We had a large Hawaiian. The crust on the bottom was very very chewy. The sauce had no flavor and the cheese was too much and over powered the rest of the items. The ham and pineapple really didn't have any flavor. On a scale of 1-10, since we value the taste of a great pizza and try different ones all across the USA. We give this a rating of a 4. Not the worst we've ever had, but definitely not the best. We won't be getting any more here! read more

Really friendly service and delicious pizza. The restaurant is one of the cleanest I've ever been in. Prices are fair. Ordering online is very easy. Thanks! Yum! read more

Big disappointment at Big City Pizza. We ordered the Deep dish Chicago style. The crust was so damn hard we had to use a steak knife to slice into mouth sized pieces only to chew and chew and chew to get it down. Then once the cheese cooled the whole pizza set up like concrete. Their sauce has a lot of a tiny out of the can flavored taste. Don't waste your money ordering. read more

My wife and I were visiting Eklhart from Arkansas for a family event. Whenever we visit Elkhart, we stay at hotels within walking distance of Big City Pizza (BCP). This was the first time we had noticed the pizzeria, and we were anxious to try it as we love supporting "mom-and-pop" businesses. I formerly owned a New York-style pizzeria and have high standards for legitimate and respectable pie. BCP did not disappoint. Upon entering, we were greeted and welcomed by one of the owners, who was genuine and friendly. The business was 30 minutes from closing, and several parties came in to order simultaneously. Yet, the owner asked each of us if we were dining in or ordering to go--definitely a customer-focused business owner. As a former pizzeria owner, I asked her many questions about the ovens (she has the best, IMHO), process, and ingredients. From my experience, what she indicated she uses is definitely the best. As it was almost closing time and we were so close to our hotel, we ordered to go and waited for our order. The owner was friendly, visited us during her tasks, and had delightful conversations with us. She exuded pride for what she had her husband establish and maintain despite getting the keys to their property the same month that COVID hit. What a testament to their dedication, resolve, and resilience in maintaining a successful business in the face of that challenge. The pizza was perfect. The crust was delicious, with great texture and flavor. The sauce was tangy, with the perfect spice balance. The cheese was just the right amount to complement the crust, sauce, and toppings without being overpowering. We also got a chicken parmesan sandwich, which we highly recommend, with a generously sized baklava for dessert. We were pleasantly surprised by how affordable the prices were, how good the food was, and how generous the portions were. This place is a bit hidden, so we would have been here on previous visits had we noticed it. I will tell you, next time we are in the Heart City, we will return to Big City Pizza! read more

Upon ordering on the phone I thought it was a good sign that they estimated their time for the food to Be ready for pick up in 40 minutes. I arrived at 35 minutes with my order ready to go. My cheesy bread sticks were cheesier than I expected with cheese inside and out. This was a nice surprise. Just nothing I could eat every day, despite my love of cheese. Next I tried Chicago classic pizza. What I was expecting was a deep dish pizza. What I received was a regular home page crust that appears to be hand tossed with a nice mild flavor of Italian seasonings. Flavor I quite enjoyed. Next was the NY pizza with crust exactly like the Chicago style. Again it was not what I was expecting, but the flavor was still there. Along with the oil. Perhaps a bit too much oil, at least for me. Next was my San Francisco Salad because I can't eat pizza all day and be okay. I didn't receive any silverware to eat my salad with, but I also didn't ask for any. I assumed it would come with it. Luckily I brought my own silverware. The salad was delicious and quite honestly better than the pizza. At least it was for me, but if you've read my previous reviews then you know I try include a second opinion. My husband is that second opinion and he was pleasantly satisfied, but had the same comments about the style's of pizza. Bottom line is I would recommend this establishment over corporate chains any day. I would highly recommend their salad as well. I look forward to trying many more salads here. Maybe even pizza as well because the service was amazing and I would gladly pay higher prices for this sort of service. read more

See all

First time customer. Ordered a deepdish pizza and a slice of strawberry cheese cake. 5 Stars on both. First the pizza: Good portions of fresh, high-quality ingredients. Very tasty! Great value for the price paid. The strawberry cheese cake slice: The desserts come fresh weekly from a top bakery from Chicago. I know the bakery well. High quality ingredients and very tasty. I highly recommend. read more

This pizza is very very good. We normally get a deep dish pizza that we carry out. We find the prices reasonable. . Service is always on time and friendly. It's a good location. read more

Visiting Elkhart for RV repair walked across parking lot twice from our hotel to pickup food for dinner.. awesome food/salads , friendly staff thank you! read more

Best pizza in Elkhart. Don't sleep on the Deep Dish either. Great family owned and operated gem

We had a supreme last night. I liked it but can only give it three stars. A little expensive $19 for the 12 inch.

Super friendly. Ordered a salad and the Seattle Pizza. Salad was good, fresh and plentiful. Medium was good for one person and had left overs. It was good, needed a little more sauce but would eat there again. read more

I love the pizza crust and their cheese to sauce ratio. This is one of our go to's for great pizza in Elkhart!

