I was walking around the area and found this pizza spot. Lots of seating when you walk in. The price is reasonable, and the lady who took my order was nice. It didn't take long to get my pizza, and it was warm and delicious. They don't offer ice, but they have bottled drinks. It seems to be a local spot for workers in the area for a quick lunch bite. I didn't take pictures of the menu, but it has a relaxing ambiance as you sit and enjoy your pizza. I did go by on Monday, July 6th, around lunchtime, but they were closed will definitely be going back read more

See all

Good pizza! I'm at the office twice a week, and it's within walking distance of this place. I'm going to be honest. I love pizza. Yes, I know it might not be the healthiest thing if you eat it often, but I can't help it, LOL. Park Ave Pizza has the best pizza in Downtown Winter Park. No doubt about it. The owners are super nice and always welcome their customers with a smile. It is not a fancy place, just your no-frills pizza shop. And that's all it needs to be. They offer pizza by the slice, made to order pies, and a few other menu items. My favorites? One pepperoni slice and one buffalo chicken slice to go. The pizza is thin, with the perfect amount of sauce and toppings, and it's super crispy. The crust is amazing. Two slices for $10 in Winter Park is definitely a good deal. Pay them a visit. it'll be worth it. read more

Park Ave Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

We stumbled upon this spot after still being hungry after magical dining at Omo and wanting a few slices. This was right next door and ended up being a wonderful surprise. It's a super small spot and the man who took our order was very friendly. We didn't have high hopes due to it basically being dead and staff loudly lounging about the dining area looking bored. However, the pizza ended up being pretty good for thin slice and the dough was especially great. The service was fast, we will definitely be back. read more

Park Ave Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

We ordered two bianca pies for takeout and the white pie was so crisp and delicious. The dough was nice and firm and cooked thoroughly so that you hold a slice and it does not bend. The garlic and seasonings on the pie are perfect. Closest thing to New Jersey pizza I've been able to find down here! read more

Park Ave Pizza - Bianca - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Great cheap bite if you're in the Winter Park area. Great pizza and great price at $9 for two big slices. Staff was very friendly and efficient. Inside is a little dingy pizza place, nothing fancy but who needs that? read more

Park Ave Pizza - White pizza slice and pepperoni pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

My Go-To pizza place on the avenue for a quick slice of pizza for lunch! Service is okay; nothing to rave about but the order is perfection every time. I'm not sure if they have AC here as sometimes it's quite warm inside on a summer day. The red pepper and Parmesan is located in a difficult to see location (in my opinion - I'm short so idk if I just can't see it! Lol ). Decor and ambiance is consistent for the style of the restaurant as its appearance is a "quick NY style pizza" and not what I would deem a date night kind of place. Their Bianca pizza is perfection but I also enjoy some of their other slices which you can add toppings to by the slice at lunch time. It's all soooo yummy. Their subs are great too read more

Park Ave Pizza - Bianca - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

A solid choice for pizza in Winter Park. It's a 2 or 3 person operation, and service can be spotty at times. I've generally had good luck but sometimes had to wait to order; other times, I've seen people need to check on their orders. But, the pizza is good every time. The crust is a good mix of crispy and chewy and there are a good variety of toppings. The inside is pretty basic, but has a good amount of seating, typical of an eat and run pizza shop. read more

Park Ave Pizza - Special Bianca and jalapeño pineapple slices - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Definitely a happy customer. Never have I been disappointed. Food is fresh fast and good. I would go back any day

This is a pleasant cafe in a nice location adjacent to Park Ave. The staff is friendly and welcoming. You walk up to the counter and order and no tipping necessary. I had pizza and found it to be very good with moderately firm crust. My friend had a tuna salad sandwich which he thoroughly enjoyed. It is a good, reasonably priced cafe and I will return again. read more

Small Mom and Pop pizza shop with great food, good pricing, and friendly owners. When I went in here, there was only one other table full so I felt kind of bad. Hopefully other nights are busier for them because the food is excellent. I really enjoyed my pizza and would return. read more

Thank you so much to Park Ave Pizza for opening up right after hurricane Ian. The owners were running the kitchen and all when we came in. We felt lucky enough to find them open and have a hot meal! This was actually our first time having Park Ave Pizza and we weren't disappointed. I'm very happy we discovered this location as it's a great place to pick up pizza for a party. The slices were large and even the average cheese pizza had great NY style pizza flavors to it. The winter park community is very lucky to have you guys! Thanks again. read more

