If you like a frozen cheesecake that's thick and heavy then this place is for you. They also have a sampler pack which you can try different flavors. All their cheesecakes are $33. They also have cookies in the front and other frozen goods in the freezer. This used to be my go to spot but the strawberry cheesecake really didn't hit the spot after it was defrosted. It was hard and the texture did not taste too fresh like it used to. Their cookies are still a great buy tho. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Strawberry Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

There is always one family member who whips up desserts, bakes the most delicious cookies, and kneads the most perfect bread. Additionally, this family member most times bakes without consulting a recipe. The ingredients are memorized or better yet she can produce these desserts from scratch. Boy, I wish I had this talent but I don't.. here's where Aunt Butchie's steps in. Aunt Butchie's baked goods are just delicious. I've had numerous varieties of their cookies: red velvet, chocolate chip, chocolate chunk cookie and double chocolate cookies. Of course, AB is known for her cheesecake cannolis, mini cheesecake cones and if you are undecided go for the Sampler Pie (Chocolate Mousse, NY Cheesecake, Mississippi Mud Pie,Carrot Cake). There is limited seating indoor and outdoors but of course bringing these baked treasures to family makes you want to run home and share it with them. The best is the "to go" fridges where you can take home all of the above and more! AB dream was to share their family desserts with neighborhood restaurants, a dream that Bay Ridgians are so happy they did! read more

See all

It was a frustrating morning. Rather than completing an appointment with a new Optometrist in Sunset Park, Waze told us "Heh... Not today, Janine" and we were directed to a random street in Carroll Gardens. FML. About face, forward march. Frustrated, pissed off and hungry, we pass by Aunt Butchies on the corner of 3rd and 83rd. Mmm... Sugarrrr. Nothing like some sweet carbohydrates to assuage an abundance of grievance. Absolutely adorable little shop. We asked the lovely young lady and gentlemen behind the counter what they recommended, as it was our first time visiting Aunt Butchies. They suggested the Cheesecake Cones, among a few other items. The container of cones were quickly snatched up out of the freezer case, while we asked for a few different cookies. They packed our items beautifully, we paid a very reasonable total for our items, and headed home. Heh... But a few of the items didn't make it home with us. We got in the car and attacked the bag of goodies. The Snickerdoodle cookie was consumed (with joy) within 2.6 seconds. The plastic box that held the Cheesecake Cones got yanked open. He took a small bite and handed me his cone so I could try it, too. I wolfed it down - whole thing. It was divine. The man had a Nutella Cookie that he said was so good, he'd trade me for another one. Five stars - No question. read more

This review is for their cheesecake cones. Oh my! I am a dessert person and this has to be one of the best desserts I've had. If you get one, make sure to leave it out for a bit as the filling can be way too cold. What I liked about the dessert is that the exterior shell was crunchy and it was not too sweet. A must! Recommended!! read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Cheesecake Cones - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I stopped in and picked up an order which included cookies like chocolate chips, red velvet, oatmeal raisins and brownies. Great tasting and fresh read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered three things and the store was out of one item. In addition to a refund for that one item, they also gave me several goodies on the house to apologize. Excellent service. Jaden is the best! read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Lovely note from Jaden (the employee). - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Picked up a cake sampler today for a birthday party, and it was a hit! The sampler had 16 slices (4 chocolate mousse, 2 white chocolate, 2 mud pie, 4 cheese cake, and 4 carrot cake) for only $32, which is great for its quality amd quantity. It comes frozen so they recommend to leave it out for 2 hours before serving. I tried the chocolate mousse, which was light, chocolatey, with a wonderful oreo crust, and the carrot cake was nice and moist. All of their cakes are sold pre-cut which is very convenient but sometimes I wished I can order a whole cake to present as a birthday cake. read more

My absolute favorite thing from Aunt Butchie's are their little cheesecake cones. I LOVE cheesecake...and having it come in the form of a cone is just perfect. Every time I come, I literally pick up 5-6 boxes that come with 8 cones per box, throw them in my freezer, and eat one cone a day as a treat for myself. It'll last me 3 months or so. Delicious...so rich...so good!!! Their cookies are also very good! Highly recommend to heat them up in your oven before eating. They just melt in your mouth. The staff are also very friendly! Love this place.. read more

