Bagel Art Cafe

Northwestern Graduation Cake !!! My daughter graduated this month from Northwestern and I found…read moreBennisons on Yelp . They truly made it easy for me to order her customer grad cake remotely . We chose a white cake with lemon curd filling and butter cream icing . They had the Northwestern purple and cap to match ! Great deal and everyone absolutely loved it. Customer services was amazing and awesome !! We will be back :)

I got this custard filled cruffin from the Roger's park farmers market. It was absolutely delicious…read moreand the perfect handheld food for a market. The edges were super flaky and the custard was creamy. The staff was super nice showing us everything they had despite having a pretty busy line. I would definitely check out their Evanston location in the future.

Bennison's Bakery.(Davis St/Maple Ave Evenston IL) Bakery Cakes Cookies Croissants Macarons Great Sandwiches Coffee etc .Cool!

See all

Valentines @ Bennison's Bakery .Evenston IL Bakery Cakes Cookies Croissants Macarons Great Sandwiches Breads Coffee etc .Cool!

Patisserie Coralie

3.9(315 reviews)

0.3 mi

Wonderful ham and cheese croissant kissed with just enough bechamel to make the whole thing melt in…read moreyour mouth...and a pretty darn good capuchino, too.

Came in looking for a sweet. Saw the chocolate raspberry in the case and could not resist. I also…read moregot the gluten free chocolate cookie filled with cream, chocolate chip cookie and coffee. I had no intention of eating all three at the same time. Loved the top two layers of the raspberry dessert. Would have preferred the bottom to be soft vs the chocolate crunch. In fact, it was so hard I could barely get my fork through. I took a bite of the double chocolate gluten free cookie. Kind of like a shortbread cookie with filling. Not much to say about this. I like gluten. A chocolate chip cookie. Not a tough one. It was dry and I swear it was sitting in that jar for 4 days. Total bummer. I threw it away. The piece of cake and coffee came right away to counter. I sat down. Then about 5 minutes passed and my two cookies just showed up. I went back up to ask the guy at counter for them. Wouldn't you think he could have brought to me since it was not busy and he made me wait or maybe just forgot about me. It is time to repaint and tidy up. As for the baked goods. Needs a major step up to make it. If I can't get a chocolate chip cookie that I would eat. Total loss. I pride myself of being positive for reviews. I just can't with this one.

Tomato and mozzarella quiche

Napoleon

See all

Cupitol Coffee & Eatery

4.1(654 reviews)

0.3 mi

Great place for a nice brunch with friends! Very hide inside with seating options as there are…read morecouches on the side for those that jut wanna place to chill with a coffee and read a book or table tops on the main dining area. Went there this past Saturday with friends and glad that we got there when we did because the line just kept growing lol. I got the Sweet Potato bowl and added some smoked salmon to it and did not regret my choice at all. Flavorful, healthy yet, satisfying. And the pastry display caught my attention (as it always does anywhere I go) so just had to snag their newer item...the Walnut Chocolate Chip Banana bread which was a nice way to end this brunch. This is going to be a nice go-to brunch spot in downtown Evanston for me...and apparently the rest of Evanston from what I saw lol. Popular spot and I see why. Great location, great food and great ambiance.

A great place in Evanston to grab a quick breakfast, catch up with friends n family, and grab a…read morecoffee. They've got a great system here, and it's efficient and appreciated. I'm a drip. A drip coffee drinker! And a refill here is free, yay. I like a healthy breakfast and there's plenty of that, and also sweet French toast options. Today I had the No. 5 Breakfast Sandwich and I would just like to see the breakfast sandwiches on a bagel instead of a croissant. Lots of seating from tables, to casual comfy chairs, gives great options. Outdoor seating, as well. Is Cupitol a chain? It should be!

Seating

See all

Coffee

Hewn Bakery

4.3(366 reviews)

1.8 mi

I am thrilled that hewn has such success. This morning around 9 AM I went to get a piece of quiche…read more They were sold out again, for the third time in a row. I inquired of staff that if they're always sold out why they don't just make more With attitude she said to me "well we always sell out at seven in the morning." I was then informed, that if they made more, they would just sell out at 7 AM anyhow, and that I should show up before 7 AM to get in line before they open. If you regularly run out of a product, a smart business person would make more. Overall, when I've had them their products are good. The breads and pastries are awesome However, the snarky attitude from the staff is unacceptable. I will definitely minimize the number of times I come to the store because of their frequent morning stockouts on products.

