As other reviewers have already noted, the exterior is pretty gruesome - essentially the far other…read moreend of the spectrum from "fancy". The inside looks like a typical rural Pennsylvania old tavern - wood paneling, walls covered in beer signs, not very large. So what - the food and service are excellent. Very friendly and attentive staff, large portions, everything arrived quickly, nice selection of beers. My wife had scallops with a side of broccoli - seemed risky ordering scallops there but they were delicious. I had penne pasta with meatballs, obviously homemade and great, although the sauce was a bit too sweet for my taste. I'm guessing Mastracchio's is popular with locals, and if you're passing through and not bothered by the look of the place, you'll be glad you gave it a try - we were.

I love their blue crab ravioli and their seafood chowder! The meals are priced reasonably and come…read morewith sides. They also have a great craft beer selection.

Got take out. Great everything was hot and good. Best pizza you can find in this area they do it…read moreright here. Great spot

I really enjoyed the food from here! The lobster ravioli is very very good! Very large portions! I…read moreordered a medium stuffed pizza, and I can't imagine what the large looks like! It is huge! I also ordered the breaded mushrooms and it would've fed 3 people! How are they making money with portions this big! The service was top notch also! I can't handle spicy food, not even pepperoni, and I have a hard time speaking some times because I had a full laryngectomy but the young lady at the counter was very kind and patient with me, and helped me find some substitutes and they didn't charge me anything extra! The place had a nice vibe going on, everyone in the kitchen was busy, but all seemed to be enjoying what they did! I'd highly recommend this place if you're looking for top notch Italian cuisine! Very tasty!

I'll start off with why I give it 3 stars. The 25-minute delivery turned out to be less than 20…read moreminutes...great. The fries were delicious...great. The pizza was very good...great (but I had to make them promise to NOT BURN it this time like the last 4 times). The loaf of bread cheesesteak (I don't know why everybody got away from steak rolls, but now everybody seems to be serving cheesesteaks on loafs of bread anymore) was pretty good but there was on taste in there that I could not identify that tasted out of place for a cheesesteak, and made the sandwich a 3 instead of a 5...not great, but decent. And lastly, the cheeseburger sub. I used to get these from Brothers regularly because they were delicious. After 1/2 of the sub I'm thinking of throwing the other half out in the trash. What happened?? I used to enjoy the taste of the burger but with this one there is only the taste of charcoal. Did they switch from the griddle to char-broil? If so, I will never order a burger from there again. It was disgusting. I love meat .... I do NOT love the taste of charcoal. And again, served in that stupid loaf of bread instead of a proper steak roll. Oh, and do you see how they describe their sizes of the pizzas??? Small (12"), Large (15"), and Party (18"). Talk about trying to mislead the public. Anywhere else you go, a 15" pizza is a medium, and an 18" is a large. If you offer 3 sizes, the one in the middle is MEDIUM, not large. A 5 year old could tell you that, but these people try to promote their Party size is so much larger than a Large. That's only because they don't even know that their Large is actually only a Medium, and their Party is actually only a Large ....... just like every other pizza place. They need to get honest and stop trying to con the public. "Telling the truth can only help you."

This place is absolutely annoying. The woman who answers…read morethe phone is so sweet and she is the only reason I gave two stars. Tonight was the icing on the cake for me. I ordered food as they said they would get it here within the hour. This was true. It was on time...HOWEVER; The delivery driver called me and was on the phone for 15 minutes with me while I told her exactly how to get to my house. I explained I could see where she was, she just needed to come to the next lot. Instantly I can hear her groaning about she doesn't know where to go, at this point I told her that she was in the right place. All she had to do was get out the car and go up the steps, she drivers back down the hill. Long story short, she did this for 15 minutes WHILE IM ON THE PHONE!! She told me to come to the parking lot because she can't find me. I told her I was unable to walk down. So she sat on the phone for an additional five minutes before I just said I guess I have no choice. Absolutely horrible delivery service, good thing the Stromboli was free because the food was horrible and cold. I'll just order from bambino's next time.

Always a pleasant dining experience inside or at home when you order from here. Friendly people and…read morea very nice establishment.

Pizza is really good. If you are looking for friendly attentive service, you will not find it…read morehere. I have stopped here about once a month for their lunch special of 2 slices and a drink for$8 for the last 2 years. They have a good variety of specialty ones in a case that you can pick from. However, they also keep slices of stromboli in there and even if they tell you they are included, they will charge you extra. So, the last time I was there, 2 slices of cheese, 2 slices of meat lovers, 2 slices of stromboli, and 3 drinks cost over $30! Plus, if you get the special, don't expect any more service then them bringing it to your table. I have always felt that they do not really want my business, so I will be taking mine elsewhere from now on.

The food was excellent. I had a Caesar salad to start which was good and the Crab and Mushroom…read moreRisotto. I thought the risotto was one of the best I've ever had. They used real crab meat. The ambience was really nice. Felt like I was in an old building from Italy. Elegant. And the servers were quietly efficient and very nice! I never had to ask for more water and every thing was very smooth.

I went here with my family for dinner and it was a great experience. The waitress was very classy…read moreand fun to talk to. I ordered the Lobster Ravioli which, to my delight, also came with huge prawns. The ravioli was covered in their special pink sauce, and tastes so deliciously creamy and tangy. My uncle ordered the barramundi, which he liked but mentioned the ones he had when living in Australia were much fresher I recommend this place, a great area to go with your family!

