Came here as this was the last stop (side note - I originally wrote "lost" stop and then realized what a Freudian slip that was!!) on the Pittsburgh Food tour and frankly, I found this place to be the usual pedestrian plastic cheese pizza place with an undercooked base. There might be other flavors but we had the cheese pizza and it was okay - not something I would come back here again for. Yelp Review 45/2017 read more

Antonio's Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Insanely enough, Kay had a craving for pizza after eating at Johnny's Diner and Scoops on Beverly. She at first craved a hot dog, but Hank's Too is closed on Sundays. She changed her mind, saying she wanted something...salty. Alas, Vinnie's Pretzels is closed on the Sabbath also. "Pizza. I'll settle for a slice of pizza." Arbitrarily, we shuffled into Antonio's for two cuts of sausage-adorned pizza, and I was thankful for it was better than I recalled. The sauce was sweet, the cheese was lardy, and the crust cracked from the dental pressure I applied to it. I was also thankful that pizza-hating Kay loved it. Her urge was satisfied, and thus her dark side went into remission for the rest of the day. read more

Antonio's Pizzeria - Pizza with sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

As someone with a dairy allergy, it is hard to find pizza that won't leave me covered in hives and miserable. Glad to say that not only wasn't the best vegan cheese pizza that I've eaten but my partner happily enjoyed his regular cheese pie. read more

I love that Antonio's has vegan options! Their buffalo Seitan is soo delicious. I don't have anything but good things to say about their food and service!! read more

With so many pizza places in this area Antonio's is one to try. We ordered the pepperoni rolls as a starter which came with 8 fairly large rolls. The had great flavor and were filled with a ton of peperoni. I wish they did give you more dipping sauce. We also ordered a large Hawaiian pizza which came with ham, bacon and pineapple. The crust is very tasty and they put plenty of toppings on. The takeout was quick and ready within 25 minutes. We were notified via text when our order was ready which was a bonus. A must try pizza place if you live near Brookline Blvd. read more

Antonio's is our go to neighborhood pizza joint. Their service is fast and friendly and our order is correct every time!

Great food and friendly staff. I got a classic pizza and garlic bread; super tasty! The vegan options were also really nice. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Tried Antonio's for the first time and they didn't disappoint. Pizza was awesome and loved the muffaletta hoagie. I don't live real close but I'll be sure to travel up to Brookline the next I want pizza! read more

I was a little hungry while walking on Brookline Blvd and was lured in by the smell of pizza and their pizza by the slice sign outside. I got one huge slice for $2+ tax. The slice was great, but I regretted adding the crushed red peppers. For some reason these were the hottest red peppers Ive ever added to a pizza. My lips were so hot that it even hurt to lick them lol. I almost always add the crushed pepper when available at a pizzeria, but wish I had passed this time. I quickly dashed across the street afterwards to cool off with some ice cream from Scoops on the Blvd. I liked the pizza and will be back for more, just gotta remember to go light on the peppers next time. read more

Antonio's Pizzeria - Boomin' - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Pizza flavor not good. Meatballs waayyyyy tooo much garlic! and sauce was bitter. Wings good. Service good. read more

Great pizza and pepperoni rolls. Tons of toppings and creative specials. A don't miss!

I'm sorry, pizza, I really wanted to like you, but you were a complete let-down. After my first love in pizza, Slice, decided to go downhill, I was on a quest for a new number 1 spot. After reading some reviews, I decided to give Antonio's a try. We ordered a large pizza with garlic sauce, bacon and half tomato and half spinach. I also ordered the chicken parm half hoagie. While the toppings were more than adequate, the crust was a complete disappointment. Yeasty, flavorless - it so brought down the excitement I had at seeing a pizza actually covered in toppings. The chicken parm sandwich was ok. It was large which I appreciated and the tomato sauce was pretty tasty, but the chicken was lackluster and there was hardly any cheese atop it's crusty shell. We will likely not be back and the pizza exploration continues! One major plus was that the guy that answered the phone might have been the most pleasant, competent and kindest pizza order taker I have ever in my life spoken to. So props for training your people how to be considerate on the phone! read more

Pizza is not the best but the staff is. Really nice guys, fast moving and generous. I stop mostly for slices on the way home. I call from my car and run in and take out for eating at home. The slices are huge. The sauce is tasty. Not the best Ive eaten but a great weekday pizza place. My only regret is that they use a pizza converyor cooker and not a pizza oven, so the crust doesnt get that crispy. Ill be back. Perfect neighborhood pizza parlor. read more