Love me a good cafe/bakery!…read more Going in there had a line and the line didn't particular take too long. It seemed like they ran out a lot of their fresh bakery items, but there still was a lot to choose from. My friend bought a sourdough loaf & it was gorgeous! We didn't get to try it, but it looked good. I bought a chocolate chip cookie, 1 chocolate croissant, 1 plain croissant, 1 ham and cheese croissant, no pics listed below. - Their croissants are honestly really good, crispy and flaky. - The chocolate chip cookie was like a generic chocolate cookie, nothing rly special about it. Also bought their brioche sandwich and I think it's overpriced for what it's worth. I think it had like their signature jam or something on it with a egg & bacon, it was $12. It's a tad bit pricy for something so basic. Overall, their service was fast. Their employees were nice and their ambiance was fun. I love me some fresh baked goods. I'd go back for more croissants!

Inside of Cheddar Chive Scone ($4.15) - it's OK. Doesn't have a very strong cheddar or chive flavor.

See all

Inside of Caramelized Onion Rye ($8.25) - good but not amazing. Less flavorful than expected.

Sugar & Spice Extraordinary Sweet Treats

4.1(7 reviews)

1.2 mi

Sugar & Spice makes some of the greatest cookies known to man. Huge, soft cookies with just the…read moreslightest bit of crispiness along the edges. You might have actually eaten some of their creations without realizing it - they are the cookie supplier to Intelligentsia coffee shops! When I was in college we used to have a pre-finals week dorm event where everyone would gather in the common room to enjoy a big glass of milk and Sugar & Spice cookies - a delicious bit of comfort before the harsh reality of finals week set in. Oh, how I miss those days! I am partial to the M&M and the Double Chocolate varieties. Intelligentsia currently does not carry the chocolate ones but perhaps if enough people read this review and make the suggestion to management, we can bring about a cookie revolution. I promise it will be well worth the effort. If you visit their website, they have a bunch of gift options available, too. I know I certainly wouldn't object if someone bought me a box of cookies or brownies! ;)

After becoming a recurring visitor to Backlot Coffee - Evanston for their excellent coffee, I…read morestarted adding an addictive "vegan morning scone" to my tab. Saw someone deliver a fresh batch midday one time, thus finally figuring out that Sugar & Spice makes these scones which have reset my expectations for scones. Now have to-do list item to visit Sugar & Spice's bakery.

Sweet Temptations Bake Shop

4.7(80 reviews)

1.5 mi

Thank you to the staff who was able to place my graduation cake order. I thought l had to reserve…read moreit 24 hr in advance. We got the 8" chocolate marble cake and boy was it delicious and not super sweet ! Thank you again !

Awesome service! Needed a last minute cake for a graduation and called same day to ask if they…read morecould hold a cake but the staff who answered the call said they had plenty to choose from so we stopped in on the way to graduation to select and personalize a cake (chocolate marble cake) and paid for it to pick up a few hours later. After graduation we picked it up and headed home to celebrate our grad and when we opened the box we were all so excited and delighted to not only see the nice lettering but also that they had adorned the cake with a grad cap...what a nice touch! AND it gets even better...the taste of the cake was delicious!

See all

Newport Coffee House

4.5(127 reviews)

