and they had 3 varieties to choose from. When I showed up, it felt like I was stepping back in time and I loved every moment. I was greeting and given guidance to what I needed. The gentleman even considered price when making a suggestion to me. Not trying to up sell or give me more than what I needed to get the job done! I'm hoping today's war against the squirrels efforts did the trick but if they didn't, I know where I can go to get some new supplies!

Photos
Store front across from CVS near Raymond Street
Store front across from CVS near Raymond Street
Ray is still talking,   and his son is taking notes of all his pearls of wisdom,    lol
Ray is still talking, and his son is taking notes of all his pearls of wisdom, lol
Ray is explaining to me how hard it is to make a living in the hardware store business while his son just keeps working

See all

Ray is explaining to me how hard it is to make a living in the hardware store business while his son just keeps working
Trust Hardware - Mass Ave

Trust Hardware - Mass Ave

3.9
(7 reviews)
1.8 mi

Not open 24 hours like advertised. This is the second time I've tried to go and they were closed…read more Very frustrating when I dealt with mass Ave traffic. Love the concept and great helpful employees when open. If you don't have the capacity to be open 24 hours, don't advertise it. Call before making the trip!

This is the latest location for local Hardware chain Trust to open. I wanted to set them up so…read morethat yelpers could find the business. I think Fusek's True Value is the only other hardware store in the downtown area, so for those who reside near here (especially those who own homes with lawns downtown), there is now another option. It is located across the parking lot from the new Bodhi Cocktail Bar & Thai Bistro in the site formerly home to Indy Reads (which moved to Fountain Square.) Before you read any further, know that because I don't live downtown, I didn't engage in any transactions while here, so I hope others will soon add more detailed shopping information than I can. The shop is especially prepared for home owners in the area. Lots of items for outdoor work as well a the standard aisles of small items do it yourselfers need and can't find elsewhere. Note that when we visited, a "house" dog was lounging near the counter. So, I would advise not bringing your pets with you to shop since I don't know how they might interact. The dog did not move during our entire visit. Seemed well mannered. One of the benefits of shopping here is that they are open 24 hours a day. My wife asked and yes, they do get shoppers throughout the night! I am glad I'm too old for those all night projects now, but realize that when you get started on something, you sometimes just want to get it done and having a place to get the supplies you need is a huge benefit! The one negative that keeps this from an even higher rating is that the parking is very limited and if you wanted to bring a big truck for hauling larger or multiple purchases, you may have some difficulty in the small parking/loading area compared to most hardware stores I have frequented. But, the store did have a lot of needs covered. I think they are supposed to be a paint supply specialty shop as well. But I didn't realize that until I got home and read some info on their website. If you are downtown for some excellent food, stop by and check Trust out. It might save you a trip to one of those big box stores later. Review #3905

Photos
Pest control
Pest control
Lumber and buckets
Lumber and buckets
They even have a lawn mower for sale.

See all

They even have a lawn mower for sale.
Hedlund's Hardware

Hedlund's Hardware

4.0
(31 reviews)
8.0 mi
•$$

They have been extremely helpful to find what I need, will locate it, and get to the store and have…read moregiven me great gardening and tools advice. An have everything!

Hedlund's Hardware has to be one of Indy's weirdest little gems. Located in practically the perfect…read morespot on the corner of 62nd and Keystone with a Broad Ripple Avenue address, Hedlund's Hardware looks and feels like a blast from the past precisely because it really is a blast from the past. Established in 1935 by Claude and Mary Hedlund, Hedlund's was at first a General Store but now limits itself to a somewhat broad definition of hardware and a personality that practically defies explanation. I avoided Hedlund's for quite some time. I'm a wheelchair user and Hedlund's Hardware is one of those places that practically screams out "You're going to break me!" as I delicately wheel myself through the aisles (or the ones that are passable, a fact that will change from visit to visit). The truth is that some people will hate a place like Hedlund's. It's a chaotic, eclectic, and seemingly disorganized (It's actually fairly well organized) establishment in a world where we want big box convenience and 19-year-old Tommy pretending he knows everything there is to know about plumbing or house repairs. HINT: Tommy doesn't know. At Hedlund's, though, they do actually know stuff. Hedlund's is not a big box store. In fact, it's not even a particularly big store though it's much bigger than it appears from the outside. Hedlund's is not a Sullivan's Hardware, a nearby behemoth that is also local but is much bigger and more contemporary. Hedlund's is, at least in my view, a bit of a cultural icon. It remains in the Hedlund family and is locally owned. I have no idea if this is the original building, but it's definitely symbolic of the history of the area. As I noted, if you need true accessibility it's not likely to be found here. You can get in the doors (most days) as they're level to the ground. That said, Hedlund's packs stuff in here and aisle passage is hit-and-miss. However, folks are friendly, helpful, and actually knowledgeable here and it's worth it to at least visit the place even if you don't completely fall in love with it. It's a unique space, a unique hardware store, and sort of an outcast right between Lowe's and Sullivan's on Keystone yet it continues to be a beacon of sorts and I'm sure glad it's here.

