The Italian Cousin delivered on every plate. We ordered the lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs, calamari fritti, stuffed mushrooms or rollatini, and a caprese salad. Each dish came out well portioned and clearly made with care. The lasagna was the standout. Browned cheese on top, a rich tomato sauce underneath. The layers held together and the filling was seasoned properly. The spaghetti and meatballs were hearty. Three large meatballs, good sauce coverage, and a side of garlic bread that was worth eating on its own. The calamari was fried light and crispy, not greasy, served with a marinara dipping sauce and a lemon wedge. The caprese used fresh mozzarella with a balsamic glaze drizzle. Clean, simple, done right. The fries were a simple side, golden and hot. Service was attentive and the setting felt like a proper neighborhood Italian spot. Make a reservation. This place fills up fast and for good reason. We walked in as they opened and so many were coming in behind us. One side note, the sangria ran a bit bitter. Stick to wine or beer instead. read more

See all

Stopped for dinner tonight another awesome meal. I'm ordering my normal dish there which is the cheese manicotti and salad and bread and dipping oil and herbs. And of course, I got my cannolis to go with it. read more

See all

This has to be the best italian food i've ever had in my life, and I've been to Italy twice. Honestly, I will preface with the face that my partner and I did end up getting sick from the food BUTTTTT it was still so good i'd come back regardless. Our server was super nice as well, and the wine servings make you realllll happy haha. It's a dark cozy place that feels like you're in someone's living room. Definitely coming back! I live 2 hours away read more

See all

Meeting friends for a birthday dinner, and I am glad I was introduced to this restaurant. The ambience is quaint and fitting. They offer bar seating as well as hosting small parties. I found the menu limiting for vegetable dishes, but the flavor of my dish was good, and we enjoyed toasting to a wonderful person. read more

The Italian Cousin - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

Some of the best Italian food I've had in town th chef is amazing and the atmosphere is nice and calm and cozy. Great service even better food read more

The Italian Cousin - Beef bolognese the best in the world - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

See all

The last time that I went to this venue, I told myself that I would not return due to the price point relative to similar restaurants in the area. I should have stuck to my guns and not given it another try. We had the sausage bolognese special which was 26 and change. The food was ok but it was obvious that they poured hot bolognese sauce over pasta that had cooled. As a result, all of the pasta except for what was touching the hot sauce on the bottom was cold. The ricotta on top remained cold because it was sitting on cold pasta. Our server was mediocre at best. Her saving grace was the bus boy who worked hard getting drink and bread refills. This cold plate of pasta dinner for 2 cost $80.00 with a tip. I won't be returning nor would I recommend it. read more

The Italian Cousin - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

See all

We love this restaurant! Jim (I think) the bar tender makes excellent drinks and is exceedingly attentive. We ordered an appetizer, mussels, which we enjoyed very much. my husband ordered soup. I ordered the special meal which included a salad. I said we were going to split it. The waitress said that there was a seven $7.50 charge for splitting. I said we don't need an extra plate. She said she would put it into the kitchen and see what happened. We were charged and that is exactly what we got an extra plate. The kitchen did not divide the meals on the two plates. Next time I will not tell her that we are sharing we will just share. $7.50 is pretty steep for an empty plate and no service. Still love this restaurant still love that bartender we will be back. We just know to order differently. We ordered a special which came with a choice of risotto or pasta. The waitress did not ask which we would prefer. I forgot to tell her that we would prefer pasta. It came with the risotto. I think this waitress could've thought outside the box and did not need to say we were splitting our meals since we had ordered plenty of other food in addition to the one main course. She also should've asked which side we preferred. We were not happy with this waitress. read more

Good italian food in a cute spot with minimal seating and parking that stays busy...staff is amazing and attentive ..ate here twice-once with a large group from work and it was delicious but pricey for what i got ..portobello mushroom appetizer, tomato bisque soup and limoncello cake was over $40 with only a sweet tea as my drink..they charge extra for large parties and using credit cards...returned with family and had chicken parm and spaghetti and linguine and clams with excellent bread and salads ...had some pretty amazing specials too....will definitely return! read more

See all

I have been to this restaurant many times and had nothing but good things to say about it. But that changed!!! The hostess ,who I have now found out is the owner was the rudest person I have ever dealt with in a restaurant. She needs to look up the definition of hospitality!!!!! Friendly of guests!!! Beware if you don't have a reservation, a simple sorry I can't seat you tonight but she be became manic! I'll miss their good food but will not return. read more

The owner of the restaurant, Michelle & Guz are the sweetest! This place is our favorite to go to when we're craving Italian food! Always got the Candoni Mascato, perfect pair with my clams pasta. The kale soup & the tomato soup are best! Super recommended 100% read more

See all

Great Italian restaurant ! Fresh food, nice owners, groups are well taken care of. Love the service too. read more

Good food, friendly and attentive wait staff, cozy, and excellent weekly specials - also, they take reservations for 2+ people!!

