So disappointed, traveled a half hour to pick up my boyfriends favorite pizza, paid 36.00 for it and got it home and it was not edible. One of the toppings was meatball and they were black, custy and hard, burnt to a crisp. Warning, if you order a pizza to go or for pick up, check it before leaving.​ Update, returned today, believe it was the owner who took care of me, was wonderful and made a new pie, the kind we are use to from this establishment. He even carried it out to my car. Check out the way this pie normally looks. Fresh mushrooms, no canned mushrooms here, onions ,fresh ricotta, eggplant and meatballs. One slice of this pie is a meal. Delicious, just check before leaving if you have a take out order as mistakes happen, but they stand behind their mistakes and make it right. read more

See all

We were here today with friends and found Pete to be not only a waiter, but a cook and an all around nice guy.All of our food was delicious.Highly recommend this place. read more

Saturday evenings they usually serve prime rib. I tried it tonight, it was the best I've ever had. It was perfectly cooked, tender and delicious. The potatoes were also tasty. As much as I tried I couldn't eat the whole generous portion , thankfully my husband was willing to help. One of my favorites is chicken Parmesan, so it was hard to venture a change by ordering the Prime Rib, but I was glad I did. It was very satisfying. The staff is very nice and attentive as well! The owner often comes out to say hello. A great place for consistently delicious food and a friendly, homey vibe. read more

Blackstones what happened? For years your food was exceptional! Now it's just okay. The portions remain huge but everything is overcooked or just meh. The service remains amazing but the food is disappointing. Please put the owner back in the kitchen! read more

We ordered pierogies for appetizer. They came out greasy and not even on a something to absorb the grease. We were charged $16.95 for 7 pierogies which I thought was pretty steep. Then I ordered fish and chips. The fish was frozen obviously and deep fried so fast that the batter was full of grease and the inside was soggy still. There was hardly any fish inside the batter at all. I sent it back after 3 bites. My fiancé ordered a burger that kept falling apart and chunks of the burger kept falling out of the bun. Also it was totally lacking any flavor. When the bill came I was still charged for the fish and chips that I sent back and had to ask they be taken off the bill, which they were. We won't be back. This was a second attempt there as the first was bad too but we figured everyone deserves a second chance. Nope!! read more

Food and drink were unremarkable, but we may have been tempted for a second chance if it weren't for the off-color, borderline racist conversations that are apparently acceptable dialogue. read more

Casual restaurant with an influence of Italian dishes. Nice large menu. Drink-wise, this place isn't great - not too many choices. We started with a shrimp cocktail app that was a special. It was good but still had some frozen ice on them. My husband got the Osso Buco - he liked it but didn't love it. Meat was tender and potatoes were good. The veggies were nothing great. I got fried calamari for dinner - yuck - it was those really large rings that look like Cuttlefish - didn't care for it. I saw a lot of Italian dishes going out - I think those are the dishes to get. Saw a lot of people getting sandwiches which looked pretty good but the fries are the ones with the coating sprayed on. Doubt I would rush back here...... read more

Blackstones Bar & Grill - Good shrimp! - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Family friendly! They'll never leave you hungry! Big portions, great with special orders for dietary needs or allergies. Clean bar and tables. Friendly staff and one of the best bartenders around. A relaxed atmosphere where lots of laughs and great conversations are always had. Been coming here since they opened. I've know the chef for 22 years now and no complaints. read more

This place is AMAZING! Last night we were there for the first time as we were looking for a place to celebrate somewhere near enough to meet our nephew and new bride. The YELP reviews weren't great but were good enough as we also needed a place with outdoor dining and Prime Rib (for our autistic son) who wanted to use his birthday money for his favorite meal. We are probably the only people in NJ still wearing masks but because of our son's rare blood disorder, we need to make every effort to avoid him getting sick. This also contributes to us rarely being able to eat in restaurants anymore, so we were really looking forward to a good meal, and good company without our masks on the lovely summer night on the outdoor patio. Because our party was too busy chatting almost all of us ordered the Prime Rib without looking at the menu. The portions were HUGE, the plate was full of delicious mashed potatoes and vegetables and an extra EXTRA large chunk of meat - the best Prime Rib we have ever had! I called the week before to make a reservation and asked about the Prime Rib. I was told that they normally don't have it on a week night, but he (I think it was Pete the owner) said if you're defintely coming next week we'll reserve the table outside and I'll have the Prime Rib for you. A week later he did just that, and was ready for us! Blackstones was about 30 minutes from our home but WELL WORTH the trip! The waitress was also great and didn't miss a beat! She didn't seem to mind coming back several times as we were not all ready to order - and it was a pretty late dinner at 8pm. She was just notably nice. Not the "phoney" Disney bubbly kind of nice, just authentically genuinely nice. Like Pete the owner. It was positively refreshing. The desserts? We shared just to try them because we were all pretty stuffed and already had our to go bags. But, the waitress said the were homemade sooooo ... They were FANTASTIC and we had more than just a taste lol! Finally, a pup (the owner's or one of the staff's maybe) came out onto the patio to "say goodnight" dressed with a glow light around his neck as we were getting ready to leave. What a nice end to a wonderful evening and dining experience. Thank you again Blackstones! We will be back! read more

Peter awesome chef !!! Great staff large portions you will be boxing for home you won't be disappointed decent menu options !!!!!!

