Delicious meal. Not fancy, just a quaint place to take your family for dinner any time. Weekends before 7 pm the place is packed. Reservations, unfortunately, only for a group of 6, I believe, so nothing else but wait for your turn. read more

My wife and I had not been here in a while. We started off with half dozen garlic knots with marinara and a small Greek salad. Then on to a 16-in your way pizza with pepperoni, sausage, garlic, extra cheese, and mushrooms. For dessert, my wife had a cannoli and I had the tiramisu. All excellent! Great service! We will be back very soon. read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - Half dozen garlic knots. - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

See all

We ordered some pizza and salad for dinner. Half pepperoni/peppers and mushrooms and a ceaser salad. Fresh and hot. Thin pizza. Awesome. Great take out. Service was great. Prices are reasonable. Atmosphere was fresh and amenities were clean. read more

Best pizza and service in the Sebastian area. Earls has good pizza as well but the atmosphere here and the food is always good. Salads is fresh with home made Italian dressing and house made croutons yum read more

I have to say they have the best wings and Pizza anywhere around. Very good salads, also. Enjoy!!

Party of 4, I asked if everyone was full? Yes they were. Myself included. This is my Pizza go to. First time going in and sitting down. Excellent service. It was good. Give it a go if ya haven't. read more

I have to start by saying, I AM a fan of Aunt Louise's pizza. However, I did a review in January 2024 questioning why they offer a lunch special that includes large slices of pizza until 3pm yet when we went, we were told there were no more slices for the lunch special. We happened to pop in for the lunch special on Sat. Jan. 18th at 2:00 pm. 2025. Can you guess what we were told when we went to order the sliced pizza lunch special? Again, the server told us "We are out of slices, and "he's" not going to make anymore." There was a full hour left until the lunch specials ended at 3:00 pm. I really, really don't understand this. You ARE a pizzeria... but you aren't going to make more pizza for your advertised lunch pizza slice specials? We were going to leave but had brought guests with us. We didn't want to order a full pizza, so 2 of us had to again select something else. Very disappointing. We heard another person in the booth behind us also request the sliced pizza lunch special only to be told the same thing. Please, MAKE the pizza so it is available through your advertised time. Don't be lazy about it. It won't go to waste. Also, it broke my heart when an older man with a cane with obvious back issues was offered seating at a front table. He asked if he could instead have a booth. The hostess told him booths are reserved for parties with 2 or more people. I watched him hobble over to the table, struggle with moving a chair out of the way to get seated at the table. Have a heart next time. The comfort of your guests is important. And what's worse? There were 3 open booths. I know we'll try again, but please can you try to get it right? 3 stars this time because of not having fixed the lunch special issue reported before (a year ago), and for inconsiderate accommodations for an older man with an obvious need for a booth. read more

We've been here a few times, the service is always good and the pizza is great. We want to try their other items on the menu but we are just drawn to pizza. Highly recommend this restaurant! read more

The food is delicious the sauce is homemade and the soup. The servers are always attentive and the ambiance is friendly and family friendly. I love the dishes and the pizza is my favorite read more

With out a doubt the most luscious Cheesiest Pizza we have ever had my family my 2 children devoured it.

Best pizza in Sebastian hands down. They run a specialty every Tuesday for their large cheese pizza. It's our family tradition. Recommend the lobster bisque when available. read more

Great little family style Italian restaurant. They don't have a bar but do serve beer and wine. read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - Menu - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

purchased a Sicilian pizza with sausage & pepperoni to the tune of $26, fyi worst pizza i have ever had!!! it was all bread, no sauce to speak of or to even taste. no chz, & the toppings looked like they had been picked out for a personal pizza. other guests have commented on how stingy they are.what a shame can't even get a decent pie in this town! read more

Good food and plenty. Nice staff can get busy. Good lunch specials. Nice place. Great pizza takeout

Went in a couple minutes before lunch ended and they still honored the special. We got the lunch specials with large slice and a drink/salad and it was delicious. Slices larger than our head with truly fresh ingredients and an incredible wood fire crust! We will be back! read more

The food was good with plentiful servings. Everything we tried was delicious. Service was great even with a shortage of help. It was fun to watch live footage of Venice while we ate. Lots of seating. A free birthday treat for the birthday girl was a nice touch. read more

