Our whole family absolutely loves, bite me cake! We discovered them a few years during their annual Krampus pictures, and they have become a staple for birthdays and celebrations in our house. Delicious cupcakes, and cakes, and affordable. The staff is always fantastic, and the atmosphere when you go and hang out? My husband and I love it and so do our teenagers. Bite me cake is a win all the way around! read more

An overnight trip in Pueblo plus a really bad sweet tooth took me directly to Bite Me Cake, and I'm glad for it. I am rarely this far south so am unfamiliar with the bakery options around town; Bite Me was one of the closest, highest rated spots right near the hotel I was staying in. The photos and vibe looked really great based on others' reviews, so I decided to stop in late on a Saturday not to get my sugar fix lol. The atmosphere is fun, and the mish mash of sweets, games, and a downstairs bar I think is super unique and also makes this place more appealing for people that want to bring kids around earlier in the day. Despite going late (I think it was around 8?), the arcade was pretty full of people, which was a great sign. The bakery case and menu is at the back, and there was one very sweet girl (no pun intended lol) running the counter. Even for the time, there were lots of options that all looked like they were pretty good and not obviously stale or old from the day which I really appreciated. There is also ice cream and a refrigerator case of goodies in addition to what's shown here, as well as various beverages you can purchase. I decided to splurge on a cherry cupcake, a cheesecake cookie with cherries, and a brookie. The total was around $12 or so, which was pretty reasonable. I took my treats back to the hotel to enjoy them while watching a show, and they were all delicious! Definitely satisfied my craving for something sweet after a long day. I think this place would be very fun for a date night or a small family outing during the day, presuming it's isn't busy inside as it seems like it can easily feel crowded. Parking is available on the street and may be a bit of a challenge depending on the day and time you stop in, but the downtown area is pretty walkable and more parking accommodations can be found further away. Stop in if you get a chance! I probably will next time I'm in town. read more

See all

The quality of food/snacks here is amazing. Customer service is top notch and they always make the best cookies. Especially the mini chocolate chip ones. Ambience is perfect for this place. Pinball games galore and some nice cold beers in the basement. If you're looking for a cool place to relax and enjoy a beer and play some pinball, this is definitely the spot for you!!! read more

Bite Me Cake - Pinball machines. - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Very cool spot in the Union Ave district! They have incredible ice cream with unique flavors that are switched up frequently. They of course have plenty of sweet treats to select from as well as coffees. Love their second chance cupcake deals and the critters treats. The shop is spacious and lovely with arcade games availble to patrons. Love visiting for a cup of ice cream when I am in the area. read more

We stopped by here during the Chili Festival because the name drew me in. The staff was so nice and helpful as we decided on what treats we would have. Very casual atmosphere. The pink champagne cupcake was so yummy and the perfect amount of sweet. The snickerdoodle was very tasty too and very moist with a slightly crispy exterior. They had a good selection to pick from! Will definitely stop by again if we are in the area. read more

Bite Me Cake - Pink Champagne Single Cupcake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Ordered their ice cream here & wasn't anything crazy special but also wasn't terrible and would totally come back to the area again and eat some more! Very clean atmosphere here as well with friendly customer service. They don't have a lot for parking, so be prepared to park on the street but still plenty of parking options here even during a sunny day like when I came by a few weeks ago. read more

See all

Ordered a custom cake for my mom's retirement party, and they NAILED IT! The cake was beautiful, and tasted just as good (got chocolate cake with coffee buttercream). It was very easy to place an order online, and finalized details over the phone. Ambiance: the store was very clean and welcoming when I went to pick up the cake (looks like they sell cupcakes and other things, too). Highly recommend for your custom cake needs! read more

Bite Me Cake - Custom cake with stethoscope and medication decorations - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

Snacks and pinball how could you go wrong?!! The owners are amazing and the service as well as drink selection works out. Kids are allowed through a certain time so they get to enjoy as well read more

