Big City Pizza

Excellent food, and friendly staff. We were tracking through and stopped for lunch. Greater with a…read morefriendly face at host stand. Service prompt and everyone was so kind. Burgers fresh and I had kettle chips. Sit outside, the view is nice.

Wow! These burgers were wonderful! Very flavorful, and you get what you pay for, a big, juicy,…read morestacked sandwich cooked to perfection. Little crunchy edges, and juicy in the middle. They weren't stingy with the toppings either. Homemade chips, juicy burger, good size portions - and VERY reasonable prices - couldn't be better. Now, our waitress Kayla was wonderful too! Kayla laughed and smiled with us, knew the menu, and her service was wonderful! If you go there, ask for her! We ate outside on a beautiful day on the lake. Just a fun, nice place to eat!

FUN staff!

All American smashburger

See all

Storefront for Flippin Cow

McAlister's Deli

3.9(36 reviews)

0.7 mi

My wife and I love McAlister's. We always have friendly…read moreservice, quick service and it's always right the first time. My wife hates cucumbers, they always take them out.... The tea is ALWAYS fresh and tasty. The prices are way better than Panera this is the reason we go here instead of the other place. We really like this place. I do think that they changed the cherry shallot dressing though. The place is always clean too. I really like that too. Great place!!

We ordered their French Dip with broccoli cheddar soup and potato salad. Plus a Chicken Salad…read moresandwich with potato salad. The French Dip was dry and chewy without any cheese. Bummer since I have had one before and was good. The Broccoli Cheddar soup was absolutely fantastic. The potato salad was good but the potato chunks were harder than I liked. My wife had the Chicken Salad sandwich which she devoured before I could take a picture. LOL......which she said was fantastic. I'm not saying we were not going back just not getting the French Dip. All in all we will return.

See all

Jimmy John's

3.4(13 reviews)

0.6 mi

A very friendly JJ's location…read more I ordered on the app and went through the drive thru to pick up. The employee at the drive thru window was personable and cheerful. I had ordered a #6, chips and a drink, and also potato salad. I had been curious about this new side, and it was very good. The potato chunks were firm, not mushy. It tasted fresh and had good flavor. While I didn't go inside, the exterior was neat and the landscape and parking lot were clean and free of litter.

Honestly this was our FIRST TIME ordering from JJ. We downloaded the app. Made our order for 6:30…read morepickup. We ordered two Tuna subs and one Roast Beef with Cheddar cheese and potato salad and two Oatmeal raisin cookies. Got to the drive-up at exactly 6:30 and everything was ready. Drove home and everything was just as we ordered. The tuna sandwiches had half the tuna salad as we'd usually get from Subway but had a lot more flavor. The potato salad was perfect. The Roast Beef with cheddar was delicious. Our only complaint was that the Oatmeal cookies were over baked and dry. We will be back!

Spicy east coast Italian!

See all

Smokin' Fattys BBQ

4.1(206 reviews)

0.2 mi

Our waitress, Madison, was AWESOME! Super attentive and provided great recommendations. We had the…read moreribs and brisket - half lean and half fatty. She recommended the glaze for the ribs and it was excellent. She recommended the Cole slaw since she made it and it was excellent! Mac & Cheese was good too. Great ambiance, great food and great service! Thanks Madison!

Was in the area with some friends and stopped by for lunch! The place is very clean and the server…read morewas very nice! 3 of us got wings with sides and I was told they were delicious and the Macaroni and Cheese was really good! I got the lunch special with pulled pork, smoked chicken, along with the smoke potatoes and a chunk of cornbread. The cornbread was sweet and delicious! The house sweet BBQ is really good too! The smoked potatoes were cooked beautifully but had no flavor or smoke taste. The pulled pork was very dry especially on the ends as if it was microwaved but with some sauce was okay. The smoked chicken though tasted just like smoke and the texture was very off almost like a microwave rewarm as well. Our server was super nice about it though when I mentioned it. Overall the place is very clean but it wouldn't be something I go out of my way for.

Love the decor!! Vibrant and unique.

