This place makes me want to rewatch The Godfather. Got the #11 on a long sesame roll. The bread was the star of the show. Fantastic sandwich. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - #11 Sandwich. Chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, mozzarella, and balsamic on a sesame roll - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Took a chance off 95 and went to this local gem. Deli is stocked with everything you want and the fresh Italian was on spot with lots of meat, cheese and just the right amount of oil and vinegar. The bread! Amazing. Don't pass this spot up, get thru the GwB and head for a quaint town with charm! read more

I had an outstanding wedge here. I decided to try an eggplant Parm wedge and it was on the perfect seeded roll. The eggplant was sliced really thin the way I like it and it was cheesy and just delicious! The staff is really friendly and they chat with you. They also have a hot food bar at the end. There are many specialty items here that I will be trying! read more

See all

Amazing sandwich shop. Authentic and fresh ingredients. Probably the best or one of the best Italian sandwich shops in the area. Ordered a few different types for my office holiday party and each one was solid. I was particularly impressed with the quality of meats and the bread. A very tasty Italian sandwich for sure. The prices were super reasonable i felt, especially considering the level of food. Everyone inside was very friendly and helpful. read more

Great place to get great food. Highly recommended to everyone who appreciates quality food.

Love this place. Best Italian foods in the Mamaroneck area. Highly recommend you visit.

Great sandwiches, sizeable portions and very popular- would go early. Lots of choices or you can make your own - we got the Italian combo + the chicken w/ broccoli rabe + mozz. We can't wait to come back! read more

Didn't know Mamaroneck would have a place of this quality. No offense to Mamaroneck but I didn't peg it as an old school italian town. This is your classic deli that checks off all boxes. They have italians running the show and they are even speaking the language with the customers. It is always a good sign when the bread comes from terranova bakery which is a top quality bakery near Arthur Ave. The sesame seed long roll is the way to go. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich with american, roasted peppers, and balsamic. It was one of the best sandwiches I have had in a while. So good. I also tried the chicken salad sandwich and it was good but I would stick to the italian sandwiches next time. I want to try the fried eggplant sandwich too. This is one of those places you have to check out when in the area. Portions are big and prices are right too. You don't find too many of these places anymore but glad I did. read more

See all

I didn't realize they had well-done roast beef and railroads beef. They made the sandwich and I asked if it was rare. The guy went over looked at it said absolutely. When I got back to eat my sandwich it was well done. Normally give these guys in A plus but today they get a C. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - This is what they said was rare - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Italian deli meets italian mini-market. Their breads and cured meats are great. And you can't beat their italian combo hero...they never skimp on high quality ingredients and for less than $10 a ridiculous bargain these days. read more

The eggs with cheese was good in a roll just take they completely forgot what a bacon eggs and cheese is would've been way better if it had the bacon it supposed to have on both rolls. read more

My new favorite local deli since moving to the area. Great selection and prices, and a nice little market within the deli, where you can find some interesting imported savory and sweet snacks, pastas, sauces, drinks, etc. Customized sandwiches are actually encouraged, and they don't bang you over the head for doing so. Moreover, the staff is really nice, helpful, and unpretentious...the polar opposite of that deluded douchebag at Dante's. read more

Great sandwiches and a large selection of true Italian specialties. The staff has always been friendly and pleasant to deal with. The Italian Combo hero is one of the best bargains in Westchester County. read more

Woooowww!!! What an amazing place. Literally one of the best Italian Deli & Grocery store in my opinion & the best sandwich shop in Westchester County! The owner and staff are friendly and welcoming. I use to go to Casa. But no more. I have found my favorite spot, finally. Takes me back to Astoria. I can not get enough. Btw they own the amazing bakery next door you can go grab some pastry & or cookies with an expresso after. read more