See all

We were close by and decided to stop in to pick up a sweet treat. They were busy on a weekend afternoon. I got a yummy banana chocolate cupcake and my husband a red velvet giant cookie. I accidentally dropped my cupcake and the sweet girl at the counter didn't hesitate to provide me another one. We will return for more sweet treats. Thanks for your yummy treats and great customer care. read more

The ice cream was delicious.... But it's the PINBALL that makes this place amazing ! There's sweets and a handful of pinball machines on the main level, but the basement is where it's really at! There are about 15 additional machines down there, and just like the ones upstairs, they are in fabulous, well cared for condition. They have a bar downstairs and you can even get beer during the family time (saturdays 1-6? I think, ask them!) don't you be judging me ! My kiddo LOVED the teeny tiny cone ice cream, and it's so tiny, an adult wont feel guilty about a second cone ! Hope to make it down there again soon read more

Bite Me Cake - Pinball !! - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

These desserts are why i was interested in the place! The Cake pops are an excellent size for the price. I come here primarily for the desserts and will always support this business! The two ladies i had at the front counter were so kind and so underrated. We need more businesses like this one! you all are so awesome! 1000000% recommend a visit for a sweet treat and some fun! read more

Bite Me Cake - Confetti Cake Pop - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

Bad ass shop, with badass women! Super delicious :) Ordered the Carmel- Chocolate milkshake and the Pink Champagne cupcake read more

So happy to find this place! My family loved the pinball machines- they were so fun! Between us all we tried the fruity pebbles cupcake, root beer float ice cream, chocolate cupcake, and cake pop- they were all delicious! Really cool vibe in this place- retro. Will definitely go again if we are in Pueblo. read more

See all

Great place to hang out, play pinball, and get a drink! Games are in spectacular shape!! Owners and staff are very friendly and accommodating!!! Stop by. You will not be disappointed. read more

This place is awesome! Walked in here with my family and I am so envious that this place is not closer to my own home. I ordered multiple items , hands down my favorite was the captain crunch milkshake. It was sweet creamy with a little hint of salt. All ice creamis made in house and you can taste the love. It's worth breaking your diet to give this place a try. read more

Bite Me Cake - Capitan jacks Single Scoop Cup Ice Cream - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

We were walking by this cake shop, and decided to stop in for a treat :-) turned out to be a great decision! We indulged in two cupcakes and a tiny cherry pie :-) both the cupcakes were delicious.! Vanilla cake w/ champagne frosting, and a carrot cake. The cherry pie crust was buttery and flaky. Sweet and tart cherry filling. The young lady that helped us was very sweet and upbeat :-) I recommend you stop in and treat yourself sometime! read more

See all

Very yummy cupcakes! My favorite was the red velvet with cream cheese icing. I highly recommend this place.

Nice staff, yummy food and good iced americano! All for a very reasonable price! The green coke ice cream is read more

Bite Me Cake - Sugar cookies for Chile Festival - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

I would do less if I could. We bought 2 cupcakes of the same flavor. Paradise peach. One was left untouched because the first one was terrible. Asked to exchange and was told that they absolutely would not exchange for a new flavor because we walked to a table. I have never been somewhere that actively wanted pissed off customers, but this is that place. Do not eat here. The cupcakes are bad and service is worse. read more

Their cupcakes are AMAZING! The cake part was very moist and the frosting was fluffy, so perfect! The staff should have a little more enthusiasm, they were not bad, but not good either. read more

Bite Me Cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Cute environment. Loved the pinball machines!!! Even won drive-thru movie tickets beating the high score. Ice cream was delish and service was quality. read more

Bite Me Cake - My baby loving a little "bite"! - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

If you like cupcakes, and pinball, this is your place. The cupcake, and cinnamon roll were absolutely delicious. The iced coffee was perfect. All pinball machines were in working order, and there were many that I haven't played in years. There were coin exchange machines both up and downstairs. There is a bar downstairs, as well as more pinball. The place was clean, staff was friendly, and there was artwork from local artists for sale. I will be returning. read more

A delicious cherry limeade cupcake, and at the half price shelf! There are so many other items on the menu that I'd love to come back for. Heard excellent things about the ice cream, cookies, and virtually everything else! read more

Bite Me Cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

Love the cake that we ordered! Was ready for pick up as promised. All the cupcakes we tried were delicious!

