If you have a mini vacay in Woodstock or you're a local like I am and want to find some unique…read morefinds, don't pass up the chance to indulge in some thrift retail therapy at the long-standing Castaways on Mill Hill Rd. The space isn't huge- but the options are almost endless and exciting here. If you're the type who loves vintage at thrift prices, you'll bring those vintage finds back to life. I recently found two white quartz(?) bookends at $6ea that may seem small- but they're heavy AF. Prior to that, I've found small catch-all trays or other items. The staff is always friendly and willing to answer any of your questions about anything. So whether you want a nostalgic vintage cardigan, a vase, tea set, this or maybe that, Castaways is one of the best thrift+ vintage shops in Woodstock that won't disappoint you.

I am a long-time customer at Castaways. I've always enjoyed the environment, the noninvasive yet…read morehelpful nature of the staff, as well as the selection of clothing and jewelry. Normally I would give the store five stars. However, my most recent experience shopping there was less than pleasant. In fact, it was notably strange. Upon entering the store my friends and I were greeted by an employee that I had never seen before. She gave us a rundown of the store while we were looking around and I politely told her that we had been there before and didn't need to be told where and what things were. That was excusable. However, the experience got stranger. I was looking through a box and found a loose pair of pantyhose that I was thinking about purchasing. The employee entered the other room where my friends and I were Coincidentally, I picked up my bag and the pantyhose and went over to another section at the same time she was entering. In doing that I think I may have set off a shoplifting alarm in her head. Without asking, she picked up the pantyhose next to my bag and told us that she was going to put them up front. I protested because I wasn't sure if I wanted her to do that. She proceeded to tell me in somewhat of a scolding tone that she was going to bring them up front (regardless of my protests) and that they should have been left in their packaging (there was no packaging). After this encounter, she kept her eye on us consistently. I tried on two dresses and she interrupted my conversation to ask me a question about the dress I had on. She also asked loudly if anyone was in the dressing room as I was clearly changing in there. I found this whole experience strange and frankly invasive. I also felt singled out because of some unfounded (and obvious) suspicion. I do enjoy Castaways and I have been a long-time patron. However, I am reluctant to go in the store again because I would not like to have another encounter like the one I had today.

For details: Shop owner was unpleasant to friends and I…read morelooking to purchase a few items. But she gave us attitude and assuming prejudices. Was annoyed when sharing a fitting room when friends were trying on pieces together to make it faster for the people waiting and also very turned off when another tried to bargain. If there was a boundary cross you can respectably explain and set rules otherwise making snide comments back is not professional. FYI * I don't waste time on negative reviews as this has been my only 1 star review but in a world where compassion is needed, I need to call out when humans are not treated equally. Even if one person had a positive one, the other negative experience still needs to be acknowledged in hopes to improve service.

Beware of people like Este L who makes sure to leave bad reviews on multiple platforms without…read moreleaving much context/explanation as to why her experience was so horrendous. Seems like a personal problem. I met heather last year when I came to visit the store and she was so welcoming and kind even though I couldn't afford to buy anything at the time. I appreciate her aesthetic and style and it's some of the best vintage in the Hudson valley. Nothing gets my goat like chronic negative yelp and Google reviewers. We should support small businesses with sustainable missions, and if it's not for you move onnnnnn

A variety of items. Many price points…read more The staff was very helpful. Private parking lot.

Service - Very friendly staff!…read more Selection - Interesting curation of goods across the different store fronts within! My favorite mug that I'll think about forever and regret not buying is shown below. Value - many of the items seemed to have a steep price compared what I am used to. That being said - I am never quite sure the true value of what I am looking at, so I can only assume the high prices mean high quality pieces! Super cute and fun stop in beautiful Phoenicia. A must see!

Owner has this Diesel skull pottery piece that i really want to buy. Please contact me if…read moreinterested. The store is amazing!