0.3 mi

Please bring back the old version of COCO BREW. I'm begging…read more I've been a regular since they first opened a few years ago, I think around 2019? Their Coco Brew used to be one of my absolute favorite coffee drinks for years, up until recently. I'm not exactly sure when the recipe changed, because as far as I remember it still tasted the same through 2025. I've been busy this year and haven't come as often, but the last three times I ordered it, it was completely different. And since it was made by different baristas, I'm assuming this is a recipe change rather than just inconsistency. (Check the photos to see the differences!) The old version was much lighter, mildly sweet, and had that lovely coconut milk aroma. It tasted fresh, smooth, and really balanced. The new version is totally different. The first thing I noticed was the color. It's way darker now. And the taste matches: darker, more sour, and with a strange almost medicinal aftertaste (reminded of some cough medicine..) The gentle sweetness and mildness are completely gone. Now it somehow tastes strong, sour, and watery at the same time. What happened?? Please don't change something that was already so good. Even the ice seems different now. It used to have smaller ice pieces that filled the cup more evenly and let the liquid move through, so you got that really pretty layered look with the coconut milk and cold brew. Now it's large chunks of ice just floating on top. Anyway, this is just my little heartbreak over a drink that used to be so beautiful and delightful. Other than that, the vibe is still nice as usual, maybe a bit more crowded than before. The decor is still cute, and I've always liked the woody interior. It's also one of the brighter coffee shops in Evanston, with really nice natural light.

Love this bright, clean, and professional coffee spot! Plenty of free parking with a large lot…read moreattached, which makes stopping by super easy. The baked goods are incredible, and the baristas are friendly and easy to chat with. Lattes are beautifully made, and I really appreciate the care put into the latte art. A great place for quality coffee with a welcoming vibe.

Indoor vibe

Bar area and tables

See all

Maple latter and avocado toast

Insomnia Cookies

3.3(69 reviews)

0.6 mi

Perfect option if you're craving milk and a cookie. And if you're vegan. Love the vegan choices and…read morethe single-serving vegan milk to go with the soft, gooey cookie. Would love it even more if they expanded their vegan selection. Points for handling their own deliveries rather than going through certain delivery apps which shall remain nameless (but which have more miscues than successful deliveries).

I placed two separate orders to the tune of roughly $200. One order was 5 dozen assorted cookies I…read moreplanned to bring to my office that regularly supplies food and likes to support local businesses. The second order was a 9 pack specifically for my wife's birthday. When I went to pick the cookies up I was given 4 boxes each with an individual receipt attached which I imagined was the contents. I took the cookies and dropped off all of them in our break room except the box with the receipt for the separate order for my wife's birthday which listed her cookies. My office loved the cookies a they were gone within a couple hours. Unfortunately when I got home and opened the box showing my wife's cookies it did not contain a single cookie she eats. The separate orders had been combined and the receipts did not correctly reflect the contents of the two orders. Sadly her disappointment was visible. I went out of my way the next day to go back and purchase a new box of cookies with what she had wanted. I detailed this on the order form through the app and was told I would hear from someone in 48 hours. Well past that now I have heard from no one. Check your boxes and your orders before you leave!!!

See all

Cookie A La Mode

Tag's Bakery - Evanston

3.9(126 reviews)

1.9 mi

Another Too Good to Go. I'll have to go back and try other items from here. For this deal, we…read morereceived half of a small white cake with floral frosting. It was only $3.99 and honestly it was perfect for a little treat for my family to share on a random weekday.

Requested a car design for my 3&5 year old grandsons birthday. They were very helpful with…read morerecommendations and design. Yellow cake layered with strawberry buttercream. It was moist and delicious! Everyone loved it!! Thank you Tags

So happy with the results of this cake! Delicious butter cream filled with strawberry buttercream. Thank you Tags!!

See all

Panaderia Evita

4.7(17 reviews)

2.3 mi•Rogers Park

Note: Cash Only I…read morewas so excited to try Panaderia Evita, I put it on my calendar to not forget. While they have some things going for them, the experience ended up falling a little below expectations. Walking in, you're greeted by the smell of fresh baked goods. The setup is similar to Paris Baguette where you grab a pair of tongs and a tray, and then grab anything you want. Therein lies complaint #1: Other than small price stickers that some amy needs reading glasses for, there are no labels of any kind as to what it what. I can recognize a donut (at least I think so), but with the rest, I couldn't even tell if they were sweet or savory. I grabbed three different pastries, including one that was recommended by the clerk. With half an exception, the feedback is generally the same. This is complaint #2: Except for the one that had a softer, yellower center, the dough was firm with very little give. There's nothing wrong with a little crispness, but in this case, there wasn't much (if any) flakiness. With all of this said, while I am open to returning and trying some more items, I don't see myself breaking down the door to come back or recommending this spot to friends and family.

