Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    An Extra Slice Of New York

    4.3 (6 reviews)
    Closed 3:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Order An Extra Slice Of New York Takeout or Delivery

    An Extra Slice Of New York Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like An Extra Slice Of New York

    Recommended Reviews - An Extra Slice Of New York

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Best pizza place in the area! They're amazing! 10/10 from everything staff to sauce! Recommend to anyone. Yahoo!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    I just ate pizza from here for the first time, and it's my new favorite pizza. I'll be back again soon.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - An Extra Slice Of New York

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Salad 120 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sweet Buzz Bean & Bistro - Iced Horchata

    Sweet Buzz Bean & Bistro

    4.1(84 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $

    This place is always amazing :-). I'm in several times a week and love the atmosphere and…read moreemployees! Food, always tasty and fresh! The older blonde lady has got customer service in her blood, always upbeat, always ensuring I like my drink before I walk away, and always adds a cute little touch to make it pretty. She knows me by name and very often is in the midst of making my drink before I order. I will never stray. They have a knack of making guests feel special! I recommend you try this hidden gem!

    This is a great place for coffee, specialty drinks, breakfast or lunch…read more I have been here numerous times and always had a good (and tasty) experience. When you walk in, it has a warm, inviting vibe. There are a variety of tables and seating options (including some couch and comfy chair type seating). You order by going up to the counter, and they either call your order or will bring it to your table when it is done if you are eating it there. One down side is that there is a fairly large menu and it isn't always easy to find/see all of the options when you are waiting to order. My daughter saw someone got a bubble tea but at the time we were looking, that menu wasn't easy to spot so we didn't even know it was something they offered! All of their food items are made to order (well, I suppose except for the soup which is home made and just dished out to order). They even have soup flights on certain days! I need to go back and try that because every soup I've ever had here has been delicious. They have the standard coffee menu but also always have some unique and quirky seasonal options. They also have smoothies, bubble teas and some other unique creations. They have tasty breakfast and lunch sandwiches, breakfast scrambles, mac and cheese and a variety of sandwiches. You can easily customize your meals and the staff is great about providing recommendations. It can take awhile to get your food/drinks, but that is because everything is made to order. A fun and tasty place for a bite to eat or a sweet treat!

    Photos
    Sweet Buzz Bean & Bistro
    Sweet Buzz Bean & Bistro - Drink Flight & mini pastries

    Drink Flight & mini pastries

    Sweet Buzz Bean & Bistro - Drink Flight 2025

    See all

    Drink Flight 2025

    Old Village Grill - Classic Garlic Hummus

    Old Village Grill

    4.2(60 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $

    The food was fabulous, fantastic and huge! I never saw a gyro so big. It could feed 4 people…read moreeasily. This was a delivery. The gyro salad was huge as well. We ordered stuffed grape leaves and a spinach/feta cheese in pastry. We were so full after attempting to eat our gyros that we had to put them in the fridge without opening them. We will order or go in person to this restaurant often. Try it you will love it.

    I've been looking for good Greek food since I came back from my honeymoon, and this is the place!…read more Everything on their menu is flavorful & authentic. The people working here are super friendly & helpful. They made a mistake with one of my orders (forgot the tzatziki on the side & no cucumbers), and they completely made a new one and allowed me to keep the extra! The restaurant is quite small; although, there are some seat by the window. Nevertheless, this spot is perfect for quick takeout, and I love that it's local! Here's what I've tried: [Chicken Gryo]: Flavorful & stuffed full. This can be super messy so ask for the tzatziki on the side. I love that they put fries on their gyros. That's what I saw in Santorini. [Hummus]: Both hummus that I have tried has been super flavorful & authentic. The classic garlic hummus is out of this world, and I really loved the spiciness & mix of feta in the Spicy Hummus. Pro Tip: order extra pita with the hummus. There's not enough! [Baklava Cheesecake]: Although this isn't exactly authentic, it was delicious. I love baklava, and I love cheesecake. This was a winning combination for me. A flaky top with a creamy inside allowed for the perfect dessert! [Rice Pudding]: I didn't take a picture of this dessert, but it was delicious nonetheless. It's creamy and vanilla-y (Is that a word?!?), and the cinnamon on top pairs perfectly for a more than flavorful dessert. They always have a special of 2 for $6. Perfect for eating one now & saving one for lunch tomorrow! [Crab Cake Gyro]: For Lenten, they have specials, and this one did not disappoint. The crab cake was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. I love the innovation of the seaside tzatziki that paired well with the crab cake. I tasted a hint of Old Bay. Perfection. I will be eating at this place over and over again. I cannot wait to try everything on the menu!

