I have been a fan of Anthony's for a long time. It's a good place to bring the family but my husband and I come for the adult vibes, food and karaoke. Music, drinks, service and food is great. I've had the pizza, sandwiches, salad and pastas. Everything is great. I used to come before the remodel so it's definitely better now with the bar and I'm glad they kept the pool tables. read more

The one star is not for the taste of the food. The pizza and wings are really delicious. I don't drink, so I haven't had anything from the bar. I've been to Anthony's quite a few times over the years and the dine in atmosphere has changed. For better and worse. I enjoy the karaoke nights and I liked how it used to be family friendly, but now it is a hookah bar with food. Service is atrocious to say the least. It is extremely slow and the wait staff aren't friendly. Today, I came into the restaurant and waited by the sign that says "Wait for seating or wait to pay at counter". I was the only person waiting by the sign and the person at the counter acknowledged me and asked me to wait while they bag a huge order. I was totally fine with waiting. But then the Door Dashers came in after me and they all got in front pass me to the counter and the same guy behind the counter helped them with separate orders. Then, a waitress came to the counter and told a woman behind me to come to the counter to pay for her food, but never acknowledged me either. After 10 mins of standing and about 5 people jumping in front of me and no acknowledgement... I turned around and started to leave. I would like to thank the man at the bar who noticed and hollered out "Y'all didn't take the Georgia State's girl order yet!" (Wearing college hoodie). Thank you sir, I would like you to know I went to another pizza place and was treated better. Anthony's, please remember Door Dashers aren't your only customers and walk in customers matter. read more

The service is top notch and great bar food! The Alfredo is pretty good, hamburgers are on point, and let's not forget the cheesiest chili cheese fries ever! Don't pass on this place! read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Chili cheese fries - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

First time coming to this place I live close in the areas and always wanted to stop by. I hate to do this but Only two stars because of the service but the food was worth five!! Walked in and the ambience was pretty nice. Live band an it was pretty busy friday night. Just Came in to order to go, as I ordered I was told it would be 20 mins til the food was ready. We decided to sit at the bar as we waited and get a few drinks, we sat down an the bartender told us she would be right with us an proceed to walk away without even taking away the dirty glasses in front of us from the previous customers. She walked out the door and went to smoke a cigarette, came back inside and walked around a bit to check on her tables and come back to the bar finally asking what did we want. I ordered a tequila sunrise and my partner ordered a jack a coke. She turns around and walks away and proceeded to walk back around tables and start bussing an even at one point was at the to go station at the monitor ringing in orders but not at the bar. By the time our food finally was coming up she still hadn't gotten our drinks even after coming back and forth behind the bar so at that point I told her just forget about the drinks to which she said ok an turned back around an walked back on the floor. Very rude to even acknowledge us properly she finally took the cups an cleaned up when we canceled the drinks. As for the food finally got it I ordered a calzone 3times Anchovies, Italian sausage, an black olives An a small buffalo chicken pizza with lemon pepper wings. Wings delicious and fresh Calzone fresh an nice size. AS well as the buffalo chicken pizza. read more

See all

We stopped at Anthony's Pizza and Bar around 8 or 9 on a Saturday night. There was no wait at all, and the staff was ready to help as soon as we walked in. We even found a parking spot right in front, which was super convenient. Our food came out quickly....we ordered pizza, wings, fries, and a Philly cheesesteak, plus two Tequila Sunrises. Everything was fresh and really good! The pizza was hot and cheesy, the wings had great flavor, and the Philly hit the spot. The Tequila Sunrises were made just right and paired perfectly with the food. The vibe was laid-back and casual, and the service made the whole experience smooth. Overall, Anthony's is a great spot for good food, good drinks, and no stress. Definitely a place we'll come back to read more

Went in to this spot that I hadn't been to in a while. I usually never get Supreme pizza. But, when I go here, there ingredients are so good, I ordered that and some wings. The waitress was really friendly and, even though she had on an Ohio State shirt, she made the experience pleasant. Lol! Overall, this place is always a nice vibe with a vibrant atmosphere. Not too loud. But enough entertainment to keep you engaged. Stop by and give it a try. read more

