Very nice place to have a good pizza or a make your own. The service is very friendly. There is…read moreenough seats for a large group or for two.

It could be worse. I've seen worse prices for less in terms of size but given that this is inside…read morea waterpark hotel, it's decent. It's a three star within that context but a 1 star compared to your favorite pizza place. Don't be fooled by the size of the box. It's about 25% smaller than the size so that was a sticker shock. The meat pie didn't have enough meat per se but just enough to call it a meat lovers pie. You'll get about 1 pepperoni per slice ... again it could be worse.

Good food and friendly service. Busy, but the food was worth waiting for. Compared to Camelback…read moremountain food, this place is serving Michelin Star food. Glad we found it.

If there was a 3.5 option that's where this would land. Tried a "chili cheese" dawg and a plain…read moreslice. Chili cheese is in quotations because this was not typical. I would have ordered it regardless and I ended up enjoying it, but I was just surprised. The chili was more of an Italian style chili with a hefty flavor of tomato, and the cheese was like shaker bottle parmesan cheese. The bun was a split top white bread style that they would serve in New England. The dog being $6 was more than it should have been, but businesses in this area are always up charging with camelback right there so I expected it. The slice was solid. Good flavor and I asked for it cooked well done and it was crispy. Don't recall the cost of the slice. This used to be Tony's on the Mountain but the pizza didn't taste the same so I'm assuming with new owners came a new pizza maker. All in all it was good, not great. To see the video on this location and hundreds of others I've eaten at and reviewed, please check my social media pages here - https://linktr.ee/Didnt_Suck

I'm guessing the 5 star reviews are from family, friends and locals; although if this review was…read morefor just the staff it would be a 5. Everyone was so helpful and polite. It seems like this place is run by a few barely post pubescents and I actually couldn't be happier about that. It's refreshing to see some hustle out there!! The restaurant itself is very cute and cozy with a fair amount of seating. The exterior is fairly unassuming and not typical of the pie joints we see in New England. I'd say more Italian bistro decor. There's plenty of parking and it's easy to get to although a little off the beaten path. The food was good, but nothing was outstanding. It came out super hot and fresh and that helped enhance it a little. The cutlet in the chicken parm was fresh and was thin without being overcooked; which can happen sometimes. The Neapolitan style pizza was serviceable and as good as you'll find in this area. I'm glad I found Bennys on Yelp! Rounding up to 4 stars because of the staff but it's probably a 3 if based on food.

Great pizza, yummy. Definitely will be coming back. The staff are also great people. Great space…read morefor hanging out with friends.

They were open later than the other places, near the resort, and wallet friendly. Service was…read moregreat, food was ok. Do not bring your water bottle inside, you must order a beverage there if you are thirsty. Kids loved the lasagna and split it. The portions are substantial. Chicken parm over pasta was huge. If you want to spend less money I recommend getting a sub. The eggplant parm sub was only $10 and huge.

Good local pizza spot…read more The food was fresh and the staff is very friendly. Try the garlic knots, they hit the spot.

I ordered 2 salads to go. One was a Cobb salad the other was an antipasto salad. Neither were…read moregood. The Cobb salad the breaded chicken was over cooked and dry, bacon was deep fried and had the flavor of the oil plus over cooked, cucumbers size of a quarter 2 pieces and they were old and dried out, didn't see any tomatoes and a hint of blue cheese crumble. The antipasto was rolled ham and cheese 2 cherry tomatoes 2 pieces of salami and provolone. Not worth the money. Sorry to say but I won't be going back. Definitely not what I would serve someone.

Ordered an upside down Sicilian pizza and an Extra cheese Sicilian and OMG - it was hard to smell…read moreit on the drive home and not eat the entire thing!!! First time I've had an upside down Sicilian pie and it's delicious!!!! Service was great and the place is jamming! Very comfortable place and very nice employees.

Great pizza and great prices Stayed at Kalahari and their…read morepizza was too overpriced Yours was perfect will be back !

Stopped in on Labor Day, as most places were closed, so it was my first visit. Very pleased with…read moretheir excellent veggie pizza and greek salad. I had ordered ahead, and when I walked in the door at the appointed time, the order was there waiting for me. Will be back!

Decided to check out a pizza place while near the Poconos. This place was very clean and the pizza…read morewas freshly made. They were closing up for the night so unfortunately we couldn't eat in the restaurant. I overheard that they have delivery services as well. The bread was freshly tossed which was cool to see. Then the guy put it in the oven. We got a medium which was big enough for me and my bf. I really liked the use of mozzarella cheese on the pizza. The jalapeños added a kick to it. It seriously looks like a good family owned business.

We ordered their Monday special - 1 large pizza, 12 boneless wings any flavor , 12 garlic knots and…read morea 2 liter bottle of soda for$28.95 Service was kind and fast. Garlic knots were delicious and boneless wings were great, pizza was bland, no flavor and taste like rubber.

My niece and I were hanging out in the Poconos. She wanted to get some pizza. She looked up this…read moreplace and my goodness she made a great choice. I had a meat lovers calzone and she had a personal white pizza with broccoli. We both give this restaurant two thumbs up and a five star rating. If you have an idea of what you want to eat, mention it to the waitress and they really try to accommodate you.

Although it's a stretch when the big sign overhead touts 'NY Pizza', I'm from here and so, not used…read moreto what NY pizza tastes like but I liked their puzza! My white SLICE tasted great with a thin, crispy crust. $3.79 The chicken Buffalo slice was fully approved by senior. $3.79 And because we like to try different restaurants' version of a cheesesteak, opted to add mushrooms, ($10.99), we both agreed it was substantially satisfying. Both Alli and Danny greeted us and helped us with order. Ciao, until the next time we return to try other specialty slices. Maybe even an Arancini ball!