Out of control tipping culture. I thought I'd try this for the first time and ordered online at their website for a pickup. Of course there is the usual asking for a tip in the process. If I don't sit down and get served, I don't tip. When I went in to pick it up, of course there is the big TIP jar on the counter. I give them my name to pick up the order. They turn and tell the kitchen staff the number. The kitchen staff walks three feet to hand it to the girl behind the desk. She hands it to me and says, we need to you sign this. It is bill for the food, with the price line filled in and a blank "tip" line with a blank total. I tell her I've already paid online, and she says she knows but I still need to sign. Three things here: 1. I don't need to sign anything - I've paid online and my card has been charged. 2. At best this is another to bully me into making a tip for a take-out 3. At worst, if I just sign and walk out, they can add whatever tip they want and I would have that charged to my card. I put ZERO on the tip line and matched the total to the food cost, and walked out. I should have called for a manager and gone over this with them, but I was too angry at this point to think of that. Even without this annoyance the food would only have rated a 2 star review. It was greasy and fairly tasteless. Lesson learned. They lost me as a future customer tonight. read more

My dine-in experience at the restaurant. Well decided on a day off a Monday to go in for 3pm, place wasn't super busy and was seated shortly after arriving. All good signs. Well as I sit and wait for my waitress with no menu, another gentleman comes in and is seated we are all being sat near the door oddly enough. So while I wait for the waitress I eye around the restaurant and it has a cozy feeling but man are things dusty a lot of surfaces has webs and slight dust build up. Not the kind you see on kitchen nightmares but enough that says august may be the last time anyone wiped things down. Now the waitress arrives and take the gentleman who came in after me orders first and attempts to leave when she realized I am there. (This is a good 10-15mins) well now I'm getting some where. She returns with my drink and service would be once much better. Ordered mozz sticks 5 for 8.50 seems steep but I can't tell if they are hand made or frozen. Breading was light which I like and why I wondered if handmade. Next I ordered a sausage calzone, and by god did I get one. Ate a 1/3 of it and took the rest home, also bought a small cheese because why not? I'm at a pizza spot that makes good pizza so I took that home for dinner and shared with my pops. All this and I was out the door for 44$ (38 + 6$ tip) would do it again maybe not. But I am definitely a fan of the food. The 3 star was for the restaurant itself inside not the food! Food is 5/5 this visit. read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - Sausage calzone. 3 - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

Don't go in expecting a pizzeria to have pizza by the slice. This guy tells me they don't sell pizza by the slice after 3. Is he serious? It's a pizzeria, it doesn't say Italian restaurant. Imagine Taco Bell or some other place telling you they their menu changes at 3pm.. that's pm meaning lunchtime read more

The best sauce in Sebastian, hands down. Pizza, pastas, garlic knots, with salads & dressing are the best tasting! The service is great. The place is nicely decorated. #1 in Sebastian for Italian restaurants! read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

This place is in a strip mall with a Publix next to the Goodwill thrift store. It seemed really popular so we stopped by, the food was OK. The garlic rolls were good. The pizzas were OK but expensive. The meatballs were good. So was the eggplant. But all in all the food was kind of average plus. I think I wanna try the other places in town before I come back. read more

Ordered a pesto pizza and added spinach & basil. So goooddddd!!!! The crust is perfect. We sat outside with breeze. Music was a wonderful surprise. Doesn't get much better. We will be back the next time we come to Sebastian. YUM!!! read more

I had calzone which was excellent... All the food was very good. Service was excellent.. The garlic knots were out of this.world .. If you get the pizza tell them to hold off on the parmesan cheese it's just too powerful and it takes over the taste of the pizza pie... Where I go back absolutely.. THEe sauce is fantastic.. read more

The food here was excellent! The pizza was especially good - fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked crust, and just the right amount of flavor. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. I'll be coming back for more. read more

Always the best! Whether pizza or entrees, eating here is a treat! This time I had the linguini with white clam sauce. Although I make this at home, having it from a professional is always good! The chef uses better and more olive oil which brings a nice rich flavor! She had gourmet Stromboli that never fails! Of course she takes half home and munches on it for the next day or so! Thanks for a great experience! read more

