I can't believe this restaurant came up in my search for Mexican food. They do passable Italian and a little American and that's it. There is no Mexican food on the menue! read more

Do you enjoy burnt food? Do you enjoy being accused of lying about burnt food? Then Art's Jug is the place for you! Our medium bacon pizza was missing part of a slice, our garlic knots were burnt, and the large pizza was burnt around the edges. Not just a little bit, but half and whole slices. Attempted to resolve this with management and we were accused of lying. They refused to make things right. If you enjoy wasting $29 go on a Sunday pizza special plus garlic knots, go for it. You can see the pictures of the food we received above. read more

See all

Went on a Sunday at 5:30pm. Got ignored at the front door by the hostess in tall boots. Eventually walked to the bar. The bar was out of just about everything, both beer & liquor. Atmosphere was dreary to say the least. Got a cocktail & there wasn't enough for a second drink? Prices are high but we know why. Lots of the older crowd here... Bacon wrapped Scallops were cold in the middle but luckily we didn't get sick. Only reason for three stars was the awesome anti pasta salad we got for $15. read more

Honestly some of the best food I've had in my travels. Hidden gem. Everything tastes homemade and super fresh. Pizza and Chicken Marsala were phenomenal, and the seafood was awesome as well. Thanks! read more

My wife did not like sheet pan pizza, she does now. So good!!! I don't even mind getting those crust-less middle pieces.

Pizza used to be great but no longer. Hardly any toppings but loaded with greasy cheese. Not worth the price.

I ordered the Hawaiian pizza most of the time! It was delicious. Our waitress was friendly. overall it was a great experience. I highly recommend this place for pizza! read more

The best pizza around, and their gluten free is awesome! I can't eat gluten and have tried many places around town. No luck on anything that taste close to pizza. More like cardboard. My family also says this is the best pizza in town. It's now the only place I'll order from. read more

We had dinner ,with 2 friends,a few days ago. I had lasagna,it was probably a Sisco special. It definitely was not home made,in my opinion. It was a perfect square,uniform layers.machine made? Dinner for 2 with 2 cocktails....$74.00 for mediocre food......//try Pete's . They are probably cousins but use a different meal supply company. I'm from NJ and expect something close to Italian read more

Got a veal parmigiana "torpedo" here that was about 7-8 inches in length total FOR $14.50. Absolutely ridiculous price for the the size and the amount of meat. Decent flavor , but for that price , not even close to worth it. Overall this place is overpriced for the quantity and quality. Thankfully, I only eat here when I visit out of town because my family ate here when the were kids and find it nostalgic. read more

Great pizza, the best in the area. Flavor is always consistent. Always had a great meal no matter what I've ordered.

Nice, low-key atmosphere. Typical Italian fare. Good for a solid meal. They have a happy hour that seems decent. Nothing incredibly special but definitely solid and reliable. read more

I remember being pretty excited to eat here but I was a little disappointed. It must be something about Watertown but a lot of the restaurants have strange hours and this is one of them. The menu is very limited. I don't eat red meat and I had maybe two options to choose from. They have a lot of specialty pizza's but not being in the mood for that I had to settle. For what they charged, I really expected more. Service was pretty poor. We had to keep flagging down our waitress constantly... even to take our order. read more

Art's Jug has always been a watertown favorite of mine. There's not to many family owned restaurants left in watertown, which is quite depressing! If you want to get away from the routine tastes of Applebees & Texas roadhouse go to Arts Jug. It's home style Italian & American food with a friendly atmosphere. My favorite dish is the chicken limone. Always perfect when I order it, and delicious. Comes with a salad and your choice of side. Along with warm bread to start with. It's casual dining, but also a popular spot to go for special occasions as well. The staff is always friendly in my experience and the prices are on par with every other restaurant in the area. I definitely recommend this place if you want to try something new. read more