Just moved down here from Cali. We happened to pass by and decided to walk in! The decor and all the games are awesome the art work on the walls look amazing. The guy who helped us out was so nice and we end up getting a milkshake you can Choose any ice cream and cereal it was delicious! Also they had samples of cupcakes and I couldnt pass it up the frosting was amazing and the cupcakes are delicious! Definitely will be back! read more

Bite Me Cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

See all

This place is sooooo cool, adorable and yummy!! I don't think I have ever found all three of those qualities in one. This is a don't miss stop In Pueblo and not far from the HWY if your just driving through. The service was good, kind and patient too. read more

Yum yum yummy. This place is absolutely unique and sooooo damn delicious. I go here every time I'm in Pueblo. Worth the stop read more

Bite Me Cake - Monkey bread - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

I just want to thank you so much from Florida..for getting those gluten-free cupcakes together for my daughter...you're very kind on the phone it's always hard to order something when you're not face-to-face but thank you so much... I'll be sure to order for the rest of the family God bless. read more

I arranged to have a cake designed for my folk's 50th wedding anniversary and it was the most beautiful cake I'd seen in a long time. It was exactly as I ordered and absolutely delicious. Being I'm a wedding and event planner I can be picky, however, Bite Me met and exceeded my expectations. I can without a second thought recommend them for any event, weddings included, as they do outstanding work. Thanks again!! read more

Staff super friendly. I wish I would have taken a photo of the cupcakes and Icecream. Cupcakes were not worth it. Icecream was ok. Cupcakes tasted old. We did go at around 8 pm in the evening so maybe that is why. We got the champagne one and cheesecake something. Anyway , it's a cute shop with pretty but no good cupcakes. They do have a fun arcade that you can play while eating. read more

Delicious ice cream, milkshakes, and cupcakes! The pinball machines are a super cool addition.

Bite me cake Co truly saved me! Had to order a last minute dessert cake from out of town. Not only did they say no problem, but they also had it ready and decorated beautifully. My fiancé was so incredibly surprised and loved his cake. read more

Bite Me Cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

The BEST ice cream in Colorado!! I definitely recommend getting a cereal milkshake. Added bonus is the owners are super kind and welcoming people. read more

A spring snow storm shut down I-25, so we stopped by the river walk area of Pueblo for the first time. We couldn't believe our luck to find a yummy cake shop just waiting for us. We got the lemon and strawberry cupcakes but I suspect flavors change daily. They are loaded with frosting, just like we prefer. The cake portion was sweet and moist. They had a weekend special of 50 cent coffee or tea, you can't beat that. read more

Bite Me Cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - Pueblo, Colorado

Love this place! Delicious, moist cupcakes in many flavors -- even later in the day -- and tasty ice cream. I haven't ordered a specialty cake here yet, but you can see from the photos and the cakes in the case that they do beautiful work. Super-nice people up front, too. read more

On July 9, 2020 I arrived a little after 1 p.m. with my daughter at this location to inquire about their hours. I was told that they would be open until 3 p.m. by the blonde female employee who was working there. I said I would be back to purchase some things later on since I didn't want them to melt in the car while my daughter and I were shopping. I returned to purchase cupcakes, as well as a birthday cake at 2:50 p.m. after driving back from the far north side of Pueblo and the door was locked. My daughter and I tapped on the glass for 4 minutes before the same employee came to the door and stated that they were closed at what was now 2:54 p.m. When I stated she had told me they would be open until 3, she just said she was sorry but the drawer was already done. I mentioned the time to her and the fact she had given me incorrect information and she just shrugged as though I was an inconvenience to her. It was my daughter's birthday and the cake/cupcakes were for her evening celebration of turning 17 years old. THIS PLACE COULD CARE LESS ABOUT ITS CUSTOMERS. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE! I went to Gagliano's on Elm Street instead and got Tiramisu cups and lady fingers which were delicious. The Bite Me Cake Company can bite me. I'll never be back. read more