Rib tips (kids menu) Follow me on facebook: currently called: MY Choices

See all

T'd OFF

3.8(4 reviews)

4.0 mi

A bit late posting the review. Excited to try T'd Off because of how much we loved the former…read moreTemper Grill. We came in for dinner after making a reservation. There were four of us. Started off with the cheese curds. Well, they aren't really curds in the normal sense. The are creamy cubes of cheese breaded and fried. We really liked them. Different to say the least. I love meat loaf. I was really happy to see that as a menu choice. That was my order. It was good, but the glaze topping was really sweet. Almost too much. And the loaf was not dense at all (good thing!). My wife ordered the Chicken Bau buns. The first one she bit into was undercooked. Zero problem getting that replaced by a very polite and apologetic cook. Other entrees were the hangar steak (excellent) and blackened shrimp salad (also great). Finished off with a chocolate crème brûlée. Wonderful. Service was wonderful. We did not ask for anything because of the undercooked chicken. Our server removed it from the bill anyway. That's how you know a restaurant cares and wants you back. And we will be.

Wow! We heard good things about T'd OFF, but it was even better! Every bite was delicious. If…read moreyou're lucky enough to get Hannah as a server, she'll explain that food is served hot with know heat lamps, so food comes out as it is made (like tapas). Great for sharing! Incredible food and a very casual atmosphere. Highly recommended. We will be back for sure!

Meat loaf. Really good, although the glaze is really sweet.

The simple menu. Sometimes that's all you need!

See all

Chicken Bau Buns. Yum!

Simonton Lake Drive-In

4.2(76 reviews)

0.8 mi

We love taking the family to have sandwiches and root beer floats for a special treat! Food has…read morealways been delivered promptly, at the appropriate temperature. The largest size root beer float is the size to get! We feel good supporting a local business and the industrious young people serving! A fun summer tradition which we recommend!

Not sure about some of the negative reviews. We always enjoy Simington Lake food. The root-beer…read moreburger is great and the chili dog kicks. Fries and onion rings are always great. Food made to order. I bring along plates because it helps. Recommended.

See all

Chili cheese dog, root beer in a frosted mug, shoe string fries, pizza burger

Chubby Trout

4.0(558 reviews)

0.3 mi

These guys have the best chips and ranch that I've ever tasted in my life. It's magnificent ranch…read more Rosemary ranch? We were seated right away. I'm glad they were open a little later than average. I was delighted to eat a smoked brisket burger. That thing must've been 6 inches high. It was a monster. My sweetie loved the fish tacos. They have an amazing wasabi, mayo sauce that goes with them. The middles split a prime rib Mac and cheese. They described it as "real American food" with a smile and a twinkle in their eye. That means it's delicious. It's actually a bacon prime rib, mac & cheese, and they don't even mention the bacon because the prime rib is so good. Very filling. I took a sample and it is probably the best tasting meat augmented mac & cheese I've ever tasted. The smokiness just does something amazing there. I like the background music. I like the barn, Midwest, rustic ambience. It was a delicious experience. I had to share about it online with some Japanese folks because of their recent enthusiasm for American "cheese violence". I asked if that magnificent burger qualifies as "meat violence".

I finally decided to try the Chubby Trout tonight…read more I was greeted by a couple of friendly and smiling faces at the door. I was Seated right away and introduced to my waitress, Taylor, immediately. Taylor deserves special accolades. She was so friendly and caring; she made my dining experience special. Thank you Taylor!! Taylor was awesome; she was friendly, always checking on me and sincerely concerned about my satisfaction. She was willing to do anything to make things right if I wasn't happy with something. First I ordered the Crab Cakes as an appetizer. Then I ordered off the specials menu; a Japanese spiced Branzino dish. The crab cakes were somewhat disappointing. Mostly filler and not much crab taste. Sometimes the taste actually resembled a tuna fish sandwich. The remoulade sauce that came with the crab cakes was really tasty. I wasn't really happy with the branzino dish. The fish was cooked pretty well, but "in my opinion" It had too much seasoning and the seasoning had an off flavor. Could just be my personal tastes. The restaurant has a lot of seating, little nooks and corners and a bar with seating. Plenty of quiet areas and areas to gather as a large group as well. Even though I didn't have great food choices today; I'm pretty sure while I'm in town this weekend, I'll go back and try some different dishes. See you all soon!!

Volcano roll

See all

Penn Station East Coast Subs

2.9(19 reviews)

0.6 mi

Ordered 10" hot club and small fries just now and it was awful…read more Unhappy cashier made the fries and instead of slicing one of the 10,000 potatoes in the cage behind her she dug around in a tub to find the smallest fragments of what were once fries. Not one over an inch long. Dirty kitchen floor and flies. Was a big fam of PSEC but steer clear of this one!

