There's a lot going on amidst the reviews of Dortoni, but I want my own write up to really focus on the here and now and the bakery aspect of this place (which by the way, is quite good). My wife and I have been here a few times and found Dortoni to be delightfully delicious. Well, for the most part. On our first trip we tried a whole bunch of different baked goods (pastries, cookies, crumbs, cakes, etc.), though one thing we were excited about was their take on the Dubai chocolate sensation via the form of a cake. Unfortunately, it kind of missed the mark, but if you take that snafu aside, everything else at Dortoni is fantastic. For instance, my wife's new favorite dessert is their cheesecake waffle cone (which is exactly what it sounds like). For me, I loved the key lime bomb which was out of this world. There's just a great selection of stuff here that makes you curious as to what they'll have each time you enter. Beyond the baked goods, I will say the staff has been super friendly. Both visits they were helpful, gave suggestions, and (though it was close to closing) offered us some rolls free of charge. It doesn't take a lot to make you feel welcome and they do more than that which is nice to see. Perhaps you won't see what is nothing more than a few tables inside this small spot that you can sit at, but I wouldn't say this is a horrible turnoff. Yeah, maybe Dortoni isn't your bakery/cafe that's going to be a place you stay and enjoy your goods, but it's definitely worth some items to-go. Overall, Dortoni in Port Jeff earns a visit. There are other locations (perhaps even one closer to me) that I might have to check out, but even if I do, I'll at least know that the quality and service in PJ is top notch. I'd gladly return here in the future (and I probably will knowing my wife's new obsession) and you should too! read more

Super cute spot but not really a sit and drink coffee kind of place. It's more of a takeout or perhaps specialty cake establishment. Cappuccino not the best. The foam was very thin and watery. read more

See all

The one particular woman working was not just indifferent but openly rude, dismissive, and argumentative. She actually refused to serve me and gaslit me that it was my fault. The other woman who stepped in could not have been more nice and accommodating. You all just lost a very loyal and long time customer. read more

First things first, their customer service was phenomenal. Thank you to the girls that helped us pick out a cake for my brother in law's birthday this evening. Such sweethearts. One of the girls gave us a sample of their hot chocolate and I was blown away. Delicious! Highly recommend when you're in port Jefferson station. I stopped by earlier today for the first time and right off the bat I was intrigued by their selection of cookies and cakes. I have a major sweet tooth and I had to get my mittens on their raspberry tart cookie, I know there's a different name for it but lol so amazing. Freshly made cookies! For my brother in laws birthday we choice the much chocolate cake with the cannoli filling. I was totally in heaven! Absolutely remarkable. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Raspberry cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Great delicious baked goods. They even had quick grab wraps. Beautiful location across from the Long Island sound on west Broadway in the village of PJ. I often tell My new residents at The Shipyard apartment complex to try them out. Everyone agrees it's so good,convenient and close by. read more

terrible. Go to Rolling pin. Worst muffin, worsh carrot cake and most expensive . Forget it.

My absolute favorite bakery on Long Island (either location!) The best loaves of bread (we go for the sourdough), the best cakes, and the BEST black and white cookies. Always fresh, always delicious. Especially when we're going out of town to visit friends or family, we love to bring something from Dortoni to show them the best baked goods that the island has to offer! I stopped by the Port Jeff bakery on my way to the ferry to CT, picked up a loaf, had a friendly conversation, and basked in the early morning bakery smells. Highly recommend! read more

Dortoni Bakery I am very disappointed with Dortoni in Port Jeff. I have lived for many years in Nassau County and have always purchased cakes from Dortoni in Levittown for so many important occasions, baptisms, communion, birthdays, ​​and more! I have relocated to Suffolk County and was so happy Dortoni opened up their Port Jefferson location, which is close to me. I am planning a small 2nd wedding and requested over 2 weeks ago, a cake tasting for my fiancé and I and still have not received any response back from them. I gave them 2 weeks and then followed up again with them and still no reply. It's really ashame since the other competing bakeries in the area not only replied back right away but we even had our tastings completed with them. I really wanted my fiancé to have a tasting since he never tried Dortoni before but again very disappointed with their lack or no care customer service! read more

