Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bimini Big John's

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Bimini Big John's Photos

    BIMINI BIG JOHN'S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bimini Big John's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Caribbean 234 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Conch House Restaurant - Key lime pie

    The Conch House Restaurant

    3.6(1k reviews)
    7.8 km
    $$

    We were in town for a long weekend for a concert and planned to come here from dinner before we…read morewent back home. It came highly recommended from locals and online. Restaurant was easy to find and close to our hotel, plenty of parking. When we walked up, the views were nice as it's on the water. Nice signage. We walked in and were able to get seated inside right away (it was raining out otherwise we would have sat outside) but they sat us at a window seat so that was nice. Our server came by soon after, was attentive and friendly the rest of the evening. Appetizers - We ordered the gator tail and calamari. That must have been THE most tender calamari I've ever had! The breading was also very good and light - and the pepper sauce they give with it... wow very good! The gator was also very tender and good! Entrees - I ordered the Butter Rum Scallops and my husband ordered the Shrimp & Grits. My first bite of my entree was heavenly... I REALLY enjoyed it. It was sooooo good. That butter rum was something else. Scallops were perfectly cooked. My husbands was very good too - great flavor!! The grits were perfect. Then we ordered a Key Lime Pie to go (way too stuffed to eat it there lol!) but when we had some later that night... probably our favorite key lime pie ever! The consistency of it was like jelly like and it was SUPER good! Overall - a 10/10 experience here! Would definitely come back and hopefully on a nicer day so we can sit outside with the water views.

    We're locals and this was our first time here, we took my parents as they came for a visit for my…read morebirthday. Ambience is really cool. Perfect for a casual night out. Bar was hopping, live music. It's giving outdoor tiki which we loved. Food was decent, on par with every other seafood restaurant in Florida. Our waitress was great. On to the negatives - the hostess stand and or management is disorganized. Came up at 8:20 and asked for a table of 4. We inquired about an over water tiki hut and were told they stop seating those at 8pm because it gets dark. That's fine. Was told a 45 min wait, we agreed to join the list through yelp. We asked for first available, indoor or outdoor. On the plus side, the wait ended up being closer to 30 mins. However, there were tons of free tables the entire time we waited. Tiki huts were empty. The whole inside only had 2 tables sat. We asked to see a menu while we waited and got an audible sigh and eye roll. When our table was called, the hostess called 4 other groups at the same exact time, leading to a lot of confusion. As we are sitting and eating (it's now 9:30) a couple walks in. They're led to a table on the patio and asks to go into a tiki hut instead, which they are promptly sat in after they clean it off. So we asked our waitress, what's the deal! She said oh just ask the hostess and they can put you on the list for those huts. So not sure what happened. Overall- ambience 8/10 Food 7/10 Service (waitress) 10/10 Management (hostess) 4/10 Not sure if we'll go back because of the disorganization, unnecessary wait times, and rude hostesses.

    Photos
    The Conch House Restaurant - Inside dining room

    Inside dining room

    The Conch House Restaurant - Ahí Tuna Salad!

    Ahí Tuna Salad!

    The Conch House Restaurant - Bloody Mary

    See all

    Bloody Mary

    The Columbia - The Melanie

    The Columbia

    3.7(2.3k reviews)
    6.0 km
    $$

    Columbia Restaurant is hands down the best overall restaurant in St. Augustine!…read more The Paella Marinera and Arroz con Pollo were absolute FIRE! Both dishes were incredibly flavorful, beautifully prepared, and the portions are HUGE, definitely expect to share! Beyond the delicious food, the atmosphere and history of the restaurant make the entire experience special. If you're visiting St. Augustine, Columbia Restaurant is an absolute must! Amazing food, generous portions, beautiful atmosphere, without a doubt our favorite restaurant in St. Augustine!

    My wife and I, in Saint Augustine on vacation, met up with a good work friend of mine and her…read morehusband that I had not seen in years. She lives in Saint Augustine and had chosen this location because it was walking distance from our hotel, very convenient. The restaurant was hopping on a Monday night and it was good she had made reservations. Although we had a great time, I felt the food was only OK given the marketing oversell in the menu. (All quotes following are from Columbia's menu). I often like to try a restaurant specialties, especially far from home. First I had "Columbia's Original "1905" Salad® The Columbia's legendary salad tossed tableside" as a side salad. It was nothing special, hardly "legendary". For the main course I again relied on the menu and chose "Merluza a la Rusa - A Columbia classic since 1935. Spain's favorite fish". Again, disappointing given the description. The fish was somewhat bland and the top coating was burnt. If this is Spain's "favorite fish"there must be a dearth of seafood there. For dessert I chose the Key lime Pie: "Key lime pie is the "Official Pie of the State of Florida."". Decent Key lime pie but nothing memorable. However, I must say the bread that comes to your table is outstanding. The Columbia is obviously a Saint Augustine institution but I wish the food had come closer to the flowery menu descriptions.

    Photos
    The Columbia - The restaurant has a gift shop

    The restaurant has a gift shop

    The Columbia - Steak Salteado

    Steak Salteado

    The Columbia - Front of the property

    See all

    Front of the property

    Bimini Big John's - caribbean - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...