Food is enjoyable and service prompt. Setting is modest and clean. Parking can be limited. Be sure to make reservation for supper. Recommend read more

This is an outstanding restaurant. Excellent food, excellent service, friendly staff and owners, we were in a party of 18 and they accommodated us with reservations and fast turnaround with our orders. I Highly recommend this place! I am visiting from Sarasota and will be back next time I'm here in Sebastian. read more

Service is speedy and friendly. The food is awesome and atmosphere is good. We will definitely be back next winter! read more

The Italian Cousin - Awesome sausage and pepper gnocchi. Had to come back the second time for it. - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

Foos was fantastic..service was outstanding and prices were very reasonable! You could tell that everything was homemade and fresh. Ambiance was wonderful as well. read more

Food is the best in Sebastian. Our waiter was awesome. I would highly recommend if you're in Sebastian. Best Italian food in town. Veal Marsala the best. read more

We caught a quick dinner on the early bird special at the Italian cousins in Sebastian. What a wonderful restaurant our waiter Jim was wonderful. He made some suggestions and we got our meal. It started with soup and a glass of wine. We both got pasta and we're very happy with it and had enough to take home for lunch. The Owner Gus stopped by our table and was very friendly and you could tell he loved his restaurant even the bus boy Matthew was helpful and so nice. This is a must if you're out in the area in Sebastian for Italian food. read more

I loved this Resturant until I tried to go there the other day and was treated very badly by the person who was greeting you as you walked in. I was with two other woman. I approached the Receptionist and the first thing she asked us if we had a reservation. I told her no and she immediately raised her voice to us and said that it was a reservation place and she pulled three business cards out and handed them to us. I said we would be happy to sit at the bar if that is available. She raised her voice again and said that she is doing something and we needed to wait. S he proceeded to talk on the phone and to one of the workers. Every time we asked a questions she screamed at us. Then she accused us of being rude. She yell again and told us to get out. She told us to tell our family not to come in either. The people around us were in shock listening to her. I have been going to that Resturant every time I am in Florida. Me and my friends left there shaking. I find out later that the woman was the owner. I have never been treated like that. This person really must have been having a bad day. She should not be the one greeting the people. Keep her in the kitchen away from people. I still cannot believe that she talked to us that way especially that she is the owner. read more

I've been going here for years and I just love the fool and atmosphere. The wait staff are very friendly and eager to help. But a little pricie. read more

Great food. Wonderful service. Huge entree portions. Really loved the olive oil with spices and herbs with bread at the beginning of the meal. We had olive oil pasta, the potato gnocchi and fettuccine Alfredo; all were excellent. It's great food and a great value. The food ingredients are also top quality. The pasta was high quality and perfectly cooked. Expect to have left overs. read more

The Italian Cousin - Inside - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

What a great experience! Grace our server was excellent! The salad dressing was delicious and the food was fantastic! Completed with the crispy crust bread it was a win! Only suggestion is the drink could have come out a little before the meal and that would have been even more enjoyable and maybe could have had another. read more

Great friendly staff! Awesome service! AMAZING FOOD! Great Local Family restaurant! The Chef-Owner came out and greeted us. I thought I went back to the 50s. I will return again and again!!!! read more

I've now been to The Italian Cousin twice in a the last month. Both experiences were great. The service is excellent, friendly and knowledgeable. It's larger than it seems at first, because there are two separate seating areas, which gives it a nice, intimate feel, while also having plenty of room for walk ins. It is probably a good idea to make a reservation on a Friday or Saturday night though, just to be sure you won't be waiting on a table. At seating, they provide a mixture of olive oil, basil and parmesan cheese, with a basket of bread. Both of these are delicious, and for the person who doesn't have a huge appetite, it would be easy to fill up on the bread and spread. Fortunately, that's not an issue for me, and I could honestly make a lunch of this alone. My table shared the mozzarella caprese on the first visit, and that was delicious. The tomatoes are clearly fresh, the roasted peppers are high quality, as is the mozzarella and the dressing. On both visits, I've had the fried calamari appetizer, which is cooked perfectly. The breading is delicious, with a very slight tinge of spice to it. The marinara served with it is also delicious, thick enough to stick to the calamari, not watery or thin as is too often the case in lesser Italian restaurants. On my first visit I had the linguini with white clam sauce as an entree. It was excellent. The clams were perfectly cooked, so as to be open and not undercooked, but not rubbery. The pasta was also perfectly cooked, not boiled to mush as is too often the case in restaurants. The sauce itself was full of a nicely layered flavor. It's a great mixture of garlic, white wine and a light touch with the parsley and a few other spices. On my second visit, I decided that because the white previous meal had been so good, I would try to Veal Marsala. I'm honestly a little picky about Marsala. It's something I love when it's made well, but is a big disappointment when it's not. This was among the best Veal Marsala I've had that wasn't served in my great grandmother's kitchen. The veal was perfectly prepared, the sauce was balanced, without the wine so overpowering the dish as to negate the other flavors. The balance of flavor with the sauce, the mushrooms and the veal was delightful. The flavor of the mushrooms suggests they're not using cheap, bottom of the barrel ingredients either. Prices are a bit higher than the local pizza joints, but the quality of the food justifies it. These are people who obviously care about the quality of their food and service, and do a great job of keeping a step above what the majority of the other restaurants in Sebastian are offering. read more

