Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Black Magic Pizza

    4.5 (84 reviews)
    Open 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    Black Magic Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    BLACK MAGIC PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Black Magic Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Black Magic Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Wings
    Alexa V.

    Updating to include a wing review... I start this by saying eating wings in Buffalo ruined basically all the local Orlando wing spots. Nothing compared. Black magic is really the closest I've come to getting that super crispiness without drying out the wing. Sauce was amazing. Also - adding the garlic ricotta dollops to the cheese pizza is a MUST TRY. Wow. Next level stuff. Black magic has very quickly become my new go to. Best pizza in Orlando.

    Ralph E.

    Wow don't sleep on this place. Yes it's a pizza place and they have super friendly service and excellent pizza. The big surprise was don't sleep on the poutine. Wow it was amazing. These are not french fries but a potato variation with a firmer texture or a different flavor profile while still using the essential squeaky cheese curds and savory gravy. The Large pizza was definitely large too much for 2 people so next time we are planning on each doing a 12" individual to be able to try different ones. Actually I might just get the poutine as that was a meal in itself. They are set up for take away but there are 2 tables outside or you can take you food into Whiskey Lou's to enjoy with a beverage. (friendly reminder Whiskey Lou's is cash only)

    Cheezus 12-inch pizza and I added garlic ricotta dollops.

    Incredible simple to order online and pick up at the carryout window. Communicate clearly once your order is ready for pick-up. We had the Cheezus 12-inch and added the garlic ricotta dollops on to it. Incredible addition might I add. Not pictured but we also had the Three Neat Deep 12-inch pizza also adding the garlic ricotta dollops. The crust was cooked to perfection; it had a light char to it that you want from a thin style pizza. All of the toppings tasted incredibly fresh and flavorful. Honestly one of the best pizza places I've ever eaten if not the best.

    Almira S.

    OMG ! Best pizza in Orlando award ! This pizza is top tier lol no exaggeration. I've tried this pizza 5 times when I'm lucky to be in the Mills area. So delicious and great tasting ingredients. The gentleman at the window are always so sweet and ready to help you pick the perfect size and type . Easy to to talk to. Food comes out hot and delicious to the point of burning your tongue ! Great ambiance and vibes on Mills . Thanks for the great food '

    Large pie
    Larry S.

    1st time eating Black Magic pie. The crust was outstanding. Crispy and crunchy the way I like it. The arrugala was not at all wilted. Very fresh topping on the pizza. Great tasting mushrooms. This restaurant is takeout only.

    Walk up window to order pizza
    Ron S.

    First time at this location, we had a pepperoni pizza with hot honey sauce and it was delicious. Customer services a walk up window with a varied menu that you could order from pizza to poutine wings. Anything you need they have and they're very willing to help you customize your menu. It's outside seating. It's quiet for being next to a road. I thought it was very nice. I will be going back and recommend checking it out.

    Mozz Sticks
    Colton R.

    This is a great little pizza shop. We ordered the Hornets Nest, the mozz sticks and the poutine. The pizza stands out. Amazing ingredients. The sauce is very slightly sweet and just tangy enough to not be overpowering. Not smothered with cheese so the toppings stand out. And hot honey belongs on any pizza in my opinion. The mozz sticks are up there with the best I've ever had. Extremely crispy outside (like actually crispy, not that crumble breading that you generally see. And a great cheese pull. These are something you would get on a boardwalk in the NE, if you've been there. And the poutine was an amazing take. Thick French fries with a savory gravy and cheese curds. It's really hard to mess up. I like my fries this way (not too crispy) and this really hit the spot.

    Ana Sol B.

    Listen... I'm that kinda of girl that doesn't eat the crust cause it doesn't do much for me, but this crust right here let me tell you I almost fought my husband for it hahaha it was so good! A little bit pricy but you can tell the ingredients they use are the best so it's worth it. Give it a try if you want some good pizza We got the pepperoni & regular cheese 8.4 on the pizza ratings for me!

    Coheed & Calabria AKA the good stuff.
    J E G.

    This is my new favorite pizza. I had the Coheed & Calabria and everything about it was right and good, well balanced toppings and sauce coupled with a crispy thin crust with the right amount of char. I also had an order of the buffalo sauced wings, they were also top tier. I try and support small local businesses and when you find one that offers great food, great service, and fair prices, why wouldn't you go there? Lou's is a fantastic spot to people watch also, so throw in great entertainment too.

    Black Magic Pizza is our absolute favorite pizza spot in Orlando. We order at least once a week! Everything from their specialty pizzas, wings, garlic knots, cannolis! Everything is delicious!

    Torey Z.

    Great food. Amazing customer service upon placing the order to pick up. Very friendly staff as well. On my partner and mines first visit they even gave us a free cannoli which was a very nice thing to see/experience. In the same parking lot was a great seating area with a great ambiance well equipped to sit and eat and enjoy your time

    Sonja H.

