Sadly, it appears that Amici is reverting back to poor service and really long wait times. Our server was great, but when you're the only one working and a kitchen that decides to prepare food only during TV commercials, you get a less than stellar experience. One of our orders was missed and the replacement took over 30 minutes. This is not surprising as the turnover at this restaurant must be over 100%. It's a different face/crew every time you go. I believe that this is now corporately owned, so please be better or you'll be regulated like all of the other restaurants in Greensboro that shuttered due to poor service. read more

I want to say this place in Greensboro is one of the best when it comes to their pizza. The one thing I find very unique tis this was my first time trying a sweet thai pizza . And I have to say it is very sweet and has bit of a spicy kick to it.But I liked it. It also came with spaghetti and for dessert I had donuts raspberry and chocolate sauces. The wonderful part about it is that the service was wonderful along with the ambiance here. There was hardly anyone here.And honestly that was one of the best parts about it that way you can go ahead and get your order and go. I highly recommend it , especially if you're ever in the greensborough area I highly recommend it, especially if you're ever in the Greensboro area. read more

See all

Great pizza and good bartender. Enjoyed sitting at the bar. Had the sausage and banana peppers and it was really yummy.

We came here to watch the GA (W) - Auburn (L) football game & we walked right in- got a great big booth & settled in. Lots of folks at the bar & others enjoying their meals. Not the best tv situation, but several around so no worries. Good sports vibe! They have a happy hour DURING the GA game. $1 off all shots, wine, beer & appetizers. Fun shots, specialty drinks- and the food seems to be great! My family got a pizza & scarfed it down. Smells amazing in the place!! Staff is friendly! Being as busy as it was they were just a little slower getting drinks to us. No biggie at all, I'm letting you know for those impatient folks who may raise a stink about it. Oh, and it is WAY bigger inside from what it looks like outside!! Pretty cool!! Great restaurant & sports bar!! When in Milledgeville, GA... check it out! read more

We ordered a half pineapple and steak large pizza and it was amazing!!! I'm from New Jersey and we have the best pizza hands down but this pizza is definitely competition! read more

Food is good but if they have live music ... room is small and music is SO loud you will leave with a headache. Not worth it (No knock to musician, he was good but management should have enough sense to not have it so so loud) we won't be back read more

We enjoyed a late lunch here at Amici's today. For a late Tuesday afternoon, the restaurant and bar had a good number of customers. We were very happy to learn about the gluten free pizza crusts Amici's offers and the Athenian and Tuscan were delicious. Our coke and Arnold Palmer were very refreshing on this hot afternoon. Taylor was an excellent server, very friendly and competent. We really liked the ambiance and decor and will be back! read more

See all

Looking for a GREAT pizza? Amici's on lake Oconee has you covered!! I have never been disappointed. They will go out of the way to make your pizza perfect! I like mine with the bottom crust browned and toasty. They get it right every time and never a burnt anything. I call my order in and it is almost always ready at the time they give. The bartenders, who take payment for call in orders, are always friendly and helpful. The dinning room is spacious but the bar is small with limited seating but you will get great service at both!! read more

Good pizza, drinks, and service. We were on a mini getaway from Atlanta with the kids for spring break, staying at the Ritz. Amici is a very good option if you want to get away from the pricier lakeside options. read more

Food was good. Service was great! Nice restaurant with a sports on the tv's. We will be back.

[Takeout review] Overall: Great option if you're looking for some takeout pizza by the lake. The good: The crust is the standout takeaway in this pizza. It's crisp yet has a comforting chewy-ness to it, leaving it not too flaky but not too flabby. The toppings are piled on high, leaving every slice satisfying. They have a decent menu to choose from (as well as the salads and wings). The darkhorse of the meal was the garlic knots that came on the side of the salads, who doesn't love some good knots. The not-so-good: Took awhile for our pizzas to be made and the prices are a bit too high. The BBQ chicken topping combination was a bit odd and didn't quite work as well as it could have. Atmosphere: N/A Service: N/A Food: 8/10 read more