Park Ave Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Horrible, worse than frozen. And very expensive. These people don't know how to make pizza, they should be making Lo Mein instead. Tourist trap because of Rollins. read more

Ordered ahead and arrived early. They put my "finished" pizzas back in the oven. Got home a few minutes later and realized they just reheated older pizzas. Crust is burnt, too is cold. Not fresh pizza. This is forgivable with a slice, but not two pizzas. Very disappointed and won't go back. Too many fish in the sea. read more

Park Ave Pizza - a pizza box with a slice taken out of it - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I just moved to FL from NY - so I know NY pizza and am accustomed to a certain level of Italian food/pizza. This place was GREAT! My cousin ordered in their regular pie for me and it was delicious! Definitely better than some places I know back home. Also reheats just as good! Excited to try more from them! read more

VERY nice owners. They go above and beyond for their customers!! Great pizza and calzones!

SOOOOO yummy! the people were so sweet, and the pizza was absolutely delicious!!!! highly recommend

Placed a call ahead order this past weekend. Was asked how long I wanted it to take, was then told 10 minutes longer than what I stated (30min to 40) which was fine since I had to drive there. Arrived only to find they hadn't even started the order even though it was completely empty in the restaurant. Then proceeded to tell me it was still going to be 30 minutes. Never got our pizza and ended up ordering from somewhere else, arriving and getting it quicker than this one would've taken. read more

At 9:20pm, website says they close in 10 minutes. They still happily made us 2 amazing pizzas and delicious freshly chopped salads. Highly recommend. read more

I really do love this place as a casual hang out spot for dinner or lunch. It's right off Park Ave and is a great price compared to the other restaurants around. You can see that because all of the Rollins kids hang out here. My current favs are their cheesy garlic bread and spinach pizza!! Mmmmm!! They do have all of the standard Italian foods, like lasagna and calzones too, but they also have some weird things on their menu, like chicken noodle soup (4$)and French fries + chicken fingers (7.50$). I would just avoid those, even though they are good. They just aren't homemade and are just pre packaged food items. A bit pricey but you're asking for something they wouldn't normally have at an Italian restaurant. All of their pizza is amazing and fresh and so reasonable $$$ def come here to get some pizza to go!!! Try one of everything :-) The owners are very nice and keep their space very clean, which I love. I also appreciate the amount of variety of drinks they offer. From beers to wine to teas to sodas! read more

Park Ave Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

"BEST PIZZA EVER" is simply just an understatement at this local Orlando pizza shop! My college buddies showed me this lovely pizzeria about 8 years ago and I have religiously been going back since at least twice a month. Located right in the heart of Winter Park, you will never be disappointed with their menu items~ A few MUST haves include: Spinach Bianca - spinach, tomatoes, fresh ricotta cheese with an olive oil sauce base - My personal favorite and go to Buffalo - I find that many pizzerias struggle to balance the hot sauce and ranch. They have perfected this balance! Chef Salad - Homemade Vinaigrette, enough said! Just try it and you'll become a regular too just for the dressing. House made garlic butter sauce - My gods, whatever ingredients they use, its's literal magic. They put it on the crust of their pizza and breads - HEAVENLY It's owned by the loveliest Vietnamese couple you'll ever meet who has perfected classic and cheap Italian cooking. Customer Service remains consistent and superb throughout the years! Considering the Winter Park Area has a plethora of fancy, upscale restaurants, it's wonderful having those casual go-to places that don't break your bank. $2.50-$3.50 for a slice? I think I can for sure do that! read more

Park Ave Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza + Chef Salad - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Decent little pizza place near the sun rail train station. Perfect lunch stop for families. Food was decent, but not a lot of seating if it gets busy. I felt the owner could have been friendlier with the customization of pizza... but whatever. It was tasty, and I'll go back. read more