Their chocolate mousse cake is so amazing, it's addicting. It's been my go-to cake for birthdays and celebrations. I also grab slices every now and then to satisfy my craving in between celebrations. This time, I tried their cookies. A lot of cookies tend to be too sweet for me, but these were great. I just had a slice of chocolate mousse cake two days ago, and writing this review is making me want to grab some more slices as soon as possible. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Chocolate chip and double chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I stopped by this bakery pretty late in the evening around 6:20 or 6:30 or so prior to going to Laila; an excellent Syrian restaurant a couple blocks away. I didn't notice the Cheesecake Cone, or else I likely would have gotten it, but instead as I just wanted a small snack, I got an Apple Caramel Cookie. As the place was soon closing, the friendly people there gave me two extra cookies. It was I think $4.95 after tax (unsure if they charge $4.50 when you pay cash) which was perfectly fine because of the size which was almost the size of a cookie from Levain but thinner and not nearly as heavy. The cookie was both not too sweet from the soft caramel and with plenty of apple flavor which had a mix of sweet and sour flavors. The dough had a good texture as well being not too soft or hard. It was in short excellent and I would recommend it pretty heavily. If I was in the area which I'm not even close to normally, I would stop here and buy cookies or cakes or other things but sadly, I don't live close. Really excellent cookie and I recommend others take the terrible R train or bus to go here. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Part of an outstanding apple caramel cookie. Large and soft. Not too sweet. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best cookies I've ever had. And I've tasted a lot of cookies. The perfect crumble to chew ratio. I've bought so many cookies here and they have more than just cookies. I dream about this place. Their desserts are made with so much love and the customer service shows it. The kindest people with wonderful sweets that made the hardest year I've had, practically melt away with the joy their cookies and desserts have brought me. And their tiramisu is so so creamy! read more

You see a name like Aunt Butchies Desserts and you think of a shop that is filled with desserts. You walk in and immediately you see a commercial freezer with frozen slices of cheesecake and a display with some cookies. Where is everything? Giving the benefit of the doubt I went with two frozen slices of cheesecake of which were very thin and $4 a slice! Wonder what the profit margin is for one whole cake?! The Slices tasted amazing but were rock hard frozen. Cakes and pies and everything dessert should be offered fresh. I have no idea how long these have been frozen for. There are plenty of bakeries nearby with fresh unfrozen desserts. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - presentation is everything - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They make the most delicious mouth-watering cookies right there at the store. There is a wide variety of cookies to choose from. Service at the store is top notch. read more

You offer gluten free items on your website yet nothing is available in your store. The salesperson only says you have cookies that are gluten free but according to your site it's not just cookies. You have chocolate chip cookies, chocolate mousse and chocolate chip ice cream sandwich. Which your salesperson had no idea about. Wasted trip. read more

This is my second visit here in a week. Great prices, quality, value and most important was the customer service. Came here just as they were closing and Autumn was AWESOME!! she is one of the best people I've met in any business. Friendly, caring, outgoing and really care about the customer and growing the business. I hope the owners read this and give her the recognition due. I highly recommend Aunt Butchie's, they care about you as the customer and do not put their bottom line before your happiness. read more

See all

A little underwhelmed. It was nice to try something new but the two items we tried were relatively standard fare. The customer service was top notch, though. read more

I also like the snickerdoodle cookies, rainbow cookies, and pistachio tartufo :) love this place

I cannot stop thinking about these PB&J cookies. Omg. They were insanely good and cannot wait to go back and get some more! read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - PB&J Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is known for there mouse cake. They do not take reservation, you have to call the same day to see if they have the cake in stock. You can buy a slice for $3.00. All the cake is frozen. The chocolate mouse cake taste extremely good when frozen. It taste like icecream. The Oreo cheese and peanut butter pie taste amazing! I would totally recommend anyone to come here to buy a cake. read more