Strip mall Italian menu, all old school pasta. Pizza crust has nice char, slight yeasty aroma, good chew. Sauce was sweet, not overly garlicky. Topping's were fresh & generous. Crust brushed with garlic oil post-oven, not a bad touch. Not fancy, a lot of locals...huge portions with entree's. Clean with attentive staff. Definitely a good visit, very reasonable pricing. read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - House specialty - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

for over 10 years we have been eating here. We often stick to lasagna and Stromboli but we have had other things and can't ever remember a bad meal. Service has always been friendly and efficient. its always clean and for this time period prices are decent. Rollatini, eggplant parm , chicken parm, pasta with alfredo ( i get that as a side with my chicken in place of pasta and tomato sauce) are all very good. pizza is great also. And they have the best blue cheese dressing I have ever eaten. Its a very good restaurant. read more

Wings were very good. They were crispy and had an ample amount of meat and sauce but the pizza was really underwhelming and the cheese had no taste and there was only a minimal amount. It was very busy and the wait for take out was supposed to be 35 minutes but it was about 45-50 minutes. read more

Pizza is pizza. However, my family is picky and did not like the pizza. I enjoyed it because I just love all pizza. The garlic rolls were a little dry. It was a win for me because since they did not like the pizza I got to eat more pizza. read more

Service was excellent, nice , fast , kind. Restaurant was clean, nice. Food : we had the calzones and garlic knots. It look absolutely perfect. It was not like I expected, it just didn't have the flavor I was used too, from here. The garlic knots had little garlic flavor . Really disappointed. We only come once a year. Yes, we are tourists and normally it's good. This time not that great. read more

I absolutely treasure this family restaurant. The only suggestions I have are to improve the salad bowl quality (the cheap wooden bowls are depressing) and most importantly to improve the bread. The Garlic knots are sad and greasy. The toasted garlic bread is no better. Here are some pics of my suggestions. The quality needs to be improved. It should be served warm or room temp. With butter and olive oil. read more

See all

My wife & I go to Aunt Louisa's because, as other's have noted, it's the best in town. Not like NY Pizza, or Chicago style, it's its own thing. Pizza has its detractors and admirers, some will like it, others may not. But we love it. read more

Food and service are excellent! I Love the Chicken Parmigiana. My husband always gets a Stromboli,it's delicious. A cannoli for dessert makes for a yummy meal!! read more

We love the pizza here. We love the service. We also dined in and the service was fast and friendly. Food was delicious, hot, fresh gigantic portions. It's a very friendly fun family vibe. Gets busy. read more

Visiting my mom In Sebastian, we ventured here. So so good. Take away pizzas that were scrumptious. Try any really. I wish we had dined in as it was very nice fir a strip mall location. Had a very warm cozy crowded feel like any good Italian place. Yum read more

Pizza is a such a subjective thing. I drove here with one of those late night pizza cravings and wasn't disappointed. But I wasn't overwhelmed either. The pizza (16") seemed small, like a oversized personal pizza. The flavor was very good and it had a nice crispy crunch to it. In fairness, I did take out--so the 15 minute drive and a cooled down pizza has to be taken into consideration. I think It would've been much better to eat it there hot out of the oven. I also could not resist an order of garlic knots and a bowl of pasta fagoli. The garlic knots and marinara sauce were great. I was happy to see that the pasta fagoli was white instead of red and i am a big fan of white pasta fagoli but it lacked flavor and I think it was because they didn't use a smoked ham hock when they cooked it. That's what typically gives it that nice flavor. The patrons were mostly locals from Sebastian and Barefoot Bay. Salt of the earth types. All in it wasn't a bad experience, but will continue to search for better pizza close by. read more

Love Aunt Louise's their pizzas are awesome. The crust is perfect not to doughy slightly crispy and doesn't flop when picked up. Slices are nice size about a quarter of a pizza. Go with an appetite portions are large. read more

The food is very good, the veal parm sub , yum and don't for get the tiramisu. Pizza is best in Sebastian read more

Aunt Louise's Pizzeria - Us after we. Eat - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

Ordered pickup. Got the specialty pizza. Really yummy! Loved the garlic crust. Nice and crispy! Will definitely order from there again! Side note: The yelp app had the wrong directions.. took me off Main street after the railroad tracks. read more

We had takeout pizza from here and it was disappointing. I had heard good things about Aunt Louise's Specialty Pizza, but it was very mediocre. I had also heard that they put garlic butter on the edge of the crust, but I guess things have changed, because that wasn't the case with our sad pizza. The Greek Salad was good, though. read more