Dr. Baumgarten has been my mom's orthopedic surgeon for many years. He is knowledgeable, honest and above all, he is really caring. He has treated my mom with kindness and always answers all our questions regarding surgeries and the best option for mom's care as she has an advanced case of rheumatoid arthritis. My mom recently broke her elbow. He evaluated my mom and he said he couldn't do the surgery because this is not his area of expertise. We trust him and asked him if he could refer us to a reputable surgeon. He immediately contacted Dr. Neil Sardesai and my mom had surgery within two days. The surgery was a success and she is recovering. We truly respect and trust Dr. Baumgarten and we are so grateful for him. If I could give 10 stars, I would. read more

I came in to go over my options after injuring my right knee in a fall a few years ago. The injury caused a meniscus tear, and I haven't been able to fully straighten my knee since then. However, I had limited knee pain and no difficulty walking; the main issue was painful compensation on my left side. He outlined several treatment options, but the conversation seemed to focus on dismissing alternatives in favor of a total knee replacement which felt far too aggressive at this stage. It came across more like a sales pitch than a recommendation based on my best interests. There is no patient portal, nothing digitized, no texts, nothing. I personally find these features immensely helpful in understanding and organizing my ongoing treatment. Seems outdated since I don't think I have any providers without a portal these days. The few pages of pre-surgery information they sent me by mail seemed painfully inadequate. When I made the initial appt, they told me they accept Blue Shield PPO, but when I looked at the claim in the BS portal yesterday I noticed they were out of network. When I called to ask about it, I was told I should have asked or looked into it on my own, but I very rarely ever run into providers who aren't in network so I didn't think of it. So I guess that's on me. Maybe I'm being picky, but I feel that is a point worth mentioning especially when considering the huge expense of major surgery. Some of the portals that I mentioned above also let you know your insurance summary *before* the appt. To be fair, he was easy to talk to, listened to my concerns, and did not rush through the appointment. Clearly he has helped a lot of people so he's doing something right. But after considering all of the above, I decided not to move forward with the surgery. read more

Years ago I wrote a review of this so called surgeon about a botched procedure he did on my foot. After years of living with his incompetence I sought out 2 more opinions on how to fix my foot only to find out that Moe had done the surgery wrong, fusing the bones in my foot at the wrong angle and I now need another surgery to undo the mess this doctor did. read more

Dr Baumgarten gave me my life back! My partial knee replacement failed after 5 years, went to the same group as the one that did the previous partial, opted for second opinion (I had prior surgeries with dr takai in the same office as dr baumgarten, but he retired). Front office is awesome, submitting authorizations seemingly as soon as I left the office, didn't waste any time. Due to a job change our insurance was running out and once approved Lisa the scheduler got me in asap. Same situation with my other knee 6 weeks later with the exception of it needing replaced instead of revised. Got me in and done in a couple weeks. All the follow ups have gone very well, due to a scheduling misunderstanding (I forgot and missed a follow up showing up the following day at their lunch time) they still got me in and seen ON THEIR LUNCH! I've had 22 different ortho procedures with countless drs, and Dr Baumgarten and staff are the best read more

The doctor may be an excellent surgeon and he is engaging when he is in the mood to speak with you. He's a busy person so he might not have time to engage you in conversation. He is human, so he's entitled to be moody like we all are, this review has nothing to do with the doctor, but entirely his front office ; but I have to say that his front office has discouraged me from returning the best way that I can describe them as haughty dismissive and somewhat a sense of entitlement. And they do not have a kind demeanor in their bones. This is the reason I have decided not to come back to the office unfortunately, this can really hurt a doctor's practice. I do not tolerate rudeness from a front office doctors office if you don't like what you're doing or you don't like patients then don't work as a front office person. Also, the front office lobby is frozen in 1970 with carpet being so disgustingly dirty; it could easily be washed or replaced a few dollars go a long way to make your office look tidy, especially a medical office. It should be tidy and clean. But nobody likes to arrive at an office where you're not even greeted with the good afternoon or good morning or opening the window wide enough to be seen or acknowledged. They act like they are mind readers and you're just an annoyance so sorry doctor for not coming back to your office But the women in your office are unbearable. They need to retire or learn some manners. read more

He operated on my broken wrist. He told a few jokes first, then got work. He is a busy doctor, but he listens

