Brenda&#x27;s Pizzeria

Absolutely great home style food. Service was excellent always. Can get pretty crowded.read more

Service was good. Went for the beer battered fish fry. We've gotten them in the past and they were…read moredelicious. Tried them tonight and someone in the kitchen really doesn't no how to make a beer battered fish. I think they floured the fish first then dredged them through extra thick batter. Fish tasted like uncooked flour even though the batter was way too dark and greasy, probably because our last fish fry here. They used to have a reasonably priced and delicious fried fish. Not sure what happened but we have friends who also mentioned that their fish dinner went down hill. It's a shame.

Interior

Shrimp scampi

See all

Menú

Josie's Pizza At The Bay

4.1(36 reviews)

16.4 mi

Good pizza, polite and helpful service. No online menu or ordering. Calling in and pick up were…read morefast and accurate.

This pizza place is awful the staff do not treat you with kindness and the pizza is terrible almost…read morelike if you mix cheese with dog poop, so never eating here again I wish this place closed down

Vegetable personal pizza

See all

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Dashnaw's Pizzeria

4.4(16 reviews)

17.6 mi

I be love the pizza and the service is amazing ! The older lady (not old) is so sweet and kind …read more Delivery is fast .

Ordered a large pizza and 10 wings for pickup the other night, everything tasted great. Good food,…read moregood service.

Garlic knots

See all

Delish pie

Cam's Pizzeria - Watertown

4.0(202 reviews)

15.8 mi

10/10! Cam's Pizza in Watertown is hard to beat, especially if you're looking for a great meal at a…read moregreat price. A couple of pizza slices and a fountain soda is one of the cheapest and most satisfying meals you can find on the Square. The pizza is always fresh, the slices are generous, and the service is quick and friendly. If you're downtown and craving pizza, this is definitely the place to go!

Okay-ish pizza. My husband and I are used to real pizzeria-style pizza from southern NY, where "by…read morethe slice" actually means multiple slice options ready to go. They advertised slices, but when we got there, they said they were out and only had plain cheese available by the slice if they had any, which was disappointing. We ended up ordering a half pepperoni, half buffalo chicken pie. It took about 35 minutes, and when it came out, it just wasn't what we expected. The center was very soft and soggy, to the point where slices wouldn't hold up and the toppings kept sliding off. There was also a lot of grease. On the buffalo chicken pie they literally used boneless chicken wings instead of traditional chicken, which threw us off and not what I'm used to for NY pizza. If you're used to southern NY-style pizza, this probably won't hit the mark.

Inside the restaurant

Delicious!

See all

Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.5(91 reviews)

13.1 mi

The food is great and the customer service is phenomena! We were in and out in under an hour. Our…read morefood was delicious. Our waitress and the staff (especially Krissy P) were on top of everything and so sweet. 10/10 recommend!

I lived in Carthage a long time ago. I was at the original location across the street that burned…read moredown over 20 years ago. This place was still pretty good. Attentive service. I was alone and I was seated immediately. The restaurant was clean. Nice decorations. I do love pizza, but I've been eating a lot of pizza on this trip so I got a pasta dish. The manicotti. It was a little heavy on the cheese on top for sure. It was good but in the end, I guess I wish I would've got a pizza. Standard selection of National and some regional beer. I got a bottle of Yuengling. Street parking out front, parking lot in the back. There's a rear entrance as well.

The storefront

The garlic knots, swimming in butter (margarine, I think)

See all

You can get artichokes on your pizza

The Sports Page Pub and Grill

3.9(17 reviews)

6.2 mi

Disappointed with Jody and inability to make an appearance. We have been visiting this…read moreestablishment since the first summer Jody opened. Bartender called him but "had errands to run." Unfortunately, that response didn't cut it. We have made a special effort to visit his bar each year we visit the region. Food was not available while we were there, and ambiance was mediocre. Best to you, as it will certainly not remain as our annual dedicated visit.

Food was mediocre for the price paid. Staff was inattentive and rude. Overall I don't think we'll…read morebe back, there's other options in the area this place just isn't worth the headache.

Poutine

Garlic Cheese Bread

See all

Outside

New York Pizzeria

4.1(28 reviews)

17.4 mi

Everything was perfect right down to the delivery. Will…read moredefinitely be back. Looking on the menu which is Perfect.

The restaurant ambiance acceptable. It's not a fancy place. It appeared clean and spacious. There…read morewere not to many customers eating in. One must retrieve menus and order at counter. Then the pizza is delivered to the table of your choosing. On the 2nd visit, while waiting for pizza, I witnessed small children running around in the kitchen area during food preparation. I thought it was dangerous because of hot appliance and frying oil. Also, quite unsanitary because of air borne bacteria. I can only assume, classes not in session on that day. I guess in this part of the state, it is ok to bring children to work. The first time we had a large Plain pizza pie and a standard toss salad. I immediately thought, a supermarket frozen pizza and bag salad would have tasted better. Also, cost me less. We thought we give it another try. Since the place is in walking distance and maybe another type of pie would taste better. Therefore, we shared a New York style pie and wings. Again, the food was very bland. The wings were horrible. Again, flavorless and not well cooked.I guess we needed to request "well done". I am accustom to NYC and NJ Italian, family owned, hand tossed dough, style pizza. Perhaps, not a fair comparison to this place. Most importantly, had to dispute bill because was over charged. Per menu, the mild flavor wings included mild sauce and blue cheese. Yet, charged separately for sauce and blue cheese. The large black binded menu, clearly stated what was included on each pizza pie and cost. Yet, overcharged for toppings. We are not returning However, if you like bland food and paying high prices; go for it.

