I have tried this place a few times and have been impressed every time. The flavors are amazing and I like how they have vegan flavors as well as regular ice cream. The last visit I tried the mango li hi mui. It was delicious, the best part was it was freshly made and they do not use chemicals. The service is quick and efficient as there is only room for a few people at a time. The decor is like the ice cream creative but not overwhelming. It definitely fits the vibe of the neighborhood. I truly enjoy going here and checking out some different flavors as I have not tried all of them yet ! read more

See all

Every time I'm in Paia I hit this place up! Still is the best ice cream I've ever had. Salted peanut butter chocolate chip is LEGIT. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Salted peanut butter chocolate chip ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

Paia, HI. The line moves fast thanks to the two hard working girls working here. We went for the basic, no frills or extras, in a cup instead of a cone. I ordered two scoops so I could at least try a couple of flavors. I did not anticipate the scoops being as large as they are and two is a bit much. Somehow I managed though. All of the flavors are really good, and the texture is very creamy with no evidence of gummy additives. Fear not the salted varieties, they are delicious. The ice cream is reasonably tempered and gets soft enough quickly on a warm day. This really brings flavor to the forefront. I like that the ice cream focus is on flavor and texture and not sugar. One flavor is called " Coffee with Sugar" but even that one is not too sweet. read more

See all

I was drawn in by the incredible buttery smell of the fresh waffle cone. I got a split scoop of coffee and Mac nut, and both are delicious. Unlike Roselani (see my review there if interested), this actually tastes like natural, fresh, small batch, artisan ice cream. It is creamy but not gummy, rich without the taste of synthetic flavors, and it's got just enough icy bits to make me feel like there's probably no industrial stabilizers and texture enhancers. I eat a relatively clean diet and I'm sensitive to additives like that. I didn't see the ingredients list so I don't know for sure, but at least I enjoyed the taste. The waffle cone smelled better than it tasted, but it was huge and well worth the money. Service was good too. Will come back! read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

One of the best vegan ice creams I've ever had. So yummy! Customer service was excellent too! Thanks ladies!

Best cookie I have ever had! Stopped by today and bought a dozen. We'll be back before we leave. Shop is run by two adorable sisters that are bosses! Def a must do when on Maui! read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Best ice cream on Maui, and has been for a few years. Better than most of the best ice cream places you'll find on the mainland too, so "best on Maui" is not faint praise. Nowhere else has the rich mouthfeel of quality ingredients and delicious flavours. I highly recommend. read more

Had a scoop of their vegan coconut macadamia ice cream and it was very creamy with great macadamia flavor. Solid ice cream spot tucked slightly down the street from the main drag read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Yes. Yes I did drive from Kihei to Pa'ia on 3 out of 5 days for this ice cream. That good. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice cream dreams. Every flavor is incredible. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

We went in about 15-20 minutes before closing, and the first thing the workers told us was, "We're not accepting cash." Then, when I asked for samples, they looked at each other, which gave off a mean vibe. I'm so disappointed because I wanted to love this place based on the reviews. Unfortunately, I didn't get that experience and I'm really turned off by the service. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Dutch chocolate. 10/10 Service: not friendly. So disappointed. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Stopped by after lunch for a sweet treat. It's hard to find free public parking in Paia by all the storefronts because it can get sooooooo busy with tourists (us included lol), but thankfully we managed to find a spot. It smelled really good when we walked in! The storefront is pretty tiny but the line wasn't too long. The lady helping us was nice in recommending some of her favorite flavors. My husband ordered the lilikoi butter, and I got the mango strawberry li hing mui. The lilikoi butter was good; the texture was creamy and buttery and the lilikoi added a good balance of tartness to the ice cream. The mango strawberry, however, did not taste like mango or strawberry, and I couldn't even tell there was any li hing mui. The texture was fine, but it was severely lacking in flavor. Looking back, I should have tried one of their more popular flavors which are more chocolatey/rich, but I was in the mood for something lighter and fruity. Overall not a bad experience, but we've had much better ice cream on the island. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Mango strawberry li hing mui, lilikoi butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Wow, this was some of the best ice cream I have ever had in my life. Not only were the flavors on POINT, but the service was top level as well. Jenna & Faith were awesome, they helped me find the perfect combination for my split scoop. Thanks Jenna & Faith, y'all set the bar for customer service real high, I'll definitely be back. The perfect start to a Friday night. PS- Give Jenna & Faith a raise read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Amazing ice cream, unique flavors, great service, value, ana cool little ambiance of a hidden store! A must try if you want dessert in this area, especially unique ice cream flavors. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Mago Strawberry swirl and the Peanut Butter flavor, both were amazing! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

We stopped in Paia, just for an ice cream treat. This time Tahiti Vanilla and Dutch Chocolate. A scoop per person. Now it's 12.00 for two. Still feels worth it. Maybe 6 choices. Endless line to get in. Good sign. Small window shop. No seats. read more