This establishment boasts clean restrooms and exceptional subs. I greatly appreciate their support…read morefor children with disabilities, and I can confidently say their subs are the best in the area.

$13. Chicken teriyaki. The bitten off part is currently in the trash and I wasn't about to dig it out for the pic. Absolutely disgusting.

See all

Grilled Italian with hand cut fries

Culver's

4.2(30 reviews)

0.5 mi

Ordered the cod sandwich...it was bland, tasteless and definitely not worth the money. Also, not a…read morevery big fillet but the bun was huge. The fish gets lost. The fries were good as was the diet root beer. Service was excellent!!

Absolutely amazing food and service. Food is hot and delicious. Please try the jalapeno cheese…read morecurds!!!!! They are super fantastic!!! This truly is an item I would hope and dream they would keep on the menu!!! They are absolutely delicious

Nice addition to the patio

See all

Old Style Deli

4.4(51 reviews)

3.3 mi

We decided to come here for breakfast while waiting for an oil change. The staff was friendly and…read morethe place is quaint. They had a huge board for their lunch menu on the wall which I thought was neat. The hangover breakfast was great, and I liked that they actually had my favorite bread; pumpernickel. My wife got the gordan hamsey which was not bad. It even came with a side of horseradish. Never thought about that for an omelette... But it works! Hope to be back soon!

Efficient service with a smile. The cafe is attractive with its old fashioned tile and ceiling…read more Love the huge chalk menu. Had a breakfast bagel sandwich. Bagel was fresh, bacon was crispy. Oh and they have Diet Coke!

Gordan hamsey

See all

The Lydia (veggie) - add turkey and avocado

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Faheem S.

0

9

0

2 years ago

Im a big pizza fan so it didnt take much to impress me, that being said the staff are super polite and the food is really good! Bathrooms were a horror movie but thats the only complaint I can make! read more

Sheila G.

0

1

0

6 years ago

I have been here several times and just love the pizza!!! The staff is super nice! This is now my favorite pizza place! Elkhart, IN

Kayden N.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Spiro Lambrou is the best pizza maker out there. This pizza is goated. Best pizza in Elkhart no doubt

Paul S.

62

170

491

6 years ago

Nice spot great pizza awesome. Visiting Elkhart otherwise this would be my hang out. Chicago pizza.

Big City Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Big City Pizza also viewed

Papa's Pizzeria

4.2

(15 reviews)

By far the best pizza in Mishawaka. Reminds me of Chicago South Side pie that I grew up on…read more Ask for it to be square cut. Their sausage is delicious. The cheese pizza is just like my childhood that came up to me and smacked in my face (get the cheese pizza -well done). Nice job guys.

We went here based on other recommendations here on yelp, boy was this a disappointment…read more Pizza was really salting tasting, sauce was too overly spiced, if I wanted tons of oregano I would have dumped that on my pizza, that's all,I could taste, no tomato, no cheese just salt and oregano. We were starving so will eat it not to waste. Papa johns is better and cheaper. Really

Bourbon St Pizza

4.4

(5 reviews)

Perhaps not the best in the area or even the best on the strip, but better than most food chains…read morefor the area. I had a hand tossed pepperoni extreme which was full of oil, a thin crust bacon and mushroom with less oil, their Buffalo wings with ranch and their famous breadsticks with cheese sauce. The pepperoni extreme pizza had far too much oil for my taste, but the flavors were very much on point. There was some spice along with cheese that didn't quite want to stay on the pizza when I went to separate my slices. The thin crust bacon and sausage pizza had less oil and a wonderful crust with the same cheese situation as the other pizza. I imagine either pizza would be great for a party with alcohol. That's not to say it wasn't delicious because it was, but when it comes to pizza I have to be a hundred percent honest. The wings were less crispy than I prefer, but with a flavorful explosion. The meat also falls off the bone easily which is a plus for sensitive teeth situations. I must say flavor is the one thing these people are doing right over here. I just hope your stomach is young enough to handle it. Next I had their famous bread sticks with cold cheese sauce. The cheese was nothing to brag about, but the breadstick had that brick oven flavor that many people enjoy. I'm not sure if it was a combination of oils, but once I started eating my first breadstick, my stomach began to rebel, as if to say I had done something seriously wrong. I would like to see what else this place has to offer and a very much suggest visiting this establishment, but I must also add that there are other options for those of you with a sensitive stomach.

