We just moved to the area and brought some family to Bailiwick. We were very impressed! The building itself and decor are super cute and inviting. We were able to eat outside, plenty of outdoor seating. The food was delicious, it probably wouldn't be my first choice for a fish fry dinner on Fridays but I enjoyed everything else on the menu. We also enjoyed their homemade ice cream flavors. We will be back plenty of times read more

See all

Best country breakfast I've had in a long time! The entire place is just oozing with charm! Adorable little tchotchkies from local vendors. All of the baked goods looked absolutely delectable! The hash brown patty was crisped to perfection on the outside & then warm / creamy on the inside. If you're in town, you must go! read more

See all

Love Bailiwick every time! This time I tried the soup/salad combo and enjoyed both! Topped off the meal with the delicious blueberry lemonade! I love the new specials every month. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch at about Noon on a Friday. Place wasn't empty but wasn't packed either. Ordered at the counter and patiently waited....and waited....and waited..... The food must've taken almost 45 minutes to be ready. I had the fish sandwich and the person I was dining with the BLT. My fish was cooked well but small and didn't have enough fries. Didn't feel like it was worth 16 dollars. The BLT was okay per their report, but could've used a little longer toast on the bread. Expensive for what it is and long service times. Not good in my book. The place is great to take pictures for instagram though, which is clearly the aesthetic they are leaning into. This place is like a white woman's paradise. I won't be back but if you're the target demographic, you'll probably love it. read more

This is a really cute, rustic cafe out in Elbridge. They mostly offer breakfast/brunch/lunch, but had some dinner entrees as well. They also have homemade hard ice cream that is delicious. You can shop amongst the local goods while you wait for your food or sit with friends and chat. I tried the quesadilla with sweet potato fries. The whole quesadilla was great, especially the fried chicken on it. The fries were also very good. They had some spicy pickle fries I'll have to try next time. The menu is quite expansive with daily specials. I also had to try their ice cream. I got a scoop of coffee and another of peanut butter buckeye. So so good! They had some other unique flavors as well. The price was very fair for my entire meal and the service was great. I will def be stopping by again! read more

The whole family was here for lunch. We all enjoyed the nice little store and our meal. Two of us had the chicken quesadilla along with the loaded cheeseburger and the turkey sandwich. The ladies at the service counter were very welcoming and helpful. read more

See all

I wish we can leave 3.5 stars. Place is a cute set up inside, cracker barrel on steroids. Much cleaner and classy. Food you go up to the counter a d place an order, receive a buzzer and pick up your food. Ordered their club sandwich excellent and very large 2 days of food. Lunch the next day. Steak sandwich was good. They also have great ice cream but passed this trip. People are not as friendly as previou trip and reason for 3.5 to 4 stars. Asked a woman behind the counter for a plastic to go cup for my spouses water. The look when she handed me the cup was, like a how dare you ask or bother me look. Hate giving issues in a small business but they need to know. However I would recommend a stop here for food when in the area. read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Turkey club excellent - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

See all

After friend's rave reviews, we finally stopped for a light breakfast. I'm sad we didn't try any of the pastries, but the highly recommended barn door was AMAZING. The drinks were great, too. I can't wait to stop by again for holiday season to shop their local goods. I also love their set up, spotless, easy to serve and quick. We also took home a pint, which was chocolate mint - great for a family, friends or date day! read more

See all

Back to Bailiwick for another treat and a relaxing break on this beautiful afternoon. This business is a restaurant, coffee and tea shop, ice cream stand and gift shop. They make their own syrups for the coffee and tea, their baked goods are also homemade and their ice cream is homemade too! I had a very tasty tea latte! They steamed strawberry milk and added raspberry tea and lavender syrup.... sweet, fruity and floral! The blueberry coffeecake was large, fresh and delicious. The patio is beautiful and has large awnings for shade, flowers on the stone wall, there is a screened in gazebo and sunny tables too. read more

See all

I absolutely love this business!! The atmosphere is adorable and calming. They have shelves of local merchandise to browse through. With indoor and outdoor seating. The menu is vast and everything is delicious and fresh. The staff is friendly and personable. read more