This is a great place to go to for 'real down home cooking' ! The portions are more than human size so you may be taking some home. Their veggie pie is great! The fried slices of eggplant and other veggies on top make one slice a meal in itself. Blackstones specials are never a disappointment, fresh and innovative. The beer assortment and cocktails are great also. read more

Went to go for lunch and was promptly greeted by not one, but 2 dogs. They were not service dogs (no identification, one wasn't even leashed). We ordered drinks then rethought the whole thing. If a business is willing to ignore pets in a restaurant, what other health code violators are going on? read more

Absolutely LOVE this place!!! I wish I could afford to eat here more than once a week, but we go as much as we can afford. Amazing portions for your $. We always have plenty to take home for leftovers. Favorites are the homemade garlic bread, house salad with homemade dressing,shrimp scampi, lasagna, baked ziti, pizza with sausage, peppers, onions and garlic. Drinks are priced fairly and are affordable. It is a nice cozy feeling dining either at the bar or at a table. Patty the bartender is not only a great bartender but also an amazing server and is usually by herself taking care of the entire place. Servers at other establishments could learn a few lessons from her! Peter the owner and chef is a great cook and always comes out of the kitchen to say hello to the guests. Definitely check this place out, you won't be disappointed!! read more

Blackstones Bar & Grill - Large cheese pizza with sausage, peppers, onions and garlic - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

See all

Good wholesome comfort food, large portions, but nothing pretty here as far as preentation. Just don't eat with your eyes. 2/3 of the staff here is oblivious to the Covid situation. No masks worn by bartender, lack of hand sanitation after using pos touch screen order system, someone really needs to teach them the rules. Food is good, but because of there non compliance to Covid we will not return!!! read more

Nice little gem, great food, timely service, reasonably priced. Interesting mixed crowd mid day lunch

Oh how I missed the Pietros' veal saltimbocca when they closed. By chance in a conversation, someone said they heard the same owner had opened a new restaurant. Finally had a chance to stop by. And hooray I can have the best veal saltimbocca around again. Portions are as gener8as they were before. My son had the penne vodka sauce which was equally excellent. We have a new go to place now when we are going out in the area. read more

Blackstones Bar & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

blackstone bar and grill is adorable from curb and service was great. no prices listed on specials. We were served white bread rolls with butter then ordered goulash because it was a special on the menu. The sauce was good but the meat was like shoe leather. We asked if pirogies were home made and the server said no they were frozen. the bar was full of guests but we were the only dinner guests at dinner time. My husband had two delicious pints of beer and I had ice water. The bill was $82.00! The food was terrible But drinks were great. So disappointed to have spent so much in money and calories. read more

Checked this place out last night because my husband has fond memories of the old Pietros. It did not disappoint, was family friendly as we had a 4 year old and 2 month old. Food was large portions and delicious. Service was great, will definitely be returning. read more

Decided to try this place while family was in town, and it did not disappoint. The food was excellent; the prime rib was a straight A+. Service was also attentive and timely. It's not fancy- which is a huge plus for me, getting excellent food without the extra. I will definitely be going back. read more

Though the food was good, it was not enough food to feed our group of 40 people. I was overcharged for a party of 40. It seems we drank $400 worth of soda. Wait staff was unresponsive. read more

One star for one reason, waitress refused to wear a mask. She had it around her next but never wore it. Also passed by the kitchen and the chef wasn't wearing a mask either. Irresponsible and unacceptable. read more

Peter is the "can do" dude. He seems to do it all, very well. Friendly, cozy atmosphere, great menu and caterer. Never disappointed

Awesome place to hang out with friends and family. Great food and service with very reasonable prices.

I love their burgers and service. I was not thrilled about their Italian food. I really like the Blackstones Bar and Grill.

Night was going great, we had ordered a pizza and we asked for a box, our waitress went to box the pizza which still had 4 slices. We watched her try to hide doing it as she kept one piece of pizza on the tray. From our seat we could see into the kitchen she took the slice and put it on the side for herself. Shocked we checked the box and there were only 3 slices left. What the heck. read more

The food is always fresh and the staff is fantastic. Been here many times from prime rib to pizza. Always good I would go better then good. read more

Not interested in a place that "cooks" your food in one of the three microwaves. Dishes are swimming in sauce.