Celebrated 50th anniversary at Danfords, Port Jefferson. I had in mind what I wanted and they were able to accommodate my request. Cake on top of cake tier with cup cakes with white and gold decoration. It look so pretty and best of all tasted wonderful. This was actually what I wanted and address a unique touch to our celebration. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Sesame rolls we purchased were stale...very disappointed we received day old rolls that were hard in the center. Service was fine, cleanliness was good. Rainbow cookies, cheese danish and butter cookies were ok, but not nearly as good as other bakeries on the Island. Cakes in the case looked good, but did not get to try them. There was a woman returning a tiramisu cake she purchased for a birthday party in front of us saying she was very disappointed with the presentation of it. read more

See all

I had placed an order for my sons graduation party for a simple cake went over it with the lady and everything seemed good to go I paid that day(200$) for not that big of a cake. I returned a week later to make a small change on his name the young women was a great help and changed what I requested. I come to pick up the cake and the piping on top and bottom was not what I requested and the name was the original not what I requested. After expressing my concern the young lady asked me if I'd like to change it, but then the cake wouldn't look right and could mess it up. I will not be going back to this bakery after spending so much on a little cake because the baker or whomever wrote on the cake could not follow direction. and yes my contact number was on the paperwork but I received no phone call for any misunderstanding read more

Great selection and service... and delicious! Purchased blueberry strudels ( large!) and apple strudels- will go again

Visited Stony Brook and stopped by for quickie cheese cake. Relied on brand name from other stores in Long Island. Reliable. But smaller inventory here read more

Absolutely the best bakery with the best service and customer appreciation. I would highly recommend this place

I have been a loyal customer of downtown Port Jefferson Bakery for over 20 years dating back to when it was La Bonne (same owners). During the Holiday season (Thanksgiving - Easter) I always bought their outstanding Italian Grain Pie ( Pastiera Napoletana ). Unfortunately, this year it was made terrible, instead of the wheat/grain being mixed in a smooth consistency with the filling it looked more like a layer cake with the bottom half a mixture of grain and filling the the top half only filling. I went back to the Bakery twice to question them if this was an unfortunate mistake or is this the "new" way of them making it. Both times they stated that is the way it is made. In fairness to the Owners if they read this review hopefully they will verify that it was a mistake! I will say that all of their other products are still outstanding and hopefully they will address this unique Italian delicacy. read more

Got a chocolate cigar and iced chai before class, staff was beyond sweet and it was so yummy even had almond and oat milk. This place is truly a gem read more

The bakery made it such an easy process to taste and place our wedding cake order. The cake came out exactly as expected, beautiful and had a few guests compliment how delicious it was (vanilla cake with raspberry filling and chocolate ganache). read more

Dortoni Bakery - a bride and groom cutting their wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

The most delicious Italian cookies I have ever had in my life. I am not is cookie person - but these were beyond delicious. Everyone was raving and kept coming back for more - this is my family who also doesn't indulge in sweets too often. I dream about these cookies! read more

Dortoni Bakery - The most delicious cookies!!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Dortoni Bakery you have a customer for life! We ordered a custom cake for my mother's 70th surprise birthday party. The day before she tested positive for COVID. Not even a full day in advance Dortoni Bakery was able to accommodate us by canceling cake and doing it the following week for NO CHARGE! This is amazing customer service. Yesterday we finally had her party and the cake was AMAZING. I can not tell you how many people commented on how pretty it was and how good it tasted. THANK YOU DORTONI BAKERY!! read more

See all

Audrey went above and beyond for my little 9 custom cookie order today. Thank you , you made my day!! I love this bakery and drove to Levittown from wading river many times to get cakes. So happy they are local in PJ. I greatly appreciate you making my order important even though I'm sure it's insignificant for your daily sales. I will always be a customer because of that level of care...thank you again!! read more

The cookies taste like sand and the pound cake should've been called a pound bread.... As you can see, my husband and I could barely eat this... read more

Dortoni Bakery - Dortoni bakery cookies and pound cake - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

