The kitchen staff knocked this pizza out of the park!!! They don't provide table service at this establishment but that's fine, the kitchen staff always brings out the pizza, appetizers & are helpful and even bring extra plates when they are not busy. Had the pick 3 appetizer as well, enjoyed that it was out well before the pizza so we could snack on it as we were pretty hungry. Definitely took care of the kitchen in the tip! I can't really comment on the young lady bartender, she didn't really give friendly service when we came in & went up to get our drinks, told us several times rudely there was no table service. Yes, we acknowledged that when we walked in and weren't even there 30 seconds, live in the area and saw the signs. Just wrote it off to her having a bad day I guess (shrug), it was just odd as there were only about 8 customers there...all at the bar not sure why. read more

Bell Mell Pizza - 1/26/2025 Deluxe Pizza with extra cheese on top... one of the best we've had a Bell's in years!!! - Pizza Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Best pizza in Port Clinton area. Order the deluxe, it's amazing! Though most of their specialty pizzas are also great.

Pizza is pretty good. Nothing special but also not the worst. Came out kinda burnt on a few slices. Can be a little pricey on some drinks, but they also have specials and $2 beers. Kept it simple and Ordered the sausage and pepperoni. Taste and texture wise it kinda compares to a fast food pizza, like dominos or Pizza Hut. Overall the food and atmosphere is just kinda alright read more

Bell Mell Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Value is the greatest asset. Staff was friendly and apologetic that they don't do military first responders discount. This is carryout only. No dine in service. This business is attached to the tavern. You can also order and receive food in the tavern through the pass-thru window. Two size pizzas, 9 inch and 12 inch. I found the pizza crust, sauce and cheese only mediocre. My closest taste comparison would be some I tasted at a buffet, cafeteria or gas station. Maybe it's fantastic at last call. read more

See all

Good pizza Good People When in Port Clinton grab a pizza and walk down the street and listen to the bands on the weekends

A bit of a hole in the all but excellent pizza and service. The tavern next door looked like a really cool local spot to grab a brew or drink. So happy to find local places Like this that aren't chains. read more

The place we wanted to grab dinner was closed so we came here. There was zero social distancing. They had a full crowded bar. None of the kitchen staff had masks on. There was a man set up selling Trump merchandise. We ordered a cheeseburger medium with fries, a 12 inch pizza and cheese garlic bread. The burger came out with chips they fixed that no problem. The burger was very well done not medium. The garlic cheese bread wasn't edible. It had so much cheese but it was barely melted so the texture was awful. Same with the pizza. There was a lot of cheese but towards the center it wasn't fully melted. The only enjoyable part was by the crust where the cheese was more done. The kitchen and bar are billed separate. We had two Millers, a tea, and a soda it came to $11 befor tip. The receipt didn't list prices but that seems pricey for 2 cheap beers a tea and soda.I won't be going back. read more

Some friends and I went to Bell Mell's for our night out. We were there for about a total of 10 minutes before the disgusting rap music forced us to leave. F-ing this and that, mf-er b----, mf-er dyke, etc. I asked the bartender if they would please change the station, and what I got was, "Hey, some lady out here wants you to turn your music down!" No, I didn't want it down, I didn't want to listen to such obscene "music". Nothing was done, so we left. If this is how it's going to be since the previous owners sold it, we won't be back. read more

This was one of if not the best pizza I have had in Port Clinton Ohio! One thing that was confusing tho when ordering they said what size 9" or 12" but ever where we seen it said only one size so that maybe something new I'm not sure on that. But just a heads up the 9" pizza has more of a traditional pizza crust as the 12" is more of a thin crust pizza both was really good. We also tried the macaroni and cheese bacon bites and they are a must try! Sooo Good! The cheese bread was great as well. So I would recommend this place for sure. read more

I've been coming to Port Clinton since I was a kid, and it's been legitimately a 2nd home for my family. As in, I spent weekends living there since I was in diapers. Back in the day, selection was sparse, but Bell Mell existed. It was what my dad ordered for my sister and I when we behaved. It was a treat for us and still is. We have been patrons for 20 years and will continue to do so. Some renovation may have changed it aesthetically, but the tried and true pizza they have... hasn't changed at all. It feels so warm and loving like home and the fact that it's remained untouched after all these years, Makes it even better. They have a bar with a Cheers vibe and tons of tables and room to watch OSU games. OSU games there are so incredibly fun!Thank you for being so good to our family after all these years, Bell Mell. You're our numero uno forever. read more