See all

I got Aunt Butchies after writing a mouthwatering review in the wretched heat. It was as good as I remember. Quick Note: Nasto's does indeed make these tontoni, and probably the tartufo as well. It's their sliced spumoni specifically that I dislike, which is helpful to me as I will be getting these by the dozen. Just no variety packs as I'm spoiled on L&B Spumoni. This is the best ice cream treat you cam get at an unbeatable price. Great for an elegant patry or a solitary celebration. read more

See all

The Cheesecake Cone [$3.75] resembles a cannoli but it is so much more. It's a level up. The cheesecake is creamy and luscious, the cone is like the crust of a cheesecake but sticky and malleable, almost close to being candied. I can't get over it. Aunt Butchie's is a cute little shop, there's only one table inside and a few outside. The refrigerator case is stacked with cheesecake cones and other delightful desserts. I spied the chocolate mousse but it looked too big and indulgent for me to eat in one sitting today. LOL. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Individual Cheesecake Cone [$3.75] - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I tried their sampler cake and it's a great choice so that when you share it with others, they can choose what they like. The sampler cake has five different flavors. I like their cheesecake and chocolate mousse. The carrot cake is very healthy and not as sweet. I like the divider that they have in place, so it's easy to separate one slice from another and you don't need a knife to cut. Overall a great choice for birthdays and holidays. If you're planning a picnic, this might be the cake for you. read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Sampler Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been here a couple of times. Always to get the Tartufo. I buy it by the case. The absolute best. The chocolate shell is thick and rich. The ice cream....delicious. I met Frank the last time I was there. I was coming back from the VA. He thanked me for my service, a real gentleman. I'm gonna try the cheesecake rolls next. Love it. Thank you read more

Once in a while luck comes your way. I live right across the street from this Dessert Heaven and am grateful I won't have to travel far to pick up these ridiculously good treats. I've had several of their selections now and every one has been terrific. The ingredients are superb and the cakes, cookies, cannolis and cones taste fresh and amazing every time. You have to love the consistency you can count on. And if the food they are serving being great wasn't enough, the staff is cordial, professional and genuinely good people. The kind of folks you want to give your business to and have as part of your community. A wonderful addition to Bay Ridge. read more

No shortage of varieties here, that's for sure. I just wish they had some in a fridge rather than a freezer. Sometimes someone wants to eat it right there when craving but I had to wait until it thawed out. read more

The Aunt Butchie's location in Dyker Heights has a small retail operation. It appears that the bulk of their action comes from their wholesale operation. My wife is firm in that she states the they have the worlds best tartufo. For those who don't know tartufo has one large scoop of Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream with a raspberry jelly inside. Most Italian restaurants will have this as a dessert option. Everything is fresh there and ready to go. If traveling bring a cooler bag with you so the items will stay frozen for you to enjoy at home. There is no seating, no coffee, no tea etc. Pickup and go. There is a cafe style location on Staten Island that has a full menu. read more

The desserts from Aunt Butchie's are a family favorite and are always well-received at gatherings. I would recommend their sampler cake which offers a hodgepodge of different slices of cakes including (but not limited to) chocolate mousse, NY-style cheesecake, carrot cake, Mississippi Mud pie, tiramisu, white delight, etc. I'm quite partial to their individual tiramisu which they sell by the cup. Truly some of the fluffiest whipped mascarpone cream filling I've come across. I believe they have a larger space in Staten Island where you can dine-in but the Brooklyn location is takeaway only read more

Someone brought desert from this bakery to my job and I was shocked by how good it was. I had the carrot cake which was moist & delicious while the frosting is the perfect amount of smooth & sweet. Highly recommend! So so good. read more

I don't even want to admit how many cheesecake cones I went through by myself ‍. This place is absolutely incredible. A diabetic nightmare but in the best of ways. Support this business, you will have absolutely no regrets. read more