The best gift Christmas can bring is a gift card to the many Coleman family restaurants. Gift card in hand, we headed to Art's on a busy Saturday night. Get there early or call ahead because this is always a popular stop. We started with a couple house lambruscos. Bright and fruity, a delight to warm up with. Usually we have their delightful Italian specialties, but today we were in a pizza mood. After a couple of tasty Italian salads, we each ordered a small pizza, knowing that we'd have leftovers. The sauce, cheese, pepperoni and sausage were all delicious. The crust was a weird texture like a fluffy pillow. Aside from the crust we really enjoyed our meal. And the service was awesome! read more

Art's Jug Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Sausage and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, New York

See all

I have to add a comment to my previous review. I was in Watertown for a visit and decided to take my daughter to Art's Jug. We ordered a small pizza - cheese / half pepperoni. If I didn't know better, this pizza could have been a frozen, DiGiorno Cheese pizza with pepperoni added to one half of the pie. It was a disappointment as Art's Jug's history is so very diffferent from what was served that night. read more

Art's jug is an unassuming Italian place with a surprisingly good menu. The specials were interesting and one of my two companions tried the Montreal Flatiron, whereas the other went for stuffed Flounder. I tried the pizza. Interestingly dinner options came with the usual potato options or alternatively spaghetti. The free Italian bread basket was very tasty, and the beer selection good, but dining companion one lamented the lack of Morretti. The pizza was great - definitely worth a return. The crust was moist inside but crispy outside, the toppings also quality. My friend with the flounder was very impressed considering Watertown is not exactly on the beach. The flatiron was also rated well. Pretty good all around! read more

Been ordering pizza from Arts the same way for over ten years. Granted it's a special order with light sauce on one side and light cheese on the other. And for the most part this has been how they come. Tonight we were told this is not their policy. When I questioned why this was the first time we were ever told that - I was put on hold with no warning and was then talking to who I assume was a manger who refused to believe that ANY of her employees would have let us order that way, she attempted to get me to believe that despite how we were ordering they were not doing what we asked. As I'm sure you can understand that only made things worse. Guess Arts has forgotten the customer is always right. So Pizza Hut it is , where their policy is to give the customer what they ask for. read more

This place is so good! We have been here 8 months and have struggled to find a decent pizza place that has flavor and is affordable...Art's Jug FINALLY met the challenge. We will NEVER order from a generic pizza place again. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and and a peanut butter cannoli and everything was amazing! I'm so excited we finally found a new Friday pizza place that delivers. read more

It has been a while since we had Arts pizza. Tried it today. Terrific. We have pizza from various vendors in Watertown and as of today Arts is hands down the best. Definitely will be back. Delicious read more

Not being from Watertown, but having lived here 30 years, we have given Arts Jug multiple opportunities, but it always seems to come up short. Tonight was no different. It took easily 45 minutes to get our meals. I joked with my husband they must've had to go to Fairground to get my lasagna. He simply order the fried haddock with roasted potatoes ( boiled? ) After sitting there for what seemed like forever Our waitress asked us if we needed additional napkins? Mind you...we have no food... Appetizer we had ordered a while back was already boxed up waiting to go home. And ...My husband had already gone to the bar to refill our beverage after they sat empty for what seemed like an eternity. I honestly think she was just trying to make conversation. Finally after 45 minutes ... no joke....my lasagna with my one meatball, as requested, and my husband's fried haddock were served... Oh... the roasted ( boiled) potatoes were still gonna be a bit??? Huh? When the roasted ( boiled) potatoes were finally served, we asked for bread. The last of the bread had just been served to the table next to us, with their salads. Would rolls be OK? They just put some in to bake... it came when we had finished. Lasagna in an Italian restaurant with no Italian bread... Who'd a thunk... We ate, paid our bill, left her a 20% gratuity... Never to return. If you are from Watertown or the surrounding area and have fond childhood memories of this once fabulous eatery... Then I'm sure you will never have the experience we did, because your visit will be clouded by emotion. Next time We'll just go to the fairgrounds and get the Lasagna ....and bread ....ourselves. Save them Arts jug the trouble... the lasagna was very good... as was the fish... but truly not worth the total experience. read more

I've only done take-out here, but both the food and the service was awesome! The pizza was good, and their homemade dressing for the salad was incredible. They have great weekly food specials as well. I would definitely recommend adding a cannoli or two to the order - hands down one of the tastiest I've ever had. The filling was a perfect texture and the shell was crunchy. Overall, it was a great place to stop! read more