I came here on lunch a few times. Every time the counter people were very nice. They have a couple pool tables in the back. The calzone the first time I went was really good, above average. Perfect amount of cheese to crust ratio and great flavor. Came back the second time and got slices which were just ok and kinda bland flavor but good for the price. I haven't ordered the whole pizza yet but by the other pictures I saw it looks better than the slices. I haven't had any pasta yet but I'm definitely going too. read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese calzone - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

The food was good! The vibe was great! The servers were helpful and sweet! The live band on Friday nights made for a chill spot. Would definitely go back. read more

Food is always hot and delicious. Love the music and the tv's. We had Ashley and she was Great. She made sure our food was the way we ordered it. She kept checking on us as well. We will definitely be back. read more

I had a deeply upsetting and unprofessional experience at Anthony's Pizza (Riverdale) on Tuesday, January 28 as I've been a long time customer for many years. I placed an online order for pick-up and was overcharged due to an order error. When I raised the issue, the employee at the register dismissed me and loudly accused me of being wrong. Instead of resolving the issue, she escalated the situation, yelling and behaving aggressively. It got worse when the employee's husband/boyfriend came from behind the counter and walked over aggressively to attack me, he also threatened me with physical violence, saying he would "F me up" / "lay me out." I felt genuinely unsafe, especially when another individual backed his threats. The Manager / Owner Anthony "Tony" Brown refused to deescalate the situation as he stood there and said nothing. This was an alarming experience and I hope that no other customer has to go through it. In my professional opinion the employees have "zero" customer service skills and the manager allows such interactions to take place in his establishment without intervening is very concerning. I deem this location as "unsafe" for customers seeing that the employees were comfortable with acting aggressively the way that they did. I can only imagine how other customers are treated. As I indicated to the owner that this could have very well ended badly. After careful consideration I am entertaining the idea of turning this over to counsel. read more

Great food. great service, great people, great drinks and great prices. Enjoy-You won't be dissapointed!

I haven't been here for years but wanted some good pizza other than franchise ones. Nevertheless make a good choice. Greeted when you walk in. Customer service was good was able to place my order didn't feel rushed. Order small (6 slices) and large( 8 slices) Greek pizza and Buffalo Chicken pizza. The place looks good. FYI no kids after 9pm (Thursdays -Saturdays). They have karaoke every Saturday after 9pm. They had about 3 pool tables that I could see. TVs everywhere and a bar. Definitely will return to try different items. read more

See all

Great food and the atmosphere is great. They have karaoke also. Great service also, and they are fast.

Food and staff were amazing ! I'm from Jersey and this is definitely the closest Italian spot to back home read more

See all

Ordered some chicken Alfredo. Got my food and there's these tiny pieces of chicken. Realized it's canned chicken. Menu says "Chicken breast meat" so yeah, that's how it's labeled on a can of chicken as well. It's highly dishonest, disrespectful, and just price gouging to charge $17 for canned chicken Alfredo. Give your money and business to a real Italian spot. Not trying to tell you to go to a specific one, but this isn't it. read more

Customer Service are not as great as it should be. No one never says, Welcome or Hello. No one never says, Please have a seat anywhere u like and someone will be with u shortly. Waitress are always walking around doing nothing. It takes them maybe 5/10 minutes to come wait on u and when they do, they're always in a rush. BUT the food is always in point. That's why I always call for to go orders. I don't have the time nor the patience to be dealing with grown adults who don't like their job. read more

I've been coming here since the 90s and it's always great quality. No wonder they are still in business. I ordered Mom a small pizza for herself (not pictured) and a pasta primavera for me and my little one. My son really loved the flavor and texture of the garlic knots that came w/ the pasta. As did I. The portions are big enough for two or three. Eat here, you won't be disappointed. read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Primavera Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

Good pizza with large portion sizes imo. Got a kids spaghetti that's huge, with two giant meatballs, an order of crinkle fries that has got to be enough for at least two people, some garlic knots, a cheesy bread, and a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. I didn't care as much for the cheesy bread or garlic knots but I didn't eat them until I was kind of full so maybe that's part of the reason why. The knots didn't have much taste and the cheesy bread had too much butter under the cheese for me. It was delivered fast and the pizza was devoured with no complaints! read more