I was disappointed that the cake we ordered for Father's Day was not like the other cakes we ordered in the past. I ordered the Chocolate Ganache, which we had previously. It was not the same; when I asked the guy he said "oh it is what we call our triple chocolate cake". If they changed the types of cakes since they reopened they should have said something. Plus the cake was a little bit smaller than before. I would have paid more to get the old type of cake I wanted. read more

If I could give this establishment zero stars, I would. Our first experience with them was fabulous, they have great tasting cakes/cupcakes and did an amazing job on our wedding cake. However when we ordered a birthday cake for our daughter's first birthday, the only thing they got right was the flavor and type of frosting. They had the wrong type of decorations on it and completely left off the 'happy birthday' and her name. We were upset, but let it go because she was only one and wouldn't care. We decided to try again this year and boy was that a mistake. Due to the disaster last year, all I told them we wanted was a 2 layer, chocolate cake with buttercream frosting that was jungle/curious George theme. Easy enough right? Apparently not. When my husband went to pick it up, it was a chocolate and white cake (we wanted just chocolate), fondant frosting (which no one in our family likes), and there was no jungle theme. It was bright blue and yellow. Understandably we were very upset. The owner claimed all she could do was give us a 10% discount if we took it and if we left it we would be out the $75 deposit I had to put down. No offer to replace it with anything more suitable. I told her about our experience last year and how disappointed I was in her customer service and she still wouldn't budge saying because of the work she had put in she had to keep the deposit no matter what. I asked if we could just take it and not have to pay the other $75 that they wanted to for it and she said no, the best she could do was a 10% discount. She is the owner, I thought customer service was important to businesses driven by customers but apparently it is not. And how she, as the owner, didn't do everything she could to make up for the mistakes made is baffling to me. We were read back the order sheet and it had only half of what I had ordered. When I placed the order the girl who took it down repeated it and it was correct then. If she had been willing to let us take the cake for the $75 already paid we would've just let it go. But she kept repeating she couldn't do that. I do not understand how she could not, as the owner, but that apparently is the way she wants to run her business. We are now out $75, have another bad cake memory for our daughter's birthday, and have to scramble at the last minute to find another cake. Needless to say, no matter how tasty the product is, we are never ordering here again. If you don't care if your order is right or like surprises, then I would suggest ordering from here, we however like our orders to be correct and will never patronize this establishment again. read more

These guys totally saved me and pulled through for me for every step of the way. TWO days prior to the gender reveal party I was hosting, the friend who was making the reveal cake canceled on me. I called Bite Me and even with such short notice they got the cake done, on time, and for a reasonable price. The cake was EXACTLY what I had envisioned (they asked me to email them photos and we talked it through on the phone), it had the gender-colored frosting hidden inside perfectly, and last but not least, it tasted great too. Their cupcakes in their dessert case were beautiful I couldn't help but notice when I went to pick the cake up, and their cute shop down on Union was adorable. Happy customer! read more

My husband and I have visited this bakery since they have opened. They have amazing ice cream, delicious cupcakes and awesome decor. The reason I give this a 4 star rating is because there a few things that are disappointing. The first is their cakes. When I had my gender reveal cake made it looked really sloppy, and the taste was repulsive. We paid a lot of money and basically threw the cake away. They also don't allow a variety of options for the cake, just the standard vanilla chocolate options. The second issue is actually the owner of the shop. She is this short blonde lady and she is always looks in a pissed off mood. The first few times I saw her years ago I assumed it was the heat(during chili fest) or bad day. But since I've been there throughout the years she always looks completely peeved. The last time I went in(few days ago) with my husband and daughter she looked completely annoyed by our presence and instead of providing an inviting environment she made us feel like we were intruding. The entire time we ordered, paid and ate our desserts she was avoiding all eye contact and eventually basically just went into the back to avoid us. Her behavior is completely repulsive and ruins the entire atmosphere of our visit. read more