Amazing food, amazing service, wonderful drinks and especially margaritas, classic authentic Italian food, no nonsense!

Italian sausage with peppers over with pasta and chicken Parm. Salads were really good and we also had dessert. Prices were reasonable. We had sangria which was the worst part of the meal. I'm fussy a about chicken Parma because some bad restaurants just take a pre-made patty, throw sauce and cheese on it and broil it. Nasty. I couldn't tell if this was premade patty but it was good. The place is very busy so go during the week. read more

My wife wanted to try a different place for her birthday and selected the Italian Cousin in Sebastian. A little drive from our place in Melbourne Beach but worth it. After being seated our server, Catalena, started our dining experience. Choice of wine was a bottle of Montepullciano d bruzzo. A light and dry red, very good. For the appetizer we had stuffed clams and they are delicious.We both had the chopped salad with our entrees. Fresh with a light dressing. My wife ordered linguine and clams in a white wine sauce that's her go to when rating an Italian restaurant. Fresh pasta and loaded with clams. She told me it was some of the best she's had. I selected lasagna with a side of meatballs. Again made with fresh pasta and cheeses. Meatballs are very good. We had leftovers as the servings are generous. For our desserts I had tiramisu and the wife had cheesecake. Both excellent. Accompanied with espresso with a shot of anisette and our meal was complete. Excellent service from all the staff. Definitely worth the trip! read more

I discover that place on 2019 and the smell saying it all when you enter the place. And after comes the test and for sure you know these Italian food is special. The service is great and some how the ambiance will take you to the God Father's days. read more

The food here is incredibly delicious. I enjoyed the wine, Tomato Basil soup, Italian bread, rigatoni bolognese- all wonderful. We capped off our dinners with the Lemoncello cake and Tiramisu with coffee. Our servers were attentive and did a great job with making our night out more enjoyable. This restaurant is a must if you are in the area. read more

We made a reservation & waited 5-10 minutes to be seated. Food was exquisite. Loved everything we had including caprese salad, the bread /dipping oil, & spaghetti and meatballs were all delicious. Our server didn't let us know there was an added gratuity for bigger parties. I would recommend to the server to just let the table know in advance next time/add it to the hostess stand so customer knows. The restaurant itself reminds me of an Italian place and it gives a very homey feeling. I would return! read more

Food-Outstanding! Service was great (ty Valerie) Ambiance was rustic but quaint Highly recommend! As visitors from the North we highly recommend! read more

Just love everything about how wonderful this place is we go for so many special occasions

Ambiance! Tiny...definitely make reservations Extensive wine list & menu, very reasonably priced. Good staff, owner frequents tables. Top 5 Italian on space coast read more

Unbelievable food and service. What a wonderful surprise. We had never been to this area and found good reviews. Thank you souvh read more

The Italian Cousin - Italian Near Me - Sebastian, Florida

It seemed a bit pricey. No doubt, the food was well prepared and was delicious. You get what you pay for. The service was excellent... read more

I recommend this restaurant for everyone and Sebastian and out-of-towners. The atmosphere is wonderful and they really go all out for their customers and new ones too They have many dishes on the menu. I wish I can eat them all. That's how good they are service is excellent and the ambience you will fall in love with. read more

It was my first time to the Italian cousin. There were 4 adults and two children. Three of us got the early bird special and one ordered from the regular menu. I totally enjoyed my chicken parm that was served with fresh , warm Italian bread and linguini. Everyone enjoyed their meal and we all agreed to return again. Service was excellent . The price for the early bird specials were all the same and reasonably Priced. read more

Mediocre at best Italian restaurant. I had chicken Parmesan and the chicken was not pounded flat the pasta was over cooked and the sauce tasted like it was canned. The restaurant is also small and guest next to us felt on top of us Will not be going back. read more

Great service; great food. A variety of really good Italian dishes. Cute family run place. A must when in Vero.

The homie atmosphere and attentive service staff make this restaurant a wonderful place and we haven't even mentioned the food. If you love Italian cusine, well made and in generous portions this is the place for you. Great place to celebrate a special occasion or to just treat yourself to a wonderful night out. I highly recommend the Italian Cousin. read more