First time here and this will definitely be my go to place for Italian Cuisine. Omg, the spaghetti and meatballs was awesome. I can't wait to come again and try something new. read more

I had the pleasure of visiting their restaurant for the 1st time it is centrally located. The restaurant is clean & tidy! They have many TVs on the walls, karaoke night, games & pool tables. I ordered spaghetti & meatballs. The sauce was very peppery for those who like the kick. I would've preferred more noodles instead of sauce (when making at home that's how I eat it). Had I eaten in, I'm sure that they would've accompanied my request. The service was quick. For 15.00 there was enough leftover for a 2nd meal. The two garlic bread twist: very soft, garlicky & tasty . They have reasonably priced luncheon specials M-F 11-2. I Wii return & try a different entree. read more

Little Caesar quality but more expensive. If you're looking for quality thin crust pizza this is not the place. I've had better frozen pizza. read more

Next time you go there look at the ceiling fans it reminds you of the moss hanging from the trees in Savanah. They say they don't serve near that fan. Take a look at all of the fans. Next time you place your order look up. Nothing like extra toppings. You decide. read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Moss covered fan. Picture doesn't do it justice. Take a look - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

First time eating here and when I say this is the cleanest , greatest customer service AWESOME FOOD great atmosphere and the food was absolutely AMAZING!!!!! Me and my hubby ordered a margarita and tequila sunrise and when I say Great Tasting!!!! You have to come here you will LOVE IT ASK FOR SHELLY SHE ROCKS!!!! read more

Ahh yes who doesn't love pizza? Though I am a self proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I take every chance I get to eat at here and I am always completely satisfied. CONSISTENT and EXCELLENT EVERY-TIME! Now I'm been coming to Anthony's since I was child, I am now 28, and my parents were coming there for they're date night in Highschool. Needless to say, I'll more than likely be bringing my kids here as well. Lol Though my ingredients may change a time or two, I am a faithful consumer of their 3 Item Calzone. Lately it's been the pepperoni, Italian sausage, and jalapeños for the win! Each time the calzone is baked to a deep golden brown with the cheese just bubbling deliciously in between the little slits on top. It's fulfilling with just the right amount of each ingredient without it bursting at the seams. I LOVE marinara sauce, so I typically get an extra one to dip in. I don't know how much more I can type without dashing out the door to get one right now! Looking for a great pizza spot of the Southside, LOOK NO FURTHER! The service is always great and prompt, staff is very friendly and helpful, and the food is... if you can't tell from above... PHENOMENAL! read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Three Item Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

See all

Anthony's Pizza did not disappoint. We ordered the deluxe pizza. hot lemon pepper wings and cheese sticks.. The food was AWESOME! We will definitely be back. read more

I like coming here especially dining in NOW because the portions here are huge and u can definitely do a family style dinner ! The staff are friendly and very helpful read more

I have been saying I was gone try this place and I finally did the other day. The Pizza and Lemon Pepper wings were great! I think I'm having this today! read more

I've tried this place a few times and the food has been great every time. I love their meatballs and garlic knots. Their marinara sauce is excellent. It's a little sweeter than I usually like but that's just a personal preference. The last time I ordered, I got the chicken parm. It was delicious. Even cold, it still tasted great lol. It definitely tasted homemade, not frozen and reheated. Anthony's is definitely a fave and will recommend you others read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Chicken Parmesan Dinner - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

Perfect pie for a picky eater . Great customer service . Would definitely come back . Thanks

Love Anthony's pizza & pasta . My favorite place for pizza and the pasta is so delicious comes with garlic knots!! read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo with Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

