Bellmore Country store is a small Amish run grocery store that also sells fresh made sandwiches to order. We found things that you can't find at your local grocery, such as Amish cheeses, fresh churned butter and Amish meats. I also bought canning supplies and picked up a few pointers on new easy canning lids.
We also ordered sandwiches on fresh made Amish bread. Sandwiches are under $4 and you select your meat, cheese and toppings. I had a turkey sandwich and the bread was so soft that it melted in my mouth.
I couldn't walk by the pastries without buying a fry cake - black raspberry to be exact. The shelves were filled with cream filled pies, cinnamon bread and cheese breads. My fry cake was delicious coated in a sugar glaze.
They sell everything from bait and fishing supplies to salt for the water softener.
The staff is friendly, though quiet. They do not accept credit cards or any form of electronic payment. We paid cash.
There is plenty of parking, including space for your horse and buggy. read more