Don't waste your time or money. We ordered delivery after a long day at work. The food was cold, items were missing, and the chicken tenders were not tossed in buffalo sauce although that is how they were ordered. I called back and the manager had the audacity to call me a liar! He said that he doesn't understand how the Stuff could be cold because "they ran it right out." So I told them to come back, collect their food and give me my money back. The woman who came to collect the food was rude and did not even bother to give the tip back! NEVER AGAIN! I don't lie Antonio's; was not looking to get something for free - just wanted hot food and the correct order to be delivered. Would have been fine with a transfer of food. read more

The prices here and quality of the pizza are WAY better than any other pizza place in the city. I always save money buying take out from here and know it's my family's favorite spot! The pizza is amazing. read more

Worst pizza ... I ordered a thin crust their thin crust & mine are miles apart... I recd a cracker with sauce...!most importantly it was ice cold... however the onion rings were excellent... read more

Amazing pizza. Delicious. Went two days in a row. Both Days yummy. Also the woman at the counter was really friendly. Oh and you need to try the garlic sauce read more

I ordered from here through Postmates and was excited to try somewhere new. I got the appetizer platter which was missing the mozzarella sticks all together and the pickle chips were random thin pickle chips in clumps with dark brown greasy batter just clumped all over. The entire thing was gross and greasy and luke warm at best. I also ordered a calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms. The dough was a light very pale color with no browning at all (I was surprised it was even cooked through) and it was a complete grease pit. Like disgustingly greasy. Puddles on my plate from one slice of the calzone. I'm sick to my stomach and am going to throw away the remainder. What a waste of $30. Definitely do NOT recommend this place unless you want clogged arteries. read more

I'd give it 3.5 it wasn't super delicious but it did the job. The cheese is super silky. Slices are extra crunchy. Cheese fries are well, cheese fries. Not extremely greasy which is always a plus! Very good customer service, however. That's important. read more

Antonio's Pizzeria - Pizza slices and order of chicken wings dining in! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Antonio's is our "go-to" for delivered pizza in our area. We are Dormont dwellers and although Antonio's is in Brookline, it's close enough. We've tried the rest, Antonio's is the one that my sweetie and I agree on. Tonight we ordered a large pizza and two small orders of wings. (We were not agreeing on the flavor of wings tonight.) Both of us started with our wings tonight, and both of us raved about them. They were perfect, just perfect. Our pizza got second billing tonight, but it wasn't the pizza's fault. Actually, it was very good. The sauce has some "tang" to it, the toppings are fresh and there are plenty of them. (Tonight we had Pepperoni and mushrooms...) Often we order their pasta dishes and have never been disappointed. I'm a particular fan of their baked ziti. I have to point out that their delivery drivers are part of the equation. Although the stand time quoted is 40 minutes, we consistently get our food (in the next neighborhood) within 25 minutes and often within 20. That is very impressive. Admittedly we tip the drivers well every time. So... If you live in Brookline, Dormont or Beechview and are in the mood for some takeout, ring up Antonio's! read more

Had the pepperoni pizza it was great! They actually use the old fashioned pepperoni which was a real treat others use the cheap stuff. Highly recommend it. read more

Such good pizza and one of the few places that has vegan options! Delivery is always quick and the order is always correct. Our new favorite neighborhood spot! read more

This place is a hidden gem! They are always willing to customize your request and the food is delicious! I would recommend if your looking for a new pizza place! read more

Antonio's is my go-to pizza spot! The staff are so helpful and the food is delicious. As a vegetarian, it's so nice to have Antonio's within walking distance. Next March, run, don't walk, to get their Shepherd's pie (my boyfriend LOVED it) and vegan Shepherd's pie pizza. Both phenomenal in the deep dish pizza crust. read more

Antonio's is my go-to local pizza joint. I LOVE pizza and IMO this is thee best pizza in the South Hills. A group of us had a party, where 15 different pizza shops were represented. The only one that held candle to Antonio's was the great Vincent's Ardmore location. Better still for me is that I can be there in 5 minutes from home. Thanks for serving up awesome pies! Keep em coming! read more

Not very flavorful. Definitely had better pizza. Tried their seitan hoagie it was dry

