Friendly staff. The pizza was not greasy. The pizza was absolutely delicious. They are BIG slices or huge pizza pies that did not disappoint. Highly recommend. Sorry no pictures. We were too hungry that we forgot. read more

I've seen a lot of pizza in my life, but never anything close to as big as these slices which need 2 plates to carry. Giving it a 3-star for the ambiance. While the brick and big pizza ovens are the characteristic of East Carson Street to be expected, the seating area was less than to be desired. The cracks in the old stuffed plastic benches are literally duct taped with electrical tape. I like the "reuse" but it could be a bit more pleasant. There aren't any options for drinks in the refrigerator that aren't super sugary or "diet," i.e. no seltzer waters or juices, just sodas, lemonades, and sweet teas. But if you're hungry for a slice of pizza two times as large as your face, you know where you can find it! read more

Benny Fierro's - Literally the biggest pizza slices I've ever seen. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I like the pizza a lot and enjoy how large the slices are. The only complaint I have is that some of the staff members have really bad attitudes and are not kind when you ask for something. It's really awkward. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

My friend ordered four pizzas to feed a crowd at his birthday party at Velum. These pizzas were HUGE. It was almost comical in a good way how big they were. We got one cheese, two pepperoni, and one other one that was maybe Mediterranean based on the tomatoes and balsamic glaze. The slices themselves are enormous as well! The pizza was a crowd pleaser and disappeared in less than an hour. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Thank God for Benny's! Such a clutch option for food, especially late at night. No matter how long the line looks, the service always moves surprisingly fast, and the pizza is consistently good. I'm always impressed by the size of the slice! absolutely huge! read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The pizza is a must try. We were blown away with the crispiness of the pie, and I don't know why people aren't recommending this order to travelers. Some of the best thin crust pizza we've had! read more

Benny Fierro's - Pepperoni, sausage, buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Ah-Mazingggggggggggggg NY style pizzas! Home sweet home! Its the stretchy dough thin, with bomb pizza sauce. Its all in the sauce I tell ya! They're sold by slicles-- HUMONGOUS! My lil one & I ordered the plain cheese, pepperoni & mushroom sausage, and they were all so good! Very affordable. I really cannot sing enough of its praises. You have got to try it for yourself read more

See all

Good luck fitting this through your front door, or even the back of your car! One of the few pizza places open on a Sunday, which gives it a few extra points in my book. Pizza has a slightly sweet sauce with a doughy and slight airy crust. Bottom of pizza was cooked just about perfect. If a crispy pizza is your cup of tea, this may not be the best place for you. Friendly staff over the phone and pickup made for a great experience. read more

Benny Fierro's - Whole 28" Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I enjoy coming here for a slice and was happy to promote their business on my socials, but a bit unprofessional to screen grab the photos and use as your own. Lesson learned. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Holy cow what a great find. This pizza was so delicious and one of the biggest slices I've ever had. Cool vibes & employees as well. Can't wait to try again. read more

Benny Fierro's - Italian Sausage Pizza Slice & Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

One thing to note. Their specialty slices are really just topping on top of their plain slice. Still good but different than what you would probably expect read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

好吃吗？yes!!! 价格实惠吗？yes!!! 服务好吗？yes, they were very friendly 干净吗？yes 氛围好吗？yes, chill! 厕所干净吗？hopefully 你最喜欢的披萨是什么？cheese!!! 我可以带孩子来吗？if you insist... 可以带宠物吗？you shouldn't... 你会再来吗？yes!!! 你会推荐它吗？absolutely :^D read more

First time here, saw it on Barstool before. Unassuming space on Carson Street that had a steady stream of customers. The slices are enormous. I took the advice of the person taking my order and selected the cheese steak slice as it was almost gone and wouldn't be back for a while. They had several types of slice to choose from. The price was decent too for how big the slice was. I can eat and I only ordered one and went home satisfied. I want to go back and try some other offerings soon. read more

See all

Roasted garlic and mushrooms in cheese. Fantastic! This place never disappoints. Beware - the slices are huge! read more

Let me tell you anytime I go here I'm never not satisfied(even when I order two slices) The pie is good and the size of it is MASSIVE but if you're in town or out near the bars definitely grab a slice read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

i was in the mood for pizza and I was near by Benny Fierro's who had really good reviews overall. The place is directly on carson street. The place has plenty of seating. The staff where all friendly and helpful. I was going to order 2 slices but changed my mid at the last second as i decided to head over for pretzels afterwards. I ordered a pepperoni slice. Holly cow the slice was huge, One slice here is like 2 slices everywhere else. I have to say as far as pizza goes it was just ok nothing special. I probably would not go again. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Everyone has to experience a slice of Benny's pizza at some point. One slice is all you need. It's huge! And only $5!! They are open all the time. You can run in a grab a slice. Or an entire pie. If you think the box can fit in your car! read more