Chicken Bacon, Ranch pizza!!! #delicious

Wings with raven sauce, heat + sweet = yummy

See all

Chicken parm

Stefano's Pizzeria

3.0(22 reviews)

8.2 mi

Menu stated $4.25 a slice with a drink but yet charged us for it for EACH slice. I think it's a bit…read morewild we spent $18 for all this. Definitely a bit expensive. The restaurant itself was super clean and decorated with cute things. Pizza was great and barley any grease. Would come back with more money to spend.

Great Bend is the worst place I've ever been to. I bought many slices before and I always tell…read morethem I want it then like their slice pie. Well I was there tonight and they burnt the pizza and then it was three times thicker than I wanted and they told me they would give me a discount and then I went get it and they said they couldn't give me one and they were sorry what a worthless place I'll never go there again

Our drinks

See all

One bacon and pepperoni slice

The Brick Oven Inn

4.4(16 reviews)

23.0 mi

Ordered their small cheese pizza, 10 wings (medium) and their fried cheese curds. ($44 total)…read more The cheese curds were pretty decent but that's where it stopped. The wings had zero flavor. Their homemade blue cheese was pretty good. For a "pizza" place it honestly was probably the worst restaurant pizza I've had in a very long time. No flavor to their sauce, the dough was super meh and the cheese was tasteless. I feel like they just buy $1.99 Tombstone Pizza and reheat it. The lady that took my order had no clue how "hot/spicy" their wing sauce was, couldn't give me an estimate on how long it was going to take (the place was totally empty). Every time the upstairs apartments flushed the toilets you could hear it in the dining room. Very unappetizing.

Pizza is always the best around and Prices are affordable...They even have a cheeseburger Pizza…read morethat's a must try

Brick Oven Inn, Beaver Falls

Outdoor seating

See all

Pizza: Large cheese pizza

Korner Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

3.0(57 reviews)

16.4 mi

When Everything else in town was closed for the "off season" this is the one place that didn't…read moredouble as a bat where my daughter and I could eat close to our hotel. Dave/David the owner was working and is a conversationally pleasant person who swears a bit much when gushing about his daughter. His employee, whose name i swear I remember but this review would say otherwise, was the nicest gentleman anyone could hope to have taking your order. Between the two of them we were treated well and comped a bottled water for our travels and an extra slice of pizza when my daughter's appetite exceeded the food she was provided. I can't say the food is any more or less than the expected neighborhood pizza joint expectations, but the variety, vegetarian options (limited as they are) and COFFEE which I badly needed, all combined with being the only business owner in this small town with the sense to realize people eat in winter makes this The place to visit. Pie isn't bad either, albeit a bit pricey. :) Service 5 stars Food 3.5 stars

I've had better gas station pizza lol Definitely won't go…read moreback Service was bad also they had no clue what they were doing

Menu

Cheese Personal Pizza

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Vickie M.

0

1

0

4 years ago

Food was fair, prices were high, and staff unfriendly.

Brenda's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Brenda's Pizzeria also viewed

New York Pizzeria

4.1

(28 reviews)

Everything was perfect right down to the delivery. Will…read moredefinitely be back. Looking on the menu which is Perfect.

The restaurant ambiance acceptable. It's not a fancy place. It appeared clean and spacious. There…read morewere not to many customers eating in. One must retrieve menus and order at counter. Then the pizza is delivered to the table of your choosing. On the 2nd visit, while waiting for pizza, I witnessed small children running around in the kitchen area during food preparation. I thought it was dangerous because of hot appliance and frying oil. Also, quite unsanitary because of air borne bacteria. I can only assume, classes not in session on that day. I guess in this part of the state, it is ok to bring children to work. The first time we had a large Plain pizza pie and a standard toss salad. I immediately thought, a supermarket frozen pizza and bag salad would have tasted better. Also, cost me less. We thought we give it another try. Since the place is in walking distance and maybe another type of pie would taste better. Therefore, we shared a New York style pie and wings. Again, the food was very bland. The wings were horrible. Again, flavorless and not well cooked.I guess we needed to request "well done". I am accustom to NYC and NJ Italian, family owned, hand tossed dough, style pizza. Perhaps, not a fair comparison to this place. Most importantly, had to dispute bill because was over charged. Per menu, the mild flavor wings included mild sauce and blue cheese. Yet, charged separately for sauce and blue cheese. The large black binded menu, clearly stated what was included on each pizza pie and cost. Yet, overcharged for toppings. We are not returning However, if you like bland food and paying high prices; go for it.