See all

Don't call it gluten free or friendly if cross contamination is not taken seriously (or maybe you served a non gluten free crust and lied? Unclear). My husband is celiac and ordered the gluten free pizza last night. His waitress assured him it was gluten free because he was surprised how good it was, he honestly was worried they had given him a normal crust. Well whether they did give him a gluten full crust or if they didn't he was then up ALL NIGHT because he consumed gluten at this restaurant. He had eaten nothing prior. If you have real gluten intolerance I do not recommend. Oh and they'll put a heart on your box while they poison you, super cute. read more

Amici Lake Oconee - Box from amici with gluten free pizza that caused celiac to be seriously sick. - Bars Near Me - Greensboro, Georgia

It's a shame that the drinks have minimum to no alcohol at all! Be aware of extra charges on the bill, they charge $1 for rocks. Ice. I've never seen that happen before. $3 for a coke that we didn't order. They didn't let us know when the kitchen was about to close because we wanted to get some food to go as well. All said, the food is quite good. I don't think I'll go back again but for someone that's looking to dine here, I definitely recommend their pizzas and tortellini. read more

Tuesday night music Bingo. I asked for bread that the menu says comes with my salad and was told "we're too busy to make it" and then asked if they have thin crust pizza. Again was told "we can make it but we're too busy tonight." I guess if I come back, it won't be on Tuesday. read more

Can't believe they even sold me this pizza considering how burnt it is underneath smh read more

Amici Lake Oconee - I ordered a pizza today and it was burnt underneath under every slice. I'm very disappointed. - Bars Near Me - Greensboro, Georgia

Food and service was excellent and portions were big! Highly recommend. Much improved from previous visit a year or so ago

Always great food. Very helpful with allergies and great service. Pretty busy on weekends. They have several locations in the Lakes area.

I was in Lake Oconee for a work event and a few people recommended Amici's. Great atmosphere inside and the half off appetizers on Mondays was a huge plus! The pizza is not my favorite kind of pizza. A bit too cheesy and greasy. But the mozzarella sticks and buffalo rollers were amazing! read more

Amici Lake Oconee - Pepperoni pizza - Bars Near Me - Greensboro, Georgia

Sports bar atmosphere great menu all entrees I have had have been great. Quick service

Great pizza!!! I'd say it's the best in the neighborhood. Always fresh. Good customer service and reasonably priced. Their salads are pretty good too. read more

Every time we go in the food gets better!! Maybe the cooks have figured out our unusual pizza order!! The bartenders are friendly and enjoy those job!! Everyone always has a smile. They know their alcohol and specialties. Enjoying trying new things each visit.Have never seen the same one twice ....maybe we have been lucky! Have never eaten in the restaurant. Always full of families and laughter. They have daily specials to entice you to try new things..... Pizza has always been good.... Salad fresh but typical selections. read more

A group of us (7) decided to eat there one Sunday afternoon. My hamburger cam out burnt.I sent it back.they were about to close, and we were about to leave.All they did was put it in a to go box. I'll try to upload a photo to show what I mean. Will never go back, even if starving read more

Amici Lake Oconee - Burger sent back, then just put in a to go box stay away - Bars Near Me - Greensboro, Georgia

The best pizza at the lake and one of my favorite pizzas anywhere. Chicken Parmigiano is amazing as well. The one point off is just because their ordering and pickup process (before COVID) was always a bit challenging as it was difficult to place orders over the phone and the pickup was tough because the bar (and pickup area) was usually extra crowded. Only suggestion would be to use the online ordering like at other Amici locations. Even with that one snag, the food is definitely worth it! read more

Perfect wings! Love the garlic rolls. Great food and service! Thank you Amber P!!!

Went for lunch and after 55 minutes of waiting for food, we left. The entire restaurant smells like a fraternity restroom and is crowded with servers who have been expertly trained to avoid eye contact or any conversations that may actually lead to the execution of service being rendered. Trust me. IF you want Amici food, drive the extra 27 miles and go to the Amici in Madison. You'll save time and frustration from having to endure the one at Lake Oconee. read more

We decided to go here for lunch and we weren't disappointed. I will say if you if you have a crunch for time I wouldn't recommend this place. I ordered the "Athenian": Grilled chicken, Spinach, artichoke hearts, crushed tomatoes, topped with a swirl of pesto fresh out of the oven. It was mouthwatering delicious. They seemed a little under staffed but the waitress didn't let it phase her one bit. I would like to go back and try one of their sandwiches, maybe the Buffalo chicken sandwich. read more

