I can only speak on a single slice that was a re-heat and I am due to return and try out some more stuff. I stopped in December of 2021 so as you can see, it's been quite some time since then and I need to get back up there and do a re-visit. The guy behind the counter was pretty much a typical pizza place employee...not what I'd call "friendly", not unfriendly...just adequate. Maybe 6-8 tables inside but mostly geared towards takeout. So a slice and a soda was over $6, so that was a bit concerning out of the gate, but I don't just based on stuff like that solely. I enjoyed the slice. There was a nice char underneath which I love, good snap to the crust, it was nice and thin, good cheese to sauce ratio. Not much else I can really say about it other than I'm due to head back in. If you're just looking for a slice though, Brother Bruno's - DIdn't Suck! read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - somehow the only photo I got here - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

Conveniently located. Good food. Large portions. Nice interior. Clean interior. Nice staff.

They make a good Pizza. There cheesesteaks have very little meat in them. Haven't found a good cheesesteak in the Poconos yet. Place is clean and they are friendly. I will be back, not a lot to choose from up here. read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

Staying in Kalahari. Place is 5 min down the road in an outdoor mall. We got a large pie & chicken francaise. Pizza was solid. Chicken was a large portion. It wasn't amazing but it was far from bad. 6/10 I swapped out pasta for broccoli and added $2 upcharge. If you aren't in the mood to overpay at the water park, it's a solid spot to grab some normal price grub. Brother Bruno's - in! read more

Great pizza, very nice people, pricing is good. Placed an order, picked it up, was still hot when I got it home. read more

Their pizza is really good and is really consistent with their pizzas. Their pizza is pretty expensive but if you get it once in a while it's great for a party or just for you. The place in general is a little boring but still nice. The service is really good. It's really nice people and fast in making their pizzas. In conclusion, the food it's great and have never gotten a bad pizza when I go there. 100th Review! read more

Best Food in Pa. Fresh.More than you can eat at once. There is a full Menu. Prices are good. Don t leave Northeast Pa without stopping to eat there, you will be back for more. read more

I came here with my family at night for a pit stop. The interior looked a little dark, the food on the counter didn't look very fresh and there were some flies around the food. Service here was prompt and the price range was decent too. I had the regular and vegetable pizza. Both were really good choices and filled me up for my trip! read more

It may look like nothing. I will tell you great pizza and garlic knots to die for. It is a simple place low key But Been there a long time And especially on weekends are busy. Worth the try I Wei's plaza . read more

A little whole in the wall but the food was actually pretty good. Lettuce was crisp and fresh for my salad. The food is super hot though... 20 minutes later it was still steaming. The tomato sauce was slightly bland but the bread that came with the pasta is really good. The owner Giuseppe is really nice too. Overall good value for the money and pretty good food. Open later that a lot of other local places which is nice too. read more

Day one of by 2022 Pocono Mountain Adventure. Today, I just arrived at my AirBnB. The homeowner provided a list of the top nearby restaurants, and he said Brother Bruno's pizza is the best in town. I decided to put his claims to the test and ordered a medium plain cheese calzone, a Sicilian pizza with pepperoni, and a mushroom with meatball Neapolitan pizza. The crust for the mushroom and meatball pie was pretty good. However, you can see that the mushrooms seem pretty underdone in the photo. I like them charged and browned, not pale. Meatballs were okay and the price was fine for the area. Also, I wouldn't call this a Neapolitan pizza. Neapolitan is more soggy, saucy, and has a very specific definition that this clearly doesn't meet. Mercurios is Pittsburgh is real Neapolitan. I don't understand why they call this Neapolitan because it definitely isn't, and they know that. 2/5 The Sicilian was decent. The portion was large and the pepperoni was pretty perfect. Not too oily, flavorful, and big. There was an ample amount of cheese. It's bready, but that's what I expect with Sicilian. Pretty pricy though. Overall, a 3.5/5. I try calzones at almost every pizza place I order from. The calzone here is quite good. It's not too bready, not too greasy, and a great size. Again, a bit pricy, but not terrible for the area. You can expect most things to be pricier here. It's loaded with more ricotta than most places I've visited. Very good calzone, but the marinara sauce is only okay. 4/5 What brings this place down a bit for me is the fact that they forgot my calzone, which took about 10 minutes to remake. No big deal though. It's clearly family own and run. Everybody is an authentic Italian! And it's super popular with locals from what I've seen. My only knocks are that the prices are pretty high and the Neapolitan isn't actually Neapolitan and overall I don't recommend that pizza style. It would be a 4 star review if I only had the calzone. The place is good, but maybe try some other shops near it. read more

See all

I love their pizza. The penne vodka is great! The food was hot. I would go here again.