Super tiny store front. They have dairy and non dairy options and the entire area was literally spotless and squeaky clean. The two women were super sweet and patient as my non verbal son tried to see what he wanted. We got two cones and a scoop in a cup. We tried vanilla, chocolate, and salted malted vanilla swirl. All delicious! Clearly all homemade, rich, and creamy. All of our selections were dairy options. The cones were freshly baked and the cookies in the window smelled divine. Worth a stop as you head down the highway to Hana or just bounce around the island. read more

See all

If you haven't been here yet, what are you doing? Get here asap! Way better than Baskin and Robbins or Cold Stone. We drive here special just for their ice cream. This spot continues to serve up delicious dairy and vegan ice cream. I love that you can get some of your favorites in pints to take home. They also come up with seasonal flavors that are always nice to try. I absolutely love their split scoop option when you can't just pick one flavor nor do they skimp on the scoop. It's a easy spot to miss as you might miss the walkway to the entrance but you can't miss the huge ice cream on the front and on the wall if you're coming up Baldwin Avenue. Depending on the time, you may even be drawn in from the fresh waffle cones or cookies or the line of people waiting for ice cream. All the workers are super friendly even when they're busy, definitely stop in and support local! read more

See all

First time coming here on a Saturday at 8:15 pm. Girls did not greet us, gave us a weird look and just said "we're not taking cash." They looked annoyed that we wanted to get some ice cream! Loved their ice cream but unfortunately will not be back because they don't seem to want our business anyways! read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Lilikoi butter ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

Super nice staff, very kind and let us have samples! This is the best ice cream i've ever had in my life. Im not being dramatic. I didn't actually order a cone for myself, but stealing a bunch of my girlfriends showed me the light. Super cool place. Really really loud in a very small space on busy nights though, so be prepared if anyone in your party has sensory issues. Ice cream is worth it. read more

Cute little ice cream shop in Paia tucked beside a creperie that was super popular on the Friday night I was there. After a long day of travel, I decided to keep it chill and go for an evening walk by the beach with a cup of ice cream in hand. Many flavors looked intriguing, but I chose the salted malted vanilla chocolate fudge because of the intriguing name! The ice cream flavor itself was kind of boring, but they gave a nice hefty size for a small. Perfect treat for a walk to the beach! read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

Amazing small batch ice cream with interesting combos, like honey lemon ginger, and huge scoops too. Nice young ladies working there also.

Great little artisan ice cream shop with excellent service. One of the young staff members encouraged me to try the Vega coconut macadamia flavor. I normally would not have picked it, but she was so kind and enthusiastic that I gave it a try. I'm glad I did because it turned out to be one of the best flavors I've had. Creamy, smooth, and perfectly balanced. The staff is friendly and makes the experience even better. Definitely a place worth visiting if you enjoy good ice cream. read more

Hands-down, this is the very best ice cream on the island! Possibly the best ice cream I've had anywhere. And I have had a lot of ice cream in my many years of life. And the chocolate chip cookies are also amazing. read more

Artisan Ice Cream is not your average scoop shop--this place is a flavor playground for ice cream lovers! Every batch is small-batch and handcrafted, and you can taste the difference. I tried the mango strawberry swirl in a cone, and the hubby had a scoop of the dutches cocoa chocolate. They were insanely good. Creamy, rich, and not overly sweet--just pure, high-quality ingredients that shine through. I sampled the lilikoi butter and that was more of a light refreshing taste. They rotate flavors and have lots of vegan and dairy-free options, which I really appreciate. The shop has a cozy cute vibe and the staff clearly love what they do--super friendly and generous with samples. If you're into unique, gourmet flavors that are made with love, Artisan Ice Cream is 100% worth the stop. read more

You know a place is good when you smell their baking chocolate chip cookies from DOWN THE BLOCK. They did not disappoint. The ice cream and cookies here have also not disappointed on any of the other 47 times i've been here. Absolutely convinced this is the best ice cream on Maui. They're flavors are local hawaiian and unique. The quality is beyond words. They ALSOOO have vegan options that are sooo good (if that is ur thing. I wish there was a bit more seating but didn't mind walking around with it also :) read more

See all

They have all nature and favors I love. They have lavender to lilikoi to coffee and more. Love this place, one of my favorite ice cream store, it's small, and workers has always been so kind read more

We couldn't resist walking in here because it smelled so incredible walking by. We had just eaten snow cones but the girls were so nice offering samples so we felt like we HAD to try some.... And I ended up getting a scoop of coffee cookies and cream because it was SO good. I guess, when in Hawaii? It's fine! But the coffee flavor was perfect and the ice cream is so creamy. Highly recommend. read more

This place, tucked behind Cafe Des Amis, boasts good ice cream and great service. It has very unique flavors with both dairy and nondairy options - no sorbets. The workers there were very nice, letting us sample as many flavors as we wanted . The portions were incredibly generous (especially for Hawaii): large scoops and reasonable prices. The flavor themselves were great. Definitely not mind-blowing, but creamy enough to satisfy any sweet craving. I recommend checking this spot out, either after a good meal in Paia, or simply as a sweet treat. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