We were in Port Clinton and looking for pizza so we gave Bell Mell a shot based on their good reviews. Its a bar, so you sit wherever you want and order food at their food window and drinks at the bar. After you order food they give you a number placard to put on your table and they bring it out to you. It took about 15 minutes for our appetizer to come out and about 40 minutes for the pizza. This wasn't a problem because they were very busy (there were shooters from Camp Perry in town). We noticed later after most people left that pizzas were coming out pretty fast. We ordered the pickle fries appetizer and a medium deluxe pizza. The pickles came out hot and crispy and had good flavor. The deluxe pizza came right out of the oven and it was very good; plenty of toppings too. We really liked the crust, crunchy on the outside and soft inside. The staff was friendly and even though they were pretty busy the bartenders came right over if you stood by the bar. There is plenty of seating inside and outside; it cooled off due to some rain so we sat outside in a covered area. Overall it was a nice experience. If you like a bar that has good food and drinks without the typical corporate restaurant atmosphere, stop by here. read more

Pizza and a couple apps were good. Had some nice local folks, I assume playing pool yelling across the entire bar room as the rest of their posey arrived, one by one. The f-bombs and other "proper" grammar made the night. Might order pizza there again but won't be sitting in the bar. read more

They did not get the order correct and the pizzas were not very good. Two-stars may be a generous review.

Pizza = 5 stars Service = 1 star The fam vacationed in Port Clinton (not as sad as it might sound initially) and after reading great reviews for Bell Mell's pizza I decided to place an order for carry out. The pizza was great, very tasty crust and they made it to order. However, if you make the (evidently terribly egregious) mistake of attempting to ask a bartender about your carry out order, you will be shamed and side-eyed into oblivion. You will be ignored for a time, then they will look at you. Now, when they look at you one might take this as one of those non-verbal signals to initiate conversation, but when you open your mouth to utter words, the barmaid will then start talking to someone at the end of the bar (while weirdly maintaining eye contact with you). It was unnerving to say the least. After the barmaid finishes her conversation with the other person, serves 5 more tables that came in after you, and uses the restroom, she will then look at you again. Thinking I learned my lesson from the previous time she looked at me, I hesitated to speak, then was told she'd be with me in a minute. About 5 minutes later the second barmaid--who's back was to me the entire time--turns around and asks me what I need. I told her I was picking up a carry-out order and she says I need to go to the other end of the building, around the corner and they can help me. I said "thanks so much" but I really didn't mean it. The order was supposed to take 35 minutes to make and it ended up taking about 50 minutes. I was gone so long my wife and kids were trying to ping my phone to get my last location. I LOVE good pizza and this does not disappoint, however I am also a fan of decent service (excellent service is a myth). Get the pizza, and avoid the barmaids at all costs! read more

A great local bar in Port Clinton, where you will feel like a local even if you are a tourist enjoying my lovely home town on Lake Erie! This is where we stop when back home visiting, for you are always able to find a friendly face! When the weather is nice, make use of the large patio out back. Make sure you try their excellent pizza, which is great for carry out, if you are taking your picnic elsewhere! read more

Bell Mell Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

We were staying just east of Port Clinton and drove into town on empty stomachs. Looked up pizza joints and saw this place looked promising. This place is a local joint, but like other reviewers mentioned, the employees and staff are extremely friendly and great! The pizza is slightly above average, nothing to celebrate, but like I said, we were starving and the pizza went above and beyond to fill us up! Don't let the two offered pizza sizes of 9" & 12" fool you, the 12" pizza can feed two people. We ordered waaay too much! We ate on the rear covered deck and had a great time. read more

Excellent!! Best pizza in the area!! Great local establishment, friendly people and good music. Our pizza go to!

This is a great bar. Dimly lit, but not creepy. Friendly but laidback staff. Good drink selection, but not trying-too-hard-pedigreed-microbrew hipsterville. Great, varied music selection - played at just the right volume to be noticed, but not require yelling to carry on a conversation. Pizza was really good. What more could you want? read more

See all

This place is truly a hidden gem what a great pizza and wings yum did a deluxe veggie out of this world!! Thank you mike and Jimmie see you soon read more

Bell Mell Pizza - Beat pie - Pizza Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

The second time was just as bad as the first. We discovered that if you are not a "regular" in this place, don't expect good service at the bar. We were treated like the invisible men after sitting at the bar directly across from the register. The two bartenders (I think they also own this place) did not give us a warm & fuzzy feeling. No smile, no banter, just "What do you need?". But, each time a "regular" sat down or stepped up to the end of the bar to order drinks, smiling and joking were the norm. I'm ringin' the bell for this place. read more

The wings are very small, breaded and were not sauced properly. The pizza was very average at best. Please go and visit the Anchor Bar or Duff 's in Buffalo to learn how wings are prepped. The other option is to visit Around the Corner in Lakewood. 6.50 for 7 wings that are so small, breaded and not sauced is not worth the price. We ordered a large Pepperoni Pizza and I counted 3 pepperoni 's per slice. Seriously? The pizza crust was very boring and basic. However, the red sauce was great. I really wanted to love Bell Mell, but it was a real disappointment to the six people that I brought in for dinner tonight. Seriously, find a better source for your wings. Do NOT bread your wings. Yuck ! Find a better source for the dough prep. I am coming back for another visit near the end of August to determine if you took my advice. read more