Terrible customer service. Ordered two entrees and a sub. Get home to an entree missing. Called and was told come back, no charge for missing entree. My husband got there and was accosted to pay for the entree. Besides that, the vodka sauce has absolutely no tomatoes despite the menu stating tomatoes and cream sauce. They deserve zero stars. Never again! read more

Stromboli was good. Customer service poor. The guy taking the order acted like I was inconveniencing him. I was tempted to not even return for my order. read more

The pizza wasn't bad but their customer service and clean standards are TERRIBLE. The person running the register is handling the house phone, cash, the register and pulled out his mobile phone; then proceeds to pull slices out on the window. Not sanitary at all. read more

Ordered dinner when we were in town with some friends. Pizza was good, the meatballs were big and reasonable, the star deduction is for the wings-they were dry. Would order pizza again when in the area. read more

Great pizza. I picked it up on the way home from work and forgot to take the picture before we already ate a few slices. Unfortunately, we live about a half an hour away in Gouldsboro so it didn't stay hot but the smell in my car on the way home was amazing. I love that the use sliced sausage instead of the crumbled type. I grew up on NY pizza growing up (I joined the Army in 1983 and haven't lived there since). Trust me, this is real NY pizza. The garlic knots were awesome too. Nice olive oil mixed with garlic and parsley. I highly recommended Brother Bruno's. read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - Take out that we heated up on our pizza stone. - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

Being from NY we try to find NY style pizza when we can. Brother Bruno's is NY style pizza. We ordered a plain pie. It was hot and delicious. The staff were pleasant and polite. This will be our go-to pizza place when in the area. read more

Fresh mozzarella pizza was great. Service is meh and the pepperoni slice of pizza that has a wire in it was....... Ummmm nearly fatal or certainly very dangerous read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - Piece of wire in blue - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

A great family owned and the pizza and food is consistently always good from the pizza hero's pasta dishes etc

Love this place. We come on a regular basis. My wife and I always get the Brother Bruno's Special. The Bother Bruno's Special has chewy crust, never a "soggy bottom" and just the right ingredients for the perfect Pizza. So happy to find amazing Pizza. Soooo Good. I honestly have had the best pizza I have ever eaten here. read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

Normally like the pizza here, we've ordered numerous times. Tonight I ordered one cheese pizza and one half veggie half extra bacon. The cashier and about 3 other men didn't know the price they charge for extra bacon so they're all trying to figure this out while we're waiting to pay. No biggie, maybe the cashier was new. Idk. But we're charged for the extra bacon only to come home to no bacon whatsoever and the half with veggies on it was so limp it was hard to even pick up... We came out to pick this up during torrential downpour so we won't be coming back to get it corrected tonight, but that's really disappointing since we're hosting family and didn't get what we were expecting. We usually like the food but to be charged an obscene amount for it and not get what we paid for doesn't make us want to come back at all. read more

Brother Bruno's Pizza - The super soggy and limp half veggie, half "extra bacon" pizza we ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania

Found this place as a referral from someone else. Ans it was overall a Nice pizzeria! Wonderful waiter helped us with ordering and was thoughtful for our large group. Food came out fast and fresh! Has a couple Sicilians slices & pasta dishes & those wings are really good! Will consider coming back again!! read more

Unfortunately I discovered this pizza place on the last few days of my month of work in Mount Poconos. The pizza is fantastic. I'm usually only a Pepperoni and cheese pizza guy, but I tried their sausage pizza and it was amazing. Thin sliced sausages which were packed with flavor. I would definitely recommend again! read more

We were at Kalahari and DID NOT want to buy pizza from them. Not really worried about the price, we just wanted better quality. Instead we found Bruno's through Yelp. definitely a better choice! Unfortunately I called them bc it said they deliver... but they didn't. So I decided to pick up. Crust was an acceptable average, cheese was above average (not acidic tasting or greasy.) Toppings were not on the skimpy side. The place was dead, and the guys at the counter had extra time to chat with me. $36 for two pizzas, and half doz knots. We live in NJ were we have 3 awesome and amazing pizza places a mile away from us. And we were pleasantly pleased with the pizza we ate tonight! There was no online menu to be found so I added pics. I doubt they change it. read more

See all

I would highly recommend. On a trip passing through the area and checked out yelp for a place to eat. This restaurant didn't disappoint. It was quick and delicious. We walked in and picked from a few pizza's and calzones that were made. They heated up a sausage and pepper calzone, a slice of white pizza and a mozzarella and pepperoni roll up. Everything was delicious. Tone of people were coming in to pick up pizzas to go. read more

Brother Bruno's has some of the best Italian Recipes and will modify your requests. I go wild over their marinara shrimp Parmesan. The marinara sauce instead of the regular sauce is my go to. When dining in with out of towers, everyone raves, usually New Yorkers and my sister family from the Midwest. Its like Luna on Mulberry Street and the even have The best Sicilian slices! Go, just go and "Joe" will treat you right! Ricky from IVREAL ESTATE. read more

Fair Pizza. Prices are too high for what you get. Service is fair to poor - a bit arrogant; tolerable for an excellent restaurant but a real "put off " for a mediocre one. No matter. I've found a better one just West of this place on Rt.940... read more

very good, thin sliced pizza with a section to eat in, one of the best around mount pocono area