How can pizza get any better? It can come from Park Ave Pizza, that's how. This hole-in-the-wall pizza joint doesn't really garner too much attention at first glance. Situated slightly off Park Ave and next to a Brazilian Steakhouse, I would have walked right past Park Ave Pizza if not for my desire to find a cheap and quick solution to my hunger. Best decision ever. This little pizza joint, run by a husband and wife, made one of the best-tasting pizzas I've ever had in my life. I got a slice of the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and I'll be back for more. The crust was amazing; not too thin, not too thick, and perfectly seasoned. The pizza, itself, was great too; fresh garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, and chunks of buffalo chicken came together to create an explosion of flavor and deliciousness. Gahhh. I wish they were open for me to go get a slice now. They also had a good selection of beers and wines too. The staff was super nice, the husband makes the pizzas and the wife handles the register and orders, while occasionally stepping in to help him. There was one more employee, he handled the register when he came in (I think he's the delivery boy too), and he was really friendly. And I don't know if they usually bring the pizza out to you or if you have to wait for it, but they brought it out to us since we got confused about what to do and just sat down, like noobs. lol. The restaurant was clean and had both inside and outside seating. It's perfect for group outings, casual dates, and college students. :) Definitely recommend and will come back. read more

Park Ave Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Best pizza I've have had. 100% recommend this place. It's family owned and their recipes are amazing. The staffs are very friendly and nice. Try their pizza and you will never want to go somewhere else. read more

Three stars is more of an average...pizza is 4-5 stars but home delivery 1-2. Saturday night, 1/15/22, I called at 6:15 PM for one medium pizza. It was delivered at 8:07 PM! I was told 45 minutes to an hour. I waited close to 2 hours. The order takers should be up front and just say they are backed up. They could also allow a recording to pick up with that message message. read more

Pizza by the slice with lots of choices and big slices. Full Italian and hoagie menu. Decent drink, beer selection ... didn't look at wine. Also have fountain soda and draft beer. Nice couple runs the place. Order at counter and a decent amount of seats. They appear to do a large to go business. Ice cream coolers filled with every treat. Prices are good too. Right off Park Blvd and within walking distance of Alfond Inn. Enjoy!! read more

Long story short: I cannot recommend this place to anyone. My kids and I stopped in for some lunch with friends. We weren't in the mood for pizza but knew they had subs so figured, let's get some subs. Now, this will be important later: the menu board read "Turkey & cheese sub" with no mention of condiments and they never asked if we wanted them when we ordered. We placed our order and were told they couldn't take credit cards that day. Luckily we were able to scrape up enough cash since I don't usually carry it. We then sat down, it was only us and one other family who had already gotten their food. It took FORTY FIVE MINUTES TO GET COLD SUBS. When I went up to ask how long it would be to get them (at the 40 minute mark), the woman who took our order mumbled something like "I'll bring it out to you". It took another five minutes to get it. When we got it, it was absolutely disgusting. It was swimming with mustard and mayonnaise and it looked like someone sat on the sandwich. It was inedible. We didn't bother complaining bc I didn't have another 45 minutes to wait. I will note that my friends liked their pizza and the fries we ordered were tasty but I cannot give any more than one star bc there are so many better pizza places in our area. Very disappointed that we wasted $25 on inedible food and poor customer service. read more

First impression I got wasn't good. The place doesn't look that clean and no one who's working there is dressed properly. We went there during lunch time. The guy working there seemed very angry and reluctant to take our orders. No one's wearing gloves while making the food. I ordered the chicken parmigiana sandwich. It's cheap (Only $7.99). My coworkers got different pizzas. We ended up waiting for 25 min which is incredibly long for a sandwich that takes 5 min to make. The wait time for Calzon pizza was supposed to be 15 and it still took us 25 min. The sandwich was tasty and I would give it a 3.5/5 start. Everything else deserve a 2/5. I don't think I'll go back considering the wait time. Do yourself a favor and go to Maestro instead!!!! read more

See all

Haven't been here in a long time,it was the best years ago,and Surprisingly the asian couple that ran it are still there working hard so it still is awesome, The white pizza with chicken it's still amazing,the veggie slice is also great,with ricotta , tomatoes, and spinach,the Buffalo chicken pizza is also pretty good,You can't really go wrong here ,just great pizza executed perfectly,I normally don't really like the crust, but this place is nice and great,they also have a great chicken noodle soup that comes with a garlic bread, keep up the good work guys, Y'all the best!!!!!! read more