See all

I've been going to Bailiwick for years. The ambience is amazing! There is a ton of seating especially in the warmer weather as they have ample outdoor seating as well. They have a full menu for breakfast to dinner. I love their grilled cheese! The coffee is pretty amazing. I believe it's cafe Kubal coffee. It's rich and deep in flavor. You'll also find some great baked goods, lots of local foods, local artisans, and other gifts you can buy AND ice cream!! They also have a drive through. I can't say enough great things about this place. It's got everything. read more

See all

Wonderful options for breakfast here. They have an espresso machine, brewed coffees, teas etc. a nicely filled pastry case. And multiple hot breakfast options. I got a quiche this day too but sadly it didn't make it to get a picture. The quiche portion is a quite hefty portion and comes with a side salad which is always very fresh and a vinaigrette which is to die for. I also ordered the barn door breakfast sandwich which is very delicious. After you order at the counter, you are given a buzzer for when your food is ready and you can pick it up at the counter. The lady behind the counter told me to let her know if I needed anything else in my coffee. Plenty of seating inside and outside if the weather is on your side. Tons of tiny shops of items for sale. Ice cream for sale too. Clean bathrooms for use. read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - The barn door sandwich with cold brew behind. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

My visit last Thursday to The Baliwick was so below my normal experience I am compelled to give them 1-star, I am a frequent diner there but have been absent for the past three months due to an ortho injury, and they seemed to have declined. This was my first take-out order. I came in around 5PM on a very rainy Thursday, and there was a light crowd with only a few tables occupied, most enjoying their burger & beer special. I ordered my favorite - the vegetable quiche & field green salad to go. I placed my order figuring I'd be in & out shortly as the quiche and salad are pre-made. I stood waiting with a good view of the kitchen to see two men, mostly leaning against the service tables chatting before one plated the quiche platter for another guest who was dining in - and as usual it looked fantastic. The quiche always looks so fresh and the field greens overflow the large plate. After about 13 minutes watching very little activity in the kitchen with the two men who were still leaning and chatting- I asked the women I gave my order to how much longer it would be for my order which prompted her to school me on how kitchens work, telling me the average meal takes 20 minutes to prepare. Because her tone was like she was explaining something to a child instead of an adult - I told her I know all about the workings of a kitchen as I am a certified chef & culinary instructor (retired) with a degree from Le Cordon Bleu, Paris. I then told her, in the business we have a saying: "if you can lean- you can clean" and the kitchen staff was basically doing very little and their was 'nothing to prepare' because all they need to do is go to the "reach-in" and grab a pre-made salad container, and put a slice of cold pre-made quiche in a container as I requested it not to be heated. No other customer is waiting for food so what is the delay about? I watched her go to the kitchen window and chat with the cook, and then she came back and said it would still be a few more minutes. After another 5 minutes of watching no activity at all in the kitchen except another employee dumping a bag of fries into the fryer - I finally told her to give me a refund as I had to leave. She then went back to the window and spoke to the head cook again, and a moment later I watched as he put a slice of quiche in the microwave to heat it up - AFTER I said I did not want it heated up - and then put a pre-made container of side salad on a shelf in the window. She bagged it and handed it to me saying : "here's your order." No 'thank you,' or 'sorry for the wait'- just: "here's your order." I got home, hungry, and tired after a 12-hour day and reheated the previously reheated quiche I had asked The Baliwick NOT to heat-up only to find the top of the quiche nearly black from overcooking and the slice much smaller then usual probably due to the too-small container. The field greens were only about half the portion you get dining in, so I felt cheated due to the size- and the quiche tasted like an older piece and was clearly overdone. I understand food prices have risen for restaurants (for me too) which explains why the price of the quiche/salad has increased from $9.99 to $13.99- and I am happy to pay that when I get what I paid for- but this time I didn't. It was so subpar and nearly inedible. (I would have tossed it in the trash had I not been so hungry and so tired) I give a lot of latitude to kitchen staff because I know first-hand what goes into feeding a crowd - but there was no crowd that night and this was a ridiculous, unexpected, negative experience for me and a total fail. It missed the mark big-time and was a waste of my money. So disappointing. Take-out orders should be consistent with dining in orders. The Baliwick does not appear to respond to their reviews, so perhaps they do not care- but for every negative reviewer there are ten others who don't take the time to post and that is how you lose customers. The Baliwick should want to keep customers in this economy- not push them away. read more

Great food and lively atmosphere! Love the vibe of the post and beam construction and open airy feel!