His absolutely an amazing surgeon he knows his stuff and nailed my foot issue. I'm so happy after doing much research after 3 surgerys on my foot he was able to determine issue and I couldn't be more happy to say that he was able to take care of it. read more

Today was only my second appointment with this doctor and so far my experience has been great. The doctor is easy going , he listens to you and takes the time to make sure you understand what is happening. He doesn't just rush through the appointment. He talks to you in a manner that you can relate too. I feel confident that he will be able to help me. He also shows compassion and empathy which is kind of hard to find these days. Office ladies are great and helpful as well. read more

He's a good Doctor. Had 2 visits with him . He listened to me . Let me decide if I want to have surgery or a different treatment

Doctor Baumgarten and team are amazing! The front desk staff are so friendly and kind.

Doctor Baumgarten is probably the best doctor I have ever had. He is not pushing joint replacement because I don't want it. I'm 81and I have Parkinson's disease and I don't think i'm a good candidate for surgery. I'm getting cortisone shots instead. Doctor Baumgarten is very personable and very knowledgeable. Could not ask for a better doctor. read more

Dr. Baumgarten did what I thought was the impossible - he operated on my knee, to which many other surgeons thought was too risky, as I have polio. Many surgeons have told me that it was not possible to operate on my knee. One look into my situation and Dr. Baumgarten said no problem, he could do it. The surgery went well and healed very well. I have no pain in my knee. I even stand taller, as I was in a "crouched position" due to a misalignment in my knee. All I can say is that the surgery done by Dr. Baumgarten was truly a miracle, as it gave me a piece of my life back. It gave me hope. read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

Dr.Baumgarten is so sweet, caring and fast.....my mama broke her wrist, we went to Arcadia Methodist hospital, after 10hrs.in the emergency waiting room Dr.Baumgarten waisted no time in putting a splint on my mama. 1week later we were at his office in Duarte. In less than an hour we filled out new patient paperwork, took an x-ray at his office, and my mama got to pick whatever color she wanted for her cast...She got a purple cast...Thank you Dr Baumgarten and staff... read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

I was crippled in a serious motorcycle accident it left me barely able to walk and in constant unrelenting pain. I Dr. Baumgarten gave me two complete knee replacements and has treated me for 21 years. I'm sure he's the best doctor on the planet. The surgery was perfect and the recovery was great. He's such a concerned and caring doctor he even came to check on me in the hospital on Thanksgiving morning. For the first time in years I am completely pain-free and I walk without even a limp, taking my dogs daily on 2 mile walks. At 68 I ride my motorcycle everywhere something I never thought I would do again. He truly gave me back my life. His staff is wonderful and so caring also he is absolutely the best orthopedic surgeon you can get. Delon Froton. read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

Dr. Baumgarten replaced my right knee 10 years ago, and now am going to him for left knee. He is amazing! no complications (if you don't count a nurse at the hospital)...and no problems at all. He has a warm and funny personality. Always a pleasure to see him. read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

See all

Great doctor. Good bedside manner, professional, friendly. I would highly recommend him for your podiatry needs.

Dr Baumgarten gets 5 stars. Successful knee replacement with plenty of good natured humor. His office staff? Maybe not so much. Calling the office to make appointments is a painful process. read more

My Family doctor set me up with Dr Baumgarten and I couldn't be happier.He a great guy and so talented. I ended getting surgery for a torn meniscus four weeks ago and it was a great success. read more

I met with Dr Baumgarten and was immediately impressed by his casual conversation regarding my issue. He was very interested with my concerns and explained in detail what needed to be done to solve my problem with my foot. I did get a first option which I was not impressed at all with another Dr . I'm having outpatient surgery on Dec 1st with Dr Baumgarten... very confident with him and looking forward to correcting my problems and no pain! read more

I saw Dr. Baumgarten yesterday. I was in terrible pain, and was sure I'd go to the emergency room after my visit. Dr. Baumgarten took time to listen to me, was very kind and empathetic. A very affable man indeed. He told me he would take care of me. He ordered medications to releive the pain and spasms. I am having a rough morning today, but I know it takes time to heal. I was extremely impressed with this doctor and his kindness. He wants me to return in 10 days to follow up on my care. What a gem to find him here in Duarte. I highly recommend this doctor! read more

So guess what?! I went from a broken ankle to performing in Salsa dance group. Thank you Dr. B! I am so thankful for your professional care. read more