This is a great bar! Capitan the bar tender makes even non locals feel as if you been there a hundred times! The prices are low and the pizza is delicious. If you are ever passing through Port Clinton Ohio and got a little time a Stop in for pizza and beer. read more

Bell Mell Pizza - Mmmm pizza and beer - Pizza Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Really good American food. We got a good mix of their menu. Good pizza, sandwiches, and starters. The waitress was a real sweetheart and took excellent care of us. We stopped in looking for a place to eat before going to the lighthouse and they treated us like we're in every day. read more

Excellent pizzas (bbq chicken on a 12" flour tortilla!..yum) and philly cheese steak sandwich. Was in the area with my son who was shooting at Camp Perry and thoroughly enjoyed the food and service. Although I went to the bar to order our drinks the barmaid came by multiple times to check on our group. Everyone was super nice and can't speak enough of the warm welcome we received. And that's saying a lot from this Alabama southern born and bred girl!! You know....southern hospitality is a serious thing!! Will definitely be back as soon as we're in the area again. I'm read more

We were seated right away the place is very clean and our waitress was super friendly. We ordered the Chicago style pizza pie. It was absolutely delicious . It was right there in the top eight pieces I've had throughout my life it was right up there in with the pizzas I've had in Chicago I will definitely come back here again highly recommended. Great experience read more

Bell Mell Tavern has the best pizza in Ottawa County. We love stopping here anytime we are in the area. We always get the 12" deluxe pizza. Definitely a place the locals hang, but always a great crowd. Live bands on many Saturday nights. read more

Meh. Pizza was ok. Nothing to get excited about but it was a nice break from everyone serving Perch!

This is a VERY local place where YOU sever yourself everything. There is a window to place your pizza order and you walk up to the bar to get your drinks. The people were very nice and pizza was great. read more

Went in with friends and we each ordered separate pizzas. When the waitress brought out our orders, I was given a sausage pizza when I really ordered a vegitarian. The waitress tried talking me into taking the one she brought out, but I told her I really wanted the vegitarian. The waitress, offering no apology, told me that if I wanted vegitarian pizza, it was going to be 45 minutes or so, because, in her words "Now there are a whole bunch orders that are in that will be ahead of yours". My reply was to just give me a refund and that I will never, ever be back due to their horrible customer service. So if you are in Port Clinton looking for pizza, I would try anyplace other than Bell Mells. read more

This is a wonderful no frills bar with extra wonderful pizza. Great service, great prices, great food! Do yourself a favor and come here when you are in port clinton read more

Ordered wings with sauce on the side and they were outstanding !! Grabbed a large pepperoni with xtra cheese it to was very good !! Lastly I ordered a Deluxe with banana peppers and it was the bomb !! Great job on the food and the service as well !! I will definitely order again !! Thanks Bill read more

It doesn't get much better than the pizza from Bell Mell! I will eat pizza about 3-4 times a year, so when I do, I want it to be excellent. Bell Mell did not disappoint. I'd recommend this place to anyone going up to the Sandusky/Marblehead/Port Clinton area! read more

Huge downslide since we visited last summer. No longer a "family" place, unless you want to introduce your kiddos to really colorful, really inappropriate language. We heard one patron call the bartender a douche-bag bitch. Food was fine, but one in the party who ordered pizza got their order a full 15 minutes before the rest of the meals came out. Seems like the beer selection is more limited. We remember at least one bottled beer last year that they no longer serve. read more

Frendliest staff ever! Great food. Section family can sit in e en though it is a bar. If I lived here this would be my neighbor bar. Owners working with staff which is awesome. read more

Sorry. Pizza is a personal choice but I'm not interested. Breaded wings, garlic parm. Yes they were good.

The pizza was mediocre at best. The new owner definitely has his work cut out for him, hope he can so something with the place.

I been coming here once a year for the last twenty years. They're always helpful and it's a great time. From the owner letting use his home printer to print Cedar Point tickets. To meeting Simon and Garfunkel. Plus having the best pizza around. It's a historic monument. A must see. Enjoy! read more

I agree this is an excellent bar. The pizza is better than any of the big three. The ambiance and friendly employees and patrons make it worth sitting down for a beer at the bar. I'll be back. read more

BEST garlic cheese bread I have ever had anywhere. tons of cheese and butter with side dipping marinara sauce. Pizza great too.

Had supper there last night. The pizza was the best I have had in years and the beer good and cold. Also the wings were great. If you like wings and pizza, this is the place to go. Service was also excellent. read more