First let me say, it's been a few years since my one and only visit here. My experience wasn't bad, but I don't think it's what I was hoping for. It felt lacking in the usual warmth and charm I associate with one of a kind (or specialty shops) such as this seemed to be driving by. read more

Always great food and sometimes they have live entertainment which is nice. I love browsing the store for cute gifts! Sometimes it's a bit loud but that's to be expected for such a high volume place. read more

Good food and great employees! Love their sandwiches and wraps and Sat. nite dinners of Prime Rib at an affordable price! Friday fish fries are also outstanding! Lovely little shop for gifts and unusual things and a great patio and gazebo for outdoor dining in nice weather. Most Saturday nites there are local musicians singing and playing....and everyone loves their homemade ice cream. Tell your friends! Its a great place for a meal and a good time!!! read more

First time coming here like many other places it's a hit or miss, I had a BLT lacked bacon to the fact that it was pure lettuce and the salad I had was meh only good thing I had was a bar dessert. read more

Great break from the cookie-cutter coffee shops & classic diner menu, although they offer some classics, as well. Ingredients always seem fresh and house prepared. Nice outdoor seating area for those nice days but plenty inside, too. Huge selection of locally sourced items and food in the retail section. read more

I've visited Bailiwick several times over the past several years. You can't miss the big red barn structure with metal sculptures on route 5. There is plenty of parking spots and a lovely outdoor patio and set up for warmer months. The inside is clean, beautiful and lofty. I absolutely love that they sell locally made goods. I always gravitate toward the ceramics and jewelry. I have not ordered food off their menu because when I'm passing bye I'm usually under a time constraint and the wait is usually more than 15 minutes from order to arrival. I've purchased their baked goods several times and they are always delicious, especially the sugar cookies. The most recent visit I decided to order a small cup of Just Got Dumped ice cream. I'm not a huge ice cream lover but holy smokes, this was just about the best ice cream I've ever tasted!! Just got dumped description is: chocolate base with homemade caramel, chocolate covered potato chips & pretzel bits, nut toffee and chocolate cookie crumbles. Love the color change spoon! The only drawback that I would note is that sometimes the service can be cold and/or wait times to be served/noticed can vary quite a bit. If I'm in a huge rush, I might not visit. A more accurate rating would be around a 4.5. The rest of the ice cream flavors looks delicious. I'll definitely come back to make my way through the ice cream menu. read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - "Just got dumped" - pure heaven. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

This is the cutest little cafe! Not to mention the breakfast sandwich was amazing. They sell lunch and breakfast, as well as little treats. They have an ice cream shop here too! You can sit inside or outback on their patio. Extremely family friendly, and all the workers there so so helpful. I can't wait to go back! read more

See all

I had the burger and fries and looked just the way I asked. The outside patio is very enjoyable and save room for homemade ice cream! This place is a gem in Elbridge NY I love it here! read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Burger and fries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

See all

Ordered from here and it was okay taste-wise but sub par service. Ordering over the phone was a chore and things were repeated multiple times (it is loud in there so I do understand). Three sandwiches and one was 100% the wrong order. The sandwich I got was supposed to have Swiss cheese and there was none to be found. The "cranberry-orange chutney" had chunks in it that were neither cranberry nor orange (I'm assuming apple by the consistency?) and two pieces were so charred (and black) that had I bit squarely into them I could have EASILY cracked a tooth. Also ordered a coffee with specific milk, received a coffee with no milk. Not the $40 experience I had hoped for. read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