This is a very nice place to grab dinner. The food was of large portions and very fresh. I woul definitely recommend read more

This place is truly a hidden gem. You can tell there's an experienced chef at the helm. We've had about 50% of the menu over the past two years and have yet to be disappointed. read more

A little gem. Excellent preparation, comfortable and friendly atmosphere, and reasonable family pricing with shareable size portions. Recommended! read more

food - 4 service - 4 atmosphere-3.5 the service made this place. I only visit Hackettstown, I do not live or stay here, was looking for a while for a good pub with good food and good prices and I think this Is the one. the quantity you get is a lot and the food is very good. Not fine dining but very good the fish and chips were amazing I extremely recommend it and I also recommend getting the fried raviolis all in all a great spot. read more

See all

Great for basic comfort food. Burgers are a good size and cooked as ordered. Pizza is amazing. Been here a number of time and I stick with the basics. The few times I have ordered a special I have not been as pleased. Service is very inconsistent, but it's not a problem. Everyone is really pleasant. If you are looking for a local place with good food this is it. We will be regulars. read more

Used to be my go to place for excellent food and service I don't want a side order of Covid-19 so will not be returning until responsible practices are in place. Currently servers do not wear masks, socially distancing is not practiced and customers are not required to wear masks. read more

The waitress took my food! We asked for to go boxes for the pizza but then I watched her package all but one slice that she took and ate in the kitchen! Even opened the box to check because we couldn't believe it-- yep! A slice missing. What is this??? read more

We went there twice food was not great the prime rib was mostly fat And I requested medium got rare crabcakes tasted like spoiled fish second time the nachos were cold cheese was hard and the garlic bread which was supposed to have mozzarella cheese on it was only on half the order I don't think will ever go back read more

They have the best mozzarella sticks and everything else is good too! I love to come here for a few drinks after work and I'm never disappointed with my meal! There's a good selection of beer on tap and the staff is very friendly! It can get a little loud at the bar, and the place isn't very big, so if you're looking for a quiet atmosphere for dinner, this might not be it. read more

Recently got the 10" bar pizza. it was very good. However, on-line menu listed price at $8.95 and I was charged $9.95. I couldn't be certain I was overcharged until I got back home to double-check on-line price, and I wasn't about to drive all the way back for a dollar. But not happy. read more

If I could give a no star review I would! We read many reviews and it seemed like a great place to try. My husband and I get nachos everywhere we go. They were the worst nachos we have ever had..the chip were all crushed like they came from the bottom of a bag and they cheese was rock hard. The burger I had was basically loose ground beef on a bun with again hard cheese...I have never have a burger fall apart into pieces as I ate it. My husband also got a burger except his had mushrooms. He couldn't even eat the burger because it had a horrible smell....definitely not a place to try! Paid $45.00 for a meal we didn't even eat! read more

Blackstones Bar & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Stopped in late on Wednesday night, looked like they were slow and ready to leave. I asked about dinner and the bartender could not have been more welcoming to me. She took my drink order and then say goodnight. The owner came over took my food order. Brought me a dozen meaty delicious buffalo wings, with excellent blue cheese. Brought me a steak and smashed potatoes, with vegetables. Hearty meal. Just what I needed. I left with a couple of cannoli. I cannot thank them enough for staying open and making me dinner, and most of all making me feel welcome. Was my first time there, but I will be going back.... just ate one of the cannoli... wow! delicious... what a surprise... as good as you will get anywhere. seriously. read more

Walked in around 9:45 pm looking to catch a game and have a few beers. Immediately me and my friend received a nasty stare down from the middle aged, female bartender who clearly hated her job there. There was about 4 other people sitting at the bar, and she had cleaned and set aside bar stools among the side we walked toward as if she wanted the place to be closed. We politely asked if they were still open (Google says they are open till 12 am or we wouldn't have even entertained going there) and she scoffed, looked at the kitchen and roughly said yes. After ordering our beer, the bartender started her pour out of the tap. This is not my business, but let me describe how she did this- she would pour the beer, filling the glass about half with head, half with the rest of beer, then let sit for 5 seconds or so. The head of the beer would settle briefly, then she'd repeat, filling the glass with head, then beer, pour out the foam, then fill again. She must've poured 2.5 beers for one that we ordered. Hilarious and sad! About 5 mins later I accidentally spilled my beer. I was not drunk or doing anything stupid, it was a clumsy mistake. When the check came, I was charged for the beer. I had drank maybe 6/8ths. Granted yes, it was my fault. I'm not looking for a handout or a free beer (not that I drank any of the one I spilled) but this happens often at bars. It's common just due to the nature of people being in that environment. What establishment charges a customer for a customer accidentally spilling a beer? Stuff happens and it's about hospitality. Ridiculous! (I did not complain about this at all, by the way.) I ordered Buffalo Calamari. It came out regular Calamari, not tossed in the buffalo sauce I asked. I told the bartender, and she gave me a confused, aggravated look which clearly bothered her. It was taken back. Not 3 MINUTES later, it came back. It was lazily tossed and completely lathered in Buffalo Sauce. When I mean completely lathered, I mean unbearably drenched. There was no care about actually fixing the issue, the chef (owner I believe) tried to mask the issue with carelessness. I couldn't even finish it, it was disgusting. When it came time to pay me and my friend asked to split the check. We were on the same bill. We simply asked to put his drink and food on his debit card, and for me to pay the rest cash, or vice versa. The lazy, angry bartender apparently couldn't do this. Yes, I'll repeat- in 2017 a restaurant could not complete this task, that or the bartender didn't give a crap enough to put in the effort. If I could give 0 stars I would! I look forward to seeing this dump slowly go downhill, which I will monitor with a smile from afar. Stay away, it's pathetic! read more