The people here are so rude. MY LITTLE BROTHER DROPPED A PENNY AND THEY YELLED AT HIM, LIKE ACTUALLY YELLED, Stop throwing that coin around it's super annoying!!! And then my friend asked what the cheapest drink was and he asked for it and the charged him 3 times the price of my other friend's drink. They charged me 3 dollars for a little cup of ranch. Overall they are rude, expensive, trying to rip you off, and just think about a chicken wing I got from there that was 7 centimeters thick and 1 inch tall. read more

Antonio's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Guys, I have never been treated as rudely or as poorly By anyone or anywhere that I've ever ordered pizza from until tonight. My husband daughter and I were out grocery shopping and we decided to order pizza for dinner because by the time you know you're done shopping you don't wanna cook. we have ordered from Antonios pizza on Brookline Boulevard many many times and have never ever had a problem. When I called to order the pizza they told me it would be ready in 20 to 25 minutes so I figured we could pick it up on our way home. So I have groceries sitting in the car my husband and daughter are waiting in the car. Almost 50 minutes later, Our food is finally ready. I ordered a plain large cheese pizza, a garden salad, and mozzarella sticks. Basic order not that difficult. I tell the woman who is checking me out that I'm very angry that it's taking so long. She says, "well there's nothing I can do, do you want your food or not?" I tell her I still want the food but they should really manage their time better. She then tells me that, " Well you're welcome to come back here and help!" Granted there are six people working on peoples orders back there. It was a horrible experience and I will never ever buy anything from Antonio's Pizza in Brookline again. read more

Great pizza! First time for Antonio's. Awesome dough. When reheated my mushroom pie kinda turned to a floppy mess. But, I can't deduct a star for reheated pizza. Go for it! read more

This place was good at one time. Tonight though pissed me off enough to write this short review. Missing an order of fries...the 2 others were cold and 2 cold gyros with big chunks of yellow lettuce and a runny white sauce mostly sponged up by the pita, making it inedible. Sorry, won't be calling back. It's not easy to find a good delivery place around here, with a little effort someone could really do well, but some don't get it till it's too late. read more

I'm not normally a fan of pizza, but I had a mean slice of pie here early last month with sausage. It surely satisfied my craving. I'm glad Vinnie's Pretzels was closed that day or else I would have never gotten to try this excellent pizza. read more

Have been a loyal customer here. Good pizza but tonight order never showed up. Was supposed to be 30-45 minutes and nothing. Called and was told he should be on his way. Never saw them. It's a shame. Called and cancelled the order. read more

I have lived in Pittsburgh 5 years, and have had mediocre pizza from several places since moving here. I even went back to just ordering from Dominoes, I was so discouraged. So ,I tried Antonio's delivery tonight. Glad I did! Their sauce is really good and the amount of cheese on the pizza was perfect! Crust was crispy yet chewy. I will definitely be back! read more

This has been my go to place lately. Lots of unique items that you wouldn't typically find at a shop like this, like the yummy desert pizzas. I've had the classic pizza and it hits the spot. Anything with the house made sausage is good also. Also try the homemade soups and chili, they are excellent! read more

This is place is just the greatest. The pizza is fantastic, one of the best I've ever had. The staff is so awesome, attentive, and personable. I've never had a an encounter less than perfect with them. Tony's garlic bread is seriously addictive. read more

I love Antonio's Pizzeria. The sauce isn't too sweet, which seems to be a trend among Pittsburgh pizzerias. I prefer a more acidic tasting sauce, and Antonio's has it. The prices are great too. read more

yelp 10% discount deal was refused because only manager knows how to apply it. note to manager: please train your employees in applying discounts. The pizza's not very good, either. Nowhere near the level of Mineo's or, of course, Fiori's. read more

Pizza and hoagies are ok nothing great. The staff is friendly. The restaurant area was clean. nice place to eat in.

I have only tried the pizza but it was very good! I enjoy taking my kids for lunch...they offer huge slices for $1.99!

Waited over an hour for a simple order of 2 gyros and order of fries. When the driver finally arrived he demanded I give him the money before he handed me my my food.. The food was cold and the fries were black and greasy. I told him I did want the food and I wanted my money back... he became rude and belligerent. I called back to talk to management and make a complaint. They basically told me to call in the morning to talk to the owner. By the way tried to give the food tome dogs and either one would eat it either! read more