Outside of the village of Elbridge (and across from Tessy Plastic) you will see the quaint barn like structure of Bailiwick Market & Cafe. I have been to Bailiwick's on many occasions so I feel I have a good idea of what is consistent at this cafe and market. As you enter you are greeted by a huge open concept. Open wood beams above but the feeling of warmth and comfort from the decorations and such that are placed around the market. To you right as you enter is a beautiful fireplace that when schedule has live music playing in front of it. Tables abound on the right side as well. On the left side you have a counter that serves their very own homemade ice cream! They offer seasonal flavors depending on the time of year! Continuing down the left and center you have the "market". Local and NY state products such as but not limited to hot $& BBQ sauces, eggs, cheeses, clothing, jewelry, coffee mugs and pet toys. Towards the end of the barn you find the cafe. There is usually a small line but it does go really fast. There is a huge menu that is over the counter along with handheld menus as you wait. Once at the counter you are greeted warmly with a smile. The staff are very welcoming and patient as you order and will adjust your order to your liking without hesitation. Once your order is completed and you paid, you will be given a buzzer to take with you while they created your meal. You can meander and shop or find your seat either inside or on their stunning outdoor patio with gazebo. Your buzzer will vibrate when ready and you go up to pick up your food plates on trays. They have a condiments area to stop at as well. The Swiss burger was cooked to my asking at medium. The cheese was melted perfectly but what stuck out the most to me the the taste of the burger. The flame grilled taste definitely put the burger over for me! The soft potato bun was soft but with a slight crisp on the outside and never got soggy. You can never go wrong with fresh cut fries as well. Such a difference then other places that may serve them frozen. The Plank Road BLT was delicious! The tomatoes were fresh along with the lettuce. The bacon was a good thickness, not overly crisp and had a good chew to it. The country potato bread was pressed perfectly so that each bite was the perfect size! I also added a phot from a sandwich I had last December (2021). The Tweedie has Roast Turkey, Swiss cheese, spinach, cranberry-orange chutney panini pressed on wheatberry bread. I remember it being the perfect sandwich for the holiday season! Something unique to Bailiwick Market & Cafe is that it has a drive thru. I do recommend that you order ahead of time and pick it up though the drive-through rather than ordering it at the drive-through. They also offer a points and reward system along with a phone app! This may be a bit of a drive for some being on the boarder of Onondaga and Cayuga County but it's a beautiful drive and well worth your time once you are there. read more

See all

My bf and I came here last Sunday and I was really impressed! I loved the atmosphere and the food!! We had breakfast sandwiches and they were so fluffy and delicious! Also the lady at the register was nice, quick and patient!! We deff plan to be back! Loved my Bagel Sandwich! read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Breakfast sandwich and coffee on Sunday! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

Nice people, great service, with excellent soups and sandwiches at reasonable prices. Nice gift shop with unique items, and SUPERB ice cream. The place is a home run. read more

Such a good first experience here. We went on a less busy day, so there was no line and very few people. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The flavors of the ice cream were spot on & if you have a dog I recommend getting them "Puppy Love". It's vanilla ice cream with a small dog treat on top. My dogs give it 4/4 paws! read more

See all

Everything is amazing about this place! The food, soups and pastries are all fresh. The sandwiches are huge made on their fresh made bread. Why am I only finding out about this place? The ambience is so inviting with it open ceiling inside fresh wood. It's just so comfortable it's almost like being at Grandmas house, filled with love and kindness. I do t drink coffee but heard that was pretty good. To top it off, I did bring home some fresh made ice cream. read more

Favorite place to stop for a quick bite with some friends or family. Service is always great, beautiful area and delicious food.

Taking the long way home from Waterloo we saw this place. I had remembered hearing about their home made ice cream so we stopped in. This place was so much more than I expected. The live music was not only awesome but just made the whole experience that much better. The shop was adorable with so many great things to check out. Now I mentioned we stopped for ice cream. But my teenage son saw someone's sandwich and decided he needed to have one and he was starving. Lol. So this turned into dinner, a show, and ice cream to go. He got the Reuben sandwich. It came with sweet pickle chips and potato chips. He also got one of their root beers. He raved about everything. He said it was the best Reuben he's ever had and told me we have to go there again soon. I got the 1/2 Ceaser Salad and added Chicken. It came with their house made Asiago dressing. Omg it was absolutely incredible. If they ever start bottling this dressing I will buy it to bring home. The salad as a whole was amazing and even came with a home made roll. My 1 and ONLY critique about this place is I wish they mixed up the salad with the dressing in the back before plating. It is very difficult to mix this properly without salad spilling out because the bowl was very full. It was a little frustrating but when I finally got there.... dang that was a delicious salad. Now finally onto the ice-cream. They have soft serve, sundaes, and all sorts of great things. They even have cartons to go. The hard ice-cream is home made and wow was it amazing. My son got the plain chocolate because he's boring. He said it was so chocolatey and really really good. I got the Coffee Chip. It was strong coffee with strong chocolate chips and it was perfect. Not only was the flavor awesome but it was creamy and rich and everything ice-cream should be. Atmosphere, check. Food, check. Dessert, check. What about service, hospitality, friendliness? Check, check, check. The people are outstanding! I even met the owner and she was so kind. So.... if you haven't been yet. Go. Now. You will not regret it! read more