    Now, I ONLY had the mozzarella sticks but they were super yummy. A very crispy outside and a divine cheeseness on the inside. The marinara to dip was good too. Driving past this place I almost didn't even see it. It's just a walk up window with a sign out front. I'm so looking forward to ordering from here in the very near future!

    Cheezus Pie
    Tyler O.

    Now this place right here is the best of the best! If you're looking for the absolute best pizza in Orlando, look no further! From their great service to their delicious wings and of course even better pizza, you just can't top this place! Have tried their Cheezus Pizza (Pictured) which is topped with Basil, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella and Olive Oil which is absolutely amazing. Their Dr. Pepperoni Pizza is just as good which is topped with Cupped Pepperoni's, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella and I can't forgot their spicy maple swirl sauce which knocks it out the park! The crust is also made of Sour Dough which is cooked perfectly fluffy yet crispy. Now their wings, the Hot Honey BBQ wings are hands down some of the best wings I've ever had! The perfect mix of spicy and sweet. If you're in Orlando and haven't tried this place I HIGHLY recommend it.

    earth crisis vegan

    See all

    3 years ago

    For what ever reason tasted more like tostitos frozen pizza. Was expecting more options and better dough.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 4

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    undercooked dough and actually yeah tastes like the frozen pizza bites microwaved for 1 minute less than requeired.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 3

    Page 3 of 3

    Black Magic Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Black Magic Pizza

    You might also consider

    Gitto's Pizza - Skull Stuffed Garlic Knots

    Gitto's Pizza

    3.7(322 reviews)
    1.7 miDowntown / Central Business District / CBD
    $$

    Stopped in one night during the Immerse event. It was right next to one of the stages I was…read morefrequenting, and I wanted a quick slice, so in I popped. Ambiance was really fun. The thinnest place I've ever seen. Only room for two lines of people in the main area, one line for ordering, one line for picking up. Behind the counter was quite the operation. Pies being baked in one oven, being put on display, and then another oven jam packed with slices being warmed for the customer, along with their accompanying garlic knot. Every slice comes with a complimentary knot. I'm pretty sure I saw whole pizzas going out with eight included knots. The service was pretty good. Efficient, friendly enough workers. There was an aura of hurry up, what do you need, but with a line out the door literally all night, I do not blame them one bit. And the slice factory line got you in an out as quickly as it possible could. As for the slice itself, it was pretty ok. Good crust, foldable slice. Very cheesy, which is needed for most clientele who are in the middle of downtown in need of munchies. Slim toppings, though, and even after the heating process, the slice was kind of cold. Overall, for the convenience and the price, this place was good. I'll definitely come back under the right circumstances.

    Unfortunately, I can't recommend Gitto's Pizza based on my experience. I understand they were very…read morebusy and there was a long line, but that didn't justify the way I was treated. I asked if they offered a military discount, and the employee told me they did. When I presented my military ID, he refused to apply the discount and then attempted to take my government-issued military ID out of my hand to inspect whether it was legitimate. That interaction really caught me off guard and made me uncomfortable. Regardless of the store's policy, there are more respectful and professional ways to handle that situation. I still purchased my food and ordered a standard cheese pizza, hoping the food would make up for the experience. Unfortunately, it was pretty average. The bottom of the pizza was pale and seemed undercooked, so it lacked the crisp texture I was expecting. The ambience, however, did seem really nice. They have upstairs seating that overlooks the street, which could make for a nice spot if you're dining in. Overall, I understand busy shifts can be stressful, but customers should still be treated with courtesy and respect. Better customer service and more consistency in the quality of the pizza would go a long way. Based on this visit, I don't see myself returning.

    Photos
    Gitto's Pizza - Inside eating area.

    Inside eating area.

    Gitto's Pizza - Lunch combo

    Lunch combo

    Gitto's Pizza

    See all

    The Corner Pizza Bar

    The Corner Pizza Bar

    4.0(115 reviews)
    1.6 miDowntown / Central Business District / CBD
    $$

    Corner Pizza Bar is the ultimate spot if you're catching a show or event nearby. It's an easy,…read morequick walk from both the Kia Center and the Dr. Phillips Center, and the food was delicious! Prices are super reasonable, and the whole vibe is great--our teens loved watching the kitchen staff make our pizzas right in the open kitchen. A huge shoutout to our server, Jason, who made the visit extra special. His service was on point--he was quick, attentive, threw in some great humor, and gave us fantastic menu recommendations. The food came out remarkably fast, too. Perfect food, great prices, and top-tier service. We'll definitely be making this our go-to spot whenever we're in the area for a show!