Panaderia Evita is a true hidden gem in the neighborhood!…read more Panaderia Evita is the type of bakery that if you walked too fast you would miss it. I came across Panaderia Evita during a random walk through Rodgers Park and I'm so happy I stop in that day. The staff is friendly and always speaks when I visit. The inside is spacious and clean not much investment into the decor but the food makes up for it. There are a ton of bakeries along the same block but the pastries from Panaderia Evita stand out from the rest. The homemade donuts are unbelievable! Pastries from the sugar donuts to the Conchas are so sweet and fluffy. I have yet to have a bad pastry from Panaderia Evita! I highly recommend trying the donuts because they're so fluffy and test so fresh. I haven't had a fresh donut like the ones at Panaderia Evita even at places dedicated to donuts.

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

23 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Patricia B.

12 years ago

I've always loved this place -- first in their old location on Chicago Avenue, and now in their new(ish) Dempster location -- but I've never taken the time to write a review for some reason. The bagels are always fantastic, as is the service. I just placed an order through GrubHub and the delivery was so fast it boggles the mind -- 16 minutes from the time I placed the order to the time the smiling delivery guy was handing me the bag. Unbelievable! For both food and service, with a great eat-in atmosphere thrown in for good measure, you can't go wrong with Bagel Art. read more

chrissy p.

18 years ago

Okay, so initially I really liked this place, especially since I chronically wake up on Sunday mornings with no food in the house and need a quick breakfast fix. But lately I guess hoards of Evanston-ites have gotten there before me so I am left with the scraggly bagel that nobody else wanted. I know that they can't really expect whole baseball teams coming in looking for bagels, but to be left with an egg bagel on a Sunday when hung over is not a good thing. read more

Luigi B.

17 years ago

File my review under the "overpriced bagels with douchebag service" heading like several of the reviews below. Honestly I'm surprised this twatty little dive is still open. Look, I didn't force you at gunpoint to get a job where you glob some cream cheese on a bagel and cut it in half. And non-toasted bagels that feel like their toasted and taste like they're burnt...save your money and go elsewhere. They're too cool to care anyway... read more

Beth K.

10 years ago

This place is great! Lots of varied options for bagels, as well as sandwiches and some salads. Great coffee as well! The café is clean and well-decorated, and the service is amazing. Bagel Art was generous and donated 2 dozen bagels to a student film set I was working on, and helped get us through a tough early morning. Thank you! read more

Max D.

16 years ago

Great stuff! The new location looks great and has much more space, both seating and space at the counter. All the old favorites are back plus they now have awesome pizza bialeys. A must try if you havent, I recommend the Roccoco, Medieval, or Tuscany! read more

Lily L.

303

9 years ago

Bagel Art donated an assortment of bagels and spreads to our Northwestern student film production the weekend of 11/17-11/19. The bagels were great, and kept everyone fueled during our long day of filming. Thanks, Bagel Art! read more

Jonathan D.

9 years ago

Bagel Art kindly donated food to a student film production I worked on. The bagels were great and helped us get through the long days of filming. Thanks for the donation! read more

James L.

3 years ago

Excellent bagels and community service all around -- lots to appreciate about the food they provide! Overall, an easy recommendation to anyone in the area. read more

Judith R.

10 years ago

Bagels are very tasty and atmosphere is wonderful! Shop smells great and plenty of natural light. Great place to hang out and eat! Owner is super nice read more

Mary J.

10 years ago

Bagel art is a great spot -- warm and inviting atmosphere, good coffee and I love their breakfast bagels. Great place to grab a quick bite to eat. read more

Lesley E.

10 years ago

Has very good bagels and cream cheese! Also the people are super kind and awesome! I always loved bagels and these bagels are really excellent! read more

Taylor J.

10 years ago

So welcoming and friendly. Interactive staff, kinda feels like I'm home. Great sandwiches, and cookies that melt in your mouth!

Daniel D.

9 years ago

Love this place. Great coffee; delicious bagels and sandwiches; cool atmosphere. Can't recommend this spot enough.