Pizza is great and always fast and ready when we get there. The people who are there are very friendly and the pizza is hot and yummy.

Just ok. Crust was kind of chewy and the green peppers tasted strong. It wasn't terrible but not great either. Probably won't go there again. read more

Love the pizza and salads here and the manager is very personable and thanks you every time we come in. We Tell a lot of our friends about this place because it is kind of out of the way not well known. We will continue to come back read more

The BEST local pizza in Elkhart. Great ingredients, great service, DO NOT waste your money on the pizza chains

Excellent food and the lady working there was very pleasant. Prices were very reasonable

Meat lovers pizza! The most cheesiest pizza I have ever had in my whole life! PLUS The best crust ever! Nice and crunchy on the bottom but soft and delicious!!! To hard to e plain you have to try it!! I have had the Atlanta CBR also chicken bacon and ranch!! SO AMAZING!! The cheese pizza all by itself is SIPER YUMMY!! You just have to give it a try I promise you will not be dissatisfied! Did I mention it is the best crust I have ever had?? read more

Big City Pizza - Meat lovers pizza!! So cheesy with the best crust I have ever had!! - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

I travel all over the state for my work every week and constantly. I'm ordering pizza in my hotel room as a quick way to have dinner. I have to tell you, this is the best pizza I've had on the road in a long, long time. The service over the phone was great. I was put on hold when I first called maybe 10 seconds. The person was very nice. Took my order arrived on time and again the pizza is delicious. The sauce is perfect. I would highly recommend this pizza to anybody in the Elkhart area. I wish they were down in Indianapolis. read more

This place is amazing. A real pizza in the middle of IN. The service and food are fantastic. If you're in the area, a must stop!!!

I should have known it would not be great when they said they didn't have garlic or oregano. The dough was similar to the type of pizza we got in grade school. The cheese was of poor quality and not good. I'm not sure what "big city" they're thinking of but it sure isn't NYC, Philadelphia or Chicago. And it isn't that I am a snob, some of the best pizza I have had was in Iowa read more

In town on business in a hotel. Pizza was awesome! Plenty of toppings quick delivery. Will eat here again. P.S. would have taken pic of pizza, but I started eating as soon as it arrived. read more

I HIGHLY recommend this place! The pizza is fabulous and the salads are fresh and delish! Prices are very reasonable for the high quality food! They also deliver anything on their menu! You don't have to order a pizza! On top of everything else, the staff is super friendly! You won't be disappointed! read more

We were staying at La Quinta. This pizza is awesome and the staff are wonderful! We walked over and ordered a 12" deep dish. It did not disappoint. If you are staying at any of the hotels near Northpointe Blvd. or you are fortunate to live in Elkhart, I highly recommend Big City Pizza! read more

This has got to be the best pizza for I don't know how miles in every direction. I have had a couple different pizzas while passing through Elkhart, and they were all amazing. The crust, the sauce, the options. It can't be beat. read more

My new favorite pizza places in town. I was a little disappointed in my dessert. I bought 3 different ones to give them a try. Cheese cake was ok, chocolate cake was to soggy for my liking and I don't remember what the third one was. read more

We tried this place after checking the reviews. Great pizza, and very friendly staff, clean too.

Ordered 2 pizzas for lunch today. This was the first time we tried their pizza. The pizza was terrific. Their restaurant is very nice, We will be returning. read more

Great pizza! We got a Chicago pizza and a regular Hawaiian pizza. Sauce is fantastic and so it the crust. The service was also wonderful. Can't wait to try a sandwich next time read more

This was our first time here. We ordered carry out. Service was quick. The pizza was outstanding! Sauce was so good! A lot of toppings. We will be back! read more

This place is so good! I've eaten here several times and the food is consistently amazing, and the family that owns it is so kind!

If you care about COVID don't come here. My husband was putting on his mask to go in pick up our order. While we were in the car I saw the worker that was folding the pizza boxes and putting aluminum in it fold the boxes without gloves and her mask barely covered her mouth. Her mask was barely hanging on. AND SHE WAS SCRATCHING HER HEAD BEFORE MAKING BOXES AGAIN and didn't go back to wash her hands. The COOK that was behind making pizzas had his mask down talking to her. When my husband went in they put on their masks. The only one that had her mask on properly and all the time was the employee at the register. I'm very disappointed at the lack of seriousness during a pandemic. read more

Great pizza and sandwiches whatever kind you order. Always ready when they say it'll be ready and very very nice friendly people. Prices are very reasonable and my newest favorite in Elkhart area. They always remember my name and treat me like family read more

Love this pizza! Crust wasn't too thick or thin, just right and baked to perfection. Will definitely order from Big City Pizza again! Oh and delivery was right on time too! read more

There food is pretty good, but I just noticed that they charge a 4% transaction fee for using your credit card. Only restaurant in Elkhart that does this that I am aware of. Prices for there food isn't cheap but worth it. I will be going elsewhere. read more

This is a new and terrific pizza place , there food is outstanding and the people are fantastic and so very friendly. They have my business from now on. Please give them a try read more