I'm somewhat astounded by how long it took for me to review this place. Maybe I was subconsciously avoiding a review since Anthony's Pizza & Pasta has been associated with a couple of unfortunate events as of late; Anthony's is the first place that my closest friend and I went to after his father passed away, and another friend locked his keys in his car the last time I was there. Notwithstanding, such occurrences really shouldn't put a damper on Anthony's because this restaurant is home to outstanding pizza. For me, one of the true tests of pizza is whether it's delicious fresh out of the oven, cold, and also after being reheated a day later. Anthony's aces that test! I've also tried their shrimp fettuccini alfredo, but the main attraction is undoubtedly their pizza. I'm a fan of the red brick and wood interior that gives this family-oriented pizzeria a classic look and feel. As a family-oriented restaurant, Anthony's features several pool tables, a few arcade machines, and an air hockey table. Moreover, it's also a family-operated business; seeing the underage kid working the register reminds me of my own formative years of "indentured servitude" working at my parents' restaurant. Now that I mention it, I should tip that kid the next time I visit. Ideally, discovering and supporting local businesses is what yelp is all about, and so I encourage others in the area to patronize Anthony's Pizza & Pasta. It's exceptional given that it's one of the few praiseworthy places in Riverdale! read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

I ordered through Uber Eats and I must say it was good! I ordered a calzone, chicken, fettuccine, spaghetti with meat sauce, and the turtle cheesecake. Everything was on point and I will be returning when I'm in the mood for Italian. read more

This establishment is located directly off the main road. It's dimly lit inside but it does have adequate seating and booths. I ordered a slice which was 3.50 and it was actually two little slices. It was average you can say but I wouldn't recommend it. Another location that can't quite seem to get it right I guess. Also their Health score is a "B" which I am finicky about. read more

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta - Slice -3.50 - Pizza Near Me - Riverdale, Georgia

I was absolutely impressed with Anthony's Pizza. Being from New York you have to have a reeeaally good slice for me to say this is great pizza. Doesn't taste boxed, doesn't taste old. Almost has that brick oven flavor with NY real mozzarella taste. Their wings were delicious as well. Not those premature baby chick wings that you find in other restaurants. The Teriyaki and lemon pepper were of my favorites. On top of everything the service there is great. Audrey made sure our food was prepared to our exact liking and made sure we were completely satisfied. She has very good work ethics and relational skills. Lastly, the restaurant is newly renovated with beautiful floors, gaming and pool table area, it host music nights and has a sports bar feel in an adjacent area. I look forward to bringing friends there and recommend Anthony's to EVERYONE!!! read more

This place is a decent cheap option. Barebones type of meal but the portion is alright. The buffalo bleu burger is a buffalo burger (no bleu). read more

See all

Would have left a review for NO STARS but it's not possible. Anyway, had a pizza and some garlic knots from here once. My son and I slaughtered them at the time but, then about 3 hours later, woke up feeling nauseous. We both were throwing up for at the least two hours. To answer your question, I knew it was the knots because everyone else in the house that didn't have them didn't get sick. Never again. I'm staying away read more

I have been a regular customer at Anthony's Pizza on Ga Hwy 85 in Riverdale for more than 10 yrs. I visited the establishment more than a month ago and noticed that none of the employees including those in the kitchen were wearing protective masks. I thought that at that time they might not be aware the the dangers of the Covid-19 virus. However, just last week I went back to the establishment and still no employees were wearing masks. I asked the owner's son why they were not wearing protective masks and was told that they don't have to. You make your own decision about your patronage. read more

I bought a large pepperoni and sausage pizza yesterday and it was DELICIOUS!!!! I have been going there for years and although I no longer live in Riverdale when I want pizza I drive to Anthony's!!!! PS I love all the pepperoni and cheese and they have the best sausages. read more

Usually good food. I like the idea off putting the pepperoni under the cheese, however it seems like only two or three pieces are under the cheese. I like cheese, but I order pepperoni pizza because I really like pepperoni. I always have to pay for extra. read more

Ok place. Nothing to write home to mom about. The cheese bread was very awesome although we had to request"the green stuff" lol...you mean oregano the employee said then finally brought oregano, Parmesan cheese, and red pepper flakes which we thought we shouldn't have to ask for. Pizza pretty pricey for the taste...not bad are the thoughts that you will have. Also had the eggplant parmesan to which everyone at the table commented that mine was much better (insert Pat on the back, lol). They do have pool, air hockey, and arcade games which is good for kids while waiting for the food. I say drop a couple bucks off your menu or invest in a liquor license to offset the mediocrity. read more