The fresh burrata was great as well as the pre packaged crostini. Just be aware of beverages and check expiration. My wife ended up drinking a 10 YEAR OLD bottle of Acqua Panna. Quite disturbing to be honest knowing that there has been no recent rotation of stock or inventory checklist being the water was produced in 2011 and expired in 2013. Just an FYI. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - You can what looks like gelatin like metallic flakes sitting in the bottom. - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Las week for Thanksgiving the Reverend had her daughter in law order us a fried turkey for Thanksgiving and it was the most disgustingly un- edible, unfit for human consumption. Wouldn't even serve it to a dog. What made it worse is that when I contacted the Pisano Bros. He couldn't care less. He said send a photo. I haven't heard one thing from them so I am posting a picture of this disgusting meal they sold to my family for thanksgiving. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - This is what Cosmo and Alex sold to me and family for thanksgiving. Not fit for human consumption. In what universe is this a fried turkey - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Classic neighborhood Italian deli where you can get hot food, sandwiches, cold cuts and huge variety of canned and dry goods. Based on the advice of a friend, I opted for a hero, wedge, sub or whatever slang term you use in your culture. The sandwich itself was kind of standard fare with the usual variety of cold cuts and cheese. Condiments were pretty standard as well. All in all, a fairly ordinary sandwich. As it was close to lunch time, there was a nice sized crowd at the counter, with some folks ordering multiple items and some who sounded like they were ordering for a couple of meals to be cooked at home. Maybe next time I'll try something more exotic! read more

This place is an institution. The best Italian everything around. Sausages, deli meats, italian candy, cookies, cakes, sandwiches, home made peppers, olives. I could go on and on. If you are an Italian and you have not been here, you are missing the best. Actually, anyone who has not been here is missing out, period. Just the smells alone will tantalize you. Frank G read more

The most incredible Italian combo hero that I've ever had for the money. 6.75 and enough to easily feed two people(or one of me). The bread was perfect. The cold cuts were of high quality. The veggies were crisp. The price was right. My good buddy at Pops Espresso told me to give them a try and I was absolutely blown away! This is hands down my new favorite deli on the area. Oh... The bread pudding is to die for here. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - Layered perfectly!! - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Far far from good, ratatouille could of cook better than them,I feel sorry to throw food away,but this had it's Destiny. I'm sorry but this is the last time I go here. I don't know about the sandwiches,but FOOD horrible!!! Look at the crap in the picture for 13.00 !!! read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

This is one helluva Italian deli. First off, they have everything you need. Everything. They make great sandwiches. I am not sure where they get their bread, but man its good. But aside from having an incredibly wide selection of super high end goods, they are just awesome people. Every time I go I wind up chatting with whoever it is at the counter. I was already sold on this place hook line and sinker, than last Sunday I ran in because I was a can of tomatoes short for my Sunday sauce.....they were closing down, lights off, the whole shebang. I told the guy who was locking up I just needed one can of tomatoes. I didn't have cash on me and the credit card machine was down. He just told me to grab a can and pay him the next time (don't worry, I won't forget). That little 3 dollar gesture means more to me than anything a shop keeper can do. read more

When in Westchester and in Mamaroneck. I always make time to stop and get that Italian Hero from Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros. It's been a staple since I was my sons age 5. My father used to take me here to get that fresh Italian wedge. Today I picked up a Chicken Cutlet with Fresh Mozzarella Basil tomato and balsamic. Amazing! read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I went in for the 1st time and got a Pat's Special (roast beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a hero) for $7.75. Came on a fresh, soft, sesame hero roll. Not toasted where the crust scratches the roof of your mouth. Roast beef was sliced nice and thin so every bite was tasty and soft. No stringy roast beef pieces and lettuce was finely shredded. Would definitely come back and try other sandwiches. It's an Italian market with a deli counter so no seating. But lots of jarred and dried italian foods. read more

This place brings me back to my childhood in the Bronx. The real deal Italian deli serving some of the best heroes I've ever had. Try the Italian combo platter! Love just walking in as it reminds me so much of all of the wonderful salumis of my childhood. Dried and cured meats like salami, mortadella, and sopressata. You just can't get this stuff at Stop & Shop. read more

Absolutely the BEST for EVERYTHING Italian! The imaginative sandwiches, often named for locals, the wide selection of imported Italian products such as oils, cheeses, nuts, etc. If you live nearby and you go to a supermarket to buy Italian foods, you're missing out on great selections and great flavors. read more

This is by far one of my most favorite delis in Westchester.Real old school Italian deli. Rules of fresh to order Italian Fair. I watched the first mid lasagna come out of the oven it looks delicious. I got fresh shaved prosciutto fresh mozzarella and I got a chicken sandwich wood fresh cut bacon that was cooked to order. You can't get that at most delis. Plus the price is more affordable than most others in the area. If you're in mamaroneck this is a must go to place read more