Great pizza! Toppings just right, and can be a small enough pizza that everyone can get their own…read more Thin crust (crispy) or traditional hand tossed. I've learned they use Grande brand cheese which is top of the line fresh soft mozzarella. Perfect for pizzas and reheats next day great. They have a great variety of options for toppings and predesigned pizzas. We just found this place a week ago, and have been 3 times! Addicting, plus they are quick to cook, and even a text when your pizza goes into the oven! Fun and helps with pickup orders.

Luigi's Pizza

4.2

(62 reviews)

My boyfriend ordered a pizza late night on Christmas Eve, I was so grateful they were open. We…read morecarried out and the pizza was piping hot even after we got home. The crust is almost like a cracker, nice and thin and crispy. It was very cheesy which I also enjoyed. Circular pizza pie with square cut slices. The only thing I didn't love was their pizza sauce. It's a bit more acidic and sweet and tangy than I'd like. Not my favorite, but also not bad!

The food is unforgettable--but the friendly people who work there make the experience even better.read more

Barnaby's

3.5

(219 reviews)

Phillip Robles is the best! Always smiling and courteous. Delighted that he greets us so warmly…read morewhen we come in.

I really missed Barnaby's after moving out of Chicago!…read more Ambiance: This Barnaby's look the exact same as the ones in Chicago. It had the dark rustic wood interior, and beautiful heavy wooden booths and tables. I've never been to Germany, but it kind of reminds me of the traditional German bars I see in history books and online! Service: Like all Barnaby's, this place is counter order only. Once you place your order and the pizza is ready, they will bring it to your table. If you're customizing your pizza, expect about a 25-35 minute wait. Food: The tavern style pizza wasn't as good as I remembered...but it was still pretty delicious! I loved that we can customize and add our own toppings on the pizza.

Bambino's Home Pizza

4.5

(2 reviews)

got the four topping thin 14" with onions, bacon, olives and sausage. Tastes delicious!! topping…read moreportions are really good. needs a bit more sauce though. wings are good. but definitely not deep fried. definitely will order again!

My husband and I were passing through town and wanted to grab a pizza to take to our hotel room…read morewhen I looked on Yelp for pizza places near our hotel. I saw Bambinos on Yelp and it had a five star review (and I liked the name of the restaurant) so we ordered two pizzas. Both were delicious, but the only thing I would say is that I would like more sauce on our pizza. When we picked up the pizza the man at the counter was very friendly, showing us the pizzas before we left to make sure they were right. We would definitely order pizza from Bambinos again!

Massimo's Pizzeria

3.1

(38 reviews)

The Alfredo was fresh and ready and also for warning it is VERY HOT and the was delicious the…read morepepperoni pizza was one of the best pizza I had ever had I will be a returning customer

Pizza was terrible crust was like not prep correctly it tasted terrible and we got breadsticks and…read morethey didn't taste same as crust on pizza so I'm sure I should of just took it back but I won't comeback for that garbage

Halls Kitchen

4.0

(8 reviews)

My wife and I are big fans of Halls Kitchen's pizza. Today, I decided to try their Turkey Club…read moresandwich. Their app showed the sandwich with stripes of bacon and tomato slices. It looked very appetizing. Unfortunately, when I opened the box, the sandwich looked nothing like the picture. The bacon was in bits that looked more like diced ham than bacon. The tomatoes were also diced instead of the full slices shown. Overall, both the taste and presentation was about average. As I was eating, I kept thinking the sandwich reminded me of what I would pick up at a gas station. The service was fast but a number of tables were dirty and no one came out to clean them while I was dining. Unfortunately. This visit was nothing special and what I received did not match what was advertised.

I've ordered pizza here many times and then tried the pasta. Everything is made well, portion size…read moreis adequate, ingredients taste fresh. I've yet to be disappointed.

Danny's Diner

4.2

(9 reviews)

I was in Lagrange for work and found this gem of a place on my map. I had the club grinder and it…read morewas the best sandwich I've ever had. I went back the next day and had a pizza, that was also delicious. However, their strawberry banana milkshake was so good that I want to go back just to have that. The service was great, the girls are sweet and make you feel like you're at home. Will make it a mission to go back.

This is a nice place to stop in for pizza. It's located on the main street in town. It's in an old…read morehouse with a deep porch for eating outside. Order at the counter and it is brought to the table. Our usual order is two 7 " pizzas and a side salad with drinks. Our pizza orders vary but all have been great. The crust is bubbly and crisp! Average cost is around 20.00

Jimtown Pizza

4.7

(12 reviews)