Wow. All flavors are delicious - confirmed because they let you sample as many as you want! Ended up getting lilikoi butter and coconut macadamia nut.- both delicious. They have fresh cones too that are delicious. The staff is super kind. Super cute vibe too. Highly recommend! read more

Best ice cream on island. 10/10 (and I'm not big on ice cream) But if you're here to see if anyone has reviewed the 2 girls , this is for you! Good Service....Only when the two young girls that keep giving people eye rolls every time they ask for a sample aren't working. The main one is a blonde girl with big round eyes and lashes full of mascara, the other one is a Brunette... seems like the brunette just follows the lead of the blonde one. They make it absurdly obvious that you piss them off. They slam the freezer door when opening and they always look at each other judging you and fake smiles. It's just awful. I will keep coming cause I want to support the shop , but I bet these girls probably don't even know what TIP Stands for either, so I will continue not tipping them till they actually start to understand they need to earn the tip as a gratitude for their promptness. I always take my visiting friends and family there but those girls can literally make an unpleasant ambiance without a doubt. read more

Delicious ice cream! We had the ice cream for dessert after have a lovely lunch at Cafe Des Amis, so we were able to have our ice cream at our table. Their flavors are rich and fresh! Definitely coming back read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

I've enjoyed this place, great ice cream and so-so service. This is for the manager. Today, Sunday June 14th, I decided around 2:30 that an ice cream cone would be great, I was all ready to get some from my usual place. There was no line, three people in the place, two girls working, and a friend who was not buying anything on my side of the counter. Not one single hi or acknowledgement that there was someone else in the place. I waited patiently, one girl left an came back, to talking to their friend, still not even a glance my way. Whoever these girls are, they need training. They are there to sell ice cream, I got the message that they weren't interested in doing their jobs, so I said "okay, I guess I have to leave". Nothing. Worst customer service,please talk to your employees about customer service. I don't need anyone to bow down in my presence, but a simple "hi,we'll be with you in a moment" was all that was necessary. Instead they couldn't be bothered. Good ice cream, but please train your staff. read more

Stopped by on my way to the airport and I was NOT disappointed! I only got vanilla , but based on the bold flavor of that I know the rest of their ice cream is good. The staff was helpful when picking flavors and selecting samples. read more

Best vegan ice cream I've ever had!! In fact, it is was the best thing I ate in Maui and I ate at the Four Seasons, Ko, Monkey Pod, and a bunch of other places!! Got the coconut milk with vegan caramel sauce and it was amazing!! My son who eats dairy got the brown sugar cinnamon and he said it was the best ice cream he's ever had. Can't wait to come back!! read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Coconut milk and caramel sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

Artisan ice cream had tons of flavors. We got peanut butter chocolate chip. The serving size was very generous and the employees were kind. There were a few benches outside if you wanted to sit outside and enjoy your ice cream. read more

See all

I will never come back to place again. The worker named Talia is so un professional and rude. She sits there on her phone and does not assist customers. The other girl Faith was so nice to me and helpful but this place is not worth the re visit. The vegan flavors were trash and Highly not recommended. If I could give ZERO stars I would. read more

Great ice cream. Stop there when we head to the beach. Seems like they have flavors you can't find at the supermarket

After dinner and a day chillin' on the beach, I wanted some ice cream to end the night with! Luckily, Artisan Ice Cream was only a 5 mins drive from our AirBNB. Downtown Paia is so hard to find parking! Even at 730pm at night, it was packed and we had to park 2 blocks up (again as during the day time). Don't blink or you might miss the entrance as I did! It's a small walkway into a door to the right. We got a cup of 3 scoops: Honey Lavender, Chocolate and Lilikoi Butter. Very creamy and delicious. Perfect to end a hot day with. Satisfy my ice cream craving. :) read more

See all

The vegan ice cream, which was coconut macadamia, was awesome. The dairy ice cream, salted peanut butter chocolate chip was super sugary. Yes, it's a bit pricey, but they do give generous scoops. Inventive flavous. Eat fast because the ice cream is not that hard and it liquefied pretty fast -- for context it was actually a cooler day when I went. read more

Artisan Ice Cream - Double scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Paia, Hawaii

See all

Nestled in the bustling town of Paia lies Artisan ice cream. They make all the ice cream themselves! I'm a huge fan of the lavender honey ice cream. I'm glad they didn't "dye/color" their ice cream purple and it's a natural white color. The honey doesn't overpower the lavender and it's lovely. Dairy based so that means it's creamy good! Waffle cone - Extra $1 but wasn't worth it to me. I like my waffle cones super fresh. read more

See all

What a cute ice cream place in Paia! Located across the street from Mana Foods and right next to Cafe de Amis. Fun flavors to choose from and best of all they offer samples of all of them! I went with lilikoi butter and key lime pie. Yum! They were making fresh waffle cones and they smelled delicious. I'll have to try them next time. With some vegan offerings there is something for everyone! read more

See all