    Great environment. Lively and attentive staff. The food A++++++. Everything we ate tonight was…read moredelicious. The jalapeño poppers were crunchy with just the right amount of heat. The "corner" pizza was insanely tasty! Combo of the creamy burrata cheese with the salty prosciutto and the sweet balsamic.....just YUMMY. THE CRUST IS DYNAMITE. Right amount of crisp with the right amount of chew. I also ordered food to go. Stromboli is a solid 100% in construction and flavor and the Mexican pizza provides flavors that will satisfy 99% of people. Phenomenal actually. This place is an absolute must.

    Photos
    The Corner Pizza Bar
    The Corner Pizza Bar - Garlic Cheesesticks

    Garlic Cheesesticks

    The Corner Pizza Bar - Bar, sports TVs, family friendly dining.

    See all

    Bar, sports TVs, family friendly dining.

    Pizza Bruno - Big rig

    Pizza Bruno

    4.1(904 reviews)
    1.8 miDowntown South
    $$

    We live within 100 yards of Brunos, and recommend trying it in person. Pizza is always better at…read morethe restaurant! And you can't beat their garlic knots! We've also enjoyed their meatballs and salads. Its a small restaurant, so recommend making a reservation or planning to wait a little bit, but theyve always been fast to seat us.

    Went initially with family, on a Friday. 7pm reservation…read more Although busy, we were handled quickly. The food was fantastic and we were checked in on regularly. Three salads, an olive appetizer, two beers, bread, three pizzas, one dessert, all nailed perfectly. Server even checked in about our food allergies. Two months later, tried going with my fiance. 6:30pm reservation on a Sunday. We showed up ten minutes early, to try and be cordial in case it was busy again, like last time. We walked in to four full tables, and four that were clearly unbussed and still dirty. Three servers are handling the four tables. We're greeted, and the first thing we're asked is if we'd "be okay sitting at the bar?" We told them about our reservation, and we're asked to wait a few minutes... while the servers went back to their other customers. Immediate red flag. It's still loud and cold, inside, with the owner and two other BoH members handling food orders. After we told them again about our reservation, we asked if we could sit on the patio. Nodding at each other and pointing that none of the dirty tables inside still had been cleaned, whatsoever. The young server that finally sat us invited to go over the menu as she went to "find out who would be helping us, this evening." (It turned out to be her, with obvious reluctance on her face.) We then waited ten minutes, with room temperature water and another couple eating takeout pizza, directly from the box, five feet away from us... On a night we both had planned for weeks. She inevitably came back, and we Immediately told her we needed to leave. There's no reason why three servers can't handle that lax of a clientele volume, while also bussing their own tables. If you're dropping around $30 a person on dinner, with the literal business owner present behind the counter, that level of blatant laziness shouldn't even be possible. We'll try again on a day expected to be busy. They clearly need some fire under their asses, and it's not coming from where it should be.

    Photos
    Pizza Bruno - View from the front door

    View from the front door

    Pizza Bruno - Tight Socks Pizza

    Tight Socks Pizza

    Pizza Bruno - Garlic knots

    See all

    Garlic knots

    Anthony's Pizza Thornton Park

    Anthony's Pizza Thornton Park

    3.9(340 reviews)
    1.0 miThornton Park, South Eola
    $$

    Legit decent pizza. I usually like more toppings the better but the cheese is pretty good and enjoy…read morejust plain cheese pizza the best Service was good and prompt. The place seems like it can get sweaty on a really hot day bc the ventilation seems limited. They have a bunch of TVs all over too Happy hours are Tues - Fri, 3-6p and all day Monday

    "What I Ordered vs What I Got"…read more I ordered a simple Chicken Palermo with chicken, shrimp and broccoli. You know, the red/orange ziti pasta? Well, I received an ALL WHITE meal, I wish I knew what flavor it was. It was disgusting. Chicken was raw, the shrimp was weirdly salty, and the spaghetti pasta was barely soaked. Just hard. Shouldn't be an issue to just call and get it straightened out with simply getting my correct order, right? No lol wrong. The woman who answered the phone gave me attitude because I told her my order was wrong and was simply wondering if I could retrieve my CORRECT order. "Well no, I put the right order out and it was sent out" in the most condescending tone. The attitude continued as I continued to explain, very disheartening as I was starving too. She didn't even apologize or say bye at the end of the call, just hung up. Disappointing because this was my second time ordering, I wanted the same experience I had my first time around. I just knew I'd be a loyal customer with 95 orders within three months. Work on it! Your 1-Star reviews are growing and it doesn't have to be that way!

    Photos
    Anthony's Pizza Thornton Park
    Anthony's Pizza Thornton Park - Garlic Knots, nice and flavorful

    Garlic Knots, nice and flavorful

    Anthony's Pizza Thornton Park - Exterior from street corner.

    See all

    Exterior from street corner.

    Black Magic Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...