Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Blue Eagle Tavern

    3.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    Blue Eagle Tavern Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Blue Eagle Tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    22 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Finger Lakes Public House - Special - Smashburger tacos. Outstanding!

    Finger Lakes Public House

    4.3(71 reviews)
    18.9 mi

    I don't care how good they are, the service was awful…read more I'm seated and she comes over right away to give me a menu. She comes back maybe three minutes later, and I wasn't ready to order yet. So she leaves. They were busy, but they only had two servers covering the entire restaurant I was ready to order just a couple of minutes later, and my server never came back. I waited, I even tried to wave down the other server. She just looked at me and walked away. She didn't even bother to tell my server that I was ready to order or that I needed something. Not only that, but the prices were pretty ridiculous. $18 for a simple Cuban sandwich? Not including something to drink? I found a little place just up the road a few miles in Geneva you could get a full dinner for a little over 10 bucks. Thanks anyway, buh--bye.

    When I think of this place, my stomach growls immediately. I think of hand-breaded chicken tenders…read morelike NO other, steaks, salads, and definitely a cocktail or two. Their smoked mac and cheese will blow your mind and you can split it with someone, it's so much food. I do have to comment that I, along with my family, does not enjoy country music at all, so listening to that isn't my favorite. More disappointing, my Mother asked if they might try some other music for those who have been frequenting that location since the 50s (maybe some 50's, 60's, 70's music) and was told "that's what the staff likes, country". Where I come from, it's not about the staff, it's about the customers. Regardless, I still go because the food is just that good.

    Photos
    Finger Lakes Public House
    Finger Lakes Public House - Shared Rueben with Kimchi and onion rings. Yum!

    Shared Rueben with Kimchi and onion rings. Yum!

    Finger Lakes Public House - Bourbon Holiday Punch

    See all

    Bourbon Holiday Punch

    Pick's Pub - Chicken salad

    Pick's Pub

    4.8(5 reviews)
    39.5 mi

    This is a cute pub in Elmira Heights, right near Anchor glass. It has a selection of about 8 beers…read moreon tap, including Yuengling. They serve breakfast, lunch and dinner. There are dinner specials every day. Great hot dogs, and lots of pickle (get it, Pic for pickle) containing items. They have a pickle section on the menu. I liked their deviled eggs! My husband had a chili dog. The chili sauce is all seasoned meat, not runny at all. It was very tasty. Hot dog was cooked so it was a little brown--perfect in his opinion. I had the fish dinner with a broiled or baked haddock (excellently cooked with Cajun seasoning), coleslaw and Mac & Cheese. The Mac & Cheese was amongst the best I've ever had. Atmosphere in the main area of the pub was nice, dark. There's a lower level that sort of wraps around the main part of the pub (that's a little different) and it has dart boards for those who play darts. Service was excellent. I think there was only 2 waitresses on the night we went. Quiara(pronounced key-R-ra) was excellent and kitchen was prompt. Ok, not as prompt as a place that feeds kids, but pretty darn close!

    Great pub bar with really good food. Service is great and fun spin the classic dishes. We have…read morevisited a bunch of times and always have a great experience.

    Photos
    Pick's Pub - Main part of the bar. Whoot whoot, the flooring isn't the usual boring grey vinyl!

    Main part of the bar. Whoot whoot, the flooring isn't the usual boring grey vinyl!

    Pick's Pub - Broiled fish with Mac & cheese and coleslaw

    Broiled fish with Mac & cheese and coleslaw

    Pick's Pub - Chili Dogs with chips and Deviled Eggs

    See all

    Chili Dogs with chips and Deviled Eggs

    Blue Eagle Tavern - pubs - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...