Sally W.

9 years ago

Yay! It's back the way I like it except for the newspapers. Thank you!!!!! Thanks for listening!!!

Agustin M.

2 years ago

I love Bagel Art!!! It is so good!!! Best bagels Ever!!! - Agustin, director of Me and I

Bianca H.

14 years ago

The bagels are handmade and absolutely delicious even the next day after being left out.

Mia B.

3 years ago

They have great service and amazing bagels! Always a good experience. Would recommend!

Terry C.

19 years ago

Great sandwiches. Close to where I live. Homemade soups. Like it's not corporate.

Sofía S.

10 years ago

Great bagels and the chive cream cheese spread is excellent! Nice people too.

Joy K.

10 years ago

Good customer service, friendly and accomodating - would strongly recommend

Bagel Art Cafe - bakeries - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Bagel Art Cafe also viewed

Lefty’s Righteous Bagels

4.0

(78 reviews)

Yum! Honestly Lefty's only real downside is cost, with every sandwich running you at least fifteen…read moredollars. But the service is always friendly and pretty quick, and the store has been immaculately clean every time I've been there so despite the cost, as you can see, I've been back several times because they ARE really good handmade bagels. I've tried a different bagel every time for my sandwiches - I will say the Rosemary Pink Salt was a little TOO salty for my tastes, but the Garlic and Onion was killer. I'll be back!

We've been wanting to try Montreal style bagels for a few years, but it's never been convenient for…read moreme to stop somewhere to get them (actually, the only somewhere I knew they actually had them). Lefty's opened in Evanston last year so I stopped by today and picked up a dozen. They're delicious. And their flavors are great. I got: pink salt & rosemary, plain, cheddar, sesame, garlic & onion, everything, and giardinera. That's right, they have a giardinera bagel! I haven't tried mine yet but my partner did and said it's excellent. They have several cream cheese blends as well. I picked up the jalapeño, which wasn't too spicy (today at least), and I also got a small one of the lemon and dill to give it a try. My toddler loved the lemon and dill. Parking is street only. I'll be back!

New York Bagel & Bialy

4.4

(207 reviews)

Best bagels in Chicagoland are here in Skokie. Old school mom & pop ambience. Great prices great…read morebagels & bialys

Check out. text door NY Bagel & Bialy ! It's become a fact that your bagels are disappointing to…read moremany at numerous locations . I complained months ago because our cinnamon raisin bagels had 0-3 raisins and very little cinnamon . It seemed to be better but last dozen we had had brown bits of something : cut up raisin pieces ? , poor flavor and were tough It's not been good . Where going on here ?

New York Bagel & Bialy

4.2

(773 reviews)

Let me tell ya', Dhally. The Poppy Seed & Salt bagel with a schmear is "to die for". If you want a…read moremid-day treat, tha Lox Sandwich can't be beat, as well!

Lots of downfalls upon my visit here…read more Most importantly, stale bagels. I ordered two breakfast bagels (egg, cheese, sausage), a plain bagel with cream cheese, and a lox bagel and two mini plain bagels for my kids. Not one person enjoyed their bagel. It was extra chewy, dry, and absolutely tasteless. The lox was forgettable. The cream cheese was good, but that was it. Add on a very long wait time for a line that wasn't very long and less than friendly service and that leads to this low review. The only perk was the parking lot and arriving early on a Wednesday left ample parking. Will definitely try out another option next time we want bagels.

Kneads & Wants Artisan Bakery

4.4

(118 reviews)

Disappointed to see the chicken and waffle sandwich no longer on the menu because I never got a…read morechance to try it. That being said, I tried The Madison, which is described as such: Neuske's bacon, creamy boursin, sharp cheddar, and a souffléd egg paired with fresh tomato, red onion, and arugula, all layered on warm ciabatta. I really liked it! I had never had boursin (a type of spreadable cheese) before. All the flavors melded well together, although I didn't like the texture of the arugula so I removed that after a few bites. Would definitely order that sandwich again. My husband had the Steak & Egg sandwich which he said was good but I didn't care for the flavor combo. It is described as such: Tender roast beef, melted American cheese, and caramelized onions layered with a souffléd egg on a toasted ciabatta. It's interesting in the picture it shows a waffle instead of ciabatta. I guess they got rid of the waffles altogether? They should probably update the sandwich photo is that's the case. Visited: 7/25/26