If you've never been wowed by a cheesecake before, you will here, formerly known as La Bonne Boulangerie. This little bakery can be easily missed if you're driving too fast down on main street, as its tucked away between a larger building and Chandler Square. As you walk into the bakery, you're hit with a sweet smell that takes me back to my childhood and captivated by the amazing displays of cakes and treats at the front. They showcase their amazing cake making/decorating skills which almost tempted me to place an order, but I came for the cheesecake. You know its good if you buy a cheesecake for no special occasion. ***Highly recommend you call ahead because they can run out*** We called ahead so we had a cake on hold for my friends and I. This cheesecake is very similar to a japanese style cheesecake from my personal experience. It isn't too sweet and the cake itself is dense but also soft and light in taste. It almost feels healthy because of how mildly sweet it is, which is perfect for me. The fruit on top is incredibly fresh and secured by a soft egg custard, giving this cake a creamy texture on top. After this first cheesecake my friends and I actually went back two more times the following week for the cheesecake with fruit and the cheesecake by itself. Both are amazing and pretty cheap for what it is. I believe one cake was around 28$ and it could easily feed 10 people. Their cannolis are also to die for and piped fresh. They're small enough to enjoy without feeling like you overindulged. (5/5) Amazing! Highly recommend you try this :) if you're ever in the area. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Cheesecake with Fruit - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Dortoni Port Jeff 125 W Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 IF YOU CAN DREAM IT, THEY CAN CREATE IT One of Long Island's most beloved bakeries for over 45 years, Dortoni prides itself on serving the finest in wedding & specialty cakes, European tortes, Italian pastries, fresh breads, and classic American desserts. Review: (5 out of 5 Stars) Clean bakery and friendly staff. My sister and I placed an order for my parents 30th anniversary. From placing the cake order to picking it up, everything was made easy. The cake looked beautiful, and it tasted delicious. Definitely give them a try. And as always don't forget to say Bismillah and Alhamdulilah for everything Not a Halal Bakery read more

See all

Oooof when i say I'm disappointed- wow. I mean it. Did this place change owners? I don't remember LaBonne being this awful. But i could be wrong. A distraught individual brought two cakes in for a birthday party and I was in disbelief it came from Dortonis. But now reading all these comments- it makes sense. The work is sloppy. The sheet cake did not have sharp edges and the frosting was not smooth. You couldn't take 2 seconds to run your smoother under hot water to make sure the cake was smooth? The rosettes look rushed. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Not straight edges & air bubbles in the buttercream. This is not professional - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Recently I had the worst experience in my town bakery. It started by them weighing my cookies directly on the common scale, no paper in between, no box. When I questioned this practice the response was " this is how we do it here" I have never seen this before and worried about this cookies being contaminated etc...I got home only to find out the 2 types of cookies I requested weren't in the box. when I called the manager she was rude , unprofessional and acted like she shouldn't hold that position. Finally , she led me to believe that she would make right on a bad situation. I drove all the way back to the bakery only to find out she wanted me toRepurchase the cookie types I ordered that weren't even in my order. Again unprofessional. Now i have cookies under unsanitary conditions and in a time where all of our health is at risk. Paying for cookies on a dirty scale is not reasonable or safe read more

If you like your pastries heavy... The hot cross buns were small, dense balls of compact dough. Tough and over-baked. I know buns are not an Italian thing, but why sell them if you can't bake the them? The croissants are terrible. Heavy, with a strange, artificial flavor. The sfogliatelle look impressive with the lamination, but the pastry is literally sharp, it's like trying to eat razor blades. Also a very odd, artificial flavor to the filling, like aftershave. Really a shame. read more

We visit Dortoni often the have the best chocolate raspberry cake with chocolate ganache. Everything is always fresh and yummy. On our last visit unfortunately service thanks to Vanessa was less then desired. She was rude, pushy and seemed to be bothered by us asking about a few items. ( they bakery wasn't busy...we were the only 2 customers) I quickly turned my $80 order into $15 and went elsewhere. read more

It was absolutely disgusting and embarrassing that I bought pastries to bring to the hospital for the patient and staff to find out it was filled with mold !!! After waiting extremely long for the order to be ready, I was hoping it would at least be fresh . I called to complain and they offered to refund me if I came back down. It's not the point, I'm so embarrassed to be giving these out to people in the hospital. read more

See all

Those gorgeous occasion-decorated cakes are awesome, but this shop creates a sponge for every birthday cake that is like no other I have ever tasted. Just come down and order a dulce de leche cake and you will be amazed and the hero of whoever's party it is. Trust me, this is special. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Wow, this is a unique sponge. Best I've ever tasted! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

