Worst customer service ever, I will never refer anyone to Atlantic Tire. I had a negative experience with a young employee, while he was busy in the register he ignored me pretending I wasn't there. That was very rude, unacceptable. In addition, it was another mature man with him also with the same attitude no customer service skills, zero empathy, and unhelpful response till I finally got his attention. Unfortunately it made no difference, after all I left and get new tires somewhere else. Simple. Customer service training will be beneficial and very helpful. read more

I really cannot say enough about how wonderful the customer service is from Greg. If you live in NJ, you know how often you'll need tires or plugs from all of the lovely potholes. There's nowhere else we'd take our vehicles! I just recently went to have tires and break maintenance done on my Jeep Compass and had a great experience as always. I'm able to email Atlantic Tire directly with what I need and receive a prompt response back with pricing details. For tires, different brands, mileage, and pricing with available rebate offers were listed out so that I could choose what would fit my needs and budget. For breaks, I was unsure if I needed both front and rear and requested pricing for both. They were able to check and let me know I still was okay on the one but replaced the other. --I feel like any other shop would've just told me I needed both even if I didn't. When you drop your vehicle at Atlantic Tire, you really feel like you are dropping it off to be serviced by a friend. read more

Atlantic Tire & Supply - Tires Near Me - Avenel, New Jersey

My tesla tire had nail and I went to few tire repair shops they were too stupid n don't know what to do since tesla tire has foam padding inside . Foam padding is worst invention for tire. One car mechanic suggest me to buy a new tire when the car is brand new. I will not buy new tire every time I have a nail. Atlantic tire help me patch the tire on Xmas Eve in the morning with short wait and was helpful explaining foam padding tire. They charge me $25 and I tip them $10. read more

Walked in with a nail in the tire. They took me in pretty quick. Only thing that I waited a little longer for a tire patch, but I am thankful that he took the time to check and recheck since my son rides in it and I want to make sure he's safe at all times. The guy who worked on my car, I didn't catch his name, sorry, was super nice and inflated all my tires. And even when he and I had a miscommunication about which tire, he gladly did the right one with no sour face included :) You get a couple of smiles here and there, but everyone is pretty busy working on things. Front desk lady was nice too! Thanks! read more

Atlantic Tire & Supply - Tires Near Me - Avenel, New Jersey

See all

Always reliable and very affordable good team plus they're fast no real long wait times

I recently got my starter changed, but it never sounded correct after service. On top of it randomly not starting, it also makes a loud skidding sound and violently shakes. ultimately, my car randomly broke down after 6 months. What was supposed to be a fix under warranty ended up costing me $600 for a new battery/alternator. Even though those parts were changed my car still sounded bad and made the skidding sound. I brought it back again to which they said they they cleaned the grounds, but that failed to work. I then brought my car to another mechanic, and he informed me that even after 6 months there's no way that my starter should have that amount of erosion and rust. There's also about 25 etch marks 1/4" apart that clearly indicates that someone banged it with a flathead and hammer. After getting a second opinion, I informed Atlantic that there's no possible way they changed my starter to which I was met with hostility. Although I won't name the mechanic he said "You hide behind a computer like a coward" "How could you leave a bad review for a business...That's the type of person you are" "You take everything out of context like the news" "You act like you know more than I do" "We can't figure out what's wrong with your car! Take it to someone else" Mind you, before all this, I informed the head mechanic that I would be leaving a bad review if my car wasn't working properly. I don't leave bad reviews....In fact this is the only place I've left a review for in my life. This place is a scam and shows no type of emotional intelligence towards its customers. read more

See all

I've been going here for years and they have never let me down! I'm always helped when I walk in & the staff here is fire attentive and friendly. I also like that they have my history saved on my profile so I can always keep up with my last tire purchase and get the same tire. Highly recommend! :) read more

I needed 4 new tires. This place is family owned I believe and that's the best. I can walk in and not need a appointment. The receptionist is amazing as well. Friendly and always nice. Thank you guys. Will recommend. Also they had a few choices of different price tires to choose from which was great ! read more