I'm disappointed because I came here to get cookies one evening and as I was eating the salted caramel cookies, I got down to the last bite and had lint in my mouth. Almost as if the cookie was dropped on the floor and put back on the tray. I ended up throwing all of the cookies out. I made a google review about this as well and was even more disappointed when I saw the owners response. Rather than apologizing for the inconvenience and taking accountability, they made it seem like I was lying. Yes, there was an apology but they also stated, "they would never pick something up off the floor and sell it to their valued customers". Where's the accountability here? So I'm just making stuff up and put the lint there myself? Come on now. I will never visit this place again. I never leave bad reviews but this was completely unacceptable and the response was no better. read more

Been meaning to try this place out, until a friend of mine bought a box over. Nice. She lives in the area and comes very often, it was certainly "on the way" when she came to visit, thanks Katie! The Sampler comes frozen with 16 slices of cake. Not sure if they're randomly put in, ours came with 4 slices of NY Cheesecake, 4 slices of Carrot Cake, 4 slices of their White Delight, 2 slices Mississippi Mud, and lastly, 2 slices of Chocolate Mousse Cake. The Carrot Cake would be my most favorite! Moist, fluffy, so comforting bite after bite, the frosting wasn't overly sweet either. Another good one that can't be missed is their Mississippi Mud, just decadent... I just wished there were more of those in the box as it only came in 2 slices. The White Delight was also a big hit, they were all delicious. Definitely recommend this place for your next party! read more

Aunt Butchie's Desserts - Sampler Cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Nice little boutique style frozen dessert place. Very pleasant staff. Didn't look like that 3 years back. It was a hole in wall that made you want to turn the other way when you got there.Their Cheesecake Cones are a must have, just as their other decadent desserts. The only problem is that they are frozen solid. They have a big see through freezer as you open the door to enter the establishment, and you can hardly see the beauty of the desserts. That is their downfall. Note to the owner: Turn the freezer temperature down and you will sell much more desserts! Do not expect to go there thinking that it's a bakery, it's not. If you're looking for a birthday cake the only thing you can look forward to, it won't be melted or smashed up when you get to your destination. I had the heat in my car at full blast and it didn't melt my goodies. Very nice place I would give them 5 stars, IF the desserts were ready to eat when you got there. read more

Their brownies are amazing. So so good. Disappointed with the chocolate mousse. Had a party. Defrosted the sampler about 40 min before serving. The mousse TOTALLY melted on the individual serving plates. There were many guests and it was ki d of embarrassing. ITF you wanted to eat it, you had to scoop it with a spoon. The other items were ok. The cheesecake was creamy, the carrot cake was good. Nothing so ..over the top Just good to .....maybe very good. read more

Order the chocolate mousse and thank me later! I'm so happy they moved to Bay Ridge - here's hoping they stay around for a while.

Sampler is a great idea, the lava cakes along with frozen cheesecake cones a must try!!! Mousse cake hands down the best!!!

Limoncello, chocolate mousse, Oreo cake, cheesecake cone all frozen in freezer. PBJ brownie thingy. read more

See all

They charge $3 a pop for a stale cookie yuck . Go to Leske's and get yourself a nice black and white cookie, way better!

If you can't decide whether to get cheesecake, brownie or chocolate mousse why don't you just get all ? The chaos slice has it all, top layer is chocolate mousse, the middle you have cheesecake and on the bottom you have brownie. It's an amazing combine. Their chocolate mousse is pretty rich !! read more

Very very good chocolate mousse indeed. Solid choice and really in our unanimous agreement the best piece of the sample cake for tonight's holiday party. The cheesecake would be my second favorite but it's not a close second. A close third would be the mudslide. The white chocolate and carrot cake were just ok. Price point is fantastic but perhaps Auntie has been a local fave for a decade too long and has not kept up with what boutique bakeries are doing these days- tons of butter, butter cream, fluffy airy chiffon cake and crepe that is most likely a result of all that butter and sugar is why places like milk bar and lady M can charge up the wazoo and people still stand in line. Still, id like to try their cannoli cones and definitely come back any time I'm craving a simple chocolate mousse cake. read more

One of the best chocolate mousse pies I've ever had! Thick, creamy, and light at the same time!! You can get it by the slice or in pie form! Amazing! read more