I am so happy we found this place, it is hidden on a back street. I always order something from their special menu or specials for the day. Broiled Sea Scallops - must order Filet of Sirloin - must order You have to try it out! read more

Worst waitstaff. Didn't get any service from the staff until we stated to the hostess that no one came by after 15 minutes. Apparently, the waitress was making salads in the back... we left. I do not recommend this place unless you want to wait 15 mins for someone to hopefully serve you. read more

A very simple and classic family restaurant with great food! The pizza is pan styled and is delicious with pepperoni and sausage! The salad is good but they do soak it in dressing! Just ask for it on the side if you don't want as much! Leave room for desserts as the cannolis and peanut butter cake is delicious! Perfect snacks if you need a little sugary treat! The ambiance is very casual! The inside is dimly lit and would be perfect for large groups! The server was extremely nice and attentive! read more

Classic diner with a decent bar. We went on Valentine's Day and it was packed as can be expected. We were seated 70 min after our reservation time. The drinks were pretty good and our food was ok. read more

I've been there twice now and so far everything about the place is amazing. The food, environment, the people. I recommend the king size steak! Mmm read more

Art's Jug Pizza & Italian Restaurant - King steak - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, New York

Definitely one of the top pizza restaurants in town. My only complaint is that the straws are too short for the cups. Stop and eat here!

Their garlic pizza is the best. Crust is soft and chewy. Wings are a little fatty but the flavor us delicious. We love this pizza and it id our go to dinner. read more

This family restaurant serves a awesome lasagna, I ordered a meatball in the side, both were excellent. Best part if the meal however was a wonderful garlic knot, you have to get one! read more

Art's Jug Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Watertown, New York

Even during the COVID19 times these folks are the best. Best pizza I have had in a long time. Price is right and the folks are great. Thank you for all you do. read more

Meh, Arts was just so-so. We ordered for take out and I wasn't impressed. The chicken parm was salty and lacking flavor. The salad was straight iceberg lettuce. They were out of garlic knots at 7pm so we opted for half knots appetizer, they were very spicy. I don't mind spice but these had little flavor above the heat. We might go back but will probably opt for a different Italian restaurant if that's what we're in the mood for. read more

If the servers can't even pretend to be friendly, what's the point. I used to really like this place.

We took my Grandfather here for his birthday dinner back in December and it was fantastic. Even though there were 15 of us, the staff was friendly and the service fast. Generous portions and delicious food! read more

Been here a few times lately for family gatherings. I had the seafood pasta which was not good. It was missing one of the seafoods, the scallops were rubbery, and it came with a swirly macaroni pasta that just doesn't go with seafood dishes. The pizza is average with a lackluster crust. the toppings are usually decent however. The anitpasto isn't like what it used to be. There like 2 slices of cheese and salami and which is enough for 2 people. when you are trying to share with everyone (like it's meant to be), it just isn't enough for everyone. Servers are pretty nice and most of the food came out at the same time. Seems as though the food standards have fallen here or are stuck in the past compared to other restaurants in the area. The nail in the coffin here is that the prices are too high for the quality of the food. read more

Mediocre Italian food. It tasted frozen to me. Way too pricey for what it is. I could have made spaghetti with Preggo sauce at home and it would have tasted exactly the same. read more

Great food & service! The establishment itself is a little rundown, very dark inside, and they had messy floors. If you can look past that, the food is awesome! read more

I'm a big fan of the pizza and pasta at Art's Jug in Watertown. The Sboro family has been providing the area with great Italian food for many years and this still continues to this day. It's great to spend an evening at a place with such a strong family history, not to mention the delicious food. read more

Best pizza in Northern New York. Have been eating pizza here since the 60's always the best.

Really not impressed with the food, unfortunately. The prices for the entrée are wayyyy too high for the amount and quality of food you get. The people are nice and the atmosphere is relaxing, but not impressed with the food. Perhaps next time I'll try the pizza since that seems to be the popular choice. read more