See all

This is the place ...for a giant slice of NY style pizza It's a big slice as in really big Friendly service Divey place they have booths a couple of high top tables Nice soda selection If you order a whole pie it's huge if you have a small car I'm serious it won't fit Great pizza I keep coming back Parking here is often a hassle Metered street parking day or night feed the meter or you will get a ticket read more

Got two huge 28-inch pizzas. Delicious New York style thin-crust. Great flavored crust, a little crispy underneath, a little thicker around the edge, foldable slices. The sauce was mellow and slightly sweet. We got classics, one plain and one pepperoni. You can order by-the-slice, too, I think. They also had a couple of interesting-sounding specialty options that change every few weeks. We had over a dozen people, and two of their huge pizza's were plenty, with seconds for several of us. We called in and picked it up. I dont think anyone delivers from this South Side Flats Carson St. location. Great pizza, done on time. We'll be back! read more

Amazing generous sized New York slices and whole pies. The Two youngsters were behind the counter were absolute legends, Very nice. Genuinely best pizza in Pittsburgh. Has a very cool vibe, idk what the kids would call it, grunge? I just eat pizza man. Seems great for friends and families. read more

Delicious!! It's a huge pizza slice for about 6$. One slice was actually enough for 2 but depends on appetite as well! Sauce and cheese taste delicious. Fast service as well. Would recommend to make the trip to the south side for this! read more

Oh my...the slices! The slices are huge. We got here and thought we needed 12 slices to get full. How about only 6 slices to share amongst 4 people. We had cheese, shroom and cheese and pepperoni. As you know, I don't eat pork, so, not talking about that. The cheese and shroom and cheese, well done! I forgot the food pics. Hunger always prevails. read more

Benny Fierro's - In the fridge... - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Tried for first time as part of "pizza passport." Freaking huge slice. Full after one!!! Really tasty. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

- second time visiting, pizza still super good - very good value for giant size (could barely finish it) - pairs great with garlic sauce - fast service read more

Benny Fierro's - Italian Sausage Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

At the beginning of the pandemic my husband and I delivered food for Uber Eats as a way to get out of the house. We had a really good time driving all around Pittsburgh delivering food to people. One of the most memorable experiences of those deliveries was showing up to Bennys to pick up a pizza and realizing the only place it was going to fit was our trunk! We knew nothing about Bennys and we were absolutely shocked. We sort of forgot about it until a few weeks ago and we had to order one!! Unfortunately, we don't live quite as close anymore so by the time we got the pizza home it had gotten pretty cold, but overall it was still a good slice. I'd say it was more about the novelty of ordering an enormous pizza than it was about how good the pizza was, though I'm sure fresh would have been better! read more

Benny Fierro's - Pictures just don't do it justice! The pizza is almost the size of our average size dining table. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Had some friends pick up the 28" pepperoni pizza and bring to our house to consume. Couldn't believe they had to put it in their trunk as they didn't have space elsewhere in the vehicle for such a large pizza! By the time we got the pie to our house it was slightly lukewarm so the next trick was figuring out how to fit the slices in the microwave--these things are monsters! The pizza was really good though and had plenty of toppings on each slice. Comes with 8 slices and cost about $40 bucks or $5 a slice. Each slice is easily a meal so I definitely think it was worth it. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This place is amazing for parties since the whole pizzas are super large - 28 inches to be exact! I ordered 3 pizzas and it fed 16 people with a lot of left overs. It's nice because you can ask for the pizza to be cut to 16 slices for each pie. They have some awesome flavor specials like beer cheese and steak or sweet and spicy pepper pizzas. All were sooooo good, and you can also do half cheese and half pepperoni if you want variety! I placed my order 12pm day of and it was ready by 5:30pm for immediate pick up. The staff was so friendly! read more

Benny Fierro's - Beer cheese and steak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Strong contender for one of best NY style slices. The pieces are absolutely massive, one piece is at least two normal pieces. Not huge inside but a few booths in the back and tables up front. Definitely recommend for a quick slice read more

Benny Fierro's - Cheese Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

You can always count on Benny's to make a solid pepperoni slice! Love this place and it's my favorite pizza place in pgh. It's great that they're open really late as well. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

What can I say, service is always stellar! Especially Jake, he is awesome! The pizza is big and delicious! I first came into this place because the smell of the dough brought me in from outside, it reminded me of the way New Jersey pizza smells. It spoke to my soul. The slices are giant and if your on a budget they can be saved and are amazing reheated. My favorite monthly slices are the Bobby Bruchetta, Jalapeño Cheddar. The Buffalo Chicken too. Oh yea and the chicken bacon ranch. Basically you cannot go wrong here. Unless you order a large pie and drive a small car, then you may have and issue! HAHAHA. When I lived on the Southside we had to carry the pizza box up the stairs sideways because it was so large! Can't be mad at a pizza for being too big! Sit in the window and you have dinner and a show because out front is the streets of East Carson which we know is uber entertaining! AND they usually have Nightingale Ice cream bars, you're welcome! read more

