Due to my mother living now with me in another state, It was very necessary to rely on an auction…read morecompany for furniture, kitchen items, etc. After signing the agreement for them to sell items, communication became very difficult. We had an issue on the items from the main auction. It did get resolved but it was not easy. I thought good it's done. I thought that would be the end of any more auctions. Since I was not made aware of any future auctions. I received an alert of an upcoming auction. This happened to be a second auction that combined some of my mother's items along with 2 other people's stuff. Once I all of my mother's jewelry online, I was shocked. I had informed them before , that the jewelry needed to be put aside. I had made arrangements with a friend to bring them to me. Therefore, I had to sign up on the online auction and buy all of her jewelry back and make arrangements for a friend of mine to pick up the jewelry and ship them to me. I believe now that I should have returned back to Ohio and oversee all what was done. Overall a very stressful experience.

I bidded on several items. Infact like 20 or 30. I was expecting to win around 10 or so. When I…read morefound out I only won 1 item. They wanted me to drive 45 minutes to pickup a 4$ item. I told them no. They told me to pay or be banned. I offer to pay shipping they said no. This auction site is NOT on the side of the bidder. I am not paying for an item I don't receive. Intact the more I think about it, the more it sounds like extortion. There is no reason they can't offer shipping. I am not driving 45 min away to get 1 item and at that spend gas and time on it.

My family has bought from Garth's since I was a child, and now that I'm in the antique + vintage…read morebusiness, I am now a buyer here as well! Their eclectic variety from Victorian and folk art to mid century modern and decorative arts is well curated. And their new location in the Municipal Light Plant in downtown Columbus, Ohio is stunning! Fun industrial historic brick built building with high ceilings, exposed beams and even the old control panel. Helps to display their collections for auctions in a much more modern approach than any typical auction. Highly recommended for any dealers, collectors, decorators or home owners! They don't disappoint!

I consigned a number of quality items from my downsizing. Many months after the auction and well…read morebeyond the contractual date for my proceeds check, there was no contact from Garths. No summary of sale. Nothing. I began to call the various numbers I had for them. No one answered. None of my 14 calls were returned. This was the definition of a dead zone. I stopped by their warehouse where I was told to call their office. I filed a lawsuit at the county courthouse. That got their attention along with a proceeds check. Gosh that was fun.

I have known Seth since early in his jewelry career, and he really knows his stuff. He is…read moreremarkably knowledgeable and well connected in the jewelry and watch industries. Seth's attention to detail is, well, extreme, and as a little aside, he is also brilliant at *photographing* the jewelry he handles--another of his passions. He's a straight-shooter who I'd trust to handle any sale, large or small. Seth has helped my wife and I multiple times; in one case he was excellent at at advising on a watch that ended up being perfect for me. I highly recommend working with him.

I had an older Rolex GMT that I was no longer wearing, and decided the money would be better used…read moreelsewhere. I got a few offers from local jewelers, but I felt they were a little low. I met with Seth in his office and felt comfortable the whole time, without feeling pressured to sell. Seth wrote me a check for more than what the other jewelers offered. I will be seeing him again when I decide to sell a few of my other watches.

I went to this business because they have shed all over the property for sale. the lady that's…read morealways there said she would email all the information to me on prices for what I quoted I wanted. I called there and left messages at least a half dozen times and never received the information email or a return call or the quotes prices or anything that was specified

I was sad to see Dutch Kitchen go, but I'm very glad that the building is being put to good use…read more Old 42 is associated with the auction house in Plain City, and they lease space to antique vendors with high-quality items. They just opened and are still filling things in, but there was a lot of nice furniture at decent prices, some odds and ends like ceramics, train schedules, etc., and a few books. It's not one of those dusty places with crappy trinkets tossed on tables- this is nicer stuff, but still affordable. There are half a dozen rooms, and it's an interesting building so it makes for fun wandering. I'll have to bring Sweetie next time we're in PC.

Nice antique market in the Ohio expo center. There were a lot of vendors with plenty of stuff. We…read morehad a good time and found a few things to buy.

Terrific shopping experience for most any item you can imagine. Great selection of antiques and…read morejewelry for a good value. Nov and Dec shows are perfect for holiday gift scouting.

Company changed model data of item that I bid & won (at an inflated price). "Justin" (owner) will…read morenot return phone calls, text nor emails. The automated purchase/delivery software does not allow the winning bidder to correct erroneous delivery address. After a series of phone calls with the software developer, VM (4) to "Justin" requesting an address correction and now more than 10 days later and the purchased item still states "Pick-Up" tag printed. However, the criminal act of changing the product description and model after my bids without notification to me. As a former Federal Officer, I find the actions an ethical violation and one in which I will follow up with the department of Consumer Affairs for Ohio. D.Lewis - Carmichael, CA

Owner pronised a month before my move that he would come to get my antique dining room set. Every…read moreweek I called and he continued to promise but said his truck was in the shop. Hmm. Then on Facebook he shows all the things he just unloaded from his truck a week before my move. He never came and began ignoring my daily phone calls leaving me stranded. Don't trust this man!!!