Thank you to Tony and his staff at Anthony's Fine Jewelry in Fair Lawn. He made my engagement and wedding ring dreams come true. I've always wished for an emerald cut diamond set in yellow gold and my husband hit it out of the park with Tony's help. They selected the perfect gem. When we came back to get our wedding bands, Tony was very attentive in the selection and sizing process. I also had a special request to get a message engraved inside my and my husband's bands. I thought it would not be possible on my band, given how thin it is, but Tony made it happen. The turnaround time was exceptional and Tony even worked out a great deal with us. We can't thank Tony + team enough! read more

See all

Professional and friendly people; if you're looking to sell or buy, this is the right place to do it. Personal profesional y amable; si buscas vender o comprar, este es el lugar adecuado para hacerlo. read more

Been going here for a number of years and have been very satisfied with the excellent service. Tony and Ron are professional, knowledgeable, very pleasant, helpful and honest. I trust them. Prices are reasonable, selection is wide. Best place to have so many different things addressed. Truly a pleasant experience to visit here. read more

The fairly new owner is knowledgeable, kind, honest and his prices are very fair. I highly recommend them. They have done work for me this past year and can't wait to go back and buy myself a tennis bracelet!!! Lisa read more

Great place. The guy working there was super nice and helped me with my earrings! Nice selection of items too.

The jewelry and repair shops in my town were closed, so I had to venture out and happened upon Anthonys Fine Jewelry. I had the pleasure of meeting Anthony (Tony) himself, and he was very professional and helpful with the 2 items that I needed to be fixed: adding links onto my watch (which he did on the spot and complimentary!) and adjusting the size of my tennis bracelet. My bracelet was returned back to me all beautifully shined up with perfect adjustments. The cost of the repair was extremely fair, as well. I'm so glad to have found jewelers I can trust.! I will be visiting this shop again soon to purchase custom jewelry read more

Anthonys Fine Jewelry - Jewelry Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

Worst experience I've ever had getting a watch serviced. I'll never go back and advise anyone else to stay away. On 9/16/20 I came in to get the battery on my watch replaced. I handed my watch to the man, who then proceeded to stand in front of me looking on his phone, not saying a word to me, for 5-10 minutes. Eventually he finally worked on it. Two days later I finally go to finally wear it, only to find new scratch along the back where he worked. I keep all of my watches in pristine condition and have never had a jeweler damage one the way it was here. Horrible service and even worse craftsmanship, I will never set foot in here again and would advise anyone else to do the same. read more

I am thrilled. I walked in today to get a new watch battery in my now 23 year old Skagen watch, which I love. This is after going to 5 other local and mall jewelry stores. I kept being told nonsense like " we won't touch this watch, it will have to be sent out, parts are in short supply, you need a watch maker" blah blah, flipping blah. These very nice gentlemen, took the watch, and in less than 3 minutes, swapped out the old for a brand new battery and only charged me $10. I would HIGHLY recommend Anthony's Jewelers for ANY and ALL of my watch or jewelry needs. Cheers, J.C. read more

I brought in my Grandmother's Opal Ring after the Opal fell out! After much discussion I asked if we could reset the Opal and add Rubies (both my boys birthstones). Anthony's created an absolutely beautiful ring for me and advised not to wear it everyday as Opals can break easily. Since then, I go to Anthony's for everything! They helped me pick out the perfect watch and saying for my son that graduated High School, the cross I wear everyday, they have fixed old jewelry and charged me $3-$5. I will never go anywhere else, Anthony's is Top Notch! read more

For the first time, I went to Shami Fine Watchmaking in Fairfield NJ with an omega to fix. Place was beautiful. The staff very professionally and courteously took a comprehensive look at it and printed out an estimate which came out to $800+. I sarcastically said "wow, looks like i totaled it, it might not be worth that much after its fixed!" He courteously replied, "well maybe if it wasn't so damaged it could be cheaper". Gave me a very nice watch holder for free on the way out. Next day, for the first time, went to Anthony's Fine Jewelry in Fair Lawn NJ. Fixed it like new for less than $150. Worn it every day since While its possible Shami does good work, you might pay a 6x multiple for it. He seems to be capitalizing on those who don't know the ranges in this space too well. I highly recommend Anthony's in Fair Lawn for fair and honest work. read more

Went with fiancée to resize my engagement ring before Covid started. Anthony greeted and took care of us in a timely fashion, answered our many questions about rings and was very pleasant and polite. We will be back to purchase our wedding bands from there. Want to invest in local businesses rather than the larger ones. I only hope they're hanging in there during these difficult times. Thank you Anthony! read more

I was looking for a very hard to find men's watch and spoke to Ronnie on a few occasions. He could not have been more helpful and selfless. I completely trust him and Anthony's as they place customer satisfaction over profit. Note this experience took place in June of 2018. However the reason I decided to give Anthony's my business was because years earlier, similarly, they provided incredible customer service (replacing a watch component for free) that the competitors would have charged for. The model at Anthony's is clear, provide great customer service to create loyalty vs squeezing the customers for each penny. For this reason I appreciate this shop and will continue to give them my business. read more

Went in to look at engagement rings. I was in the store for around 5 minutes, with a gentleman sitting right behind one of the display cases, and was not acknowledged or greeted at all. Their inventory looks good, but I wouldn't purchase from a place with lackluster customer service. read more

My daughter, her fiance, and I had an exceptional experience at Anthony's Fine Jewelry in Fair Lawn today. I wanted to pass down my engagement ring to my daughter. It has great sentimental value and has been in our family for years. The original plan was to buy a new setting, but as soon as the owner realized that my daughter wanted a setting identical to the original, he recommended resizing it and renewing the white gold with rhodium and a good thorough cleaning. He worked a miracle on that ring. It was dull and grimy and too small for my daughter when we brought it in. He let us sit in the workroom to watch him work his magic and the end result is a gorgeous engagement ring that looks brand new. My daughter and her intended are thrilled and I am ecstatic that the family diamond ring has been restored and is moving on to a new generation. The price was incredibly fair for the amount of care and work he put into it. Anthony's Fine Jewelry was recommended to me by a friend in town. I now live quite a distance from Fair Lawn but knew it would be worth the hour-long drive to visit this store. I am so glad we did. Thank you, Anthony's. read more

I went in to have my ring repaired. He told me to come back in two days, so I did. When I showed up it wasn't even fixed yet so I had to wait another 10 minutes while he fixed it. And to top it all off, he put fake metal on a real ring and my finger is now green. I've had this ring over a year and it has never turned green until I brought it to Anthony's. No wonder it only cost $10 to fix. read more

I went to Anthony's to have my brand new $1950 watch sized to my wrist and the gentlemen acknowledged that it was an nice expensive watch. After about 25 minutes of him struggling with it he gave it back to me with the links all chewed up on one side claiming it was a factory defect and that the pins wouldn't come out. Of course I was pretty sure he was wrong I walked out and kept my cool not realizing how much damage he had actually done. I then took it to a much nicer jeweler in Englewood and he said that Anthony's should be ashamed of themselves for doing this and not offering me compensation (mind you this costed me over $100 to fix because he didn't stop after just destroying 1 link he destroyed the entire side) after about 30 minutes after him drilling out the links so he could put new pins in the links I left there happy with my watch sized. Moral of the story is don't go to Anthony's. I REPEAT DO NOT GO TO ANTHONY'S. read more