We did go in for a 6 PM dinner of sandwiches and we were hoping for snacks and such. We ordered two…read moresandwiches a cappuccino and a San Pellegrino. That came to $49 with tax and tip. There's nothing extra included. As you can see, it is very boring looking. There's no music playing. It's very, very basic and highly overpriced. I also wish they would've had a list of ingredients for make your own sandwich. There wasn't even suggestion from the counter person.

Emma's Bagel Cafe

3.3

(178 reviews)

First of all, Asher at the counter who took my order is very HANDSOME, and extremely polite. There…read morewere two of us and we each had a bagel with lox, and a side of Jerusalem salad. Delicious, honestly the best bagel I have had in ages. Everything else was lovely. Listening to the older crowd around me at the other tables, it must be difficult to be polite. Service was quick, everything fresh, coffee good, and clean.

A quick stop for a bagel and lox. Filled the gap and left satisfied. Very clean and organized…read morespot!Tasty Israeli salad side choice. Coffee was great. I'd return.

Great Harvest Bread

3.3

(210 reviews)

I stopped in yesterday morning after taking the furry kids to the Green Valley off the leash dog…read morepark. About half an hour after the bakery opening for the day. The breads are delicious. I enjoy the low carb whole wheat bread. And I occasionally buy the old fashion white bread. Putting both loafs in a paper bag I remarked to the lady at the counter how heavy they are. She smiled and nodded. I also purchased a fresh out of the over blueberry scone. Driving back home I enjoyed piece by piece the delicacy as if it was manna from heaven. It is out of this world. Stop me I'm salivating for another one. Let me light a cigarette and inhale after the goose bumps go down. Pillow talk with a scone. It's a great bakery with friendly staff and owners. Highly recommended. I'm not a fan of the over commercialization of Naperville but I'm definitely a big believer in the goodness of Great Harvest Bread and their delicious delights.

Always great friendly staff. The bread is something not comparable to anything you could get at a…read moregrocery store

Mensch's Deli

4.0

(159 reviews)

Get the tuna salad platter, you will not regret it…read more So fresh, so much food- great value. Dining in was great, good vibe, & service was good as well.

There were plenty of people eating inside but I wanted to try it. Menu is very extensive and some…read moreitems expensive. I love the pastrami sandwich in Manny's so this is probably somewhat similar. I ordered it which is around $21 and it was fairly small (in length and width) compared to Manny's. Taste was ok, I saw that my sandwich was ready but they took a bit to call you name for pickup. I don't think I will come back to Mensch's deli.

Button Bakery

4.9

(52 reviews)

Love love love this place! Scones were wonderful…read more I'm eating at work... but honestly best scones I ever had. I got lucky to find this place during my morning run. I wanted to bring some to my mom

Great food Lots of choices…read more Friendly helpful staff Convenient neighborhood bakery No doughnuts

Fred's Bread Bakery & Café

4.1

(7 reviews)

* Fred's Bread is a wonderful addition to the neighborhood…read more * The bread is fantastic -- sourdough and baguettes that rival any in the area, including Hewn * The pain aux raisins is a standout, alongside a fabulous selection of other quintessentially French pastries -- a must-try for any serious bakery connoisseur * The sandwiches and soup are excellent too * Local residents and family-owned -- will definitely be back and happy to spread the word

We stopped for dessert after having lunch near by. To our surprise they only opened the day before…read more Paid street parking is available. The space is open, bright and clean. Staff greeted us as soon as we walked in. It's a very welcoming and friendly environment. They said goods are cooked daily. I believe it. The fresh baked bread smell is hard to fake. Most importantly, the fresh baked treats we ordered were just perfect to end our long day. We ordered a Brioche Feuilletee, Orange Blossom Cinnamon Bun and a Latte. Nothing better than a fresh baked treats already looking forward to returning.

R&A Sourdough

3.6

(118 reviews)