Amici Lake Oconee - "Athenian" - Bars Near Me - Greensboro, Georgia

Amici Lake Oconee is OPEN for business! Boneless lemon pepper wings were so good we placed a 2nd order. The staff were welcoming and our server Taylor was very attentive. Large pepperoni pizza and cold beers at the bar were perfect. This location is our new go-to. We'll be back for more wings on Super Bowl Sunday. read more

Best wings in Oconee. Honey Xx - try it you'll agree Artichoke hearts Chick Parm Sub + pasta salad = lunch winner Slices are awesome with tomato basil salad read more

Disappointed that they closed; quality deteriorated and friends didn't enjoy the pizzas.

Tried out the remodeled Amici's the other night. Went in to pick up a couple of spaghetti and meatball dinners for take out. Got home, plated the spaghetti and became disappointed immediately. The "Amici Marinara Sauce" was right out of a can of commercial sauce. There was nothing unique, nothing tasty, nor any fresh ingredients in this sauce. No way this sauce was made in their kitchen. The only thing unique about this sauce would have been the can opener, opening the can. If we had had a jar of "Insert Name of Any Store Brand " Pasta Sauce I would have restrained the spaghetti and used that as the sauce. Those two spaghetti dinners went right into the trash. read more

Amici's was our go to restaurant but continues to disappoint and tonight we are done. There was not wait for a table but, an hour after being seated and without food we realized that patrons who had pre-ordered their food were dining in the restaurant ahead of the other patrons who had placed their orders after being seated. If we had known it was a "pre-order take out but dine in experience" we would have planned accordingly. Poor management. read more

Lunch was salty and not enough sauces. Seating was okay, service had a hint of reluctance. Just not welcoming enough.

Called to place togo order was put on hold for 15 minutes to be hung up on. So I drove to the restaurant for the manager to tell me it's a hour and half wait. If your restaurant is that busy when you have a customer calling in a order you should just go ahead and let them know it's a extremely long wait. But you know stupidity starts with management. read more

My family, friends, and I stayed at a lake house on Oconee for the weekend. We wanted pizza, so we tried Amici. We got three pies. I thought the pizza was very good! We got it to go, but we checked out the inside of the restaurant while we waited. Played a little Mrs. Pac-Man. It was fun! read more

We were staying at a campground, had rained all day, so we decided to order from Amici's. It started off with a bang as the order taker was the most pleasant lady, being so helpful ! Ordered a pizza which was the best I've had in a while! Also ordered 12 wings xtra crispy. Our food arrived promptly and pizza was piping hot! Opened the the box of supposedly wings and it was a salad. Oh well, I didn't need wings anyway and it didn't even bother me. I bet someone was surprised expecting a salad and ended up with 12 crispy wings. During these Covid 19 times, I know times are tough for restaurants, but I was so appreciative from the order taker to the delivery lady! Good food and great service, except for 1 little mixup. No problem! read more

My favorite spot for wings on the lake! Hot honey is where it's at extra crispy! Pizzas are always great! We use them for catering for our company and it's always a hit in the office! read more

Best pizza in the area--hands down. The Works is my favorite, along with the Honey X wings. Spicy, but not too hot. We always get take-out. read more

My wife and son ate at Amici's last night. We were immediately seated and our server came within a very reasonable time. She took our drink order and appetizer order and was quite friendly. We ordered a pizza and we were not disappointed! The toppings were fresh and delicious. We'll be coming back. My wife and I just returned from another very good experience at Amici's. We were served by Lele who was great. Our drinks were actually served by the manager/owner who asked us if everything was going fine. We generally eat there at least 1 time ever month when we are in town. The food was served very quickly and it was great as in the past. The restaurant was crowded and busy, however, we had a great meal along with friendly service. read more

Labor Day weekend in Lake Oconee was great! We went in search of some non-bbq type food since we were going to have that Monday, so we chose pizza......we made a great choice!! The pizza was delicious and the Georgia Mule was mixed just right!! The service was a little slow, but it was busy and nothing out of the ordinary......definitely will return! read more

Went to Amici today and the majority of their staff was either not wearing a mask or wearing it on their chin. All bartenders were mask-less. We had to leave and take our food to go. Enter this place with caution. read more