See all

Nancy Hourigan envisioned an ice cream stand across from the Tessy Plastics plant on Route 5 in Elbridge. But, that vision grew into the Bailiwick Market and Cafe, an eclectic 4,000 square-foot restaurant/store that sells local merchandise--free range eggs from Elbridge chickens, Wake Robin Farm cheeses from Jordan or 4 Tin Fish Farm cheese from Conquest. The shop has locally produced pottery, fiber art, soap, candles and scents. Bailiwick means realm of interest; geographical area, and their goal is to create a gathering space for people to connect with others through our shared realm of interest: the beautiful CNY landscape.  The wife and I have been wanting to come here for a while, so looking for lunch yesterday, we figured we'd give it a try. The menu has items on it named for local people or that reflect local history and there's Field of Creams ice cream, the store's brand. Breakfast, lunch and dinner options are available. They have usual offerings you'd see at a cafe, such as deli sandwiches, soups, etc, but also stuff you wouldn't expect to find at a cafe, like a chicken tender basket and even a NY strip steak as a daily special sometimes. The cafe itself is beautiful inside. Huge, barn styled building, all exposed wood inside. It has plenty of tables to sit at and also plenty of local goods for sale to check out. My wife ordered their chicken pot pie and daily soup, which was shrimp and roasted red pepper, while I got their daily sandwich special, which was sliced turkey breast with pesto mayo, red onion, tomato and provolone on wheatberry bread, along with a side of their house cut fries. Their dressings and breads are all house made and most meats are house roasted as well. We were given a little vibrating device to alert us when our food was done. It was made pretty quickly and when we dug in, everything was great. Their fries are absolutely amazing. Some of the best home made ones I've ever had. Perfect size, shape, nice and crispy. My sandwich was great too, the pesto mayo was very flavorful, but I think I would've enjoyed it more had it been a hot sandwich. My wife LOVED the shrimp and red pepper soup and said her pot pie was great too. My wife got a big waffle cone of ice cream after, and I got a peach milkshake, made with their own peaches. Bailiwick is owned by a farm, so most of the fruits and veggies come directly from the farm. They also have a rewards program with coupons and rewards on anniversaries and birthdays. We will definitely be back to try out some more food! Great little place to buy and support local! read more

See all

Nice atmosphere and the food was very good. The chicken pot pie could have used a bit more "crust" than they add to it. Was still very good.

Ordered the special (vegetable lasagna). It was dry no sauce, looked and tasted like it was made 3 days ago. Very disappointed in a restaurant that we frequent a lot read more

Good food, nice atmosphere. Customer service was fine, could've been a little better for how slow they were. Little pricy.

The people who work there seem to be happy and very helpful. We have been going there for quite some time and have not been disappointed with the service or the quality of the food. Their homemade ice cream is amazingly delicious and comes in a variety of different kinds of flavors, My favorite is Lake Effect which has coconut, chocolate fudge and almonds in a vanilla ice cream base. Kind of tastes like an almond Joy candy bar. Make sure you bring your wallet, but it's worth it. read more

This place is awesome! We had a chicken salad club which was the best I ever had. The service was quick and really enjoyed the meal! read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Ice cream menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York

Very kind staff and homey environment! Great food at very fair prices - I highly recommend!

Cute place, friendly staff, varied choices on the menu. The ice cream is amazing!! The salads and soup were both very good. My husband wasn't too impressed with the burger. If we get a chance to visit again, I'd try the pot pie or the quiche. 4 stars not 5 because the breads were all kind of stale and the font on the menu board was really hard to read. After waiting in line for a bit, we found a printed menu at the counter ... that helped. read more

First time visit and it certainly won't be my last! Amazing customer service and the food was so delicious! Will be back again! read more

See all

Saw an ad for a fall festival here on Facebook and decided to give it a try. This place is so cute. Everyone was so nice and inclusive. From the second I walked in people were coming up to my son and I and letting us know about all the events taking place and activities. The food was good but I only had a small amount so can't speak for most of the food. The activities were catered to kids of all ages and my son loved all of it. read more

Bailiwick Market & Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Elbridge, New York