I'm guessing the 5 star reviews are from family, friends and locals; although if this review was for just the staff it would be a 5. Everyone was so helpful and polite. It seems like this place is run by a few barely post pubescents and I actually couldn't be happier about that. It's refreshing to see some hustle out there!! The restaurant itself is very cute and cozy with a fair amount of seating. The exterior is fairly unassuming and not typical of the pie joints we see in New England. I'd say more Italian bistro decor. There's plenty of parking and it's easy to get to although a little off the beaten path. The food was good, but nothing was outstanding. It came out super hot and fresh and that helped enhance it a little. The cutlet in the chicken parm was fresh and was thin without being overcooked; which can happen sometimes. The Neapolitan style pizza was serviceable and as good as you'll find in this area. I'm glad I found Bennys on Yelp! Rounding up to 4 stars because of the staff but it's probably a 3 if based on food. read more

Benny's Restaurant and Pizza - Small pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Casual, family-friendly restaurant serving pizzas and a variety of other Italian dishes. Food is always fresh and service is always with a smile. What else can you ask for? read more

See all

Great pizza, yummy. Definitely will be coming back. The staff are also great people. Great space for hanging out with friends.

We found Benny's on our way to the mall. Decided to sample their pizza first. We're glad we did as we thoroughly enjoyed their Meat Lover pizza. They also offers a good variety of sandwiches and Italian dishes as well. Staff was friendly, and service was fast. It seems to be family owned and operated. At the time of our dining, interior was well decorated for Halloween, which gives a nice touch for the season. They may not be the best in the area, but they do provide a quality pizza at a good price. read more

Benny's Restaurant and Pizza - Halloween decorated dining area. - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

The manager was great and contacted me this morning and offered a refund. He was extremely nice and apologized for my order not being correct. It was much appreciated read more

Looked for a quick pizza and pasta spot for lunch in the Poconos and we were not disappointed! Quite literally in the middle of nowhere it seems, but we ordered a large pie with pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers which was perfectly crisp and generous with toppings. I live in nyc so I feel like I'm a pretty good judge of a ny slice and this was great. We also ordered a penne ala vodka which was kid approved. I did feel that the penne dinner order could have been bigger but flavor was good. Great spot to visit! read more

Good pizza ! I got the plain pie and a sweet chili chicken ranch pie both very well made! I'm a pizza maker and I'm very picky about what I eat lol but this is definitely my new go to spot! read more

Benny's Restaurant and Pizza - Sweet chilli chicken pie and a plain cheese - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Ordered from here several times during our recent stay in the area. The pizza is good, service is friendly and quick, and the restaurant is clean. read more

go there often the food is always awesome. It's a great place small gatherings, and the staff is extremely friendly.

Once again catered from Benny's for New Years Eve party. Food was fantastic. Guests were impressed as usual. It also gives my wife a chance to spend more time with our guests. Highly recommend Benny's for pizza, dinners and catering an important events.. read more

Party Trays .. if you're wondering about ordering party trays from Benny's, this is my experience .. in general, party trays usually come in half or full sizes, and approx 2.5" deep .. however the party trays from Benny's are half that depth, a much shallower pan, therefore you're actually getting much less food (for the same price) than if you order party trays from other places. We also ordered party trays from Catty Corner and Sam Owens for the same event, which were the normal depth. The food from all locations was very good. read more

Always enjoy eating here at our annual gathering of friends each August. Pizza delivery by Polak was fantastic, speedy and called us ahead as requested to let us know he was on his way se needed to meet him at our gated property entrance. Also dined at the restaurant, and while our waitress wasn't that knowledgeable about the menu, e we were able to figure it all out. Chicken Parmesan dishes with both tomato sauce as well as the "not on the menu" version with Alfredo sauce were all fantastic. The homemade Alfredo was really incredible. I just wish this place would get a license for beer and wine. But 5 starts overall from me both on delivery and dining in the restaurant. Looking forward to next August! Maybe the Boss Man will finally stop by to say hello. ;-p read more

See all

The food is amazing! Service is good! And location! Defiantly try the plain pizza and garlic knots!

Best pizza and Italian restaurant in the area and the state probably. We were staying at Camelback resort coming from NJ and decided to stop by for dinner. We tried the pizza and pasta dishes and everything tasted fresh and delicious. It was better than any family pizza place I've tried at my home state in NJ and I've tried many. The service can be slow at times but the food overall was worth the wait. Restaurant has a nice, cozy, friendly atmosphere. The only downside was the parking lot which was unpaved and you need to avoid potholes when parking. read more

I never leave Yelp reviews but I have to recommend Benny's for takeout. We ordered a lasagna pizza, a cheese and pepperoni pizza, garlic bread, and a Greek salad. It was a great value and very tasty. The staff was very helpful and gave us a military discount. highly recommend! read more

I was pleasantly surprised coming here. I was not sure what to expect from the outside, but am happy I decided to try this place out. We tried the pepperoni pizza and there was a nice spice to the pepperoni. Unfortunately very greasy pizza, but when I wiped off the grease it was pretty decent. read more

I love their zeppoles It's very good but i don't care too much for the pizza but i'll come here every week for the zeppoles!