With the family at a nearby water park and got lucky finding this place while on a Walmart run. Ordered a fresh pie and it was delicious. My review may be biased based on the amount of crap food I've eaten at the "resort" I'm staying but this place really hit the spot. No frills / NY style pizza that was better than anything else I ate while in the area. read more

I make the effort to visit here every time I'm I'm the area. Staff is always so nice and the food is to die for. Not to mention you can get a massive salad, garlic knots, and a slice of pepperoni for under $10. Not much to complain about there. read more

Pizza was expensive and tasted like the oven wasn't cleaned in years. It was very greasy and tasted like rubber. For the price of 2 slices. I could have purchased 2 small pies for $10. read more

My husband and I ordered spaghetti with chicken and shrimp. Waiting about half hour to 45 minutes. Paid $50 left and got to our place to eat. It was breaded shrimp and chicken! What would make you put breaded chicken and shrimp in spaghetti??? Grilled chicken and sautéed shrimp would have been ideal. The spaghetti had no sauce on it. It was very disappointing and a waste of gas and money. Too much money for plain spaghetti and breaded chicken patties and breaded shrimp. Yuk. So very disappointed. Do yourself a favor and Do Not Order Spaghetti From this restaurant. They make whatever they want for you not what you ordered. Disrespectful and trifling read more

Worst service ever! Waited an hour for one cheesesteak, a regular cheese slice and one pepperoni slice. A lot of people came after us and received their order before ours. I kept asking about the status of the order and the girl at the register was not helpful. When I asked again telling one of the guys we've been waiting an hour. His reply was, "I know." No apology or effort to find out what's going on with our order. Finally, the elderly man gave our food and apologized for the wait and said someone must've took our order. Nice gesture to apologize, but he blamed another customer for taking our order, wasn't it your mistake that you gave our order to someone else?? Never again will I give business to this dump. And I'm from NYC, I understand the pizza and food isn't as good here, but I tasted better pizza. The pizza was mad oily, and the cheesesteak was meh, not even worth the wait! read more

Ordered $40 worth of food. 2 hero's & a chicken parm dinner w baked ziti & salad. Unfortunately, I trusted the order was correct. Big mistake! I drove 20 min back to my hotel, in the rain, opened the bag found 2 hero's & spaghetti w a salad (no dressing(requested ranch)). No chicken parm!!! WTH did i pay for? I called & they told me to bring it back & I'd have to pay more money! Does that make sense?? So, he found my order & told me to bring back the spaghetti & swap it out the next day!! So inconvenient, especially for a family that was expecting to eat. I had no food to eat, but i made sure everyone else ate. This killed the mood when we found this out. Really unfortunate for a traveling family. Now I know never to go here again & won't recommend it to anyone, unless you want to waste your time going back & forth trying to correct an order. read more

I really like this place. Not really a place to go out for an event but food really solid. In a small place service good with young attentive staff Touch of scicilisn mafia about the place including some authentic pictures of (I assume) relatives "T he Godfather?simply tastes better than typical Italian food. Not so much as an event or food hole but just great value and if you fancy it a great choice. I usually go lunchtime and always the same. Plenty of seats and worth a visit if you want something to hit the spot. read more

Terrible pizza... the pizza wasn't the correct size so they folded it in the box The regular place I go to wasn't opened so I thought I'd give it a try. Um no. read more

I LOVE this place. It took my months to find a place out here where I liked the wings. The wings are their star player in my opinion - someone said they were dry in the reviews below, so I felt compelled to say I get wings here probably twice a months, and they haven't been dry once. They must have had a rare hiccup! I like the margherita pizza thin crust, cheesesteaks and wings the best. Only thing to note is that their Neapolitan pizza is not the kind most people are thinking of, so just be aware of that. It's still delicious though :) Oh their garlic knots are so good too, completely drenched in raw garlic...mmmm read more

I work in a large resort and people think our pizzas are overpriced. I paid $24 for a 16-inch meat lovers at Brother Bruno's and the pizza was just okay. Our pizza at my Resort which resorts are notoriously expensive. Our pizzas and 18in meat lovers pie for $23 and not only is it bigger and cheaper it's also a real New York style pizza and is better quality. So to cut it short I was not impressed at all and it's overpriced Show less read more

Yo, I'm from New York--straight up! First time visiting a pizzeria in Mt. Pocono AND Pennsylvania. First time first time. Anyway, walked in there, place was full of good vibes, atmosphere was welcoming so no issues. Some mutt decided to act like a child and raise his voice to the friendly waitress about why he couldn't have the corner seat(while people sitting there eating). So, minus that bullsh*t. Food was good! Calzone, SMALL, slamming. Fried calamari? Jeezus! Was good! That garlicky zesty spicy sauce it came with. DOPE!!! My manz at the counter was telling us that good food take time so I was like Ight no problem. Beer selection was also on point. Big bottle Budweiser's, Fat Tire, Becks, Yuengling, Bud light Platinum, the works!! Will order food here again, no problem! If I'm in a rush, I'll call HALF AN HOUR ahead of time so it can be all good. Peace and love! read more