Food delicious , fresh ,right proportions. Valentine menu…read more Service fast , pleasant Recommend reservation BYO wine

Thank you, Maria for the ultimate service! This is a favorite restaurant of a special friend and a…read morebirthday dinner was decided to be spent here! Thank you for your help to make it a special moment - remember that call from CA! I appreciate it. I know the food is good because they boys love it.

Don't let the strip mall location fool you--this place is a hidden gem. The food is outstanding,…read morethe drinks are excellent, the service is friendly and attentive, and the prices are very reasonable. If you're looking for a great meal without breaking the bank, you won't be disappointed.

This restaurant has amazing and authentic Italian food! I…read morehad the eggplant stack and it was absolutely delicious! Highly reccomend. Can't wait to go back!

Me and my son had a stop in Millerstown, PA and we decided to have a lunch at this family-owned…read moreItalian restaurant. I ordered gluten-free pasta and chicken, which was exceptionally tender. Chicken was organic which is a great bonus too ! . My son thoroughly enjoyed his sub, finishing every bite. The meal felt light and fresh, clearly indicating that it was made from scratch. The service was friendly and welcoming. I would definitely recommend trying their food.

Family operated and Irene will treat you like family. Stop in for pizza or any of the other menu…read moremeals from a sandwich to spaghetti and meat balls.

My friend and I went to the Sunday buffet. It was a cold winter day but the room the buffet was in…read morewas light and cheerful. They used real cloth napkins and tablecloths! There was a choice of two soups, a fresh salad bar, a great selection of well labeled entrees and a choice of desserts. The staff was attentive. I'm bringing my husband back for his birthday in February!

I got the bruschetta, Caesar salad, chicken Parmesan, homemade tiramisu. My waiter was very…read moreattentive and kind. It is older style inside, but still a nice environment.

On the positive side: Delicious food!…read moreLarge portions of pasta! Friendly staff. Decent prices. Nice music and atmosphere. The negative? Very bright lights. We went for Sunday lunch. It was very busy and they were definitely overwhelmed. We waited for a long time to get drinks and a long time for food. Hiremore staff for the busy times!

Friday night date night on the nicest evening of the year so far felt like the perfect excuse to…read morefinally check out Nonna Ilva after seeing it all over social media. I was craving pizza, my adventure buddy was craving a cheesesteak, and this seemed like the perfect place to satisfy both. Parking is street-only, but it's free after 5pm, which is a win for dinner plans. I managed to snag a spot right out front without having to parallel park or circle the block, which honestly felt like a small victory before the night even started. We had planned to meet at 5:30pm, but due to a slightly delayed adventure buddy situation, we walked in closer to 5:45pm -- right at peak "everyone else had the same idea" time. The place was absolutely PACKED. There was one table left in the main dining area (which we grabbed immediately), though we were told there was additional seating in another room. From our table out front, we had a full view of the action...which turned out to be both entertaining and a little telling. Going into the evening, I had already done my homework (because of course I did) and had spent the week narrowing down my order. Everything on the menu sounded incredible, but I ultimately landed on the Broccoli & Sausage Pizza Bianche -- a white pizza topped with mozzarella, broccoli, sausage, chili oil, and burrata. My adventure buddy chose the standard cheesesteak (hoagie roll, onions, provolone), which was exactly the level of culinary risk I expected from him. It quickly became clear that Nonna Ilva was significantly understaffed that evening. We waited about 15 minutes before anyone came to take our drink order, and the three staff members we saw were absolutely hustling -- managing the dining room, takeout orders, and a steady stream of DoorDash pickups. They were working hard, but there were simply too many customers for the team on hand. When our server did make it over, we placed both our drink and food orders at the same time to avoid any additional delays. About 20 minutes later, the cheesesteak arrived -- hot and solid, though a bit more straightforward than expected. Despite ordering it with onions, it came out fairly plain with just steak and cheese on a toasted roll. Flavor-wise, it delivered, but it didn't quite stand out. About 10 minutes after that, my pizza arrived -- and WOW. Absolutely stunning. Piled high with sausage, broccoli, and burrata, and finished with a generous drizzle of chili oil, it looked every bit as good as I had hoped. The timing, however, was a bit of a letdown. My adventure buddy had waited to eat until my food arrived (a noble decision), but by the time the pizza hit the table, his cheesesteak had cooled off quite a bit. Not ideal, but we made the best of it. Now let's talk about the pizza -- because this is where Nonna Ilva completely redeemed itself for me. I have been on a lifelong search for a truly great white pizza, and more often than not, it's been a disappointment -- bland, oily, and clearly an afterthought on most menus. But Nonna Ilva? Nonna Ilva cares about white pizza. This was hands down one of the best white pizzas I've ever had. Perfectly balanced, flavorful, and clearly crafted with intention. The chili oil brought just the right amount of heat, the sausage and broccoli were generous and well-distributed, and the burrata? Game changer. I've never seen another local spot incorporate burrata into a white pizza like this, and it absolutely made the dish. This is the white pizza I've been searching for. The kind I will go out of my way to come back for again and again. Unfortunately, the service side of the experience just didn't match the quality of the food that night. The staff was clearly overwhelmed, and it showed throughout the entire visit. Even paying the bill proved to be a challenge -- we eventually walked up to the register and waited in line with DoorDash drivers just to close out. We still left a good tip because the effort was there -- the team was working hard -- but the overall experience inside the restaurant felt chaotic. I had originally planned to grab dessert from their case, but decided to skip it and head elsewhere given the situation. Next time? I'll absolutely be back for that pizza... but I'll likely go the takeout route like many others seem to be doing. Because while the service may have struggled that night, the food -- specifically that white pizza -- is 100% worth coming back for!