I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza at Benny's! The restaurant itself has plenty of parking and the interior decor is nice and quaint. We ordered 3 pies: plain cheese, pepperoni and a custom pie with 5 toppings. The plain and pepperoni was good but the custom pie had way too much cheese which made it very difficult to eat. Also, the chicken cutlet they used was definitely old and more fried instead of breaded which is what you would typically expect. Overall, the pizza was pretty good. For some reason, they won't provide spices on the side if you pick up. I found that pretty odd. Also, looks like it's a one man show doing everything there. Maybe that's Benny?! read more

The staff is always Pleasant! The food is delicious and fresh! Super close to me. Good to have around. I like that the pizza never taste too salty! Great job guys! read more

The food is fresh just not much taste for me. Everything is just a little under seasoned, I like them but I'm not too crazy about it

Spending a long weekend in the poconos when we got the craving for some chicken parm. My expectations were measured as I am a snobby New Yorker and also of Italian decent, but we gave it a shot. The crew of guys working there were friendly and recommended the calamari. I was even more skeptical about ordering fish in a place I didn't yet trust, but the one guy insisted so I figured why not. Everything was incredible, but what tied it all together was the sauce that came with the calamari and mozzarella sticks. Honestly some of the best sauce I've eaten. I recommend this place without pause!! Good job, Benny's! read more

The pizza was amazing and friendly service. The menu has some pasta dishes I am looking forward to trying and it's got a sweet dining area. Right on 715. read more

A great regular stomboli and the italian hoagie was also great i also got a cannoli zeppolis OMG awesome and regualr cannoli also very tasty read more

Not only did I have to wait for inside while my order was apparently already done the meat on my burger was undercooked

Service was incredibly slow. Pizza was just ok, slightly undercooked. Been there a few times in the past but it seems to have gone downhill since. Crossing it off our list. read more

First time experience here was a good one! Small inside but very clean and comfortable. I ordered spaghetti with pesto and shrimp, and received penne. The server acknowledged the mistake, I stuck with the penne and it was very good. The meal came with a salad and bread, both very satisfying. I also had a plain slice that definitely impressed me. Service was very good. The staff seemed very friendly and appreciative of the business. I will definitely return here again, motivated to try other menu items. read more

Benny's Restaurant and Pizza - Penne pasta with pesto sauce and shrimp. - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Delicious pizza with good kind service. My family and I stayed at Great Wolf Lodge 2 wks ago, and we were so hungry after our road trip. This restaurant is only 10-15 mins away and worth the short drive for good pizza and great service. read more

Fresh and tasty foods!! Pizzas are fantastic, but we love their sandwiches, too. And the fried raviolis?? Totally worth you money and time. Support family and small businesses!! read more

Yummy! Delicious food, great service! Calamari melted in the mouth and garlic knows myself were gobbled you immediately. Everything was awesome! read more

Fresh fresh fresh!!!! Stopped here for dinner by recommendation and were not disappointed!! Alfredo sauce was homemade and flavorsome....my 10 year old couldn't stop raving about it. My 9 year old said the mozzarella sticks were perfect, and he devoured the pizza. My husband got a German stromboli, mini size, and it was HUGE!!! Slight longer wait, but sooooo worth it!! read more

Nice people, but the burger I got was barely cooked at all, would not recommend eating here

Great food at a fair price , Benny's never disappoints , there cheese steaks are the best around and they deliver

Love their pizza. I live nearby and order often. At the beginning of the Covid 19 pandemic, Benny's was doing a fantastic job trying to keep staff and the public safe. I was impressed and felt comfortable ordering take out here for myself and my pregnant wife regularly. However, the last two times I ordered, NO ONE was wearing a mask when I entered to pick up my order. The person who took my money did not have a mask on, nor did the staff preparing the food- who can be seen from the pick up counter. It's disappointing as this has been one of my solid go-to pizza places. read more

The food here is fantastic!!!!! We've been a handful of times now and have tried everything from the subs, to the mouthwatering eggplant parm. Mozzsticks to calamari and the salads. Everything is fresh and made to perfection. We are excited to see them opening a Benny's 2 a little closer to our house as well. Can't wait to try there as well. Always kind service in and quick for take out! read more

Eating in or take out this is the spot to eat! Ike and his crew always make you feel welcome and remember you after a few visit. The pizzas great but the garlic knots, fried ravioli and chicken Alfredo is where it's at. Probably one of the best pastas I can find around here. YUM! read more

Benny's Restaurant and Pizza - Chicken Alfredo w/ Penne Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

I just wanna say I was very satisfied with Bennys pizza. This is my first time coming up to the Poconos for vacation so I decided to take the kids and my wife out somewhere nice and so thankful I choose here. Such great workers and a wonderful owner. read more

This is THE BEST place EVER!!! Calamari was absolutely PERFECT!! everything was super fresh, family atmosphere and you can taste the love in the food..... Can't rave enough about this place!!! read more

Bennys might be slightly off the beaten track, but MAN!! They at so worth the trip! The food is delicious! The staff is very friendly and courteous! I am so happy I followed my instinct, and tried them. I will be back and will probably order more than this time! Everything is on point! read more

The pizza was excellent! The meat and sauce were both very flavorful and the crust was very good. All five of us in our party thought the pizza was great! read more

I have decided to try a Benny's Pizza I thought Ingredients was fresher than some of the pizza places around. Keep up the good work. Thank you for a decent pizza. read more