The last two times I brought my car here they called my house number when I was at work & specifically asked them to call my cell as I'd be at work. Fast forward to dropping my car off on a Friday at 9am & asking the receptionist to call my cell due to this. Called back at noon and it was on the lift... Explained to please again call my cell. Called back at 2pm and the mechanic left me 3 voicemails I never got because he didn't call my cell. They never ordered the parts on time so I was without my car for a full weekend. Monday went in to explain all this & never wanted to return again. Started driving my sick son to the doctor and the same lights, brake and battery came on. I spent $450 on a battery brakes, roders, labor etc. Called today to explain the lights back on & the receptionist passed me back to the mechanic who then passed my call to another man ! No one wants to deal with their issue of not fixing my car after it was there for four full days! Never again will I take any of our 3 cars to Atlantic Tire!!! read more

Quick great quality work. Been a couple times with flats that they were able to fix. Destroyed a tire On my way to work one morning, they had it changed and back on in 20 minutes, thankfully. read more

The family is great, and they really do know their stuff. What do you need? Winter tires? Summer tires? All Season? Whether price or performance is more important to you, they'll give you plenty of options. They'll find you a good deal if you're open to suggestions or get you exactly what you want. If you're scoping, they're helpful keeping an eye out too. There may have been 5 or 6 different cars I've brought through here, and all with different driving styles. I can go in and say I want a set of Blizzaks for a BMW 335 xi. Their question: do you really need that? (Insert suggestion here) would work just as well for how the car is driven and are cheaper. Boom. Done. Coming in with a flat or with a previous appointment, they're quick and careful. I'm usually talking to them longer than it'll actually take to do any work. I haven't come across a tire shop I can say that I like better than Atlantic Tire. ^_^ read more

Atlantic Tire is a family owned and run business that is fair and honest. I have brought my cars there for 20 years and I couldn't be happier with their service. read more

It was a Saturday morning and I needed just one tire for my '03 Altima, wanted it fast and - here comes the hard part - used. I called around to several tire dealers. Two told me they could help out. Nothing against the other place, but Ed of Atlantic Tire had an exact match and demonstrated a sense of humor as we spoke so I went with them. I hustled down to Atlantic Tire and in about an hour my donut spare was back in my trunk as I drove out on four regular wheels. Atlantic seems to be family run, which may explain why they gave me the impression of not just being a business that's only about the numbers. The weather was hot that July morning and the waiting area offered only a fan instead of air conditioning. Okay, I was in there only an hour but I felt bad for the nice gal who manages the traffic there all day - on her feet, no less - and anyone who gets hit harder by heat, especially if they have to wait longer. The price I paid Atlantic for my used tire compared well to the quote from the other dealer. And as I don't know if that other tire was an exact match and what kind of tread it had, for all I know I did even better with Atlantic than I thought. Next time I need tires, I will see what Atlantic Tire is offering. read more

Needing to replace a bald pair of Bridgestone Turanzas, I asked Atlantic Tire if they could sell me one used tire and install a spare Firestone I had. I worried such a small order would be of no interest but they said, "Yes." The pleasant fellow with whom I spoke on the phone checked inventory and invited me to drop by, as he had what I needed for my car in stock. The gal at the desk could have been friendlier but, who knows, we all have those days. Anyway, in about an hour my car was ready. Inspecting the work, I noticed . . . a pair of Bridgestone Turanzas? Where was the Firestone I left in the car for them to install? Had the staff made a mistake? Checking more closely, I realized these two Bridgestones were not the baldies I asked them to replace. Someone should have explained it to me but I figured out that Atlantic swapped the Firestone for one used Bridgestone and sold me the second used Bridgestone. The receipt did not name the tire brand, designating it merely as "used." Despite those communication shortcomings, Atlantic Tire satisfied me. read more

they honest and they are pro in their area, greg helped me with my wheels problem, they do the work fast and clean read more

Atlantic Tire & Supply - Tires Near Me - Avenel, New Jersey

Customer service is horrendous and they are expensive but get away with it bc no other place around to compete against.