Best deli in Westchester. Great people, authentic food! Those who know, know this is a neighborhood gem that can't really be replicated elsewhere. Very fortunate to live in a town with great traditional spots like this. read more

Folks, it is not just a deli. They import hard to find Italian products that just recently have made their way to the US and Northeast only. Their authentic ingredients and products make well trained foodies like me , happy . Make sure that you stop by and ask for Pasquale, when you are in town. Sandwiches, get creative and you will really see what Cosmo's is all about.. Check out some of the recipes made with their products at my website "Some Love Around the Island" http://lovearoundtheisland.blogspot.com/. Search for Cosmo Salute ! read more

Love the hot food options. Lots of cold cut options. Cold food is also great, olives, oils, seafood. Everything here! Staff not that friendly but not horrible read more

My favorite spot on the Mamaronek strip, great hot meals, best fresh sandwiches, and a bounty of Italian ingredients. Love the staff here too, so friendly, patient and efficient! read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - My favorite sandwich, ciabatta roll, prosciutto, provolone, artichokes and arugula - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I got turned on to these sandwiches by my good friend Mark T., a Mamaronecker. Top quality meats, cheeses, bread, and Italian delicacies. Really good sandwiches made all kinds of ways. read more

Certainly the finest Italian market/deli north of Arthur Ave. Fine imported groceries, meats and cheeses. Widely loved for its excellent sandwiches, but do yourself a favor and don't stop with just a sandwich. Some of the counter men can be brusque; but if it's slow try engaging on the subtle differences between domestic & imported prosciutto or hot vs sweet capicola. read more

This always an option for me during lunch time. The sandwiches are delicious down to each component. Pricing is more than reasonable and the hot bar has some great selections as well. I usually go for the "juice" sandwich special which is fried eggplant, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella and onions. The juice is beyond delicious of course. I also am a huge fan of sundried tomatoes and they make them fresh here. If you are also a fan of sundried tomatoes you will not be disappointed, its very delicious. Staff is very friendly as well. They also have various imported products which are great. Please by all means if you need lunch and are craving deli come here! read more

Delicious mozzarella, sausage. Great selection of imported Italian products, pasta & cheeses. Very friendly service. Felt like my salumeria on Court street, Brooklyn- Aiello's. Definitely will be back for soprasatta & provalone & an Italian wedge. read more

Excellent deli, with really top notch subs. I got a chicken parm with some marinated artichokes on the side and everything was delicious. This is also a great place for imported Italian cheeses and salamis. Worth a visit if you're in the area. read more

Best heros in Westchester. Fresh ingredients and freshly sliced meats and cheeses on classic bread. Friendly sales people. Also have good Italian groceries. Have not tried the prepared foods. read more

This place in unbelievably good! The sandwiches "wedges" are out of this world. Great prices too. $7. for a massive wedge that even a heavy eater will have problems finishing. I will be going back tomorrow for some road trip sandwiches and to get a gift basket of Italian goodies. I'm from North Jersey and know my Italian delis, this is the real deal. read more

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros - Italian Combo - Delis Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

This place was recommended by a local because I wanted red, moist roast beef. When I ordered a sandwich, there was no acknowledgement from the worker looking right at me. I waited patiently and another older man asked me for my order. When I tried to explain I think my order has been placed, he cut me off rudely and asked the lady next to me. Another younger man asked who was next so I explained I had placed my order but had no acknowledgement that they heard it so he took my order. The older man kept giving me dirty looks. I know people have bad days, but I felt bad for this grouch who lashes out at hesitant customers behind the safety of his counter. Communication and politeness go a long way in this competitive world. When I opened the wrapper on the sandwich, the roast beef was brown and dry. Lose, lose situation and I won't go back there to eat. read more

Like you are in Italy. Must see this place. A real neighborhood gem you would be happy to drive 20 miles out of your way to shop!

This deli is so amazing. High quality and authentic Italian deli. They have high quality meat and cheese. Imported items from Italy. Their cooked food and sandwiches as out of this world. Definitely the best place in mamaroneck for a deli sandwich. So delicious, and a large selection of olive oils, balsamic vinegar and much more. read more