Art's Jug

3.6

(108 reviews)

First time ordering from this place. Just did online take out. Pizza was delicious! Just wish it…read moredidn't take almost 2 hours to get two smedium pizzas.... Employees seem nice though

I've been here many times. In the eighties it was my parents go-to and for pizza takeout. The…read morelady bartender who I've seen many times has absolutely no hospitality skills at all. She actually scolded me a few times. I will never ever ever sit with her at the bar again I paid and didn't even eat the food I ordered. A very hostile environment if you were not one of the regular customers. Shame on Arts Jug. I dont care how good or consistent the food is,,,,hospitality is far more important.

Dashnaw's Pizzeria

4.4

(16 reviews)

I be love the pizza and the service is amazing ! The older lady (not old) is so sweet and kind …read more Delivery is fast .

Ordered a large pizza and 10 wings for pickup the other night, everything tasted great. Good food,…read moregood service.

Pete's Trattoria

4.2

(165 reviews)

Sharing apps at Pete's Trattoria in Watertown. Clockwise from left, bacon wrapped scallops, Utica…read moreGreens, half-hots, roasted beet , walnut, goat cheese salad. I had Sauvignon Blanc. Tiramisu to go. We ate in the lounge, because their dining room was 'fully committed' until 6:30- it was 4:45. I was surprised as it was early on a Thursday in the winter, but maybe I shouldn't have been! A wholly satisfying experience. Our server was terrific especially considering she also had a full dining room. This is a classic Italian restaurant we are blessed to have.

Had a craving for Italian so stopped in when I was in town…read more Upon arrival they have a small parking lot next to the restaurant but there is a parking lot across the street attached to a vacant building folks were using. There was a separate bar and dining area for folks to chooses from. I opted for the dining area, I was alone and it took a while to be seated because they didn't want to seat me at an empty table in the middle of the dining room. When seated I was a table on the edge. The space looked accustomed for larger groups and had many large and small parties. The light in the space was a bit low in comparison to the bright sun outside coming through the windows. My server was very attentive and I was quickly able to order. The home made loaf of italian bread came out warm and was light and fluffy. I ordered the Utica Greens and Shrimp Riggies. While I enjoyed I had expected there to be a bit of heat in each dish which they didn't have. i ended up adding red pepper flakes to both to get it to my liking.

Fairground Inn Family Restaurant

3.8

(109 reviews)

This was an interesting visit. The place was packed when we got there, then quickly cleared out…read more Tables were not bussed in an appropriate amount of time. Food menu was huge.... Our waitress was fantastic though and dealt with our shenanigans. The wings were crisp, the pizza was cooked exactly how I like it (,extra brown) but others may not like that without asking for it, the burger was gigantic. Decent place for a local joint in Watertown. A family favorite for my fiancee. I just didn't like how loud the place was when everyone was talking.

Weekly prime rib special and it was fantastic. 10oz prime rib, salad, garlic rolls and baked potato…read morefor $22. You can't beat that. The restaurant has been here since 1933 and the vibe was pure local. Everyone seemed to know each other. I was waiting for someone to yell "NORM!" Service was wonderful.

Good Fellos

3.9

(211 reviews)

A friendly lively spot throughout the year! Great pizzas and large portions. Everything I've eaten…read morehere has been very good. I will keep returning!

Wednesday "Wine Night" can't go wrong! Excellent Italian food Very Attentive Staff.....read more

Tonys Pizzeria

5.0

(1 review)

Tony's Pizzeria to me has always been the first thing I recommend to people that have never tried…read morethe pizza scene here in Watertown and the surrounding area. Sure there are other pizzerias that have been here for far longer, and they all have their own good pizzas; but none of them come even close to the pizza and other menu items offered at Tony's. The amount of toppings available is amazing, and even toppings available at Tony's that aren't available in most places (anchovies being my top pick). The desserts are an excellent cherry on top with the cannolis and tiramisu being the peak options to go for. You won't find a better pizzeria menu anywhere else. The staff there are always very friendly and have good small conversations when able to. I'm always greeted with a smile and greeting of the day. The venue itself is reminiscent of the small pizza joint you go to with your friends after school or a long day's work. Always very clean and the music never being too loud and obnoxious. You will be sorely missing out on amazing food if you never come here. Make sure you pop in and get yourself a whole pie or a slice. Your tastebuds and stomach will definitely thank you for it and you will definitely not regret it. 10/10 food, staff, service and experience.

Wise Guys Ristorante

4.5

(188 reviews)

As always, the staff were genuine in their professional and personable attention. We were welcomed…read moreas we were family. It was a quiet celebration of 48 years married. Everyone made us feel special. And Greta's "sweet" dessert presentation was so special. Everyone should have at least one evening enjoying these wonderful people and absolutely amazing food. Every dish we have been served is always delicious and served with a delightful presentation.

BEST Italian around!! We have been coming here ever since they opened! Recommended to countless…read morepeople!

Primo's De Tico's

3.3

(108 reviews)