The selection here is spectacular and it's in the heart of Woodstock. The prices reflect the true…read morevalue and quality of the prices, which are high, but if you truly appreciate vintage you get it! I was lucky to score a dress here that I will truly treasure. There's a lil dressing room in the back and the owner was friendly.

Mélange is worth visiting if solely for the handcrafted wooden items that you'll find in the…read morewindow. They are made by a local artist, and the prices are quite reasonable too. I loved the elephant puzzle that consisted of many small elephants. Man, just thinking about it makes me wish I had bought the elephant though I think it's a kid's toy. If animal puzzles aren't your thing, I also spied skulls, I[heart]U signs, treble/bass clefs, trouts, boxes, and racecars. So apparently if you don't see what you want, the artist can probably make something just for you. Awesome. Mélange also carries other items such as clothes and jewelry and home decor. Heather who helped us was also very informative and welcoming. Nice shop!

A hidden gem!! Kim at Melange is amazing. Her store is adorable with one of a kind items. My…read morehusband & I had such a great time shopping there. She has everything from unique & adorable household items to beautiful hand carved wood pieces, lovely ornaments & so much more. The moment you step into her store it's like being wrapped in a hug you never want to leave. We purchased a few gifts which she wrapped beautifully as well as some items for ourselves. Thank you Kim! Will definitely be back!!

If you're in Poughkeepsie and love a deal - stop by this space! It's a pretty wide selection of…read moreitems - and if you're searching for clothing they have a wide variety at all sizes (always nice to see!) The woman behind the counter was super friendly and the prices are definitely affordable. This is one of those small businesses you really want to visit again and again in order to support them!

Great little thrift/vintage boutique on Main St in Poughkeepsie. Owner is so friendly and makes…read morethe shopping experience fun! Great selection of womens and mens clothing in all sizes and accessories- even some furniture. Prices are very reasonable. They even do consignment!

Amazing store...great customer service highly recommended. Great selection. Clean & neat. Parking…read moreis available.

I forgot to add to my review that I did buy some socks! They're black and white gingham. Very very…read morecute and comfortable. And I just found out that they ship items so I was able to order more socks for myself.

You're in for a treat when you come to Reservoir Antique Mall (not far from the well-known Ashokan…read moreReservoir) on NY-28 in Shokan, NY. You'll notice is an interesting hodge-podge balance of timeless antique china, alongside rare furniture, 1970s cookbooks, vases, costume jewelry, a lot of knickknacks and perfect retro decor. Their 2nd fl., is similar with more furniture pieces. I actually found interesting decor pieces than anything. The owner and her family had a sale going on during the Thanksgiving weekend where you bought a regular priced item and got the other for 1/2 off. Best of all, the owner was willing to offer me a bargain on an item I was eyeing. This is a treasure trove and might probably leave with something. Remember, it's only CA$H, and Venmo(?).

Owner is rude. Ignores the customer while she rearranges items on hangers. Very poor customer…read morerelations.

love that I get to share items that are in good to excellent shape with others and get paid for it!…read moreThe store is so well organized and fun to browse in.

An eclectic selection of various merchandise awaits you here. It's definitely worth checking out if…read moreyou are in Phoenicia. The staff is knowledgeable and there are a range of prices to choose from.

a few months ago, while booking our air b&b I googled "what to do in Phoenicia" and the Mystery…read moreSpot was the first thing to come up. Now ive done a bit of traveling and sometimes a place that looks great can be kinda gimmicky, so this was my fear with this location, BUT now that I have been I can promise Mystery Spot was easily my favorite part of our trip. The owner was there, she was funny and kind and very knowledgeable! Another highlight was a shock, the layout! it was so easy to walk through and get lost in each room, everything was organized and easy to look through. I can't say enough how much that helped, I hate feeling like a bull in a china shop so feeling comfortable walking around was a big factor for me. My partner and I purchased our first antique and have our eye on our next purchase here, giving us an excuse to come back to the beautiful little paradise that is Phoenicia. Thank you Mystery Spot! You all helped make our holiday extra special. Hope to see you soon!