Worst doctor ever (Baumgarten)...the way he spoke to me was beyond unprofessional, he stated he's a republican and doesn't care if I have surgery or not and if he were to be a democrat then he would be sympathetic and ask me if I'm ok. I asked several questions and got no answers. He stated I don't need surgery for my knee yet I have a meniscus tear. The girls at the front desk are the worst ever they are rude and don't care about anyone. I'm never going back to this doctor that's for sure. Also I have a bakers cyst and he didn't tell me, he had no clue why I had swelling from my knee down to my foot. read more

I cannot believe I have not put a recommendation here for Dr. Mo - I broke both 5th metatarsals. I went to one guy who put a screw in my foot and I felt pain FOREVER. I could feel the screw coming out of my foot. I didn't go back to that man. I was referred to Dr. Mo by SO MANY PEOPLE. I went and he said we should take the screw out and put me in a walking boot for 3 months. About a year later, I broke the OTHER left metatarsal. He said "either way there is 50/50 it will heal even with surgery. He put me in another walking boot (which was great cause all my left shoes were already worn down so I could use the right ones! Not only did he NOT recommend surgery I would not need, but then once at my son's high school he broke BOTH his arms at the same time doing "Back running". As I picked him up from school I immediately called Dr. Mo. They said "He's in surgery right now" ... I said "WHERE"??? They told me Arcadia Methodist so I said please call them, I'm driving him to the emergency room right now. Without a heartbeat he met us in the lobby and reset both of my son's arms. Cast him up and 5-6 weeks later he was done. He doesn't have any pain and never had to go back, see anyone else. I also have a great back surgeon who has a great practice, but for LIMBS... nowhere to go but Dr. Mo. He is amazingly funny, totally truthful. Anyone that left 1 stars are just are having a bad freaking day. I've heard NOTHING but positive reviews from everyone in the medical community. This guy is THE BEST. read more

Dr Baumgarten is a doctor who will actually sit down and discuss your issue, give you options so you have some control in how to deal with your problem and still will give a recommendation that I have always trusted to be what is best. read more

I love this Dr. He is the most amazing physician I have ever met! He did my total knee replacement on my right knee and i couldnt be any happier with my results i am currently 6 wks post op. And i have not had any issues, hes kind and really cares of your results. He is straight forward no sugar coating things i just love him! I can never repay him for giving me my life back!!! My husband and I am forever grateful to him and his staff!! His girls are amazing very helpful never rude and always take care of stuff! Thank you all!!! read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - The day after my sx! - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

See all

Baumgarten is the Surgeon around! He first did my foot which I had some mass that was causing pain on top of a bunion. While he was in surgery, he noticed a problem with my sesamoid bone, so he fixed that also even though it was not in the surgery plans. I suffered minor pain for 30 years driving Manual Transmission car and fixing the sesamoid cured my Pain when driving long distances and now I can vacation like I wanted to 30 years ago, going out to Palm Springs and doing my favorite hobbies, or having a good time down at the Beach! I went to see him because right knee kept swelling up on the side of the kneecap, creating discomfort. I had seen another Surgeon previously and that surgeon said there was no way to fix the fluid leaking without creating another problem with the knee which could cause premature knee replacement surgery. So I go to Baumgarten and he had a totally different perspective and said he will do surgery to remove a leaking Bursa. Also, he was super nice to order an MRI of the knee to see what else might need fixing while he opens the knee up. Sure enough that MRI revealed a minor tear in the Meniscus so am going to get that fixed at the same time. And where the Meniscus was torn, I had some discomfort for 20 years and Baumgarten is the first of 5 Surgeons to identify the cause of that pain. Often I heard Scar Tissue as reason from other doctors. His office is rather busy as he has a lot of patients, but I really like how he will spend quality time with you in the office. read more

I cannot stress the importance of finding a dr who you trust and believe in. Dr. B is him. I would trust him with my kid, which says a lot. Personally he has always Ben there to help me and all my ortho needs. read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Standard Room - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

Doctor is very funny caring person I have seen him for 3 month he is very quite busy guys do a lot of sugary , knee replacement / feet surgery after surgery next day want you come over to the office check your foot read more

Baumgarten Morris MD - Also you can pick a case color for your foot - Surgeons Near Me - Duarte, California