    Photos
    Old Village Grill - Information

    Information

    Old Village Grill - Crab Cake Gyro with Seaside Tzatziki

    Crab Cake Gyro with Seaside Tzatziki

    Old Village Grill - Baklava Cheesecake

    See all

    Baklava Cheesecake

    Out of the Fire Cafe - Hummus Platter at Out of the Fire Cafe

    Out of the Fire Cafe

    4.3(556 reviews)
    22.8 mi
    $$

    A Hidden Gem Worth Leaving the Turnpike For! After making…read morethe drive between Northern Virginia and Ohio for more than 20 years, we couldn't believe we had never discovered Out of the Fire Café before. Anyone who regularly travels the Pennsylvania Turnpike knows how hard it is to find a truly memorable place to eat. This one is absolutely worth the short detour. The atmosphere is charming, the view is beautiful, and the food exceeded every expectation. We had to try their famous mushroom soup, and even though I'm not normally a mushroom fan, it was hands-down one of the best cups of soup I've ever had. The smoked salmon salad was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. My husband ordered the Filet Mignon Sandwich special, and every bite was packed with incredible flavor. Our server was warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. She made us feel right at home and added to what was already a wonderful dining experience. We finished with the Bananas Foster. While it wasn't the tableside flaming presentation you'd find at a fine-dining restaurant, the flavor was outstanding and the perfect ending to a fantastic meal. We'll definitely be making Out of the Fire Café a tradition on our future trips. If you're traveling the Pennsylvania Turnpike, do yourself a favor and make the stop--you won't regret it!

    Some of the best food in the region and great ambiance and service. Nice outdoor area and views…read more Love this spot

    Photos
    Out of the Fire Cafe - Seating Area at Out of the Fire Cafe

    Seating Area at Out of the Fire Cafe

    Out of the Fire Cafe - Prince Edward Island Mussels

    Prince Edward Island Mussels

    Out of the Fire Cafe - Storefront for Out of the Fire Cafe

    See all

    Storefront for Out of the Fire Cafe

    Jaffre’s Stone Bar & Kitchen - Dirty Chicken Sandwich

    Jaffre’s Stone Bar & Kitchen

    4.7(35 reviews)
    16.3 mi

    This was our first visit. They offer dining on two floors. The bar is on the first so we chose the…read moresecond because of noise level. The room is large and nicely decorated. Service was exceptional as was the food. Recommend the Cauliflower, Pot Roast, and Apple Cobbler. Most meals come with a very nice Wedding Soup. The best is their Skillet Corn Bread. You will not find better anywhere. Prices are low and portions huge. Hope you get Ben as your server. He is super.

    Cute place! The vibes are adorable and there is PLENTY of seating. Me and my boyfriend went this…read morepast weekend because we were gonna golf but it got rained out and we were hungry. Upon searching good ol Google we found this place and the Gluten Free menu was huge so we knew we had to go here! To start out with, we ordered Shrimp and Crab Fries. They were really good. The flavors all together were perfect and it was a huge portion size definitely worth the money! Since never being there before we asked the waitress the fan favorites and she recommended the burgers so we had to try them. I got the GF regular Cheeseburger and he got the GF Maple Bacon Burger- unfortunately when it initially came out it was on a normal bun but, they were quick to fix it by making a whole new burger and discounted the burger! The server was so sweet and apologized. I do think the burgers were juicy and big! Great portions and very reasonable pricing. I cant wait to try their other options!

    Photos
    Jaffre’s Stone Bar & Kitchen - Xmas decorations near the entrance.

    Xmas decorations near the entrance.

    Jaffre’s Stone Bar & Kitchen - Margherita Pizza

    Margherita Pizza

    Jaffre’s Stone Bar & Kitchen - Gnocchi Short Rib

    See all

    Gnocchi Short Rib

    An Extra Slice Of New York - salad - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...