See all

What a great hidden gem! Was wandering around park avenue looking for a quick bite, which is usually hard over to find over there due to all of the amazing sit down restaurants lining the streets. Somehow, I spotted this place nestled behind the Brazilian steakhouse. This place has the ambience of your typical pizza place. Cute paintings of Italy and small tables to grab a bite at. I got cheese pizza by the slice (very reasonably priced at $2.50) and was blown away. This is probably the best NY style pizza I've ever had here in Orlando. The crust was amazing, garlicky and buttery, and it tasted like everything you never knew you even wanted! The people behind the counter were so nice and the place felt very cozy and homey. It was a great experience! I am looking forward to going back and trying some more of their entrees. They have a variety of baked pasta dishes, meat entrees, salads, subs, and all at great prices! They also sell full sized pies which go up to a whopping 18 inch size for just around $16. I know this will be the place I think of for pizza from now on. read more

I was disappointed. Wanted to like it but took way too long, service wasn't great and the pizza was mediocre.

If you like cardboard you will love this joint. All ingredients are straight out of a box or bag. Nothing is made in house. Salad was $10 and was all brown lettuce with a scant amount of pepperoni and 2 slivers of rotten ham. The worst pizzeria in central Florida hands down. Absolute rip off! Buyer beware! read more

What a classic pizza joint right in the middle of Winter Park! I just love this place! The owners are always so friendly and welcoming and the pizza is pretty good! Their Bianca non veggie slice is extremely tasty and their buffalo chicken is probably the best I've ever had! I would say it's the closest pizza I have to my hometown NY pizza. You will eat the entire pizza even the crust, especially since they brush on this garlic oil on the crust right before serving, yummyyyyy! There is indoor seating and then 2 or so outdoor tables. Overall great place and great owners!! read more

After an extensive search, I found my go to take out pizza place in Winter Park! There are so many choices and, really, all of them are tasty. The service is quick, friendly, and reliable (called ahead to place orders for specific times on several occasions) and the pizza quality is great every time. If you're looking for NY-style pizza with a delicious crust, give them a shot. Also, must I say that who knew Asians could master pizza making so beautifully! See you soon! Update: I recently ordered from them and there was a slight snafu with the order. The owners stand by their product and went above and beyond to take care of me and treat me like a valued customer and friend. Thanks, Park Ave Pizza! read more

Park Ave Pizza - Garlic-y, pepperoni-y goodness! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Such a friendly relaxed atmosphere Very nice family takes care of the most excellent pizza and other menu items. I stop in every once in a while for the best pepperoni pizza and beer. Find the time and relax your mind Come in and have your senses treated to an excellent surprise. read more

This place looks like a hole in the wall. But their pizza is SO good - you can buy it by the slice (only $2.50!) for a quick snack. The people working there are very friendly and helpful. There are lots of different choices of pizza. We will definitely be coming back. read more

It's not quite NY pizza but it pretty, pretty, pretty close, at least for Orlando. It definitely has that unassuming hole-in-the-wall vibe that a good NYC place has (but it's very bright and clean). Staff is super friendly and they are open late, which is awesome when you are a tired and hungry Rollins grad student. I picked up a couple of slices the other night and they really hit the spot. They added a buttery garlic sauce to the crust when they came out of the oven -- didn't add a ton of flavor but it smelled HEAVENLY. One of many little gems in the Park Ave area! read more

Pizza was great. Feels like a small NY restaurant. The couple who runs the shop is great. Overall great experience would recommend.

Pizza by the slice or whole pies. Pick your topping if you don't like what's pre-made. Cheap & quick lunch for the area. Expect to smell like garlic, they use a lot. read more

If you love pizza this is the place to go. I can never fully explain my snobby attitude towards pizza; I'm sure my girlfriend can better explain the struggle of trying to convince me to eat pizza. She loves pizza. If your mother was right and you would transform into what you are most she would be pizza. Now that you understand where I stand in the serious nature of pizza business this place is truly amazing. It's currently raining and I traveled a small bit to get some take out to snuggle up to. It's so good the rain is nothing to tackle to eat it's amazing gooey goodness. The shop is small but not too small. Best white pizza ever reminds me of my philly days. read more

Park Ave Pizza - White pizza with broccoli - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

My aunt and cousin took me here when I came down to visit. Their Christmas pizza and garlic knots are to DIE for. I'm from NJ/NY area and very picky about the pizza I eat, and they definitely hit the spot! Their flavors are on point and the crust holds up all on its own. No flimsy crust over here! I can't wait to eat here again. read more

See all