When I knew knee replacement surgery was inevitable, I spoke to a number of people who work in the OR at Methodist Hospital about who they thought was the best. Every single one that I talked to recommended Dr Baumgarten, so that was a no brainer. I couldn't be happier with him or his staff, they're very accommodating, professional and use the latest techniques. Rarely is one of patients stapled, meaning that you can shower immediately and you don't have to have them removed, and you get a cleaner looking scar. I hope I never need another surgery, but if I do, Dr B will be my first choice, as he should be yours! read more

Doctor B was so amazing with my husband. Took added time with us for his other medical issues, was so kind and really did a perfect job on his knee replacement. He has fixed so many of my friends knee's, feet, and hips. Thank you Dr. Baumgarten. read more

Don't expect the doctor to talk to your loved ones. I sat at the hospital recovery room left to use the restroom told the other families I will be right back and he could not wait 5 minutes. Now I sit here crying worried because of the unknown. This is his 5 the surgery on same leg due to MRSA and 3 infections. And he could not waid 2 minutes !!!!!!! Think before you leap read more

HORRIBLE BUSINESS PRACTICE. Covert way of getting patients in. Very disappointed! Lost 2 weeks of getting care for my knee because of their sneaky business practices. I made an appointment 2 weeks ago for my knee. I was told at the time they took my insurance. THEY MISREPRESENTED this. I called today to confirm my appt and was now told another story and she tried to dance around the fact that they are NOT part of the Covered California Obama care plan. I would be more than likely responsible for 50% of the bill. What upsets me the most is why didn't they tell me this upfront. The girl who answered the phone tried to play me. I now have to find another doctor and this puts me 2 weeks behind in getting help for my knee. This office seems to only care about money and not the needs of the patient. This is a sneaky way of getting the patient in. HORRIBLE BUSINESS PRACTICE! read more

I was referred to Dr Baumgarten for a knee problem and I expected him to advise surgery. Instead of just accepting my previous diagnosis, he spent extra time evaluating my problem and ordering xrays and an MRI. He advised me to do exercises that may help me avoid surgery. I was very pleased with my experience there. read more

This doctor is very unprofessional. He is very polite at the consultation but that's it. After he gets his money he can care less about u or your questions. His staff is not friendly at all. They all look so miserable and not a smile on their face. Do not complain to this doctor about his staff because he does not believe in customer service, it's all about himself and his staff. read more

Dr. Baumgarten is experienced, kind, and pretty funny. He did my mother's knee replacement and she is recovering nicely. He is quite busy and he seems to do many knee replacements/ feet surgery in a week. In fact, many staff I spoke with at Methodist Hospital had some kind of surgery performed by Dr. Baumgarten, so I trust that he is experienced. His nurses and front office staff are professional and friendly. read more

Dr. Baumgarten is the BEST!!! Now at days you don't find many doctors that actually seat and talk with their patients but he does. He is very good at what he does and his confidence makes one feel safe to be under his care. FIVE STARS!!! read more

Awesome doctor ‍Great staff and awesome surgeon. I had a big surgery to my foot/ankle and thanks to him My surgery was a success and I no longer live in pain. read more

This doctor is da bomb. There are no words to express the quality of care my daughter received from Dr. Baumgarten. Dr. Baumgarten has a great bedside manner, but, most importantly is an excellent surgeon. I also give this office staff kudos for scheduling our appointment within a reasonable time frame and faxing necessary documents back to my PCP quickly. Thank you, Dr. Baumgarten and staff! read more

He is the best Dr. I have ever had to deal with, and the staff follows suit. Yes, they are always busy but they make time to ensure that their all clients questions are answered and they are taken care of. I am 43 and had to have a total knee replacement, and I couldn't ask for better care. After the surgery the staff made sure that everything was going according to plan. If I needed to get in for any reason they would squeeze me in ASAP. As for my knee, it feels better than it has since I was 17. I have referred a few people to him and they all love his as well as the staff. I highly recommend at least giving him a chance. read more

Dr. Baumgarten has been an incredible Dr who has pulled me through two difficult knee replacement surgeries within a year. I owe him big time. If you want something done right by a Dr who cares about your outcome, then he is the man to see. He is up front and to the point, which I respect. His staff have been great, especially with their help with paperwork etc.. He has a busy office, which speaks highly to his reputation. I thank God I was referred to him read more