Benny Fierro's - Chicken bacon ranch & plain - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This is a decent pizza place for those large NY style pizza slices. The pizza slices are massive whether you buy by the slice or the pie. So make sure you have the room in your car if you buy a whole pie. The slices are made to order, with a limited variety of toppings based on their monthly special. The fun part is their large slices. The pizza is decent. The crust is good. The toppings are ok, so I actually preferred the cheese over the other varieties we've gotten. read more

Benny Fierro's - three slices of pizza on paper plates - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

One slice is a meal. Two slices are if you are high. Three slices are if you completely hate yourself and actively desire to throw up. I usually eat 1.5 slices, so figure it out. Staff is consistently good at their job. Limited seating. Only canned/bottled beverages, so don't expect a big gulp level soda. read more

Benny Fierro's - Three is way too much for one person. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We've been trying a different pizza slice each Friday night - Benny Fierro's is the best so far. The "slice" is huge and perfectly baked - thin crust and not a lot of cheese - highly recommend. read more

This pizza is absolutely amazing and it comes on 2 paper plates per slice. You literally have to use both hands to hold it to your face. It's self serve at the counter but that's okay the deliciousness makes up for everything. read more

I was walking on this side of uptown and wanted a slice of pizza when I saw a sign down the street from an Italian spot, found out it was closed. I kept walking down the street and saw a guy eat a huge slice of pizza. Someone else had asked him where he got it and I proceeded to walk down that way! This spot was perfect. The peperoni slice ran me about six dollars and I got a drink from the fridge. Total came out at around eight dollars. I loved the punk rock atmosphere of this spot. The guys behind the counter were friendly and prepped my slice fast. Good spot to stop at and eat. Many choices to eat at in the neighborhood but a slice of pizza from here is good choice! read more

I've been wanting to come here for a very long time so when I was in the area this afternoon, I stopped in Got to say, I was disappointed, so maybe it was because of the time of the day and the circumstances of my order. The size of their slices are legendary so I just ordered one pepperoni, but it was after the lunch hour I guess and I got a slice that was barely reheated and honestly wasn't very good. Had it been in the old days when I needed to soak up some alcohol and there was a place open with these comically large slices perhaps I would give it a better review. The counterperson was nice enough, but otherwise, meh. read more

I went to Benny Fierro's after getting into a friendly disagreement with one of my pals regarding where you can get The Best Pizza in Pittsburgh (TM). He insisted that Benny's was number one, so I decided I had to check it out. The location is super convenient. Right on Carson street. Perfect for fueling up before a show at The Rex or sobering up after bar hopping. You can buy pizza by the slice, but saying that doesn't accurately describe what you receive. It's a GIANT slice of pizza. Takes up 2 plates. Easily the equivalent of 2-3 normal pieces of pizza, which for $3.50 for cheese and $4.50 for pepperoni is pretty good. The pizza is very good. The crust is super thin. Like super super thin. It can make it a challenge to pick up such a giant piece of pizza weighed down with so much cheese, but overall I don't really have complaints about it. I've heard from some friends from New York that Pittsburgh's pizza is good, but the crust is too thick and chewy (or "rubbery"). You don't need to worry about that at Benny's, for sure. The best part of this pizza is the cheese -- it's what really gives the slice a punch of flavor that you don't get at a lot of other pizza places. My friend was right in that Benny's is amazing pizza. Hands down best in the South Side. I'd put it at number 3 on my list of favorite pizza places in the 'Burgh overall, but considering there's some stiff competition, that's really good. Highly recommend. read more

Benny Fierro's - Benny's giant pizza slices. Cans of soda and excited concert-buddy for scale. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I crave Benny Fierro's even when I am MILES away from Pittsburgh, PA and I bet I am not the only person. This is a humdinger in my opinion and I don't even know what that really means, the truth is I am salivating about the pepperoni slices as I am typing this out. Bennys stays open late (until midnight) and you truly only need one slice for yourself. Photo included for size reference and this place is very #LGBTQIAUNO Friendly ‍‍ read more

See all

This is the best pizza I have ever had. Huge slices and awesome prices! Seriously will come here again. Only difference is I'll order a few more slices for later in the evening. The seat at our booth was a little wobbly but I didn't even care because the pizza was so good. Would sit on the floor to eat this pizza again. Also, the cheese guy was top notch. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Definitely one of the better pizza slices in Pittsburgh. Great flavor, crisp crust, and a good fresh sauce. Slices are massive. Not having a homemade ranch is really disappointing for a place like this though. Their crust is perfect for it. read more

Benny Fierro's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania