BEST sandwiches! Hot food great! BLT very special. Favorite deli ever. read more

Very small, 4 car parking, park on street, long lines... but oh my what a great place for sandwiches! The prices are right on the staff move at lightning speed. The food is to die for, fresh fresh fresh. Just the best place around for lunch. Try it. Frank G read more

Antho y'all Deli is one of those rare "hole in the wall" type delis that is always packed with customers. From their piled high sandwiches, to their double-fisted grabs of bacon for their BLT's, to their homemade Chicken Cutlets, and everything else in between; Anthony's Deli is THE deli to go to!!! Line looks long, but turns over quickly. Staff is patient, nice, and will throw in your bag a mint or two. read more

Made my way to New York from Texas to bury a dear friend. One of the bright spots in my pilgrimage was a visit to Anthony's. It's like a time warp, everything remains the same. Enormous wedge sandwiches..... Same price....... Same people. This place is timeless and really really good. I only come up every couple years.... And I always make it a point to visit my favorite deli. read more

Their special Chicken Cutlet Italiano (under $10) is an amazing sandwich. Fresh crusty sesame hero bread is stellar. Their cutlet is wonderfully crispy and breaded, as well as actually hot when served in the sandwich. A bit light on the fresh mozarella, the bruschetta and vinegar helps keep the sandwich vibrant. And obviously a two meal ordeal with its size. Compared to Cosmo and Alex, this is a superior cutlet sandwich. read more

Love the food here. Crazy amount of options, big sandwiches for a really great price.

When you need a property deli in a pinch for breakfast, lunch or really any number of a million ways to stop your heart from beating and gain 50 pounds Anthony's is there and does a great job putting quality deli out consistently read more

Just say no. Lived in Westchester all my life and Anthony's used to be good but not any more. Dry impossible to chew pastrami, soggy fries and onion rings, tough chicken parmigiana with no cheese, indifferent help, long wait. Not worth it. read more

Racist deli is still racist. I should have read the reviews to figure out they were rude. They actually whisper about you in front of you as if they are little school girls. SMH. We went there to try something new and the moment we stepped in it, it was like stepping into the "Insurrection Deli". Fine, hopefully the food is good right? We spent $40 bucks on breakfast and lunch. The reviews must be somewhat right...right? Wrong! The sausage was grey and tasteless, the eggs were undercooked, and to top it off, they got the order wrong?!? If you are going to be racist, at least get the order right. Odd enough is the people in the back are not whyte but still racist??! So, if you want a 0.5/10 sandwich seasoned with racist undertones, this is your deli. If you like racism, then you'll give this a good rating (see other ratings). But if you have any active tastebuds, even if you like racism, you will realize the sandwiches are barely edible. read more

I don't know how Anthony's Deli stays in business. Your average sandwich/hero has enough cold cuts to remove more than 1/2 and still have enough left over to make 2 more average sandwiches. (No Exaggeration). The sandwiches are huge, the price is cheap. Have a look at the photo of the Balboa I posted. $7.25 for a 1FT hero stuffed with Roast Beef, Swiss & Garlic Oil. It's Lunch & Dinner. Awesome! read more

Anthony's Delicatessen - The 'Balboa' - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

All the food is Top notch. Would definitely recommend this place. Breakfast or lunch and Even a early dinner you can't go wrong.

Generously stuffed cold cut sandwiches. Prices are more than reasonable. Some "specials of the day " disappoint once in a while. Overall my favorite deli! read more

Good , generous sandwiches, fast friendly service and reasonably priced. You do have to get past the messy, dark disorganized wait line to appreciate. Someone recommended I try Anthony's, but if I walked in off the street I would have walked right back out. read more

Excellent heros. The bread is so good. Everything we've ordered is excellent. Bacon, egg and cheese. Philly cheese steak. Grilled chicken. All big. Excellent. read more

Everything here is amazing, you can't go wrong - every time. And I have ordered from them A LOT. Would recommend BEC, Italian delight, eggplant parm, and mozz sticks. read more

Not really for vegetarians. I'm not a fan of this delicatessen since I'm vegetarian plus the place doesn't look clean. It's filthy plus the options are not a lot. Don't recommend if you are vegetarian read more

Great sandwiches very fair prices. Tough to park but worth the wait. Skip salads and just get the wedges..

Alyssa V can go scratch. Good food takes time and this is by far one of the 10 best delis in Westchester. You don't stay in business this long without doing something right. Please don't go back so the line is just for the un-privileged. read more

This is your classic New York deli. Don't bother going anywhere else if you want a good wedge. You'll find fair prices for wedges that are bigger than your face. The food is so delicious and even though that wedge is bigger than your face and you say you can't finish, give yourself five minutes and you'll find all that's left is a bunch of crumbs. read more

A hometown favorite. They have high quality food and make HUGE sandwiches. My personal favorites are the "chubby chicken" and the American combo. The staff is always friendly. The line can be very long sometimes but they go through customers fairly quickly and the food is worth the wait. I probably go at least once a week. read more

Makes the best sandwiches. They do not skimp in the meat. Delicious bread. Cash only.

Best baconeggandcheese of all time. Hashbrown. Salt pepper hot sauce.

I first visited Anthony's when a friend took me there on our way to Wrestlemania; he told me these sandwiches would be worth it, and they are. I had a massive American Combo, which is possibly the best sandwich I have ever tasted! Over subsequent visits I have ordered more American Combo's, a Philly Cheesesteak, and the legendary "Godfather", all of which were indescribably delicious. Over my next two visits I plan on trying the Balboa, and the Pastrami Reuben, and I cannot wait. Fantastic taste, huge portions, and a steal of a price (I swear they give us at least $10 sandwiches for only $7.50), Anthony's Deli gets 5 stars from me, and I constantly recommend it to everyone. read more

Anthony's Delicatessen - American Combo on a roll - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

The Godfather is an experience. I've never braved one - bitten, but not braved. Every deli meat piled high onto one hero. I've seen it SHARED by three growing teenage boys (and they instructed the sandwich master to hold the olive loaf). My brother, quite confident in his hero-scarfing heroics, laughed - scoffed even! - when I dared him to take this on a five-hour plane ride to Texas. He took the challenge, returning from Anthony's with The Godfather, noting, "I think this weighs about 8 pounds," with a gleam in his eye, before gingerly tucking the hero into his carry-on. That evening, he called. He had failed - nobly. Never before defeated by a sandwich. read more

Uber eats order was sloppy w/ raw bacon and missing toppings. Sandwiches were also smaller than in store. The Uber eats menu could also use an update a lot of items are missing. read more

Amazing bacon and and cheese sandwiches, good coffee, super nice staff! Great prices - 2 sandwiches, 2 coffees, 2 seltzers for $14. I wish I lived closer so it could be my regular spot. Nice that they have a parking lot - it's small but there is plenty of street parking too. Thanks for a great breakfast, guys! read more

Anthony's Delicatessen - His and hers. Oh so cute. :-)) - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

For the $9.50 the godfather wedge could feed a small family but the quality of the meats were not up to my standards for a good " italian" sandwich. Lots of pepperoni , salami and other low budget " Italian " cold cuts. Spend same get a smaller sandwich with better ingredients somewhere else. read more

Regretfully, I only used my hand as the pespective in this photo. You should know my hands are 5 feet long. Kidding. They're normal guy hands and the photo is only HALF of a Godfather. I've been going to Anthony's for almost 20 years. I have never had a bad experience. The sandwiches are amazing. As previous posters have said, I have no idea how they stay in business with what they give for what you pay. Actually, I do. What they've done is create a fiercely loyal following of people who know they can go in, be served promptly, have their sandwich made expertly and get a tremendous value. I have compared all other deli's and sandwich shops to Anthony's and they have all come up wanting. To the reviewer who posted a pic of a Balboa - no knock on you sir, but it's either the wrong sandwich or you had it made with lettuce - a bold move, sir. One that I may not be on board with but I shall not get between a man and his proclivities when it comes to a Balboa. I know only not to lay a hand on another mans, for fear of losing finger. In either case, as with my shot of the godfather, we are not doing them justice. I am not in the deli right now, but can tell you from memory that it is made with roast beef, garlic sauce (itialian dressing with garlic powder most likely) and swiss. It is then toasted to perfection. Ask for extra sauce and save half for the next day ;) Honestly...hands down, no doubt about it, you can feel confident in telling your mother to shut her mouth if she disagrees, the best sandwich place in the world. And I am not one to tell my mom or yours to shut their mouth! But honestly, if they disagree, you should say "Mom, honestly. I love you. But shut it." Or not, but I would. read more

Anthony's Delicatessen - "The Godfather" - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

People seem to confuse quality and quantity. My balboa came packed with average roast beef. The Arthur Avenue bread is a slice above other deli's, but the dry meat killed the sandwich. I ordered pickup and no one acknowledged I was there. I waited a good 10 minutes before being helped. I'll update my review if I decide to return and have a redeeming experience. Disappointing three stars. read more

I have been coming here for year's and you cannot go wrong with any sandwich they make. However, you really need to have the Godfather. it is so jammed with great italian meats, sometimes i think it is less of a sub and more of a delivery system for deli meat. it is a must have. read more

Even with all the breakfast spots in new Rochelle I still take the ride out here when I don't want to be disappointed. The breakfast barge can't be beat! Great place, great food and great people, what more could you ask for. read more

Anthony's Delicatessen - Breakfast Barge. Yes it's as good as it sounds. - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I get the turkey club each time and they are really good about making my bacon extra crunchy when I ask. Every sandwich is good, and huge! For the price. Their substitutions are a little pricy but it's deff a treat. They have a great drink/arizona selection, as well as chips and other candys. Even though its really annoying they dont accept debit or credit cards, theres an ATM right inside. The parking lot right outside the entrance fits only a few cars at a time, so I recommend parking on one of the side roads or closer to Carvel. I try and come to Anthonys at least once a week, its a treat and my boyfriend and I will split a wedge. read more

This place is a must....You can get 4 meals out of one sandwich! I have been eating here since High School (18 years ago) and they still serve the same size portions. Of couse back then I could finish one of their wedges, but thats besides the point. I weighed the Ham and lettuce wedge that I got, and it weighed in at a whoping 28oz....WOW. Delicious! read more

Oh man! Favorite deli in town! Sandwiches are absolutely amazing. I can't say enough good things about the staff and the sandwiches. Plenty of drink and staff chooses as well. Crazy John is absolutely stunning. read more

Amazing food at amazing prices. Their sandwiches are top notch and are always packed full with meat. My go to order is a pastrami sandwich on a wedge with mustard. The wedge is huge and the amount of pastrami that is loaded into the sandwich is ridiculous. So much food for such a low price. On multiple occasions, I have split the wedge into quarters, creating lunch for 4 days. Writing this review has got me craving a pastrami sandwich. Looks like I'm going back to Anthony's! I highly recommend it! read more

The BEST deli and the BEST staff. There is not a single thing on the menu that is bad. Best deli in existence! High quality food made quickly. This place is as good as it gets, if not better! read more

I have been going here for ages and I have to say it is the best deli around. There proportion are awesome and the food is always made fresh. Some of my favorites are - chubby chicken -meatball Parmesan - the breakfast barge Place is always, even if there is a line it moves quick. Always awesome. read more

Solid place. I can't say much about anything but the godfather sandwich as I have never had anything but that it's very delicious. Been going here 10+ years. Good food. Wish they took credit cards. Good place. read more

Gotta give these "Magic Mikes" a big good job! Four young dudes behind the counter hustling out great sandwiches in A carry out only deli. Sandwiches are thick with meat and super tasty. The guys are friendly And knock the orders out ASAP. BLT had so much Bacon and my pastrami was on point. read more

quite quite quite good! I had the chicken cutlet one... on a wedge... the thing lasted me all day. BUT OH SO DELICIOUS! sadly, they dont take cards so be prepared when you go. I enjoy using a debit card and was denied, but an in house atm exists! the sandwich however left me satisfied and almost craving more.... I will have to try a breakfast one from there when I have an early meeting one day! YUM! and the price... a can of Arizona and a massive sandiwch... $9 - priceless! read more