Photos
Hedlund's Hardware
Got bed bugs?
Got bed bugs?
Hedlund's Hardware

See all

Ace Hardware West Washington

Ace Hardware West Washington

4.0
(4 reviews)
5.8 mi
•$

Luv this place, they are actually really helpful. Especially when you come in needing such things…read moreas doohickeys and thingamabobs. Very skilled at charades and guessing what you might be trying to say. And if they can't guess it, they get more players (store emploees) involved, until the mystery is solved and the proper tool or gadget guessed and found for you. I have always heeded their advice and they have not steered me wrong yet. So much better than those huge stores where you have to beg folks to help you and run around finding them, which can take a few miles. In this ACE store, you won't make it to the first aisle without someone greeting you and asking if you need help finding something. Kudos to this mom & pop store.

A miraculous place. Was told they have a lot of nuts and bolts including metric and it's no lie. I…read morewent in to replace a screw and a finishing washer for a 1960 Vespa Motorscooter headlight bezel and presto! I had them in my hands in five minutes. Then they sold me a fingered oven glove which was just what I needed for my small hand. I have literally been looking for months for this thing. So then I asked them if they also had cotton candy and a pony and that's when I finally struck out. A real true-blue old hardware place like I like them. It's basically the Tardis inside. Looks like a standard Ace - but don't be fooled. Also, everyone is helpful and nice. A huge bonus. This is a bit of a drive for me but so worth it.

Photos
Ace Hardware West Washington
They cut keys.
They cut keys.
Ace Hardware West Washington

See all

Sullivan Hardware & Garden

Sullivan Hardware & Garden

4.3
(112 reviews)
8.9 mi
•$$

I love this store! It is so fun. They have a wide selection of plants and even a wonderful section…read morefor indoor plants. The staff is friendly and very helpful as well. The plants are high quality and healthy. I appreciate all the variety, as you'll find much more here than the big box stores. They have anything you need for an outdoor space including grills and furniture. They have a nice selection of other decor and trinkets and even a restaurant inside the shop. I always leave here with a lot of inspiration.

This is my go to. Family owned and operated since 1954, Sulivan Hardware has grown over the past 70…read moreyears into one of the largest home and garden retailers in the state as a member of the Do it Best hardware stores. Because of this massive network of over 4,100 individual stores, they can use this network to provide lower prices to compete with the big box stores. They have everything for every season whether it's flowers, plants, trees & shrubs to outdoor furniture, Christmas trees during the season accessories and a huge array of grills for those grill master enthusiasts. Oh and of course typical hardware stuff like paint, tools etc. Don't miss going into the yellow house and they even have a restaurant, yes in a hardware store, called Sully's that you can eat and also take cooking classes there. You can also walk around with an adult beverage while you browse! They have the OG at 71st and Keystone, they acquired Allisonville home and garden by Sullivan, 49th and Pennsylvania and in Cicero. NOTE: This review was specifically for the 71st and Keystone location.

Photos
Thanksgiving pizza, mashed potatoes, gravy, spicy, cranberry, and turkey
Thanksgiving pizza, mashed potatoes, gravy, spicy, cranberry, and turkey
Sullivan Hardware & Garden
Sullivan Hardware & Garden

See all

American Hardware & Supply - hardware - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...