I have spent a lot of money at this place for custom cakes, and will now never go back after my encounter with a manager there. After booking a custom cake months in advance of the day of service, and agreeing on me bringing the decorations for the cake a week beforehand so they can decorate the cake, I am told with a huge attitude that the policy has changed and they no longer do this. I never recieved a phone call telling me this, or any kind of communication, and was left thinking they would decorate the cake. The manager proceeds to tell me that I have the picture and to go decorate it myself, and that they dont have to update me on anything they do. After our lovely conversation she then tells me that she can take it the day of and they can decorate it. I thankfully did not trust her and said I will be back with the receipt to get my money back and go elsewhere. When I go back I am told this is not accurate and I would have been left with a non decorated cake the day of the party. Extremely unprofessional, rude, disgusting, and extremely disrespectful in front on my 2 year old, and other people in the bakery. I will never recommend this place again, and will make sure people in the village know what I went through. Unacceptable. read more

Terrible service. Went to order a wedding cake. We were the first people to enter and told them we wanted to order a wedding cake. Counter person went to get the woman who was going to help us. We stepped away and let the next person in line order. The cake woman came out and took an order from that person. We stood there for 15 minutes watching the "cake lady" discuss his order with a look of disgust on her face the entire time. Not once did she smile and just appeared angry. I was reluctant to go in to begin with because friends of ours were telling us how inedible the deserts are. We were going because it was convenient. Bad mistake. We told them we were leaving, nobody cared. The woman who is in charge of the cake orders is just miserable! She's tiny and wears glasses. We will never return! read more

Horrendous experience. They charged me $65 for a cake that looked nothing like what I ordered. They refused to help me in any way after even agreeing that it didn't look like what I ordered. Apparently the cakes you order here are made in Levittown and then delivered to Port Jeff for you to pick up. One of the owners names Corey was so unprofessional.. he wouldn't even call me back. He had one of the girls from the bakery call me to tell me that he said they don't offer refunds. What a joke. I can't see them surviving much longer if they continue to provide such disgusting customer service. I will never come back to this bakery again. read more

Dortoni Bakery - What I ordered. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Was in the area and had a pasterie craving. The selection was great and the staff friendly and helpful. The hardest decision was which delicious looking item to buy. I got two whip cream eclairs which were totally delicious. Dedfinetly would go again if I was in the area. read more

See all

They had a name change for this place, I've been coming here for years for all their baked goodies. I stopped in on Saturday to buy fresh breakfast croissants. All of their breads are wonderful, its really a nice community bakery. Their breads are great but if you really want to impress, get a cake/pie and bring it to your neighbors house for some coffee. If your in Port Jeff and going to New England via the PJ ferry, swing by and get some goodies for the trip. If it were me? Go to Pindar on Main St, buy a bottle of Winter White and a fresh quiche at this place. Now eat on the ferry in front of those punk asses that brought on their Venti Starbucks thinking their hot shit. Oh yeah baby... read more

Omg butter cookies are Amazing. And the coffee hits the spot. Great job. Hate the stairs going into the bakery and very small once inside but well worth it. read more

I think they are cheating at Corn Muffins as well. These things are soooo delicious with just the right amount of corniness and texture. They are my newest favorite. I don't know how they do it, and I'm trying to recreate my own in their mold but it evades me. Whatever they are doing with Coffee Cake and Corn Muffins is working for me on more than one level. You should let it work for you as well! read more

Dortoni Bakery - Yellow coffee cake. See the raspberry jam? - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

sunday I bought a lintzer cake to bring over my girlfriends bbq and the cake was horrible. It tasted like chaulk, no taste. My first time there . So expensive. I will never go there again. read more

A real class act. Maybe if they put as much time into their quality control as they do reading yelp reviews and marking them funny--their cakes may actually be edible. read more

Dortoni Bakery - Real classy owner! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

I'm so sorry, but this pastry shop is horrible. I used to come here years ago and it was good. The last two times I came, the pastries were so bad I literally had to spit one out. I really want to like this place, it's so close and convenient. But Rolling Pin Bakery will remain my go to unless Dortoni does some serious soul searching. I honestly don't know how you can screw up pastries. I'm not even holding them to high standards, the pastries were completely inedible. Glad to see someone is enjoying themselves here, we must be in two alternate universes. read more

In this case, you can judge this book by it's cover. It is a quaint, free standing building located just up the block from the Bridgeport Ferry. The inside is just as pretty. Their pastries and cakes are phenomenal! Thanks to this establishment for doing a stellar job on the wedding cake as well as all the other delicious cakes and pastries for our son and daughter in law' s wedding. Everything was absolutely delicious! read more

Dortoni Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York