Couldn't ask for a better place! No matter what the problem is they are able to help. People are friendly and honest, prices are fair and the work they do is great. After some questionable issues with my dealer on what problems actually existed Atlantic Tire is the only place I will bring my Jeep for service. read more

*Note: 1.5 for Location, parking, also nice sounding receptionist when I called. Called in morning. They had 5 tires of the unique size tires I required. Went after work and guess what !? Only 1 goddamn tires left. Why did the person I spoke to (who was pleasant over the phone) not tell me to reserve these hard to come by tires !! I would have paid for them over the phone on the spot. I'm sitting outside in my car, infuriated with the lack of communication in this auto establishment. Going to call OTHER places. Seems I have the chupacabras of tires to hunt down. Thanks for nothing !!!!!!! my advice for future patrons. If you call ahead and they have your tire. Buy it (if you need them right away) If not they will NOT hold them and you will waste your time, like I just did ! (I will update IF and only IF they find my tires) read more

Today I went to Atlantic Tire to replace a tire that was leaking. Atlantic came highly recommended from the mechanics that service our SUV. I'm glad I took their advice. There's not much to say. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly, the tires are excellent quality and the prices are much lower than I expected. That doesn't happen very often, at least not to me. I can wholeheartedly recommend that you trust Atlantic Tire for all of your tire needs. Their service is fast, friendly and affordable. What else do you need? I can't think of anything so I'll surely be back. In the interest of fair balance, I have to say that the parking situation leaves a few spaces to be desired. It's a little bit of a pain in the neck because the pre-service parking is on the side of the building and when it's time for your car to go into the garage you have to make a left onto St George Avenue (no light) and then make another immediate left into the driveway of the garage. It's not a deal-breaker by any means, but it was a pain in the neck. If you need one tire or four, used tires or new, Visit Atlantic Tire. You will be in and out in no time and be glad you have them a try. read more

Needed new tires on my SUV. Atlantic Tire has been our go to place for many years. Best Price and Service. Staff is Awesome. Thanks Guys

I stopped in at 8 am to get my 37 inch tires high speed balanced that nobody else could do. They took care of me on the spot I was done and on my way by 845. This place rocks read more

Ok place to get a tire in a hurry. Kind of pricey. Go to elizabeth or perth amboy for cheaper deals.

Usually, folks only take time to post a review when they've had a bad experience - well... I'm writing because I had an Incredible experience and I want you all to know! I've used Atlantic Tire twice now and Both times, they were great. Yesterday, they replaced a tire for me - they gave me a great deal on a like new, used tire - installed it & had me in & out, within 20 minutes. Price is my #1 and I'll tolerate a lot, to achieve the savings but these folks provided it all - they were polite, quick, honest, professional and inexpensive!!! I'll surely be going back and I would recommend them to anyone in need of tires or auto repair. No - I'm not related to anyone there nor do I know any of them. Just a straight up honest review from a happy customer. read more

this is a prime example that good businesses stick around. my family has had several cars in the past decade and we've always come here for the tire service. we've moved since but i know it's well worth a drive for a job done right. read more

I come here for all my tire and wheel needs. Honest and reasonable prices. Also great to support Americas small business.

Went for a flat tire fix. A mechanic started working on my car the moment I parked it. He identified and showed the nail in less than 2 minutes. The flat was fixed super quickly. Very friendly and efficient team. Will visit again if required in the future. read more

The guys at Atlantic Tire are honest and will help you get the most for your money. They will recommend tires that are affordable and high performance as opposed to overly expensive. And they are quick! In and out in 30 minutes. I won't buy tires anywhere else. read more

Great customer service in the front and very skilled mechanics in the back! With very good prices, what more can you ask for?

Most unorganized place ive ever been to. If you need your tire repaired prepare to sit a long time, see confused staff write notes on paper instead of a computer system. Its unreal read more

I needed a new front tire after mine busted on the way to the beach. I put on the spare but that one ended up flat too. After a quick tow to Atlantic Tire, they ended up replacing all four old tires at a relatively low price. They were friendly, straightforward, and prompt. And the nice owner, Ed, even threw in a new spare free of charge. I highly recommend these guys for any of your tire needs. read more

This shop is across the street from my house so I thought it would be convenient, but I'm never going back to this place again. My fiancé had a bubble on her tire so I called to see if they had this specific tire size & brand. I waited on hold for 14 minutes because they were "checking" just for them to hang up on me. I literally heard the person take me off hold & slam the phone to hang up on me. Next day my fiancé's tire had a flat so we had no choice but to go to Atlantic Tire. She was there for an hour just for the lady to tell her they have to order the tire & it'll be here tomorrow. She comes back tomorrow and it took them over 90 minutes to change ONE tire..... ONE TIRE. The lady at the front desk was extremely rude the whole time. It's like we were bothering her for asking her to do her job. We wanted to see the tire before they put it on to make sure it was the right one & no one would let us go look. Car is finally done & what do you know, they put the wrong type of tire on the car. We specifically asked for a Pirelli tire & they put some random brand tire on there. The tire fits & the wheel has been okay, but they did such a horrible job. There was glue ALL OVER the rim & tires, would it have killed you to wipe it off? It's like they just slapped the tire on there & pushed the car out. We will never be going back to this place, you should really go to any other shop in the area. I would rather push my car a mile down St Georges to go somewhere else then come here again. Absolutely horrible experience, I have no idea how this place has good reviews. read more

I've been waiting to get a tire an hour now and they put someone in front of me. Mistakes happen. Woman behind the counter is not courteous and made no effort to make sure I was next. Price is fair. read more

I needed a tire to replace a flat I received when driving. They had the tire I wanted in stock. They were very quick and friendly. They also sell used tires as well. Great experience and very recomended. read more

Glad that the staff here were able to help remove a nail from one of my tires. The waiting room appears to always be crowded. The lady at the front desk could at least put on a smile and be a little more friendly for all of those waiting customers. She wouldn't even give us the receipt. By the way, someone scratched the rim of the tire...tisk tisk. read more

A great family run tire store. Quick service with a smile. They carry an assortment of tires. When I need a tire replaced, I prefer to order an exact match from Tire Rack. They happily mount & balance it for me. For tire repairs they do a good job - not a shoddy patch job that I have experienced elsewhere. read more

Once again, the service at Atlantic was exceptional! Walked in with a vague "something's making noise" complaint about my car, and they diagnosed the trouble quickly & efficiently. Explained my options to me, including costs. Replaced 4 tires within an hour, with no appointment . Best thing- they never made me feel like "only a women" which so many other car places do! read more

Great place to have your vehicle serviced. They are honest people, not looking to "get you" like so many shops out there. Very reasonably priced among reputable competitors. Responses to inquiries are almost immediate. I've worked with lawyers who take longer to answer questions. Eddie is the point of contact through email and Lisa answers the phone. I would describe the communication as no nonsense, no BS, and to-the-point. Service speed is good. It took about an hour to replace two of my blown tires (due to the legendary NJ potholes). They honored the road hazard program without requiring me to produce the receipts. As a result, I ended up paying only installation for the tires. They don't have grandiose waiting areas like BMW repair shops do. They don't have loaner cars for you to drive when your car is in service. They don't even have free snacks laying around. If you are looking to be treated like royalty and are OK with subsidizing such treatment, look elsewhere. But if you are looking to get your car serviced/tires replaced efficiently at a reasonable price, look no further. read more

I own 2005 Ford Five Hundred SEL which is one of the heaviest in its categories.Was running on old tires.Was thinking to get tires from Wallmart or Costco etc , but didnt hear anything great about mechanics at those stores.So I discussed with Eddie & his team about my best options and he suggested me one of them & I moved ahead with that ..... Just now finished 500 miles test trip to DC and Amish village , so thought to write a review.I feel while driving on fresh sets I banked upon the knowledge,expertise & the confidence which these guys provided.So would recommend them for safe & confident trips.They did provide me road hazard protection ...but i wish never I should be in condition to use that :) Thanks guys !! read more

I would highly recommend this place to everyone. They got me out quick. It ended up that my tire was leaking from multiple spots. They ended up replacing the tire for cheap. Very happy with the service they provided. Will be back there again for sure. read more

I've been to Atlantic tire on a few occasions and they also give me great service the staff there is awesome ecspeclly APPLE the big guy I asked him a question while he was helping another customer, he didn't blow me off he said he'd check out m issue and did he also saved me a lot of money which at the time I didn't have these are a great bunch of people who work here and know there stuff I will recommend MY Freinds and family and anyone else's I know to shop here . read more